My copy of Dragon Quest V. Not just because it's an amazing game, but because I bought it new for 21 euros. It's going for almost ten times that price now.
@MajorTom You're absolutely right. Looks like many people didn't even read the question before answering the poll. I guess most people just look at the game they have played and judge ''Nintendo's'' year based off that.
''Once you've accepted what Federation Force is rather than what it isn't, it becomes a much easier game to enjoy and a thoroughly decent Metroid spin-off.'' ''Our score: 8/10'' Didn't know ''decent'' meant 8/10.
''And if you're more of a retro gamer, and you don't want to deal with season passes, microtransactions and so on (which are mainly optional, with games like FIFA giving a bad rep to DLC and add-ons that can actually be fun)''
Graphically it's one of the best GBC games, but I never liked the stage design. Gameplay-wise it was never that good imo. But hey, that's just me. I have played games from that era and earlier with much better stage design.
@gaga64 I don't really think it's fair to compare the price of a rom collection to the price of each retro game cartridge. If you put it that way the developers could charge about 50 euros for this collection and it would still be a ''good deal.''
My biggest problem with this collection is that it's 20 euros for 3 Game Boy games. If you compare this to the prices of Game Boy games on the 3ds Virtual Console, it's basically twice as expensive.
Indie games can be good, but I never consider them a big deal (1 or 2 exceptions aside). A few indies definitely do not make up for the lack of Nintendo games, their output has been quite low if you dont count Wii U ports. Thankfully I have a huge backlog and wont be bored, but I can definitely see why some people arent happy.
For what it was, it was good. However, it shouldn't have been this. A 3rd party only Direct when there are almost no Nintendo games to look forward to? It's bound to piss people off.
''The results [of Sticker Star] were mixed, and fan reaction was similarly diverse as a result.'' I'm pretty sure the fan reaction wasn't diverse: the majority was dissapointed.
@scully1888 Yes I do know that, however you all represent the same website. And a lot of reviews from this site fall into a very ''interesting'' pattern: it is very remarkable how a lot of ''controversial games'' get 8/10s from this website: Paper Mario Sticker Star/the Origami King, Star Fox 0, Pokémon Sword and Shield, the SuperStar Saga remake, the Wonderul 101, Federation Force, the list goes on. It seems like more than a strange coincidence how almost no ''controversial (nintendo) game'' gets a lower score than an 8 on this website. Except for the obvious bad games like Amiibo Festival.
That aside,I just can not understand how a game can score an 8/10 when even the reviewer admits that a lot of the time is spend on battles that are just not fun. Even when the rest of the game is fun, it just seems a bit too high, but that's just my opinion.
I agree with everything but the loading times...those are incredibly long in MHW. I prefer a couple of 4 second loading screens over a single loading time that is 3 minutes long
@Videogameguru50 I never said that just using an old engine made a game ''lazy''. Using an old engine does mean that you won't need to put as much effort into a game as in a brand new one, for what you need to make a new engine.
So they didn't need to put in a lot of effort into that aspect of the game. But then they just reused the same sprites as in Dream Team and Paper Jam, without slightly changing them to match the look of the original GBA game. That was the part where the developers DID need to put effort in, and they didn't.
And no. They did not remake Bowsers sprite in this game. They just used the one they used in Paper Jam and Dream Team.
TLDR: using an old engine is not lazy. But not even changing the sprites in that engine to match the source material in a remake is.
Comments 72
Re: Spike Chunsoft's Annual Survey Wants To Know More About Your Gaming Interests
Just remake Explorers of Sky PLEASE
Re: Talking Point: What's The Highlight Of Your Game Collection?
My copy of Dragon Quest V. Not just because it's an amazing game, but because I bought it new for 21 euros. It's going for almost ten times that price now.
Re: Switch Online N64 Controllers Were Restocked Today, Did You Get One? (North America)
Europe literally hasnt gotten a single restock. Meanwhile this is like the 3rd restock for the U.S.
Re: Talking Point: In An Age Of Endless Delays, Nintendo's First-Party Flow Is Extraordinary
I mean sure, this year is amazing. But we've also had years like 2018 with a very lackluster output from Nintendo.
Re: Talking Point: Is It Ever A Good Idea To Start At 'The Beginning' Of Series Like Zelda Or Dragon Quest?
@nukatha I will join you on that hill!
Re: Best Kirby Games Of All Time
Lists like these always feel like an ad for the new Switch game, or is it just me?
Re: Talking Point: Nintendo And Mobile Is An Uneasy Alliance, But It's Still Vital
"It's still vital." I'd argue it was never vital in the fist place for Nintendo. It's just extra money.
Re: Konami Is Celebrating Castlevania's 35th With An NFT Auction
And I thought the Zelda 35th anniversary was bad
Re: Poll: So, How Would You Rate Nintendo's 2021?
@MajorTom You're absolutely right. Looks like many people didn't even read the question before answering the poll. I guess most people just look at the game they have played and judge ''Nintendo's'' year based off that.
Re: Feature: 30 Years Of Sonic The Hedgehog - The Many Faces Of Mario's Biggest Rival
With just how many of the Sonic games are bad, I find it very surprising Sonic still has so many fans.
Re: Random: Fan Transforms N64 To Play Switch Games, Complete With Cart Reader And USB Inputs
I wish I could do the same with an NES-shell, that's some serious skill.
Re: Mini Review: art of rally - Stylish Driving With Plenty Of Substance
The Switch version of this game has become a joke on various subreddits for how downgraded the graphics are...
Re: Nintendo's Stock Price Sees Biggest Fall In Two Years Following Earnings Report
Nintendo is probably glad with this, since they wanted to buy their shares back.
Re: Best Metroid Games Of All Time
''Once you've accepted what Federation Force is rather than what it isn't, it becomes a much easier game to enjoy and a thoroughly decent Metroid spin-off.''
''Our score: 8/10''
Didn't know ''decent'' meant 8/10.
Re: Zelda: Skyward Sword HD Will Have "Various Quality-Of-Life Enhancements", Nintendo Says
''Master, your joycons appear to be drifting!''
Re: Talking Point: Why Metroid Dread Will Be Worth $60
Thankfully Nintendolife is here to defend the poor small indie company
Re: Metroid Games You Need To Play Before Metroid Dread
Lemme guess, you guys saw the post on reddit and decided to write a whole article about it?
Re: Nintendo Asks That You Don't Co-Stream The E3 2021 Nintendo Direct, Thanks Very Much
It's ridiculous Nintendo thinks they have any authority over something like this.
Re: Back Page: Things That Will Absolutely Definitely Happen During Nintendo's E3 2021 Direct
No mention of BotW2 at all. The internet will go insane.
Re: E3's Just Days Away, Yet Nintendo's Being Oddly Quiet About Its Plans
News: there is no news
Re: Talking Point: Do You Replay Games?
Where is the "I dont reread books because I dont read books" option?
Re: Talking Point: amiibo Have Always Been Physical DLC, Skyward Sword HD Is No Different
''If I defend a company this much, do you think they'll notice?''
Re: Soapbox: Be Happy, This Is The True Golden Age Of Gaming
''And if you're more of a retro gamer, and you don't want to deal with season passes, microtransactions and so on (which are mainly optional, with games like FIFA giving a bad rep to DLC and add-ons that can actually be fun)''
This really is a new low for this website.
Re: Talking Point: Surely It's Time For Game Boy On Nintendo Switch Online?
''we likely are close to the point when Nintendo enhances and improves Switch Online''
That's a very good joke
Re: Review: Shantae - A Dated Dance That Completes The Set On Switch
Graphically it's one of the best GBC games, but I never liked the stage design. Gameplay-wise it was never that good imo. But hey, that's just me. I have played games from that era and earlier with much better stage design.
Re: Nintendo Is Suing A Reported "Leader" Of The Notorious Piracy Group Team Xecuter
So many people blindly defending a company that doesn't care about them in this thread, it's pretty hilarious.
Re: Guinness World Records Has Declared This The 'World's Smallest Nintendo 64'
All that effort for a device that will have drifting sticks in a few months...
Re: Review: Ghosts 'n Goblins Resurrection - A Masochistic Medieval Marvel
Wow, even harder than the original games on the default setting? I definitely didn't expect that.
Re: Review: Collection of SaGa Final Fantasy Legend - A Nostalgic Curiosity, But That's About It
@gaga64 I don't really think it's fair to compare the price of a rom collection to the price of each retro game cartridge. If you put it that way the developers could charge about 50 euros for this collection and it would still be a ''good deal.''
Re: Review: Collection of SaGa Final Fantasy Legend - A Nostalgic Curiosity, But That's About It
My biggest problem with this collection is that it's 20 euros for 3 Game Boy games. If you compare this to the prices of Game Boy games on the 3ds Virtual Console, it's basically twice as expensive.
Re: Nintendo's Doug Bowser Talks About Switch Joy-Con Drift
Its just corporate speech, devoid of any meaning
Re: Review: FIFA 21 - EA Insults Switch Owners Yet Again With This Half-Baked Effort
Remember that Nintendolife headline about EA's releases for the Switch in the upcoming months, ''Now that's some support.'' Aged as well as milk...
Re: Ubisoft's Summer Blow Out Sale Is In Full Swing On Switch eShop (North America)
@abbyhitter I played both and I think the only big difference was a sidequest that gives you an extra partymember.
Re: Soapbox: We've Reached The Point-Of-No-Return In This Nindie Love Affair
Indie games can be good, but I never consider them a big deal (1 or 2 exceptions aside). A few indies definitely do not make up for the lack of Nintendo games, their output has been quite low if you dont count Wii U ports. Thankfully I have a huge backlog and wont be bored, but I can definitely see why some people arent happy.
Re: Is The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Taking To The Skies On Nintendo Switch?
Why is this tagged as news? Its a rumour.
Re: Watch: Nintendo Direct Mini: Partner Showcase July 2020
For what it was, it was good. However, it shouldn't have been this. A 3rd party only Direct when there are almost no Nintendo games to look forward to? It's bound to piss people off.
Re: Feature: Upcoming Nintendo Switch RPGs To Look Out For In 2020
Paper Mario: The Origami King is not an rpg. Even Nintendo itself says so: https://www.nintendo.co.uk/Games/Nintendo-Switch/Paper-Mario-The-Origami-King-1782440.html#gameDetails
Genre: adventure, action.
Re: Feature: The Complete History Of Paper Mario
''The results [of Sticker Star] were mixed, and fan reaction was similarly diverse as a result.''
I'm pretty sure the fan reaction wasn't diverse: the majority was dissapointed.
Re: Review: Paper Mario: The Origami King - A Puzzling Battle System Can't Kill This Funny Adventure
@scully1888 Yes I do know that, however you all represent the same website. And a lot of reviews from this site fall into a very ''interesting'' pattern: it is very remarkable how a lot of ''controversial games'' get 8/10s from this website: Paper Mario Sticker Star/the Origami King, Star Fox 0, Pokémon Sword and Shield, the SuperStar Saga remake, the Wonderul 101, Federation Force, the list goes on. It seems like more than a strange coincidence how almost no ''controversial (nintendo) game'' gets a lower score than an 8 on this website. Except for the obvious bad games like Amiibo Festival.
That aside,I just can not understand how a game can score an 8/10 when even the reviewer admits that a lot of the time is spend on battles that are just not fun. Even when the rest of the game is fun, it just seems a bit too high, but that's just my opinion.
Re: Review: Paper Mario: The Origami King - A Puzzling Battle System Can't Kill This Funny Adventure
An 8/10, just a reminder that this website also gave that very same score to...Sticker Star
Re: Yep, The New FIFA Game For Nintendo Switch Will Be Another Legacy Edition
"NoW ThAts SoMe SuPpOrT"
Re: Review: Bug Fables: The Everlasting Sapling - A Lovely Indie Tribute To Paper Mario
Since Nintendo refuses to make a new Mario RPG, I'm glad this exists. And for those of you saying that the Origami King might be a return to the classic Paper Mario formula, it probably won't be. Nintendo isn't even describing it as an rpg, but as an ''action, adventure'' game on their webpage: https://www.nintendo.co.uk/Games/Nintendo-Switch/Paper-Mario-The-Origami-King-1782440.html#gameDetails.
Re: PlatinumGames Was "Really Terrified" The Wonderful 101 Kickstarter Wouldn't Be A Success
Platinum Games: breathes
Nintendolife: Write that down! Write that down!
Re: Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE Encore Dances Onto Switch Early Next Year
I have literally been playing this game for the past week and have ~30 hours in it...all because I never expected this game to actually get a port XD
Re: Review: Caladrius Blaze - A Mechanically Competent Shmup With Gratuitous Presentation
An entire paragraph on why the author is against fanservice. Its just unprofessional to put that in a review.
Re: Feature: 30 Third-Party Nintendo Switch Ports We'd Love To See In 2019
And how is Monster Hunter Generations Ultimate a spin-off?
Re: Soapbox: Why I Prefer Monster Hunter Generations Ultimate To World
I agree with everything but the loading times...those are incredibly long in MHW. I prefer a couple of 4 second loading screens over a single loading time that is 3 minutes long
Re: Talking Point: What Are You Playing This Weekend? (August 18th)
Having finally completed Hyrule Warriors, I can pick up Octopath again
Re: Nintendo Download: 5th October (Europe)
Stardew Valley....finally!
Re: Review: Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions (3DS)
@Videogameguru50 I never said that just using an old engine made a game ''lazy''. Using an old engine does mean that you won't need to put as much effort into a game as in a brand new one, for what you need to make a new engine.
So they didn't need to put in a lot of effort into that aspect of the game. But then they just reused the same sprites as in Dream Team and Paper Jam, without slightly changing them to match the look of the original GBA game. That was the part where the developers DID need to put effort in, and they didn't.
And no. They did not remake Bowsers sprite in this game. They just used the one they used in Paper Jam and Dream Team.
TLDR: using an old engine is not lazy. But not even changing the sprites in that engine to match the source material in a remake is.