Comments 180

Re: Paper Mario Producer Says His Team Has "Almost Complete Control" Over Creative Direction

Nemesis666

@Toy_Link Yes, Tanabe mentioned first and he mentioned something before as well. I believe this is true because something similar was said two years ago by Aquamarine, a nintendo insider that had info

https://www.resetera.com/threads/tanabe-paper-mario-it%E2%80%99s-no-longer-possible-to-modify-mario-characters-or-to-create-original-characters-that-touch-on-the-mario-universe.249178/page-7#post-39857767

As for giving it to Miyamoto, all the interviewed talked about Miyamoto and that was it. It was an Iwata asks so it was revised and so on, so it's pretty clear that there was no false info on there as all of that would have a overseen there. Tanabe, Kudo and other involved also gave their own opinion on the matter there.

And yes, Tanabe said this on 2020 much like Risa said, which is why it's clear to me that this isn't a politic for either of them but Nintendo as a company. i don't know if Mario & luigi will come back or if with it on hiatus now they'll try to make paper mario as rpg again, but that's the situation.

And as far as the IP team, I can't say anything without looking at the guideline, which we probably never will. But considering how open Tanabe has been with info and Nagaya also is, I hope more details surface. I don't think all will be out if it does, considering how much rules probably exists in cases like these, but would be cool to see how it is.

Re: Paper Mario Producer Says His Team Has "Almost Complete Control" Over Creative Direction

Nemesis666

@LinkSword Are you going to ignore the fact that Nagaya literally says the same thing? Why are you ignoring the fact that the director of the game literally agree with him on this mater? Open the Nintendo Everything interview and you'll understand what I mean, considering how Nintendolife cuts the interview.

@Maxz You clearly have no idea how an IP team works. IP team in any company is for external matters, so license for merchandise, for characters in games like Mario+Rabbids which is a product from another company and in this case, a development from a contractor in a game produced and published by Nintendo. Anyone working on a project like this would have guidelines to follow, much like it happens on any other company.

Also, Nintendo EAD is dead for more than 5 years since its merger.

@NEStalgia That's not how it is. Those things didn't began after Iwata died. It began already on him there. The link I posted before says things that are connected with what Tanabe says about how this IP team was created in 2009 after Super Paper Mario to oversee the mario brand on games of the series made by contractors.

Aside from this, the only change that happened since Iwata's death was the merger of the development and production divisions of Nintendo EAD and Nintendo SPD into Nintendo EPD and other divisions inside of Nintendo, which reorganized into 3 main ones. With that said, this happened just a few months after his death so it's obvious that this came from him as a reorganization can't and won't happen fast like this.

Re: Paper Mario Producer Says His Team Has "Almost Complete Control" Over Creative Direction

Nemesis666

@Toy_Link Stop spreading misinformation. Tanabe didn't blame Miyamoto at all (that was said by Iwata and Tanabe on Iwata ask, along Kudo), he never said anything about Alpha Dream either in 2016 (Risa Tabata said) and the IP team isn't something he said alone but also by Nagaya, who is the IS director in the game and also confirmed. If those things were untrue, Nintendo would come to public and deconfirm.

Re: Paper Mario Producer Says His Team Has "Almost Complete Control" Over Creative Direction

Nemesis666

Also I love how Nintendo Life don't pick the entire quote. If you guys are going to pick the translation from Nintendo Everything, at least pick all of it instead of just one sentence from Nagaya. Would also be cool to point out that Tanabe is a Nintendo employee and Nagaya is part of IS to not make confusing.

Same for that title focusing only on Tanabe as if Nagaya isn't part of the interview.

This site is really a mess.

Re: Paper Mario Producer Says His Team Has "Almost Complete Control" Over Creative Direction

Nemesis666

@Not-Geno "This dude" is a person who have been working on Nintendo for more than 30 years. I know you guys don't do any kind of research on the company you all love but at least try to do it before commenting. Would be nice to see who Tanabe is and what he worked at Nintendo.

@Moonlessky This isn't some "PR nonsense". What he's talking about is something that exists on lots of companies and what he said already has been said by an insider in resetera 2 years ago about how this IP team was created:

https://www.resetera.com/threads/tanabe-paper-mario-it%E2%80%99s-no-longer-possible-to-modify-mario-characters-or-to-create-original-characters-that-touch-on-the-mario-universe.249178/page-7#post-39857767

@Snakesglowcaps None of this will taken away. This IP team exists since 2009 when Iwata still was president and continues to this day. Most companies in entertainment have it and Nintendo began to have it for contracted companies as well.

Re: Nintendo Is Reportedly Japan's Richest Company Of 2020

Nemesis666

@Clyde_Radcliffe BOTW don't count, I see. So I guess Persona 5, Yakuza 0 and Yakuza Kiwami don't count as PS4 games as they launched on PS3 as well, same for Twilight Princess. Interesting.

Also, your notion of only counting Nintendo developed games is ridiculous man. All of those games are produced by Nintendo EPD, have producers, coordinators, directors

Why do you think Tanabe in Paper Mario has influence? It isn't because it's Mario, it's because it's a game published by Nintendo that has Nintendo staff on it. Why do you think that Kaori Ando is credited as director on Astral Chain when she's a nINTENDO employee? Nintendo has an entire section on Nintendo EPD from the time of Nintendo SPD where they work with external developed games. I recommend you to give a look at staff and credits because you only counting internally developed games is absurd when Nintendo always had more external developed games than internal ones, which is clear when Pokémon, Kirby, Fire Emblem, Smash Bros, Paper mario, Mario & Luigi and so many of their series were never developed by them but outside, with Nintendo overseeing.

I recommend you to give a look to this:
https://www.resetera.com/threads/nintendo-first-party-thread-ot3-internal-x-external-x-publishing-whats-cooking.116419/

Re: Nintendo Is Reportedly Japan's Richest Company Of 2020

Nemesis666

@Clyde_Radcliffe Yeah, when you take out Wii U ports (which are just 8) it's fairly weak. Wait, no, it isn't. Let's Smash Bros Ultimate, Astral Chain, Splatoon 2, BOTW, Arms, Snipperclips, Tetris 99, Ring Fit Adventure, AC New Horizons, Yoshi Crafted World, Fire Emblem Threehouses, Super Mario Odyssey, Xenoblade 2 and many more don't exist, I see.

Also, I love how Nintendo don't make new experiences on a console where they released Labo and Ring Fit Adventure, two experiences that are very traditional!

Re: Nintendo Is Reportedly Japan's Richest Company Of 2020

Nemesis666

@Razer Whoa, their output don't appeal to everyone? What a surprise! Here's a secret: The output of Nintendo won't ever appeal to everyone, neither will from any other company in this business. That's literally impossible.

You ignore the fact that there's things called resources be it in money or human resources and many companies nintendo contracts and Nintendo itself are responsible for franchises. If you're not interested in Kirby or Fire Emblem, they won't stop to make them because of you.

Re: Nintendo Is Reportedly Japan's Richest Company Of 2020

Nemesis666

@Hobbesyall Yes, Furukawa is riding on predecessors when he's part of Nintendo for his entire life and is president of the company since then. Also, I love how you think that a president does everything in a company as if a board of directors don't exist, neither other tons of different internal positions.

Re: Nintendo To Host 'Management Briefing Session' Next Month, Days After Mario's 35th Anniversary

Nemesis666

@Ambassador_Kong Your post is absurd. I have been buying games on Switch during the entire year with new indie and third party games. Stop playing just Nintendo games and expand your horizons, which even with Nintendo itself, they have launched a lot of games this year, with Clubhouse Games and Paper Mario Origami King on the last two months.

And to think that "not focusing in two platforms" would mean more games is to have zero understanding of development. 3DS games are 240p, much smaller scale, have less staff, budget, have in many times the same people working on those projects and console projects, etc. This thinking makes no sense due to this, as HD development focus will make things much above than developing for a hardware like 3DS.

Re: Yep, The Switch Has Now Outsold The NES

Nemesis666

@DrJoson No, we shouldn't. The Switch is considered by Nintendo and by all market a home console with handheld capacities. There's a reason for why the games are $60 and the console is more expensive instead of being $40 in its base game.

Re: Retro Studios Reminds Us It's In Need Of A Lead Producer For Metroid Prime 4

Nemesis666

@Slowdive Tanabe NEVER was executive producer in his career. A basic research of his works show this. But yes, you're right that games have more than one producer, even more when it's a game that has a different developer and publisher. Tanabe here is the Nintendo producer of the project, so he obviously doesn't count, which is why Retro wants more lead producers inside the company.