Why the .3? Assigning a number to a game is dumb at the best of times, but muddying that process by using redundant decimal points is moronic and one of the weirdest measuring sticks that is now popularised thanks to IGN.
Even though the whole "I work harder than these people" thing comes across as a little desperate and needy, I am behind what you're trying to say.
Dom consistently puts out reviews that either bring no new insight to a title (hive Mind type scores) or completely overlooks worrying trends and issues with games that are published by big name companies (NBA 2K and playground series).
@Ventilator the reason for no 45fps option is that home consoles are generally played on TVs. Most TVs operate at a refresh rate of 60hz, meaning the screen refreshes 60 times each second. That also means the maximum amount of frames a TV can output is 60. Games are either 30 or 60 because it's easily divisible by 60. That's why games at a locked 30fps can feel "smooth" because every second image displayed on the tv creates a level of consistency.
Because 60 is not exactly divisible by 45, it leads to weird frame pacing issues and may look, at times, to be either 30 or 60fps anyway because of the refresh rate of the display.
@GetShulked Was thinking about this today and ended up coming to the conclusion this may end up coming to fruition via potential GBA/N64 games with the Switch online service. Not the most ideal solution, but could be something.
@Scoopz My bad on the low res textures. That was just my low quality stream of the direct.
I'm still in the boat of "remaster" though as a side by side comparison shows every camera angle and movement to be nearly identical. I'd say all the coding it the same as it was with new models.
I can't help but feel this was a missed opportunity to not be bundled with X and released as some form of bundle.
As we know this got ported to 3DS, but it also got the Wii U "port" treatment as a downloadable Wii Game that was fully playable with the gamepad if people remember. That version cost a fraction of what this one will though
@Jonasty198460 8bitdo controller DOES have analog triggers, but it's uncertain whether or not they will be interpreted in that way by the Switch. Someone should test this in Trials
Does anyone else remember the smear campaign Sony fans put together for Bayonetta 2?
There were guides on YouTube telling people to buy ONLY second hand Wii Us and second hand copies of the game so that Nintendo saw no money from their playthroughs.
How dare that evil company! Funding the game that Sony and Microsoft refused to! #boycott
@Tao You reeeeeeaaaaaaally think that? Without programming fish to respond to sound, this sort of thing doesn't just miraculously happen. It's not likely that this is some unfortunate oversight or glitch.
@Mr_Muscle I hope you understand your comment is entirely subjective based off your personal experiences and not objective fact like your wording suggests you'd like it to be
@BenAV so I have a PayPal account linked to my Australian account, but when I switched it over to Russian, I got an error stating that my PayPal account was not linked to this region or something along those lines.
In theory, if I created a new account (or switched my second account to Russian), would I still be able to link the same PayPal account? Because I fear I'll just keep hitting the same issue.
With all the people saying it's "easy" to access this game from another eshop, how exactly do you do that? As someone without an international credit card, it becomes incredibly frustrating trying to purchase anything from a foreign eShop (and yes, I tried PayPal and it would not allow me to make purchases in foreign eshops).
Also worth noting is that SuperHot is SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper on the Russian, Polish and South African eShops compared to everywhere else in the world. Trying to purchase that game led me to my frustrations regarding this.
I feel a strategic port of any of the halo games to Switch before the launch of infinite (especially considering the bad press regarding its development this week - i.e. director leaving and microtransactions confirmed) would be beneficial in potentially driving sales of the next system by expanding the interest base.
Also Rare Replay in some form or another almost feels like a no-brainer for Switch at this point. At least the N64 era titles.
Well despite what the others have said here, I enjoyed my time with this game on launch as my friend had recently introduced me to the fun of MASHED and Micro Machines when played in local co-op.
There were a few things that struck me as strange though (like split screen between 3 people dividing the screen vertically rather than into 4 screens like most games), so I sent the development team a polite message suggesting an option to change this and never heard back from them despite saying my message will be addressed within 2-10 days or something.
@Cosats Boasting about being digital only doesn't make sense to me. The Switch has such little on board memory. High capacity micro SD card are still smaller and more expensive than external hard drives. You don't have the ability to lend, sell or trade digital media. Counties such as Australia still have terrible internet access and therefore it takes a criminally long time to install these large games relying entirely on wifi or ethernet.
Then there's the whole thing about potentially losing your digital media in the future with server shut downs, account hacking, accidentally using a hacked game, etc.
There's no excuse for physical media such as this to require you to download most of the game when there are game cards big enough to hold the majority of the data readily available.
@chardir except for the fact the game was in development longer than anyone knew about the Switch.
I think they made the right adjustments to the game to make "working on the Switch" the main focus towards the end of the development cycle, but it was never a game with primarily the Switch in mind. If anything, the other consoles took a hit to make the switch version look like more of a viable option (e.g. no 60fps mode even on PS4 Pro/XB1X).
"The general consensus here is that, despite being rather obviously inferior to its rivals from a technical point of view, the Switch version is solid enough to make a portable purchase worth it."
And come on @Dom. You guys are reviewers. Influencers. Unless you get some monetary kick back from the publishers, I feel like it's almost your responsibility to warn consumers away from these unfair money-grabbing implementations in these sorts of games. I am a die hard Lakers fan so I generally want to play as an assortment of Lakers players and that's about it most of the time. My initial free packs wouldn't give me "enough to get me by" in the game.
You KNOW people just scroll to the bottom to read the score before they make a buying decision.
If you have a microphone, use it to /say something/.
The gameplay being a little bit better, but twice the price of the first (with no way to now purchase the first game according to another one of your articles) is almost predatory by 2K's behalf. And just because they do it doesn't mean we should all just stand back and be okay with it.
I dunno. To me, review scores are a big indicator in determining whether a game is worthwhile to purchase or not. That is ultimately their one objective. But there's way too many factors hurting this game without me playing it.
First of all, I'm a huge basketball guy. I've played for over a decade at very high levels and have spent the last few years coaching kids at a representative level. I love the 2k games and buy them every year because I can look over the microtransactions and play the game for the on the court simulation. They're great imo
This game, however, is almost twice the price of the first game in Australia (first was $26, this is $48) because it has to keep the same pricing structure as the other machines due to them receiving a physical, something the Switch did not (at least in Australia). The other big off-putting factors (outside the completely unnecessary inclusion of micro transactions, regardless of how little they impact this game. This game arguable does it worse than 2k's main series as it at least lets you play as every player and every team as soon as you start it up which is what you WANT out of a basketball game) are that the visuals clearly look worse than last year's title considering they've had a longer time to work on it and a bigger budget, the frame rate is wildly inconsistent according to analysis videos on YouTube and that, overall it is hardly an improvement on last year's title aside from a few new camera angles and animations.
Considering it's a sports title as well, describing it as "great" is a stretch (your website's rating system, not mine. Also inherently the problem with video Game review scores in general. You guys have done a soapbox on that topic before, but regardless that's a whole other conversation). Great is a word used to describe only a select few in basketball. Kobe. Michael. Magic. Dr J. Wilt. Shaq. They are great players. You don't hear people call Channing Frye or Javale McGee or Julius Randle "Greats" yet they all do a pretty darn good job at what they do.
This game great? Seems a reach. Again, coming from a basketball fan who enjoyed the first but quickly grew bored of it. And for comparisons sake, I spent 155 hours in 2k18 without spending a cent more than what I paid for the game and got to play with whoever I wanted from the get go. I don't feel like grinding for hours just to play as the Lakers that I want to play as.
@Rika_Yoshitake but the Switch CAN run it. It was great playing it up until season 5 and even then it was very playable 80-90% of the time.
Yes, the Switch is "underpowered". Yes, this game was initially designed with more powerful hardware in mind, but that doesn't mean 30fps and a somewhat lower resolution in a cartoony looking game makes it unplayable. That's just the entitlement people have these days because of the technical marvels we have seen on other systems or by other developers.
@sanderev if you're playing solos constantly and not understanding the game mechanics or how to get better, I can understand why you'd find that boring.
However, if you're playing Duos or Squads with a group of friends that know what they're doing and having quality banter whilst you play, it is a loooooooot more enjoyable. Especially when you start getting those W's!
Comments 248
Re: You Can Now Play Online With Your Friends In Super Mario Maker 2
@sanderev
HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
GOOD ONE!
Re: Review: Ori And The Blind Forest: Definitive Edition - An Unmissable Experience
@sanderev
Why the .3?
Assigning a number to a game is dumb at the best of times, but muddying that process by using redundant decimal points is moronic and one of the weirdest measuring sticks that is now popularised thanks to IGN.
Re: Untitled Goose Game Is Out Now, And You Can Buy It Cheap For A Limited Time
HONK
Re: The File Size Of Luigi's Mansion 3 Isn't As Scary As You Probably Thought
@PBandSmelly looks like you've never tried game development
Re: Random: 3D Movement In Untitled Goose Game Was Inspired By Super Mario 64
@kepsux were you complaining about the coverage of BOTW, Odyssey or Smash?
This game is the same tier as those.
Re: If You Want NieR: Automata Ported To Nintendo Switch "Please Ask Square Enix"
@JayJ
You do realise it's not one or the other, right?
It's not like Square Enix are going to be like "oh you want Nier? As long as you throw out/delete your copy of Astral Chain, we'll see what we can do"
Re: Review: The Sinking City - A Solid Port For This Lovecraftian Detective Mystery
@nessisonett not just the website, but this exact reviewer.
I'm yet to see a review from Dom that surprises me. The screen grabs from Hylian Ticipated are quite humorous and intriguing imo
Re: Review: The Sinking City - A Solid Port For This Lovecraftian Detective Mystery
@Hylian_Ticipated
Even though the whole "I work harder than these people" thing comes across as a little desperate and needy, I am behind what you're trying to say.
Dom consistently puts out reviews that either bring no new insight to a title (hive Mind type scores) or completely overlooks worrying trends and issues with games that are published by big name companies (NBA 2K and playground series).
Re: Review: The Sinking City - A Solid Port For This Lovecraftian Detective Mystery
The pricing on the Australian eShop for this is great:
https://youtu.be/oT4rvYHMbvs
Re: Review: NBA 2K20 - An Impressive Port That Delivers The Full Experience On Switch
Everyone talking about microtransactions is one thing, but can we acknowledge they, again, stuck a nearly 40GB game on a 4gb cartridge?
That's just rude. Pass the storage coat on to the consumer and then expect them to pump more money into the game through the gambling features
STOP GIVING DOM THE SPORTS GAMES TO REVIEW
Re: Iron Galaxy Helped Bring Overwatch To Switch, Nintendo Version Runs At 30fps
@Ventilator that's not what motion blur does. Motion blur alleviates the "stuttery" look when panning the camera around
Re: Iron Galaxy Helped Bring Overwatch To Switch, Nintendo Version Runs At 30fps
@Ventilator https://youtu.be/K6jxhgMteB4
Seems to be a quite consistent 30fps. I think you are referring to motion blur
Re: Iron Galaxy Helped Bring Overwatch To Switch, Nintendo Version Runs At 30fps
@Ventilator I don't think you quite understand all of what you're saying.
It's like you've watched a couple DF videos and are regurgitating what they've said
Re: Iron Galaxy Helped Bring Overwatch To Switch, Nintendo Version Runs At 30fps
@Ventilator the reason for no 45fps option is that home consoles are generally played on TVs. Most TVs operate at a refresh rate of 60hz, meaning the screen refreshes 60 times each second. That also means the maximum amount of frames a TV can output is 60. Games are either 30 or 60 because it's easily divisible by 60. That's why games at a locked 30fps can feel "smooth" because every second image displayed on the tv creates a level of consistency.
Because 60 is not exactly divisible by 45, it leads to weird frame pacing issues and may look, at times, to be either 30 or 60fps anyway because of the refresh rate of the display.
Re: This Weekend's Smash Bros. Event Celebrates "The Ultimate Partnership"
@GetShulked
Was thinking about this today and ended up coming to the conclusion this may end up coming to fruition via potential GBA/N64 games with the Switch online service. Not the most ideal solution, but could be something.
Just a thought.
Re: Shulk Gets Another Encore In Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition For Switch
@Scoopz
My bad on the low res textures. That was just my low quality stream of the direct.
I'm still in the boat of "remaster" though as a side by side comparison shows every camera angle and movement to be nearly identical. I'd say all the coding it the same as it was with new models.
Re: Shulk Gets Another Encore In Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition For Switch
@Scoopz this ain't a remake. At least not from the trailer. You can still clearly see the low res assets
Re: Deadly Premonition 2 Is Coming To Switch, While The Original Is Available Right Now
@whanvee it's $45 AUD, so if imagine roughly $30 USD/GBP
Re: Bethesda Brings Hell To Switch This November With The Release Of DOOM 64
What a missed opportinunity not to release it in 14 years time to get that 11/22/33 date.
For real though, this has been rated by classifications boards already. Was surprised it wasn't a shadow drop for "after this presentation"
Re: Shulk Gets Another Encore In Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition For Switch
I can't help but feel this was a missed opportunity to not be bundled with X and released as some form of bundle.
As we know this got ported to 3DS, but it also got the Wii U "port" treatment as a downloadable Wii Game that was fully playable with the gamepad if people remember. That version cost a fraction of what this one will though
Re: Dante Returns To Switch In Devil May Cry 2 On 19th September, Pre-Purchase Now
An additional 10gb like the first one? With, of course, no physical option again?
Edit: eShop has this game listed as 1.7gb
Why is the first game so big??
Re: The Switch Version Of GRID Autosport Will Support GameCube Controllers
@Jonasty198460 8bitdo controller DOES have analog triggers, but it's uncertain whether or not they will be interpreted in that way by the Switch. Someone should test this in Trials
Re: The Switch Version Of GRID Autosport Will Support GameCube Controllers
@RedderRugfish the interest comes from the fact it suggests it will be compatible with analog triggers like Trials Rising was/is.
@KingBowser they've already given this game a release date on their Twitter account. Can't recall it off the top of my head however
Re: Hideki Kamiya Slaps Down Demands For Nintendo Switch Exclusive Astral Chain On PS4
Does anyone else remember the smear campaign Sony fans put together for Bayonetta 2?
There were guides on YouTube telling people to buy ONLY second hand Wii Us and second hand copies of the game so that Nintendo saw no money from their playthroughs.
How dare that evil company! Funding the game that Sony and Microsoft refused to! #boycott
Re: Players Discover Ultimate Way To Catch Fish In Zelda: Breath Of The Wild, Years After Release
@Tao
You reeeeeeaaaaaaally think that?
Without programming fish to respond to sound, this sort of thing doesn't just miraculously happen. It's not likely that this is some unfortunate oversight or glitch.
Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It
@Mr_Muscle
I hope you understand your comment is entirely subjective based off your personal experiences and not objective fact like your wording suggests you'd like it to be
Re: Hotline Miami Collection Removed From The Australian Switch eShop
@Prizm okay Hitler
Re: Hotline Miami Collection Removed From The Australian Switch eShop
@BenAV oh okay. Thanks for the response.
So if I set up a UK account do I need a UK address?
Re: Hotline Miami Collection Removed From The Australian Switch eShop
@BenAV so I have a PayPal account linked to my Australian account, but when I switched it over to Russian, I got an error stating that my PayPal account was not linked to this region or something along those lines.
In theory, if I created a new account (or switched my second account to Russian), would I still be able to link the same PayPal account? Because I fear I'll just keep hitting the same issue.
Re: Hotline Miami Collection Removed From The Australian Switch eShop
With all the people saying it's "easy" to access this game from another eshop, how exactly do you do that? As someone without an international credit card, it becomes incredibly frustrating trying to purchase anything from a foreign eShop (and yes, I tried PayPal and it would not allow me to make purchases in foreign eshops).
Also worth noting is that SuperHot is SIGNIFICANTLY cheaper on the Russian, Polish and South African eShops compared to everywhere else in the world. Trying to purchase that game led me to my frustrations regarding this.
Can anyone give me advice on how to remedy this?
Re: Microsoft Has "No Plans" To Bring More First-Party Exclusives To Other Consoles
I feel a strategic port of any of the halo games to Switch before the launch of infinite (especially considering the bad press regarding its development this week - i.e. director leaving and microtransactions confirmed) would be beneficial in potentially driving sales of the next system by expanding the interest base.
Also Rare Replay in some form or another almost feels like a no-brainer for Switch at this point. At least the N64 era titles.
Re: Mantis Burn Racing Gets A Physical Release In North America On 12th December
Well despite what the others have said here, I enjoyed my time with this game on launch as my friend had recently introduced me to the fun of MASHED and Micro Machines when played in local co-op.
There were a few things that struck me as strange though (like split screen between 3 people dividing the screen vertically rather than into 4 screens like most games), so I sent the development team a polite message suggesting an option to change this and never heard back from them despite saying my message will be addressed within 2-10 days or something.
I think it's been roughly 2 years now...
Re: Play An Unannounced Team17 Game At PAX West Later This Month
Peculiar. I ponder the content of the soon to be revealed game announcement
Re: This Fully-Functioning Calculator Course In Super Mario Maker 2 Is Utter Genius
People did this in Mario Maker for Wii U too.
I remember seeing YouTube tutorials on how this works.
Re: This Might Be The Actual File Size For The Spyro Reignited Trilogy On Switch
@Cosats Boasting about being digital only doesn't make sense to me. The Switch has such little on board memory. High capacity micro SD card are still smaller and more expensive than external hard drives. You don't have the ability to lend, sell or trade digital media. Counties such as Australia still have terrible internet access and therefore it takes a criminally long time to install these large games relying entirely on wifi or ethernet.
Then there's the whole thing about potentially losing your digital media in the future with server shut downs, account hacking, accidentally using a hacked game, etc.
There's no excuse for physical media such as this to require you to download most of the game when there are game cards big enough to hold the majority of the data readily available.
Re: Feature: The Best Movie Licences On Nintendo Systems
No South Park? Just finished Fractured But Whole and it's so far been one of my favourite games on Switch in general
Re: Spyro Reignited Trilogy To Require Additional Download In North America, But Not Europe?
@KoekiieWoekiie the game only ran at 1440p on both the pro and X.
You'll notice the box art for the Xbox One version doesn't have the usual "Xbox One X Enhanced" logo in the top right corner as a result.
Re: Random: Two Nintendo Presidents Are Listed In The End Credits Of Starlink: Battle For Atlas
@chardir except for the fact the game was in development longer than anyone knew about the Switch.
I think they made the right adjustments to the game to make "working on the Switch" the main focus towards the end of the development cycle, but it was never a game with primarily the Switch in mind. If anything, the other consoles took a hit to make the switch version look like more of a viable option (e.g. no 60fps mode even on PS4 Pro/XB1X).
Re: Elon Musk Couldn't Convince Nintendo To Add Mario Kart To Tesla's Electric Car Line
@Ttimer5 seems like you misread the heading and not the article
Re: Video: Digital Foundry Analyses Panic Button's Porting Efforts With Warframe On Switch
"The general consensus here is that, despite being rather obviously inferior to its rivals from a technical point of view, the Switch version is solid enough to make a portable purchase worth it."
A purchase of a free game?
Re: Random: Here's Why One Of The World's Best National Teams Isn't In FIFA 19
E. A. Sports.
It's in the game.
Re: NBA 2K Playgrounds 2 Gets Free Halloween DLC, But Switch Players Will Have To Wait
"8/10 - Great!"
...Great is a very strong word
Re: Review: NBA 2K Playgrounds 2 - Microtransactions Can't Sink This Enjoyable B-Ball Romp
And come on @Dom.
You guys are reviewers. Influencers. Unless you get some monetary kick back from the publishers, I feel like it's almost your responsibility to warn consumers away from these unfair money-grabbing implementations in these sorts of games. I am a die hard Lakers fan so I generally want to play as an assortment of Lakers players and that's about it most of the time. My initial free packs wouldn't give me "enough to get me by" in the game.
You KNOW people just scroll to the bottom to read the score before they make a buying decision.
If you have a microphone, use it to /say something/.
The gameplay being a little bit better, but twice the price of the first (with no way to now purchase the first game according to another one of your articles) is almost predatory by 2K's behalf. And just because they do it doesn't mean we should all just stand back and be okay with it.
Re: Review: NBA 2K Playgrounds 2 - Microtransactions Can't Sink This Enjoyable B-Ball Romp
I dunno. To me, review scores are a big indicator in determining whether a game is worthwhile to purchase or not. That is ultimately their one objective. But there's way too many factors hurting this game without me playing it.
First of all, I'm a huge basketball guy. I've played for over a decade at very high levels and have spent the last few years coaching kids at a representative level. I love the 2k games and buy them every year because I can look over the microtransactions and play the game for the on the court simulation. They're great imo
This game, however, is almost twice the price of the first game in Australia (first was $26, this is $48) because it has to keep the same pricing structure as the other machines due to them receiving a physical, something the Switch did not (at least in Australia). The other big off-putting factors (outside the completely unnecessary inclusion of micro transactions, regardless of how little they impact this game. This game arguable does it worse than 2k's main series as it at least lets you play as every player and every team as soon as you start it up which is what you WANT out of a basketball game) are that the visuals clearly look worse than last year's title considering they've had a longer time to work on it and a bigger budget, the frame rate is wildly inconsistent according to analysis videos on YouTube and that, overall it is hardly an improvement on last year's title aside from a few new camera angles and animations.
Considering it's a sports title as well, describing it as "great" is a stretch (your website's rating system, not mine. Also inherently the problem with video Game review scores in general. You guys have done a soapbox on that topic before, but regardless that's a whole other conversation).
Great is a word used to describe only a select few in basketball. Kobe. Michael. Magic. Dr J. Wilt. Shaq. They are great players. You don't hear people call Channing Frye or Javale McGee or Julius Randle "Greats" yet they all do a pretty darn good job at what they do.
This game great? Seems a reach. Again, coming from a basketball fan who enjoyed the first but quickly grew bored of it. And for comparisons sake, I spent 155 hours in 2k18 without spending a cent more than what I paid for the game and got to play with whoever I wanted from the get go. I don't feel like grinding for hours just to play as the Lakers that I want to play as.
Re: Review: The Room - A Touchscreen Classic That Feels a Little Sparse On A Home Console
@MagicEmperor
I literally came here to post that exact comment
Re: Fortnite Update On Switch Sacrifices Video Capture Feature To Enhance Performance
@Rika_Yoshitake but the Switch CAN run it. It was great playing it up until season 5 and even then it was very playable 80-90% of the time.
Yes, the Switch is "underpowered". Yes, this game was initially designed with more powerful hardware in mind, but that doesn't mean 30fps and a somewhat lower resolution in a cartoony looking game makes it unplayable. That's just the entitlement people have these days because of the technical marvels we have seen on other systems or by other developers.
Re: Nintendo Spends Big On Television Advertising In Month Of August To Fend Off Spider-Man
@Seacliff how do you make that connection at all?
If anything it's more like Sunset Overdrive considering it's Insomniac
Re: Random: Hasbro Launching Officially Licensed Fortnite Nerf Blasters In 2019
@sanderev if you're playing solos constantly and not understanding the game mechanics or how to get better, I can understand why you'd find that boring.
However, if you're playing Duos or Squads with a group of friends that know what they're doing and having quality banter whilst you play, it is a loooooooot more enjoyable. Especially when you start getting those W's!