@wazlon @NintendoFan4Lyf The mini-DVD problem could easily be fixed by splitting the game into multiple discs. Third-parties didn't have a problem with that on the PS1 before, and they didn't have a problem with that with the Xbox 360 after.
The Xbox used DVD's, but still got demolished by the PS2 in sales.
I think Nintendo Life is correct with why the GameCube failed.
"On paper, EA’s decision to field the B team makes some sense, as did the ‘Legacy’ versions that got released on Wii. In its launch week just 1% of FIFA 19’s physical sales in the UK were for the Switch version (this didn’t account for digital sales, but we don’t imagine them being much better). On the face of it, this indicates that the audience simply doesn’t exist on Switch to warrant putting effort into anything other than a ‘legacy’ (read: old) release."
The U.K. is never a good sample of sale performances on Nintendo consoles, considering that it's Nintendo's weakest region. In contrast, the head of Nintendo's French division was pleased with FIFA's sales. And in Japan FIFA 18 on Switch is believed to have outsold the PS4 version!
EA has no one to blame but themselves. They are not doing their best.
@Heavyarms55 Detective Pikachu showed that a live-action video game movie can be done well. That, and making it animation doesn't mean it's going to be good. Look at Pokémon, it's had 21 movies ranging from mediocre to dreadful, yet it's live adaptation blows them all away.
@Itzdmo You do know once you get the figurine, you can unlock anything compatible with it and any future stuff as well. You won't need to buy things separately.
You can also save data to an Amiibo and use it elsewhere.
How this is somehow worse than lootboxes is rather insane.
I actually knew about this character before the video existed. I lost my other 3DS and had to buy a new one, had to redownload all my games and DLC. You won't have to pay another penny for Rusty's Real Deal Baseball, and hence no need to haggle. That's when I got to see the old dog!
@Silly_G You said this earlier: "I dread this being enormously successful for that will only indicate that the worst is yet to come. Different strokes, I guess. I still enjoy watching some of the traditionally animated Pokémon films from Japan though."
It appears that you're complaining about the aesthetics about the movie and how it is a "b******dization" of the Pokémon IP. If you have this much of a problem with the aesthetics, then the problem is on you, not the movie. The idea that Hollywood does not meet "social, cultural, artistic/literary, and/or historical merit", and "are often disappointingly unambitious in their storytelling" isn't remotely true, there are plenty of fantastic movies that meet one or more of those qualities.
You sure sound jealous due to the fact that Detective Pikachu is positioned to become a financial hit and succeed critically whereas the anime movies have not.
@Silly_G I bet you think that the Pokémon anime movies were good. You seem rather jealous that Detective Pikachu is getting better-received than those crapfests.
It should be noticed that Detective Pikachu is currently the highest rated video game based film in Rotten Tomatoes, with a score of 69% as of this writing, beating Rampage's 52%. It also breaks the record of The Power of Us, which is at 60%, if we include movies with limited theatrical releases.
AFAIK, only Yo-Kai Watch: The Movie and Resident Evil: Damnation rank higher, but they weren't released in theaters in the west.
@Kutal Actually, a great movie needs to appeal to everyone, not just enthusiasts. This is where the Pokémon anime movies failed and where Detective Pikachu succeeds.
Comments 396
Re: Video: Pokémon: Mewtwo Strikes Back - Evolution Gets Gorgeous New Movie Trailer
Another year, another crappy Pokémon anime movie. I'd rather watch Detective Pikachu again.
Re: Sony Doesn't See Nintendo As A Major Rival, More Worried About Microsoft Next Generation
@Luna_110 To be fair that picture turned out to be inaccurate.
Re: Sony Doesn't See Nintendo As A Major Rival, More Worried About Microsoft Next Generation
@zool If you were paying attention to recent news, Nintendo is much more likely to team up with Microsoft than with Sony.
Re: Sony Doesn't See Nintendo As A Major Rival, More Worried About Microsoft Next Generation
@darthstuey Those three games are also on Xbox
Re: Nintendo Has No Plans To Censor Video Games Like Sony
@DDFawfulGuy What games did they censor?
Re: Nintendo Has No Plans To Censor Video Games Like Sony
@Andigaming What games did they censor?
Re: Tweet Analysis Reveals Controversial Pokémon Cull Has Fans Evenly Split
This article needs to be considered pseudoscience.
Re: The Wii U Just Received Its First Firmware Update For 2019
Most underrated console of all time.
Re: Ubisoft Happy To Be "The Last Game On Wii" With Just Dance 2020
@chardir Axiom Verge was released physically on Wii U this year, if that means anything.
Re: A Forgotten (And Kirby-Free) HAL SNES Title Has Been Preserved For The Ages
So Nintendo owns the copyright to this game... would that make this game or Kirby's Dream Land the first Nintendo-HAL collaboration?
Re: Former Epic Games Director Says He Tried To Axe Fortnite
@AlternateButtons You seem upset.
Re: Feature: Every Nintendo Console Ranked From Worst To Best
@wizzgamer The Wii was niche? Did you really just say that? Please use your head next time.
Re: Feature: Every Nintendo Console Ranked From Worst To Best
@wazlon @NintendoFan4Lyf The mini-DVD problem could easily be fixed by splitting the game into multiple discs. Third-parties didn't have a problem with that on the PS1 before, and they didn't have a problem with that with the Xbox 360 after.
The Xbox used DVD's, but still got demolished by the PS2 in sales.
I think Nintendo Life is correct with why the GameCube failed.
Re: Random: Animal Crossing's Angry Mole Mr. Resetti Has Lost His Job
First he was cut in Smash Bros. as an assist trophy, now he's losing his job. Poor guy can't get a break.
Re: Random: The Nintendo Wii Simply Refuses To Die
@azoreseuropa You've met with a terrible fate, haven't you?
Re: Soapbox: EA’s Approach To FIFA On Switch Is Typically Short-Sighted
"On paper, EA’s decision to field the B team makes some sense, as did the ‘Legacy’ versions that got released on Wii. In its launch week just 1% of FIFA 19’s physical sales in the UK were for the Switch version (this didn’t account for digital sales, but we don’t imagine them being much better). On the face of it, this indicates that the audience simply doesn’t exist on Switch to warrant putting effort into anything other than a ‘legacy’ (read: old) release."
The U.K. is never a good sample of sale performances on Nintendo consoles, considering that it's Nintendo's weakest region. In contrast, the head of Nintendo's French division was pleased with FIFA's sales. And in Japan FIFA 18 on Switch is believed to have outsold the PS4 version!
EA has no one to blame but themselves. They are not doing their best.
Re: Future Versions Of FIFA On Switch Could Be Legacy Editions, Just Like FIFA 20
@Trajan You've missed out on plenty of games. The Wii U was also for hardcore gamers and Miyamoto said that too.
Re: Future Versions Of FIFA On Switch Could Be Legacy Editions, Just Like FIFA 20
@jarvismp The richer don't get richer if people don't buy from them. Vote with your wallets and keep others informed.
Re: Future Versions Of FIFA On Switch Could Be Legacy Editions, Just Like FIFA 20
@Scollurio In Japan the Switch version of FIFA 18 actually outsold the PS4 version. Take it as you will.
Re: FIFA 20 On Switch Will Be A Scaled-Back "Legacy Edition"
@Trajan The Wii, 3DS and Wii U had plenty of fantastic games. "Dark years" my balls.
Re: FIFA 20 On Switch Will Be A Scaled-Back "Legacy Edition"
@sixrings Look what happened to Sega, sixrings. They're a total shadow of their former selves.
Let's not have Nintendo do the same thing.
Re: FIFA 20 On Switch Will Be A Scaled-Back "Legacy Edition"
@LuciferOnReddit That's gonna be a heavy task, especially in Europe.
Re: FIFA 20 On Switch Will Be A Scaled-Back "Legacy Edition"
Will Nintendo call EA out on this?
Re: Worry Not, The Sonic Movie Trailer Has Been Fixed Now
@Heavyarms55 Detective Pikachu showed that a live-action video game movie can be done well. That, and making it animation doesn't mean it's going to be good. Look at Pokémon, it's had 21 movies ranging from mediocre to dreadful, yet it's live adaptation blows them all away.
Re: Previously Unseen Footage Of EarthBound 64 Emerges Online
@Hordak I'd bet had Earthbound 64 been released, people would look back at it fondly, not say it didn't age well.
Re: Natsume Announces Harvest Moon: Mad Dash For Nintendo Switch
@Alucard83 You can play Stardew Valley if old-school graphics is what you want.
Re: All Those amiibo On Your Shelf? You Can't Use Them In Super Mario Maker 2
@Itzdmo You do know once you get the figurine, you can unlock anything compatible with it and any future stuff as well. You won't need to buy things separately.
You can also save data to an Amiibo and use it elsewhere.
How this is somehow worse than lootboxes is rather insane.
Re: All Those amiibo On Your Shelf? You Can't Use Them In Super Mario Maker 2
@tr573 You are very selfish, you know that, kid?
Re: Spice And Wolf Brings A VR Anime Experience To The Switch This Summer
@FlyingFoxy There are plenty of childish anime, you are deeply mistaken.
Re: Resident Evil 4 On Switch Is Missing Something Pretty Major For Nintendo Fans
@ShaiHulud Therefore, you have a phobia. You'd best lose it.
Re: Rumour: New Ubisoft IP Supposedly Leaked Ahead Of E3 2019
@Agramonte What bothers you about the game?
Re: Resident Evil 4 On Switch Is Missing Something Pretty Major For Nintendo Fans
@sinn1 Because they're fun? Did that ever come to mind?
Re: Resident Evil 4 On Switch Is Missing Something Pretty Major For Nintendo Fans
@Disco_K Lose your phobia for motion controls. It can bring new life to plenty of games.
Re: Resident Evil 4 On Switch Is Missing Something Pretty Major For Nintendo Fans
@Ulysses You should lose your phobia for motion controls and give it another try.
Re: Resident Evil 4 On Switch Is Missing Something Pretty Major For Nintendo Fans
@ShaiHulud people need to lose their phobia for motion controls, including you, Shai.
They can be a great experience when done correctly.
Re: Nintendo Switch Overtakes PS4's Lifetime Sales In Japan
@GrailUK The sales numbers show that plenty of people need them. Hurts, doesn't it?
Re: Video: Meet Pappy Van Poodle, The Nintendo Character Nobody Knew Existed
I actually knew about this character before the video existed. I lost my other 3DS and had to buy a new one, had to redownload all my games and DLC. You won't have to pay another penny for Rusty's Real Deal Baseball, and hence no need to haggle. That's when I got to see the old dog!
Re: Random: One Episode Of The Pokémon Anime Has Been 'Banned' From Airing In The West
The actual offense is turning Ash into a phenomenal failure in order to get him there to begin with. I share you this link:
https://www.nintendolife.com/forums/general_discussion/the_big_problem_with_the_pokemon_anime_-_an_essay_and_a_rant_warning_long
Anyone who still watches the anime at this point is supporting corruption.
Re: Movie Review: Pokémon Detective Pikachu Does Enough To Break The 'Bad Video Game Movie' Curse
@Silly_G You said this earlier: "I dread this being enormously successful for that will only indicate that the worst is yet to come. Different strokes, I guess. I still enjoy watching some of the traditionally animated Pokémon films from Japan though."
It appears that you're complaining about the aesthetics about the movie and how it is a "b******dization" of the Pokémon IP. If you have this much of a problem with the aesthetics, then the problem is on you, not the movie. The idea that Hollywood does not meet "social, cultural, artistic/literary, and/or historical merit", and "are often disappointingly unambitious in their storytelling" isn't remotely true, there are plenty of fantastic movies that meet one or more of those qualities.
You sure sound jealous due to the fact that Detective Pikachu is positioned to become a financial hit and succeed critically whereas the anime movies have not.
Re: Talking Point: Detective Pikachu & Let's Go Are The Keys To A New Pokémon Audience
@dimi "Nintendo should focus on hardcore gamers"
They tried that with the Wii U and it failed.
Re: Video: Fan Recreates Smash Bros. Melee Opening With Smash Ultimate's Video Editor
It was a good attempt, even if it didn't capture everything of what made the original so great.
Re: Talking Point: Detective Pikachu & Let's Go Are The Keys To A New Pokémon Audience
If there's one certainty about Pokémon, it's that Ash Ketchum will never win a Pokémon league.
Re: Movie Review: Pokémon Detective Pikachu Does Enough To Break The 'Bad Video Game Movie' Curse
@Jaalsky The Pokémon anime movies were all bad and contributed to the "bad video game movie curse".
Re: Movie Review: Pokémon Detective Pikachu Does Enough To Break The 'Bad Video Game Movie' Curse
@Silly_G I bet you think that the Pokémon anime movies were good. You seem rather jealous that Detective Pikachu is getting better-received than those crapfests.
I look forward to seeing the film.
Re: Movie Review: Pokémon Detective Pikachu Does Enough To Break The 'Bad Video Game Movie' Curse
It should be noticed that Detective Pikachu is currently the highest rated video game based film in Rotten Tomatoes, with a score of 69% as of this writing, beating Rampage's 52%. It also breaks the record of The Power of Us, which is at 60%, if we include movies with limited theatrical releases.
AFAIK, only Yo-Kai Watch: The Movie and Resident Evil: Damnation rank higher, but they weren't released in theaters in the west.
Re: Random: Nintendo Shuts Down Its Anti-Piracy Website
@Chibi_Manny Beg them to re-release GameCube games.
Re: The Detective Pikachu Movie Reviews Are In, And It's Actually Pretty Mixed
@idrawrobots Sure seems to be the case with those who watch the yearly anime movies. They're quite bad, IMO.
70% on Rotten Tomatoes is solid though. I look forward to seeing Detective Pikachu.
Re: The Detective Pikachu Movie Reviews Are In, And It's Actually Pretty Mixed
@Kutal Actually, a great movie needs to appeal to everyone, not just enthusiasts. This is where the Pokémon anime movies failed and where Detective Pikachu succeeds.
Re: The Detective Pikachu Movie Reviews Are In, And It's Actually Pretty Mixed
@HeroponRiki The Power of Us ranks higher and managed to get 60% based on five critics. Detective Pikachu is beating that right now.
Re: Feature: Forget Sonic, These Are the 10 Worst Video Game Movies Ever
The Pokémon anime movies deserve a dishonorable mention, if not outright belong in that list.