Comments 272

Re: Opinion: Sonic Racing Crossworlds > Mario Kart World, And It's Not Even Close For Me

rosemo

Ok, I'll take the bait. It's a low stakes discussion... video games right? So, I respect the opinion of the author, but it seems common among the video game journalist community. I have listened to a number of podcasts/videos where the opinion among people who play videogames for a living is that MKW is a letdown. Free roam is boring, not much content, etc. And, compared to the final form of MK8DX, it probably isn't as good, though it looks a lot nicer. But I just have to say, I think in general people may be expecting too much of Nintendo. If they did MK9 that spammed out crossovers like the Sonic game, then a good chunk of people would criticize that. MKW, taken for what it is, is a really good attempt at a new direction for Mario Kart. Nintendo needed to do it to stop the series from getting stale. And guess what, it will happen for Smash Bros and maybe Animal Crossing this generation too. Enjoy the ride and see where it goes over time. My kids and I are having a great time right now and are looking forward to more content down the road.

Re: Nintendo Confirms US Price For 'Switch 2 Welcome Tour'

rosemo

I will join the chorus of people who are saying this should be a pack in title and the fact that it isn't indicates that Nintendo is a little out of touch and trying to nickel and dime. On the 3DS, they included a lot of software to show the capabilities of the hardware. It builds goodwill with your customers and gets them excited to buy other software that uses these capabilities. To charge for this means that almost no one will buy it.

Re: Braid: Anniversary Edition Sales Have Been "Utterly Terrible", Says Creator

rosemo

I am extremely not shocked at all by this. It is a 16-year puzzle platformer. First, about half the owners (or more) of a Switch weren't even born when that game first came out so there is no "name recognition". Second, many who had been born came back to gaming with the Switch so there is no name recognition there either. To others' point, many already own it on another platform and it still plays great. Third, like Metroidvanias, there are a lot of other puzzle platformers on Switch, many of which stand on the shoulders of Braid...and are regularly on sale for $2. That undermines the value proposition of this release.

Re: New SteamWorld Game Sales Fell "Slightly Short" Of Thunderful's Expectations

rosemo

My take is that the problems began with Quest, which hardly anyone has mentioned so far. Steamworld Quest was fun but not particularly memorable. Unlike the other games, my kids and I will never replay it. So I think the momentum began slowing with Quest. Then, instead of following a new genre game with a sequel to a previously covered genre (e. g. Heist 2), they took a long time to make Build, which as others noted wasn't maybe as appealing to the fan base. A final point: in the past, the Steamworld games were released first on Nintendo consoles, giving the impression that it was a Nintendo fan driven series. Build came out on everything at the same time which gives the impression Thunderful is moving away from its roots as a Nintendo first dev. I think this mattered in the Wii U/3DS era. Anyway, I still plan to support the series since I'm a fan but won't be looking for Build 2 anytime soon.

Re: Mario Movie Already Set To Be The Highest-Grossing Video Game Film Ever

rosemo

I thought a lot of the critical reviews were off on this movie. Granted, I am a lifelong Mario fan, but this movie was clearly made to introduce you to the characters and the world. Sales people often talk about "land and expand" as a sales strategy. You get your foot in the door with a product or service and then try to expand from there as you learn more about your client. This movie is where they "land" to get a foot in the door with audiences and now they will "expand" the franchise over the next decade. My thought is that this will include series for some characters on Peacock and mainline movies. There will be plenty of content.

Also, and this is a little bit of a hot take, but Chris Pratt did well as Mario. While watching the movie, I never thought I was just listening to Chris Pratt talk. I've seen a lot of internet discourse about his casting in particular and using more actual voice actors. However, I doubt this push back came when Tom Hanks voiced Woody in Toy Story or even Jack Black in Kung Fu Panda. Famous actors are cast all the time as voice actors for animated films. You may not like Chris Pratt's personal life or views and that's fine. But in my opinion, he fit in well with the rest of the voice cast. The only one who I was disappointed in was Fred Armisen as Cranky Kong. In my head, CK is supposed to sound like a doddering old man, but oh well...

Re: Soapbox: If You Thought Last Year Was "Sad" For Switch, 2023 Might Be Hard To Handle

rosemo

I had read one of the articles that the author linked to and thought the same thing, that you could say any platform holder had a rough year of not for a couple games.

I've basically stopped listening to a certain Nintendo podcast because one or two of the co-host keep talking about how Switch is "long in the tooth" and "Steam Deck is so awesome." These people play games as a profession and may be in touch with the hard core gaming crowd. However, I know at least three kids that got a Switch for Christmas. They and their parents don't have a clue that a Steam Deck exists and frankly don't care. Steam Deck is much better in the specs department but it's also sold at a substantial loss. Nintendo won't and shouldn't embrace that model.

Further, in my son's college dorm, everyone has a Switch. Almost no one has an Xbox or PS5 and absolutely no one has a Steam Deck. When they play competitive games, they play MK8 or Smash. These are not old geezer Nintendo fans like me. They are all born this century.

In my opinion, Nintendo had a great year and the next financial report will prove that. People in games journalism need to think about encouraging people to enjoy the things we have, though in some cases criticism is warranted and should be voiced. Others who complain about nothing to play may need to consider a new hobby or a change of pace to learn contentment. Now I'm off to play some Kirby and Great Ace Attorney!

Re: Review: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Booster Course Pass Wave 2 - Harmless Fun, But More "B-Side Filler"

rosemo

I agree with the Second Opinion more than the actual review. My family all played the new tracks last night and the consensus was that this wave is better than the first one. Most of the wave one tracks we felt were kind of "meh" except for Ninja Hideaway. Sky High Sundae is broken but an interesting experiment. Waluigi Pinball and Mushroom Gorge are awesome and we liked the changes to Kalimari Desert. Sydney Sprint is a good Tour track. Keep 'em coming, Nintendo! Wave 3 as a Christmas "present"!

Re: Watch: This 90-Minute Deep Dive Into Two Of The Most Underrated Zeldas Is Well Worth The Time

rosemo

I haven't watched the video but I've played both games extensively and played almost every entry in the series. In my opinion, neither game is fantastic. Phantom Hourglass has some redeeming qualities but poor design choices. Spirit Tracks is the worst Zelda game and the only one I didn't bother finishing though I got close to the end. ST is so boring, empty, repetitive and frustrating towards the end. I had fun even with Chibi Robo Zip Lash but really struggled with Spirit Tracks.

Re: NoA President Responds To Alleged Working Conditions At Nintendo, Finds Reports "Troubling"

rosemo

I have read the report and listened to Kat Bailey (the IGN author) talk about this on Nintendo Voice Chat. As a manager, I always endeavor to treat my employees fairly, no matter if they are FTE (full-time employees) or contractors. Bullying and harassment are never right. However, the truth is that contractors are not owed the same benefits as full-time employees. Nor are they owed a permanent position. Many of them grow into this based on the value they bring to the company. The contract defines the terms of employment. That is the nature of the "gig economy". Further, if the contract is through an agency, then technically they are employed by the agency. Whatever benefits are provided by the agency is what they are entitled to receive. Nintendo has no say in that, though they could (and should) refuse to work with an agency that does not treat their employees well. As a client of the agency, Nintendo can request that a person be removed from their account at any time for any reason. If Nintendo abides by the terms of the agreement, either with the independent contractor or with the agency who employees the contractor, then they cannot be accused of wrongdoing. However, they are responsible for their general work environment and should not abuse or demean their employees or contractors. On the other side, a contractor should not abuse their position with Nintendo by disclosing confidential information. Let the investigation proceed and report back if there is something substantial to report.

Re: Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack Release Date And Pricing Revealed

rosemo

Well, I'm not angry about this but I am disappointed. You can get most of these Genesis games on the switch for cheap. The N64 games are cool but not worth it at the moment. I have still have NES and SNES games I want to play in the service. I'll stick with the base sub for now. $40 would have been a better price point. It may be worth $50 if they add GBA. In general, I think their pricing is high. Warioware was fun but probably not worth $50. I paid $30 from having a gift card and it was definitely worth that. That's just my opinion.

Re: Metroid Dread Staff Say They've Been Left Out Of The Game's Credits, MercurySteam Responds

rosemo

@CharlieGirl There are many things that are "utterly abhorrent" in this world but being left out of credits is not one of them. People are unfairly treated all the time in the corporate workplace. Is it ok? No. Is it just? Likely not. However, did these folks know the policy and are just using this to get their five minutes in the limelight? Maybe. We only have one side of the story and to call it "abhorrent" is a bit of a stretch. Let's agree to save that for issues of life and death.

Re: Review: Baldo: The Guardian Owls - Exquisite Ghibli-Esque Art Can't Hide Tortuous Gameplay

rosemo

@Yodalovesu I haven't played the game so I am speaking as an outsider on this one. However, bugs and lack of polish in my opinion should be counted against a game. If you applied this to a sports team, then you could say "Well, if only the players and coaches just made better decisions or better plays, then they would be an all-time great team." But they didn't, so their record is bad. In hearing people talk about this game, it sounds like they are going way out of their way to be charitable because it looks nice and they want it to be good. I heard Casey on NVC talking about this game and you could tell she hated it but was trying to be nice. I think our society is geared that way now, where we have to try to find the good in everything. However, there is nothing wrong in saying, "This is not a good game. It's disappointing. I don't recommend you buy it." The developers may try harder to either patch this game or make a better game next time. Or they may be inspired to start a new career that leads to astronomical success. I'm not saying to be overly critical or harsh, but be honest. If it's not good, give it a 2 or 3. Don't lead people to spend their hard earned on something that isn't worth it.