@UglyCasanova well they are right. Watching others play their games instead of playing them yourself is an abomination. They are great games mostly. Not movies.
@nessisonett poor wittle programmer can't find an artist on the internet to team up with? That's it, he's forced to use Nintendo extremely famous IP then.
@Mattock1987 I don't think they want to understand. It means not doing what they want and accepting reality. Makes me wonder what kind of upbringing they got. It feels like that gets worse every generation.
@TheFrenchiestFry yes they are two seperate things. The article is supposed to be about fan projects but it serves up the melee pedo gate as another example of Nintendo putting out a C&D.
That's why I added a counter argument in the second part of my first comment. I don't understand your problem with it I think?
@TheFrenchiestFry first of all: sorry for hurting your feelings but I am not saying those creeps are the majority.
Just that Nintendo doesn't want to be linked to a group that has people like that in a major position there AND uses their IP in a way they do not give permission for.
@Mountain_Man I suppose they are technicians with not much imagination or too shy / afraid to propose their own ideas for world and character building.
The Sonic Mania argument is also completely disingeneous.
Sega haven't got a clue nowadays and were publishing appallingly bad sonic games for decades. Of course they jumped at that fan offering his skills. They were desperate. They are still desperate. That's why they have that stance towards fan games.
Obviously that's not an argument for Nintendo to agree to fan games for Nintendo IP. Nintendo is far from desperate. They have actual skilled developers.
I don't care for fan feelings. Make your own game. Loads of indie developers have and are succesful with it, DESPITE the obvious likeness to Nintendo's IP. They even might have started out as 'fan games' before switching things up and making it know publicly. Blossom Tales is Zelda but with original graphics and music, so is Baldo and loads of others.
Another thing is that Smash Bros. Melee thing. Nintendo probably also shut that thing down because of the many creeps and pedos in that niche community. Wasn't this exposed some time ago? Nintendo must have suspected.
@nessisonett well ok then. I always remember it being written without the capital first letter so black, white and so on. Must have remembered wrong then.
@nessisonett ok I did not know that word. So I looked it up on wikipedia. It says: "First introduced in the 1780s by members of the Göttingen school of history,[b] the term denoted one of three purported major races of humankind (those three being Caucasoid, Mongoloid, and Negroid)."
@Mgene15 no. The experience of playing together cant be replaced online. And the hyper obediant youth of today is too scared to get together because Trudeau screamed Covid. It's over for experiences like Goldeneye back then.
This is very disrespectful to all survivors of domestic abuse and also victims of happy slapping. I hope the publisher reconsiders the name and puts at least 2 trigger warnings in the game.
Absolutely hilarious and telling that nobody mentions the game in the thumbnail. Time for another soapbox to drive that point home again soon eh? They keep resisting, damnit!
Anyway for me it's F-Zero X...so good, so hard, so on point. 🤟🏻
@HammerGalladeBro "While I agree that preservation is important, I want to add that preservation and distribution aren't the same thing.
If the real intention was to preserve those games, you wouldn't go around giving them to everybody"
This is the best point that too many are overlooking. That site has nothing to do with art preservation. It's facilitating piracy. Nothing more. Nintendo is right.
@Lyricana if you're comparing 2 things to see if it's precendeted or not you don't bring in other variables. Otherwise there's no point in the definition of unprecendented.
Comments 323
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@UglyCasanova well they are right. Watching others play their games instead of playing them yourself is an abomination. They are great games mostly. Not movies.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@Nepo it is. Nintendo are not selling fiction, they are selling games.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@locky-mavo "Standing on a tall person’s shoulders doesn’t make you tall."
But it does make it easier to spit in his face.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@Kitoro you can make fan games without the IP. Check out the Nintendo eshop for some absolutely brilliant ones.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@nessisonett poor wittle programmer can't find an artist on the internet to team up with? That's it, he's forced to use Nintendo extremely famous IP then.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@Mattock1987 I don't think they want to understand. It means not doing what they want and accepting reality. Makes me wonder what kind of upbringing they got. It feels like that gets worse every generation.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@TheFrenchiestFry it might have done for Nintendo is what I am saying.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@TheFrenchiestFry yes they are two seperate things. The article is supposed to be about fan projects but it serves up the melee pedo gate as another example of Nintendo putting out a C&D.
That's why I added a counter argument in the second part of my first comment. I don't understand your problem with it I think?
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@TheFrenchiestFry first of all: sorry for hurting your feelings but I am not saying those creeps are the majority.
Just that Nintendo doesn't want to be linked to a group that has people like that in a major position there AND uses their IP in a way they do not give permission for.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@Mountain_Man I suppose they are technicians with not much imagination or too shy / afraid to propose their own ideas for world and character building.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
The Sonic Mania argument is also completely disingeneous.
Sega haven't got a clue nowadays and were publishing appallingly bad sonic games for decades. Of course they jumped at that fan offering his skills. They were desperate. They are still desperate. That's why they have that stance towards fan games.
Obviously that's not an argument for Nintendo to agree to fan games for Nintendo IP. Nintendo is far from desperate. They have actual skilled developers.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
@nessisonett no, but the mod feels like a convenient excuse to shut that thing down and not be associated with that sort of 'unsavoury stuff'.
Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?
I don't care for fan feelings. Make your own game. Loads of indie developers have and are succesful with it, DESPITE the obvious likeness to Nintendo's IP. They even might have started out as 'fan games' before switching things up and making it know publicly. Blossom Tales is Zelda but with original graphics and music, so is Baldo and loads of others.
Another thing is that Smash Bros. Melee thing. Nintendo probably also shut that thing down because of the many creeps and pedos in that niche community. Wasn't this exposed some time ago? Nintendo must have suspected.
Re: Review: No More Heroes III - A Swaggering Joke Of A Game That Suda51 Fans Will Love
Reads like a fanboy review to me. I think I will need to check out a more objective review for this one to see what it will be more like.
Re: Bravely Default II Is No Longer A Nintendo Switch Exclusive
If this game was 20 hours I would have liked it. I stopped playing at that point, it was getting into Groundhog Day territory.
Looking at that trailer I am also glad for the Japanese voice over.
Re: Random: This In-Development Musical Video Game Went Viral On TikTok
@Tandy255 oh thanks for clarifying!
Re: Random: This In-Development Musical Video Game Went Viral On TikTok
@nessisonett well ok then. I always remember it being written without the capital first letter so black, white and so on. Must have remembered wrong then.
Re: Random: This In-Development Musical Video Game Went Viral On TikTok
@nessisonett ok I did not know that word. So I looked it up on wikipedia. It says: "First introduced in the 1780s by members of the Göttingen school of history,[b] the term denoted one of three purported major races of humankind (those three being Caucasoid, Mongoloid, and Negroid)."
Re: Random: This In-Development Musical Video Game Went Viral On TikTok
I see you are capitalizing the B in black when it comes to race. Why?
Re: Get Pumped For An Animal Crossing X Puma Collaboration
Sad, just sad. Real sad. Might as well have mcdonalds and gilette adverts in Animal Crossing now.
Re: Feature: The Inside Story Of Mockumentary Sequel 'Bringing Back Golden Eye'
@Mgene15 no. The experience of playing together cant be replaced online. And the hyper obediant youth of today is too scared to get together because Trudeau screamed Covid. It's over for experiences like Goldeneye back then.
Isolate and stare at your phone.
Re: Talking Point: How Much Would You Pay For A Mint Copy Of Super Mario Bros.?
@Darkyoshi98 hehe, an oldie but yeah love that one. 😉
Re: Talking Point: How Much Would You Pay For A Mint Copy Of Super Mario Bros.?
About 3 fiddy.
Re: Feature: The Inside Story Of Mockumentary Sequel 'Bringing Back Golden Eye'
That's such a sweet move to ask for donations for a cause he believes in instead of profiting. Lovely man.
Re: XEL, A "Vibrant Sci-Fi Zelda-Like", Will Launch On Switch In 2022
Very generic character design.
But the gameplay might be good, let's see how it turns out.
Re: Asterix & Obelix : Slap Them All! Fights Its Way Onto Switch In November
This is very disrespectful to all survivors of domestic abuse and also victims of happy slapping. I hope the publisher reconsiders the name and puts at least 2 trigger warnings in the game.
Re: Fatal Frame: Maiden Of Black Water Adds New Character Costumes On Switch
@PBandSmelly that's pretty racist of you to smear an entire country like that.
Re: You "Won't Believe" Super Monkey Ball Banana Mania's Next Character, Says Geoff Keighley
The boxing coach from Punch-out! ?
Re: Talking Point: Which Video Game Song Could You Listen To For Ten Hours?
@nessisonett searched for it but it didn't come up since he spelled it wrong.
Still a lousy result of course after that subliminal hint. 😉
Re: Talking Point: Which Video Game Song Could You Listen To For Ten Hours?
Absolutely hilarious and telling that nobody mentions the game in the thumbnail. Time for another soapbox to drive that point home again soon eh? They keep resisting, damnit!
Anyway for me it's F-Zero X...so good, so hard, so on point. 🤟🏻
Re: Zelda: Breath Of The Wild 'Second Wind' Expansion Mod Adds Age Of Calamity Boss And Mammoths
@Nintenbr0 no I think the Nintendolife crew could do a far better job. Hopefully they will!
Re: Zelda: Breath Of The Wild 'Second Wind' Expansion Mod Adds Age Of Calamity Boss And Mammoths
I would also like to know how to play this. NintendoLife men and women, would you be so kind as to post a tutorial sometime?
Re: The Quake Remaster Is Out Now On Nintendo Switch
A game with zero representation for all you bigots out there. 😉
Re: Soapbox: Life Is Strange On Nintendo Switch Signals Better LGBTQ+ Rep To Come
@khululy well maybe you can start a lobby to include autism people in the list?
Re: Soapbox: Life Is Strange On Nintendo Switch Signals Better LGBTQ+ Rep To Come
So why isn't Lesbian Gay? I don't understand the need for both the L and the G in that grouping.
Why not just H for Homo? Both are covered that way. Would make it a bit more efficient as the list name keeps growing every couple of years.
Re: Video: Check Out This Fan-Made Remaster Trailer For Banjo-Kazooie
I appreciate all the effort that went into this and it looks super polished.
But it's not Banjo Kazooie, it's devoid of the humour, the charm, the whimsicalness, the flavour. The dramatic remixed music does it no favours.
"What if we like, took the Mona Lisa yeah, and made it like big and 8K and like HDR man that would be even better!"
Re: 'Best Month Ever' Will Take Us To The 1960s For An Emotional Road Trip
Sounds a bit too mushy for me.
Re: Mini Review: art of rally - Stylish Driving With Plenty Of Substance
@nessisonett unless you want to play handheld.
Re: UK Charts: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Returns To The Top Of The Podium
Gray Brittain, what's for dinner? Spam.
Re: GameStop Reveals Top Ten Switch Pre-Orders Since June 2021
Where is F-zero though? At position 11 then?
Re: Random: Sakurai Doesn't Appreciate Being Featured In Some Memes
@Silly_G that would depend on if Sakurai even appreciates Turkish though. 😉
Re: Switch Takes Japan's Entire Top 30 Software Chart, The First Console To Do So Since 1988
@Deerock69 thanks for clearing this up. Now that's indeed, unprecedented!
Re: Random: Sakurai Doesn't Appreciate Being Featured In Some Memes
I love how this comment section is teaching people about the ego and narcisism of Sakurai.
Going against the party line and counter narratives are sometimes hard to come by on here.
Re: Court Orders Popular ROM Website To "Destroy" All Of Its Unauthorised Nintendo Games
@HammerGalladeBro "While I agree that preservation is important, I want to add that preservation and distribution aren't the same thing.
If the real intention was to preserve those games, you wouldn't go around giving them to everybody"
This is the best point that too many are overlooking. That site has nothing to do with art preservation. It's facilitating piracy. Nothing more. Nintendo is right.
Re: Court Orders Popular ROM Website To "Destroy" All Of Its Unauthorised Nintendo Games
@MissAshheart the fact that something isn't going away is no reason to tolerate and accept illegality.
Re: Court Orders Popular ROM Website To "Destroy" All Of Its Unauthorised Nintendo Games
Removed; user is banned
Re: Switch Takes Japan's Entire Top 30 Software Chart, The First Console To Do So Since 1988
@Lyricana if you're comparing 2 things to see if it's precendeted or not you don't bring in other variables. Otherwise there's no point in the definition of unprecendented.
Re: Switch Takes Japan's Entire Top 30 Software Chart, The First Console To Do So Since 1988
@Lyricana there was no digital back then.
Re: Switch Takes Japan's Entire Top 30 Software Chart, The First Console To Do So Since 1988
@JasmineDragon ok I never played it. Was it hugely popular? Seems like quite a niche weeabo type game to me from the looks of it?
Re: Switch Takes Japan's Entire Top 30 Software Chart, The First Console To Do So Since 1988
@JasmineDragon isn't that a port of a 12 year old game?