@Yorumi I think you're just making assumptions about them purposely hiding it, without any real evidence to back it up, but I do agree it would've been better if there was at least a mention of the things that are missing.
Let's just hope all or at least most of the missing things will be added in the future, I'm sure we will both be happy about that!
@Yorumi Right now you seem to be the one "getting so up in arms" about this. I already said it would've been nice if they included that information, but many reviews everywhere on the internet have incomplete information, that's also not the main purpose of a review. Like I said, it doesn't automatically make the review dishonest. If you think some "this game sux 0/10" review is equal to the the 10/10 review NintendoLife wrote for New Horizons, that's your opinion.
Bare in mind, I also don't think it's a 10/10, but I also don't think NL was being dishonest with their review. In the end no game is perfect and there's always going to be things that can be added/improved upon.
And there's always going to be inconsistencies when comparing one review to the other, especially when they're written by two different people.
@Yorumi I guess for you them giving a 10/10 means they think it's absolutely perfect? Since they don't literally say that. I would think you've been around this site long enough to know a 10/10 here doesn't mean the game is perfect. And even if they do think that way, a review is subjective. I do think it would've been better if they mentioned all the missing stuff, but I wouldn't say not doing so is lying by omission.
I also would've loved to see more stores, furniture and special characters, but not having them doesn't seem to bring the game down for most people, or at least not by much.
@Yorumi I never said they didn't cut anything, nor did I say the game is perfect. I also never implied that's not something worth noting in a review, however not noting it doesn't automatically make the review dishonest. Not sure what point you were trying to make.
@Yorumi "In this game they cut about 70% of the content from NL just to give us terraforming(which btw proves how dishonest this site's reviews have become)."
Ah, the good old pulling statistics out of thin air and saying someone is being dishonest when they don't have the same opinion as you. Those make for some great arguments...
@Unit_DTH If savegames were on the SD card, nobody would be complaining. Unfortunately, they're locked to the system, so unless you hack it, you can't access it..
Sigh >,< (only sighing for my money), instant-buy. This game blew me away on WiiWare and with the amount of games I've played since then, this one really made an impact. Already bought it digitally again on Switch, but I won't be able to resist this one, it really is a master-class in awesome game design.
I highly recommend Broforce, especially at that price, though I think it's worth the full price as well. Amazingly fun and responsive side-scrolling shooter with very diverse characters that are a joy to play with. The destructible environment is great too. ^^
@Gravitron "despite being a purely digital input, the D-pad does not, in fact, behave like one – rather, it emulates the left analogue stick. This may seem trivial at first but this opens up the library of compatible games"
So while it doesn't change the fact it's a hard sell, this is not one of the reasons why.
I love Nintendo's franchises, but I also love how they dare to try new things. And while I'm at it, I also love Miyamoto for being the founding father of some of my most beloved franchises (and my number one most loved franchise, Zelda). With all he has accomplished and put out, he'd be hard pressed to do wrong in my book!
@antdickens I think it's great that you do, that's for sure! It's one of the things I love about this website, the engagement by the staff. ^^ Just felt like I've never seen these many responses before (for something that IMO doesn't deserve it), which could just be me, I don't go through every comment section, obviously.
@antdickens I can't believe you even keep responding to this drivel. I haven't ordered/bought Sword or Shield yet, but it's clear that Alex isn't the only one who thinks this game was FUN enough to deserve an 8. I'm still sceptical, but that's his opinion and I respect that and the most important thing are the things he actually wrote about, not the score. Comparing this game's score to a game that's decades old is just complete nonsense. Not only is that by a different person, but it's also in a different age/time. Anyone who tries to compare these scores and thinks they're making a valid argument are just acting.. silly.
Probably going to get downvoted, but am I the only one getting tired of this non-news about Untitled Goose Game? Yes, it's a fun game, but most of the posts about it are just social media nonsense.
I'm just wondering if this is ever going to sale significantly. I would think pricing a pack like this much cheaper would net you more money in the end, since so many more people would buy it.
Was already leaning towards Pokemon Sword and this announcement is definitely not changing my mind. Will still wait and see, so I can compare all versions exclusives and pick the one which has the ones I like most (which is how I choose all my Pokemon versions except Pokemon Red, because Charizard [plus not having a clue there were version exclusives until playing it with friends]).
Why would anyone do this on the Switch instead of a computer?
EDIT: Seeing as my comment apparently didn't go down well, I'll add that it's just my opinion and that I hope anyone who is interested in this will enjoy it and/or learn from it. ^^'
Comments 762
Re: Animal Crossing: New Horizons Has Already Exceeded Nintendo's Lifetime Sales Predictions
@playstation_king Zelda is clearly not a JRPG...
Re: Wii Hacker Dismisses Recent Nintendo Leak As "Complete Nonsense"
@Branovices I agree, it made me think the leak was fake, before reading the article of course.
Re: Review: Super Pixel Racers - Top-Down Racing Action That's Worth A Spin
"Your car auto-accelerates for one thing, while using a drift button to slide around corners will accrue boost for your nitro."
What does this mean exactly if I may ask? Does the car drive by itself or does letting go of the accelerate button not do anything?
Re: New Checkout Bot Targeting Online Switch Stock Is Driving The Scalpers Market In North America
@Shepdawg1 "Hopefully supply rebounds and they're left with an abundance of stock that they can't profit off of."
Exactly what I was thinking (and hoping)!
Re: Team17 Is Publishing Hokko Life On PC, And It Sure Gives Us Animal Crossing Vibes
@Yorumi I think you're just making assumptions about them purposely hiding it, without any real evidence to back it up, but I do agree it would've been better if there was at least a mention of the things that are missing.
Let's just hope all or at least most of the missing things will be added in the future, I'm sure we will both be happy about that!
Re: Team17 Is Publishing Hokko Life On PC, And It Sure Gives Us Animal Crossing Vibes
@Yorumi Right now you seem to be the one "getting so up in arms" about this. I already said it would've been nice if they included that information, but many reviews everywhere on the internet have incomplete information, that's also not the main purpose of a review. Like I said, it doesn't automatically make the review dishonest. If you think some "this game sux 0/10" review is equal to the the 10/10 review NintendoLife wrote for New Horizons, that's your opinion.
Bare in mind, I also don't think it's a 10/10, but I also don't think NL was being dishonest with their review. In the end no game is perfect and there's always going to be things that can be added/improved upon.
And there's always going to be inconsistencies when comparing one review to the other, especially when they're written by two different people.
Re: Team17 Is Publishing Hokko Life On PC, And It Sure Gives Us Animal Crossing Vibes
@Yorumi I guess for you them giving a 10/10 means they think it's absolutely perfect? Since they don't literally say that. I would think you've been around this site long enough to know a 10/10 here doesn't mean the game is perfect. And even if they do think that way, a review is subjective. I do think it would've been better if they mentioned all the missing stuff, but I wouldn't say not doing so is lying by omission.
I also would've loved to see more stores, furniture and special characters, but not having them doesn't seem to bring the game down for most people, or at least not by much.
Re: Team17 Is Publishing Hokko Life On PC, And It Sure Gives Us Animal Crossing Vibes
@Yorumi I never said they didn't cut anything, nor did I say the game is perfect. I also never implied that's not something worth noting in a review, however not noting it doesn't automatically make the review dishonest. Not sure what point you were trying to make.
Re: Team17 Is Publishing Hokko Life On PC, And It Sure Gives Us Animal Crossing Vibes
@Yorumi "In this game they cut about 70% of the content from NL just to give us terraforming(which btw proves how dishonest this site's reviews have become)."
Ah, the good old pulling statistics out of thin air and saying someone is being dishonest when they don't have the same opinion as you. Those make for some great arguments...
Re: Animal Crossing: New Horizons Update 1.1.3 Is Out Already, And It Fixes An Annoying Bug
@wariosmith I wouldn't hold your breath for that, highly doubt they will ever add that.
Re: Hands On: First Impressions Of Sea Of Stars, The Next Project From The Messenger Dev Sabotage
Those are some gorgeous Chrono Trigger-esque graphics with a modern twist!
Re: Random: It's OK, We Didn't Know There Was An Animal Crossing Movie Either
@Damo I understand you [one person] not knowing, but the title says "we", which implies no-one at Nintendo Life knew about this movie.
Re: Random: It's OK, We Didn't Know There Was An Animal Crossing Movie Either
So none of the people working at NL knew about this movie? At least that's what the title makes you believe.
Re: Recovering Your Animal Crossing: New Horizons Save Data From Nintendo Is A One-Time-Only Deal
@Unit_DTH If savegames were on the SD card, nobody would be complaining. Unfortunately, they're locked to the system, so unless you hack it, you can't access it..
Re: World Of Goo Is The Next Indie To Get A Physical Release On Switch
Sigh >,< (only sighing for my money), instant-buy. This game blew me away on WiiWare and with the amount of games I've played since then, this one really made an impact. Already bought it digitally again on Switch, but I won't be able to resist this one, it really is a master-class in awesome game design.
Re: Hold Up, Nintendo Is Now "Considering" Animal Crossing: New Horizons Cloud Save Support
@TioRogerio Me too, still have to find out what the amiibo's actually do though. I guess we will find that out in a Direct soon. ^^
Re: Hold Up, Nintendo Is Now "Considering" Animal Crossing: New Horizons Cloud Save Support
@TioRogerio That has already been confirmed.
Re: Video: See La-Mulana 1 & 2 In Action With This Brand New Gameplay Trailer
It's also being sold in Europe:
https://store.nisaeurope.com/collections/switch-1/products/la-mulana-1-2-nintendo-switch-limited-edition
Re: Devolver Digital's Switch eShop Sale Is On Now, And It Contains Some Proper Corkers
I highly recommend Broforce, especially at that price, though I think it's worth the full price as well. Amazingly fun and responsive side-scrolling shooter with very diverse characters that are a joy to play with. The destructible environment is great too. ^^
Re: Feature: Game Of The Decade Staff Picks - Miitomo
@Damo I guess you're referring to the word "nice"?
Re: Feature: Game Of The Decade Staff Picks - Miitomo
Nice click-bait..
Re: Hardware Review: Live Your Life As A Giant With The Tiny 8BitDo Zero 2 Controller
@Gravitron "despite being a purely digital input, the D-pad does not, in fact, behave like one – rather, it emulates the left analogue stick. This may seem trivial at first but this opens up the library of compatible games"
So while it doesn't change the fact it's a hard sell, this is not one of the reasons why.
Re: Soccer, Tactics & Glory Brings A Turn-Based Take On The Beautiful Game To Switch
Those are some very rough graphics, looks like a PS2 game to me.
Re: Miyamoto Would Rather Focus On New Nintendo Experiences Than Old Ones
I love Nintendo's franchises, but I also love how they dare to try new things. And while I'm at it, I also love Miyamoto for being the founding father of some of my most beloved franchises (and my number one most loved franchise, Zelda). With all he has accomplished and put out, he'd be hard pressed to do wrong in my book!
Re: Shigeru Miyamoto Wants Nintendo To Be As Big As Disney, But Concerned Parents Are Making It Difficult
@Sanangelo89 Yes please.
Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed
@antdickens I think it's great that you do, that's for sure! It's one of the things I love about this website, the engagement by the staff. ^^ Just felt like I've never seen these many responses before (for something that IMO doesn't deserve it), which could just be me, I don't go through every comment section, obviously.
Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed
@antdickens I can't believe you even keep responding to this drivel. I haven't ordered/bought Sword or Shield yet, but it's clear that Alex isn't the only one who thinks this game was FUN enough to deserve an 8. I'm still sceptical, but that's his opinion and I respect that and the most important thing are the things he actually wrote about, not the score. Comparing this game's score to a game that's decades old is just complete nonsense. Not only is that by a different person, but it's also in a different age/time. Anyone who tries to compare these scores and thinks they're making a valid argument are just acting.. silly.
Re: Nintendo Switch Has Now Sold 41.67 Million Units Worldwide, First Switch Lite Totals Revealed
@LinkSword Afaik digital sales are not included in these things, which means the software sales on Switch would be way higher.
Re: Nintendo's Shigeru Miyamoto To Be Recognised As A Person Of Cultural Merit In Japan
It makes you wonder what Nintendo would be without him.
Congratulations Miyamoto, IMO nobody in the gaming industry is more worthy of (life-time achievement) awards than you.
Re: You Can Now Get Switch Joy-Con Inspired By The GameCube Controller
@xzacutor Unbelievable how they would get something like that wrong. How hard is it to buy one Gamecube controller for reference. ^^'
On a more positive note, I do think they look quite nice and if I had as much love for the Gamecube as I do for the SNES, I'd probably want these.
Re: Feature: Pokémon, Zelda, Mario, Metroid... Nintendo’s Biggest Bugs, Glitches And Errors
Thoroughly enjoyed the article and even the caption, great job Gavin! ^^
Re: Random: Someone's Made A Fake Untitled Goose Game Spotify Soundtrack Of Rebellious Gangster Hits
Probably going to get downvoted, but am I the only one getting tired of this non-news about Untitled Goose Game? Yes, it's a fun game, but most of the posts about it are just social media nonsense.
Re: Mario Kart Tour's Diddy Kong Pack Costs £39, The Same Price As Mario Kart 8 Deluxe On Switch
I'm just wondering if this is ever going to sale significantly. I would think pricing a pack like this much cheaper would net you more money in the end, since so many more people would buy it.
Re: Animal Crossing: New Horizons, Luigi's Mansion 3 And More To Be Featured At Nintendo Live 2019
You're welcome. ^^ I obviously can't wait to see some more Animal Crossing!
Re: Nintendo Switch SNES Controllers Are Now Available To Buy In The UK And Europe
@Paperboy I sort of managed to get mine, but got an error after coming back from the payment website.. so now I'm not sure. >,<
Re: Nintendo Switch SNES Controllers Are Now Available To Buy In The UK And Europe
Did anyone actually manage to order one?
Re: Pokémon Sword And Shield's 'Glitched' Pokémon Is Sirfetch’d, A Version-Exclusive
Was already leaning towards Pokemon Sword and this announcement is definitely not changing my mind. Will still wait and see, so I can compare all versions exclusives and pick the one which has the ones I like most (which is how I choose all my Pokemon versions except Pokemon Red, because Charizard [plus not having a clue there were version exclusives until playing it with friends]).
Re: Hands On: Overland Is A Game Where You Don't Always Get To Save The Dog
Why has this been "reposted"?
Re: Official Sword And Shield Website Teases New Pokémon With Glitching Image
@Simon_Fitzgerald That seems a bit far-fetched... I'll let myself out.
Re: Review: FUZE4 Nintendo Switch - A Powerful Package That's For Serious Coders Only
@RasandeRose Fair enough. ^^
Re: Review: FUZE4 Nintendo Switch - A Powerful Package That's For Serious Coders Only
@AugustusOxy Sorry to disappoint you, but I wasn't thinking with a "hateboner" (whatever that's supposed to be).
Re: Review: FUZE4 Nintendo Switch - A Powerful Package That's For Serious Coders Only
@SteveZX81 Nice if that's the case for you!
@HikaruKitsune There's plenty of ways to learn how to use Unity (for example) for free though. Same goes for learning C(++).
Re: Poll: Box Art Brawl #7 - Star Fox
Not to be mean, but those Star Fox 2 covers look so amateuristic to me..
Re: Review: FUZE4 Nintendo Switch - A Powerful Package That's For Serious Coders Only
@ThainEshKelch True, I'm probably just too old to get its use. ^^'
Re: Review: FUZE4 Nintendo Switch - A Powerful Package That's For Serious Coders Only
Why would anyone do this on the Switch instead of a computer?
EDIT: Seeing as my comment apparently didn't go down well, I'll add that it's just my opinion and that I hope anyone who is interested in this will enjoy it and/or learn from it. ^^'
Re: Reminder: Tetris 99's $30 Physical Edition Is Now Available In North America
@HobbitGamer Exactly this. If I wasn't already subscribed to NSO and didn't already buy the DLC, I'd have bought this in a heartbeat.
Re: Reminder: Tetris 99's $30 Physical Edition Is Now Available In North America
@Paulywally With a 20 dollar worth online subscription..
Re: Guide: Where Can I Pre-Order The Nintendo Switch Super NES Controllers?
Those ZL and ZR buttons seem really awkward to use though.
EDIT: I got ninja'd. ^^'
Re: Award-Winning Steampunk Adventure 80 Days Races To Nintendo Switch Next Month
@luke88 Indeed, a little too much even.
Re: Review: Pokémon Masters - One Of The Best Pokémon Mobile Games, But Still Not Quite There
@BakaKnig "love gatcha systems"
Was reading your comment thinking "hmm interesting", until I read that and I all I could think was "what the..."