Comments 323

Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?

Clarice

The Sonic Mania argument is also completely disingeneous.

Sega haven't got a clue nowadays and were publishing appallingly bad sonic games for decades. Of course they jumped at that fan offering his skills. They were desperate. They are still desperate. That's why they have that stance towards fan games.

Obviously that's not an argument for Nintendo to agree to fan games for Nintendo IP. Nintendo is far from desperate. They have actual skilled developers.

Re: Talking Point: As The Fan-Made 2D Metroid Prime Game Is Shut Down, Where Do You Stand On Nintendo's Takedowns?

Clarice

I don't care for fan feelings. Make your own game. Loads of indie developers have and are succesful with it, DESPITE the obvious likeness to Nintendo's IP. They even might have started out as 'fan games' before switching things up and making it know publicly. Blossom Tales is Zelda but with original graphics and music, so is Baldo and loads of others.

Another thing is that Smash Bros. Melee thing. Nintendo probably also shut that thing down because of the many creeps and pedos in that niche community. Wasn't this exposed some time ago? Nintendo must have suspected.

Re: Video: Check Out This Fan-Made Remaster Trailer For Banjo-Kazooie

Clarice

I appreciate all the effort that went into this and it looks super polished.

But it's not Banjo Kazooie, it's devoid of the humour, the charm, the whimsicalness, the flavour. The dramatic remixed music does it no favours.

"What if we like, took the Mona Lisa yeah, and made it like big and 8K and like HDR man that would be even better!"

Re: Court Orders Popular ROM Website To "Destroy" All Of Its Unauthorised Nintendo Games

Clarice

@HammerGalladeBro "While I agree that preservation is important, I want to add that preservation and distribution aren't the same thing.

If the real intention was to preserve those games, you wouldn't go around giving them to everybody"

This is the best point that too many are overlooking. That site has nothing to do with art preservation. It's facilitating piracy. Nothing more. Nintendo is right.