Comments 530

Re: Editorial: With Lowered Expectations E3 Can Still Be Full of Nintendo Magic

buildz

As long as Monster Hunter Generations, Dragon Quest VII: Fragments of the Forgotten Past and Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE aren't the only games being shown off on the second day, I'm somewhat looking forward to E3.

I say this because their E3 website (which is pretty cool, by the way), states that "Nintendo Treehouse: Live will showcase upcoming games such as Monster Hunter Generations..."; the use of 'such as' could mean that they have more games to show off...

Re: Video: Court Is In Session For Ten Minutes Of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Spirit of Justice

buildz

For those that are wondering, I'm pretty sure this is from the DLC that you get for pre-ordering this game in Japan, which is called Turnabout Across Time. Why?

Edgeworth is prosecuting; the main prosecutor in the game isn't him, but rather someone else (I won't spoil it). Plus, Phoenix's portion of the game takes place exclusively in Khura'in, from what I've learned. And, this takes place after the main game - there's a few subtle hints that point at this.

Re: Soapbox: Why Websites Don’t Need to Give a Game a Review Score (and Probably Shouldn’t)

buildz

@Dave24 You're taking my essay example too literally. Of course if you hand your essay in on a piece of toilet paper you'll get an F (or even U). Though, I have seen that happen...

I wasn't trying to outright say an essay is exactly like a review, I was merely saying there are a few elements that carry over - in specific, the fact that a teacher shouldn't be marking based on opinion (such as, for example, if they liked it). I understand a review cannot be 100% objective - but, on the flipside, a review shouldn't be too heavily weighted on opinion. I'd point you towards Kotaku/Polygon's review of Star Fox Zero for what I hate in a review.

Still, you present a valid point. Whew, there's been a lot of controversial news posts on NintendoLife lately, eh?

Re: Soapbox: Why Websites Don’t Need to Give a Game a Review Score (and Probably Shouldn’t)

buildz

A review should be an objective look at a game/movie/song/whatever that should be assessing its merits and faults. I feel that a score is basically a summary of the merits/faults and which side has a bigger weighting. A review should be objective for many reasons. Think of it like an essay in school - did your teacher mark you lower because he/she didn't like the font you chose or the format you presented your work in? No - it has to purely based on the quality of work. And that is what a review should be:

"a written piece assessing the quality of a game without bias"

A score should complement this. If a game has lots of good things about it, the score should reflect this. Yet, time and time again, I see reviews about games with many good things, yet because the writer didn't like a specific element, even if it was 'good', the score gets bumped down - which is why many news outlets seem to be dropping scores because they become too opinionated. Scores should be a representation of the quality of a game, which is why I vote in favour of them. As long as they aren't opinionated, and come from a true assessment of how good a game actually is, I'm fine with them. If a game that is actually good gets a 6 because the writer didn't personally like it, I get annoyed. If you want to include your opinion, it's not a review, but a personal recommendation. Why else do you think I don't trust IGN anymore?

Scores are also good for the lazy, I guess.

Re: Reminder: This is the Final Day for a Number of My Nintendo Rewards

buildz

I'm personally quite happy with My Nintendo. Maybe that's because I must be one of the few people here that truly like Miitomo.

Regardless, physical rewards and points from physical copies of games would be nice. Even if it's only half as much as you would get from buying the same game digitally would be good, and still allow Nintendo to try and push people towards digital.

Re: Review: SUPER ROBO MOUSE (Wii U eShop)

buildz

@A01 Both Mario vs. Donkey Kong: Tipping Stars and Mini Mario & Friends: amiibo Challenge were also made on the Nintendo Web Framework. It can produce excellent games when people put effort in.

Re: Review: SUPER ROBO MOUSE (Wii U eShop)

buildz

@bezerker99 Yeah, the sound effects ruin it for me. How hard could it be to add sound effects? I'm not entirely aware what engine he uses to create his games (isn't it like HTML5 or something), but it mustn't be too hard, surely?

Re: Nintendo Download: 28th April (North America)

buildz

I'd recommend to everyone Mini Mario & Friends: amiibo Challenge. It's one of the most unique and well crafted Mario vs. Donkey Kong games in the series - and it's free! Well worth your time, provided you have at least half of the required amiibo.