Comments 871

Re: Nintendo Wins $2.1 Million In Lawsuit Against ROM Website

TryToBeHopeful

Here's a real analogy. A book I want to read is free of copyright in Canada, and not in the UK.

Am I really doing something morally wrong if I download it outside of Canada?

If I lived in Canada, should I delete it if I left the country?

If I bought a paperback copy, should I burn it if I left the country?

Re: Nintendo Wins $2.1 Million In Lawsuit Against ROM Website

TryToBeHopeful

It's not just physical vs intellectual property confusion, we're now down to facts vs. opinions. Just like there are different degrees of murder, there are different degrees of theft, and no one in their right mind would think having a downloaded copy of Steamboat Willie is theft.

If people really think buying a used NES and a used copy of Tetris is somehow better for the creators than downloading a ROM, I really don't know what to say.

If the argument is because it's illegal, is it some how more moral in countries where it's not illegal?

Because if it just comes down to morality, and we're talking about something where there is no possibility of anyone being deprived of anything (and I'm talking about pre-N64 games, not things you can buy now), then it just comes down to opinion.

Re: Nintendo Wins $2.1 Million In Lawsuit Against ROM Website

TryToBeHopeful

@Dr_Lugae I don’t think rom sites are about preservation, but they still enable preservation. Every time someone finds an old dr who episode in their attic we can thank ‘citizen archiving’. The problem with the digital age is copies are lossless. In the 90s no one would prefer a copied cassette tape vs a store bought one.

Re: Nintendo Wins $2.1 Million In Lawsuit Against ROM Website

TryToBeHopeful

People really struggle to get their heads around physical property and intellectual property. There’s no solution for the big producers where they just get what they want and piracy ends, so they either need to provide the games to rent at a reasonable price (Netflix/Spotify) or reissue legacy titles with added value (Beatles remasters / Castlevania collection).

These whole ‘you wouldn’t steal a car’ arguments just don’t wash. No pun intended.