So the options are either the barely functional Switch 1 version or the waste of plastic pseudo physical Switch 2 version. Guess I'll play S1 version on S2 and hope it's playable.
@Solid_Python Where did you get no physical version for the West? All of our retailers still have it listed. If you're right then the game is skip for me unfortunately.
I honestly think the game is like 5-6/10 but the ending is like 12/10. So 7 in the end for me.
A lot of the mechanics are outdated, the game plays less like Pheonix Wright and more like those really ancient text based point and click predecessors. Not much happens at all till the ending sequence. You can get anything wrong and it will affect only one of your extras in an undetermined manner, kind of defeats the detective part a bit. Overall the game is really just meh, the ending I won't spoil but it's a masterpiece.
I highly recommend it, it's a near perfect series of games hindered only by their technical state in the last years. X breaks this trend and looks much better while also running way smoother.
Basically this is very similar like CryStar, cringy story and godawful one button mashing against billion HP enemies combat, but somehow amazing in every other way.
@DemonKow I feel like not in a good way, I like Warriors games, but in those you have at least some variety and it's fun how strong you are. In this game every enemy takes million hits from some point of the game, and most of the time you literally hit only a single button, without combos or using specials.
@Ralizah Yeah, as much as I enjoyed YS IX the game was all around a technical disaster, I don't expect X to be particularly better honestly since the PS4 version of IX was also disfunctional. Hopefully their new engine actually works.
@ArcticEcho Depends on what you want from a game, the OST for example is absolutely top class, story is kind of weird but ok, graphics are nothing special.
The problems are that you need to replay a major part of the game 3 times, the maps are completely barren of anything other than enemies, most of the combat is extremely easy and generally resolved by using only a single button, and from some point, everything has billion hp and takes forever to kill on anything other than Easy difficulty
That being said some JRPGs make massive progress between 1st and 2nd installments, like Blue Reflection or Caligula Effect, I'd wait for the reviews for this one.
Oof I'm not sure about this one. I love the games that NIS America brings over but in my eyes Crystar which was also action RPG made by FuRyu is a genuinely a really bad game. I will need to wait for some gameplay videos and reviews for this one.
This game cannot be rated despite already coming out, it's a 4 at best though. Feels like a game that exists solely for an 18+ patch despite actually never having one. Divinity Stage from the same series isn't awful though if you don't mind low budget romance VNs.
I disliked this game so much sadly, the OST is stunning and among the best, but the story is kinda dumb and the combat is basically spamming one button over and over against same enemies and bosses that take several hundreds hits to kill despite being mostly harmless. I can't finish this but if there's ever a sequel that fixes the flaws it could be a game I would absolutely adore.
Not really a "hidden gem" but Caligula Effect 2 hasn't been rated, it does not have a NLife page up either so nobody can rate it (which is a shame because I wanted to give it a 9)
I shipped the game from PlayAsia few months ago (could have saved myself some taxes if I waited smh), it's a flawed and very grindy dungeon crawler, unless you are a really hardcore dungeon crawler fan you will probably not like the game.
I don't know I feel like sequel of this game can be a masterpiece but this game just cumulated too many small mistakes in one place. I honestly think performance is fine compared to vast majority of new Switch games but that just speaks about the console. I personally love the game but I think that obejctively it isn't great, it's a very love it or hate it game I believe.
@Daniel36 There are like 4-5 jokes or moments in the entire series that don't feel appropriate since the characters are like 9 years olds but I don't think it's that bad. I definitely wouldn't call any of them fanservice either I guess.
Comments 125
Re: Review: Persona 3 Reload (Switch 2) - A Great Remake, But Still Not Definitive
@fenlix It's a Switch 2 and there's no reason for P3 to run that way other than Atlus not really caring.
Re: Atlus Rules Out Persona 3 Reload Switch Port
For me the cut content, the performance and the game-key card are coming up to a really unimpressive port. Might pick this for PC later.
Re: Rune Factory: Guardians Of Azuma Latest Update Now Live, Here's What's Included
I don't understand why people hate extra content all of sudden, if you have problem with patching physical games, go full digital.
That being said the level 100 bond cap seems absurd to me, it will take an eternity of grind to get there.
Re: Videos: Square Enix Releases New Trailers For 'Octopath Traveler 0' And 'The Adventures Of Elliot'
@topsekret Elliot is confirmed to be Game-key card
Re: Review: SHUTEN ORDER (Switch) - An Audacious Swing That Doesn't Quite Connect
First time I see 2/10 and 10/10 in the same day of critic reviews
Re: Ys X: Proud Nordics Sails West On Switch 2 In Early 2026
Would be a day 1 buy if it was physical, but I guess I'll just buy it in resale for PC instead.
Re: Review: Pokémon Friends (Switch) – Pretty Plushies, Puzzling Pricing
I actually love this game a lot. It starts off way to easy but once you get level 9s across the board it becomes quite intense and fun.
Re: Trails Beyond The Horizon Lifts Off With New Switch 1 & 2 Release Date
So the options are either the barely functional Switch 1 version or the waste of plastic pseudo physical Switch 2 version. Guess I'll play S1 version on S2 and hope it's playable.
Re: The Legend of Heroes: Trails into Reverie
I wish the last patch of this game didn't render it unplayable, it gets 1 from me for that
Re: Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time Finally Lands New May Release Date
@UltimateOtaku91 Dang, hopefully PlayAsia gets an international version
Re: Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time Finally Lands New May Release Date
@Solid_Python Where did you get no physical version for the West? All of our retailers still have it listed. If you're right then the game is skip for me unfortunately.
Re: Rumour: Kirby: Planet Robobot Will Indeed Come To Switch, It's Claimed
One of very small amount of Kirby games I never got to play, would definitely buy.
Re: Rate Your Favourite Switch Games Of The Year 2024
Prince of Persia: The Lost Crown wins the year for me, but The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom is a close second.
Re: Croc Remaster Will Miss Its December 2024 Launch Window
Oh man, that was the only game I was looking forward to this month
Re: Zelda's Voice Actor Would Love To See The Princess In "More" Playable Roles
I don't understand all the negativity here, Echoes was an amazing game and it's not set in stone that Zelda needs to be a summoner in every game.
Re: Poll: What Review Score Would You Give Emio - The Smiling Man: Famicom Detective Club?
I honestly think the game is like 5-6/10 but the ending is like 12/10. So 7 in the end for me.
A lot of the mechanics are outdated, the game plays less like Pheonix Wright and more like those really ancient text based point and click predecessors. Not much happens at all till the ending sequence. You can get anything wrong and it will affect only one of your extras in an undetermined manner, kind of defeats the detective part a bit. Overall the game is really just meh, the ending I won't spoil but it's a masterpiece.
Re: Jack Jeanne
This game would be 9/10 if it didn't take 3 hours to start a new route when there's 7 of them... I finished one and watched the rest on Youtube
Re: Ys X: Nordics Will Launch On Switch In The West In Fall 2024
I highly recommend it, it's a near perfect series of games hindered only by their technical state in the last years. X breaks this trend and looks much better while also running way smoother.
Re: Demon Slayer's New Mario Party-Style Game Gets An Overview Trailer
I don't have the best memories of MP clones, hope this one will be different.
Re: Miyamoto And Avi Arad Have Been Discussing The Zelda Movie For A Decade
I liked the scene where Link said "IT'S LINKING TIME" and linked.
Re: Review: CRYMACHINA - Silly, Stylish, But Oh-So-Repetitive Action-RPG-ing
Basically this is very similar like CryStar, cringy story and godawful one button mashing against billion HP enemies combat, but somehow amazing in every other way.
Re: Review: Might & Magic: Clash Of Heroes - Definitive Edition - A DS Classic Returns In Mighty Fine Form
Wait, I thought there was going to be a physical release. I'm sad now.
Re: Action RPG CryMachina Looks Stunning, And It's Launching This October
@DemonKow I feel like not in a good way, I like Warriors games, but in those you have at least some variety and it's fun how strong you are. In this game every enemy takes million hits from some point of the game, and most of the time you literally hit only a single button, without combos or using specials.
Re: Action RPG CryMachina Looks Stunning, And It's Launching This October
@Ralizah Yeah, as much as I enjoyed YS IX the game was all around a technical disaster, I don't expect X to be particularly better honestly since the PS4 version of IX was also disfunctional. Hopefully their new engine actually works.
Re: Action RPG CryMachina Looks Stunning, And It's Launching This October
@ArcticEcho Depends on what you want from a game, the OST for example is absolutely top class, story is kind of weird but ok, graphics are nothing special.
The problems are that you need to replay a major part of the game 3 times, the maps are completely barren of anything other than enemies, most of the combat is extremely easy and generally resolved by using only a single button, and from some point, everything has billion hp and takes forever to kill on anything other than Easy difficulty
That being said some JRPGs make massive progress between 1st and 2nd installments, like Blue Reflection or Caligula Effect, I'd wait for the reviews for this one.
Re: Action RPG CryMachina Looks Stunning, And It's Launching This October
Looks promising but I advise caution with this. Crystar was probably the most button mashing game I've ever seen.
Re: Review: LEGO 2K Drive - A Fun, Colourful Racer But Not Quite Open-World Mario Kart
Would get this game for any other console than Switch if it wasn't a wallet sim since it looks cool. Too bad
Re: Dotemu Is Bringing 'Might & Magic: Clash Of Heroes' Back On Switch This Summer
I completely forgot I ever played this ! Excited to see it come back
Re: Community: Have You Played A Great Switch Game We Missed? Let Us Know About It
There is no page up for Lovekami -Healing Harem- . Which isn't really a good game at all but I have OCD about not being able to rate it.
Re: Square Enix's 'Voice Of Cards Trilogy' Bundle Available On Switch eShop
This is almost exactly what I've been waiting for with these games except it's still not physical
Re: NIS America Reveals CRYMACHINA, An Action-Packed Sci-Fi RPG For Switch
Oof I'm not sure about this one. I love the games that NIS America brings over but in my eyes Crystar which was also action RPG made by FuRyu is a genuinely a really bad game. I will need to wait for some gameplay videos and reviews for this one.
Re: Review: Persona 4 Golden - A Must-Buy Classic That's Stood The Test Of Time
Release the physical version you cowards !
Re: Lovekami -Healing Harem-
This game cannot be rated despite already coming out, it's a 4 at best though. Feels like a game that exists solely for an 18+ patch despite actually never having one. Divinity Stage from the same series isn't awful though if you don't mind low budget romance VNs.
Re: Random: Players Are Finding Ways To 'Hug' And 'Kiss' Their Pokémon In Scarlet And Violet
This mix of excitement and complete disgust is exactly why I came to this comment section.
Re: Review: Chaos;Child - A Stand Out 'Science Adventure' VN That's Compelling And Gruesome
I'm willing to give it a chance, Robotics Notes sequel was the worst VN I've ever read but the first one was decent.
Re: Random: After Three Years Of Anonymity, Minecraft YouTuber Reveals His Face
Face of a cheater and a lunatic. Great
Re: CRYSTAR
I disliked this game so much sadly, the OST is stunning and among the best, but the story is kinda dumb and the combat is basically spamming one button over and over against same enemies and bosses that take several hundreds hits to kill despite being mostly harmless. I can't finish this but if there's ever a sequel that fixes the flaws it could be a game I would absolutely adore.
Re: Community: Found A Great Switch Game We Didn't Review? We Want To Know
Not really a "hidden gem" but Caligula Effect 2 hasn't been rated, it does not have a NLife page up either so nobody can rate it (which is a shame because I wanted to give it a 9)
Re: Dragon Quest Treasures Overview Trailer Showcases Impressive Scope
Dragon Quest spinoffs are pretty underrated, I loved every single one that I played, probably even more than the main games.
Re: Dungeon-Crawling JRPG 'Demon Gaze Extra' Bags A January Launch On Switch
I shipped the game from PlayAsia few months ago (could have saved myself some taxes if I waited smh), it's a flawed and very grindy dungeon crawler, unless you are a really hardcore dungeon crawler fan you will probably not like the game.
Re: Review: Made in Abyss: Binary Star Falling Into Darkness - Makes You Work For The Good Stuff
I don't know I feel like sequel of this game can be a masterpiece but this game just cumulated too many small mistakes in one place. I honestly think performance is fine compared to vast majority of new Switch games but that just speaks about the console. I personally love the game but I think that obejctively it isn't great, it's a very love it or hate it game I believe.
Re: Rumour: Cryptic Whispers Of Incoming F-Zero News Are Doing The Rounds Online
I can totally imagine another F-Zero track be part of the Mario Kart 8 expansion / Mario Tour to be fair.
Re: Type-Moon's 'Witch On The Holy Night' Receives Western Release In December
Please tell me it does not have out of place awful sex scenes like other Type Moon games.
Re: Anime RPG 'Made In Abyss' To Contain Two Unique Game Modes
@Daniel36 There are like 4-5 jokes or moments in the entire series that don't feel appropriate since the characters are like 9 years olds but I don't think it's that bad. I definitely wouldn't call any of them fanservice either I guess.
Re: Anime RPG 'Made In Abyss' To Contain Two Unique Game Modes
Made in Abyss are my favourite series of all time and Spike Chunsoft has made some killer games lately, so I can't wait for this one.
Re: Review: 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim - A Rich Narrative Adventure/RTS Hybrid With Outstanding Art
If there weren't 9 unfinished Switch games waiting on my table I'd buy it day 1...
Re: Review: Rune Factory 5 - A Dependable Old Farmhand That Could Use A Spruce Up
This is good enough review for me, both 3 and 4 are among my all time favourites, shame that 80% of new releases have performance issues though.
Re: Pre-Orders Are Live For This Sweet Shin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne Figma Figure
Alright, but what's Figma ?
Re: Free Couples Update For 'Haven' Adds Same Gender Options
That makes me want to play it even more, now only if I'd be able to get my hands on a LRG copy that costs less than 250EUR...
Re: 'Missions And Rewards' Added To Nintendo Switch Online
Consdering how extraordinarily worthless Platinum Points were up till this point I think this is actually not a bad change at all.