Comments 1,267

Re: Mario + Rabbids Sparks Of Hope Update Available, Here Are The Patch Notes

BAN

@mereel Bugs have always been a thing, QA has always been a thing. If anything, QA has only gotten MORE robust over the decades, to a significant degree.

The issue is that games are also significantly more complex and data-rich than they were in whatever era you're envisioning. When you make boats longer and put more windows on them, that means you have more chances to spring a leak.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

BAN

@Arminillo That's a good question. If you were to take the sound effects from any generic film or tv show and put them up against the appeal and value of a James Earl Jones, then I would say no, it's probably not as big a draw for that project as James Earl Jones.

However, when you consider just how iconic the sound effects are in the Star Wars franchise, and how ultra-iconic/important/famous the lighstaber sound by itself is, then I'd say the foley artists who worked on those films were as critical to the film's long-term success as the voice actor behind Darth Vader. Those are some extremely valuable artists to that production. Just googling "lightsaber" brings up a google suggestion for "lightsaber sound". I would honestly bet that literally billions of people have gone around imitating that sound, just as often as they'd said "Luke, I am your father!"

But more to the point, it's just my opinion that if the voice artist in this case is arguing for the fair value of those who work to produce video games, then her assertion that "I'm THE voice of Bayonetta, I should get special treatment and be paid like I'm famous!" defeats her argument of fair pay for hours worked for all parties, and her call for a boycott damages that claim even further because now she's putting her ego over the success of her peers. And her rate might seem low based on our preconceived notion that a character being famous should mean its VA is paid like they themselves are famous, but it's a good standard rate for the amount of voice work she was going to be doing.

Should she get some small piece of the royalties based on her contribution? I think that would have been an incredibly nice and appropriate token of appreciation by Platinum, but that would have been an extremely rare perk and she shouldn't have expected it. VA's almost never get that. Especially when dealing with Japanese studios, who like to keep their budgets as buttoned up as possible and aren't known for gestures like that.

Re: Talking Point: Given The Voice Artist Controversy, Will You Be Boycotting Bayonetta 3?

BAN

”Taylor…has a much more evident claim on the character than, say, an animator who worked on her transformations, or the artist who textured her infamous pistol shoes.”

I wouldn’t think that. The devs working behind the scenes on things like this toil away on the character far longer than a voice artist, hate to say it. Her job is highly visible but is, to put it bluntly, the briefest and easiest link in the chain when it comes to producing a video game.

Should the actors be paid more, maybe get royalties? Perhaps. Probably. But calling for boycotts on the work of hundreds of other people not long before release just because you feel personally slighted just seems a bit childish to me. Just my take though, as a software developer who has worked on video games in the past.

Re: Random: Toad Will Also Have A Musical Moment In The Mario Movie

BAN

@somebread I mean, Disney has been doing this with their animated movies literally since the 1930's and no one seems to mind that. Granted, the modern iteration of this style can be pretty obnoxious at times, and a lot of big CGI films have foregone musical numbers, but I'm willing to give it a shot. It's nothing new or unique. It's practically the standard for animated films.

Re: Talking Point: What's Your Favourite Music Track From A Nintendo Game?

BAN

If I'm forced at the end of a gun to choose, I MIGHT have to say DKC2. But really I have several Nintendo soundtracks that rank roughly that high. Super Mario World, Mario Galaxy, pretty much any Zelda. The Pikmin series has some subtly great music that I'd consider to be in "favorite" territory. Hell, even Nintendo Land knocks it out of the park. This is like asking me to pick my favorite pet, you know?

Re: Poll: So, What Do You Think Of Mario's New Look?

BAN

@nessisonett Haaaaave you seen long facial hair before? Hate to say it, given my status as a bearded man, but most men's facial hair is dark and coarse and somewhat crinkly and a cynical person could say that for a lot of men it's similar to that hair of which you speak.

Re: The Super Mario Bros. Movie Teaser Trailer Is Finally Here

BAN

Honestly, I think it looks really good! Or as good as it can when you consider we only saw like one minute of footage. And visually it looks great, ESPECIALLY considering the fact that it's an illumination production and could have gone very wrong.

I also think Mario's design really works. It's different, but when has there ever been one consistent Mario design over the last 40 years? They made him look like Mario but with much more personality and expressiveness, which he needed for a movie. And I think it's more accurate than Sonic's movie version, even the redesigned version that everyone loved. All in all, I'm very relieved.

Re: Fired Nintendo Worker Comes Forward With An Account Of Their Dismissal

BAN

@strollin_stu Correct. They are not your friends. They're your employer, and as is the case in virtually every job on the planet, they tell you up front what you can and can't do and that if you violate your employment contract they will fire you. Who's actually struggling to understand this concept besides people that have never had a job?

Re: Fired Nintendo Employee Comes Forward With An Account Of Their Dismissal

BAN

Imagine making an obscenely obvious breach of your contract which even a child could understand why it's wrong, getting fired for it, making up a conspiracy theory as an alternative explanation because you don't want to admit that you blew it, and then having people write articles defending you. Must feel good to get away with stuff.

Re: Nintendo Has Already Started Banning Splatoon 3 Cheaters

BAN

@iLikeUrAttitude It’s literally just targeting modded versions of the game, because the blatantly obvious implication is that mods can be used to cheat, as everyone knows.

And given how prevalent and obnoxious cheating has been in the previous two games, a zero-tolerance policy on these people is the only acceptable/workable option. The system that’s designed to catch modded games isn’t going to discern if someone’s “just tinkering around for fun” or weigh whether or not they deserve to get banned for it. If you want to have fun, don’t do it in a way that can ruin everyone else’s fun.

Re: Reggie Talks About Nintendo's Slow Adoption Of Online Play

BAN

@RareFan Calling Nintendo "slow" for not emulating what virtually everyone else does is like calling those other studios "forgetful" for not making games that appeal to traditional gamers who don't give a sh*t about things like cutscenes, voice acting, and online multiplayer.

It's not an issue of ability, it's an issue of choice. Studios choose to do or not do certain things based on their own internal culture and who they want to appeal to. They don't all have to be the same, and I thank god that they're not, because we certainly have more than enough games that come from the non-Nintendo development dogma.

Re: Random: Many At Retro Studios Weren't 'Excited' To Work On Mario Kart 7

BAN

I mean, what else would they prefer to work on? If I were a Retro dev I'd have been stoked. One, it's a change of pace from their other games. Two, it stands out on a resume/portfolio. But also it's a freaking Mario Kart game, what developer wouldn't want the opportunity to make official Mario Kart tracks??

Re: NoA President Responds To Alleged Working Conditions At Nintendo, Finds Reports "Troubling"

BAN

@Ryu_Niiyama Glad to see there's someone else here with common sense! There's a lot of very young, very naive people on this site who think their own personal ideals should be the law of the land, and arguing with them is like trying to reason with a brick wall by ramming your head against it. It's frustrating.

And honestly, at this point I don't understand how anyone still takes the likes of ign and kotaku seriously. They're both essentially activist rags by now.

Re: April NPD: Switch Has Overtaken PS4 Sales In The US

BAN

What are the signs that Switch has passed its peak? It's sold what, 21 million units per year and Nintendo forecasts another 21 million this year. And that's amid a component shortage that's causing demand to outstrip supply. Games are coming out and selling in droves for the system. I think we're still in the peak.