CANOEberry

CANOEberry

I'm not tippy. You're asymmetrical.

Comments 1,596

Re: Nintendo Asks That You Don't Co-Stream The E3 2021 Nintendo Direct, Thanks Very Much

CANOEberry

watching via "proxy" like that, makes it more difficult for Nintendo to actually gauge how many people watch their stream

@UndoControl Perhaps. But Nintendo is far from alone in having this "problem"; many media organizations have to do some legwork to establish the true size of their market. How do radio broadcasters provide more-or-less accurate audience numbers to potential advertisers? I'm not shedding any tears for Nintendo here.

In addition, the lateness of this request implies, to me, that this notion was an afterthought. I'm not impressed, and I suspect that those people telling us how NCL has all the rights as a creator are betraying a certain contempt for the public here.

EDIT: You are correct, though, in saying that it's not difficult to watch both NCL's stream and the YouTuber's, together...

Re: Minute Of Islands Is Out Now On Switch

CANOEberry

@KateGray Thanks much! Impressions corroborated!

I'm not trying to push you or the other reviewers... I'm just saying that you've reviewed some intriguing indie titles (or you, in part, made them seem intriguing). If I have trouble keeping track of all the stuff released this year, I can't imagine your problems. All this can happen later, though, hehe!

Re: Metroid Prime 4 Was First Announced Four Years Ago Today

CANOEberry

who in their right mind actually believes AAA games take less than 3 years to develop?

@Razer Ah, so I misunderstood you, then! Sorry about that.

Yes, it is really really common around here. I really wish Nintendo Life would do a feature about AAA development, explaining it to people. You are 100% correct to say that it takes serious time.

Re: Minute Of Islands Is Out Now On Switch

CANOEberry

Judging by the art alone, the game does look compelling, but I will reserve judgment. @KateGray, I trust you will be reviewing this?

On that score, I wanted to ask you a question. You've reviewed many many indie games since you joined NL and started rubbing shoulders with us mangy gamers. Will you and the other staff writers be giving us a "year in review" type article, where your most memorable reviewed games will be listed?

Re: Metroid Prime 4 Was First Announced Four Years Ago Today

CANOEberry

People are way too pessimistic. Let's put this into perspective. Metroid Prime 3 took two and a half years to make.

Why would Prime 4 take any longer to produce?

@dudujencarelli From all I've read, Metroid Prime 1 and 2 were produced under truly heinous crunch conditions. Many of the staff responsible for those games left Retro as a result. The industry today is more sensitive to this issue than it was (at least, they are sensitive to accusations), and Nintendo themselves have publicly stated that they do not engage in this practice. That might sound cynical from a Japanese multinational, but this is in the public record. Moreover, Nintendo has said on multiple occasions that (they find) HD development is more difficult than work on games of prior generations.

In addition... and these are purely my own thoughts... the Metroid franchise is at a crossroads. Nintendo is investing some serious time, effort, and even reputation into MP4, particularly. They seem to be aiming for another breakout success, as Fire Emblem has finally achieved. Metroid now seems to really matter to Nintendo - to my mind, for the first time. I personally think that the "flowering" of the Metroidvania genre has stirred something in the management in Kyoto, be it pride or a desire to dominate a market they helped pioneer.

I have been playing these games since the 1980s, and I can tell you that the reputation and publicity around this franchise now would have been unimaginable to me before 2010, let alone around the time of Super Metroid, when it was the finest game no one else in my town had ever played. The development resources being thrown at this game, the sheer demand for new entries, warms my heart, but I worry also. Will Metroid finally become the sales success that it should have been? Nintendo is treating Samus Aran at last as their golden child, and if MP4 is to follow in the footsteps of the last great success - MP1 - it will need a great deal of time to make comparable innovations, let alone match the quality of prior entries.

Could they release something this year? Maybe. Should they? Absolutely not.

Re: Nintendo's Official Website Reveals Mario + Rabbids Sparks Of Hope, Coming To Switch In 2022

CANOEberry

why steal to learn? Would you walk into a book shop, pick up a educational book and walk out of the store without paying? Even if you are making a spiritual successor, no need to use graphics someone else owns

@Trikeboy Your points here are fair. Yes, it would be better to skip the "slavish imitation" or "borrowing" stage directly. For me, this issue is a little more nuanced, though.

If you are making a game and plan to release it to the public, the material should be original. Obviously, some people are simply trying to cash in on the popularity of existing games, and that is disreputable. Nintendo can and will crush such rip-offs legally.

And yet, when I think of a game like AM2R, I have mixed feelings. To my knowledge, no one attempted to cash in on that product. I have not played it, but I have watched a fair bit of a playthrough, and it seems to have been created by people who have deep respect for the Metroid franchise (both lore and gameplay), and Metroid II particularly. All of that unpaid labour - like yours - means something. Legally, we talk of IP and franchises, but to me, culture belongs as much to the fans as to the creators. In the long run, the companies are only a means to an end...

Re: Nintendo's Official Website Reveals Mario + Rabbids Sparks Of Hope, Coming To Switch In 2022

CANOEberry

Trials Rising(Switch) is inferior to what, it's predecesor(Trials Fusion), other consoles?

@WoomyNNYes I very much appreciate the detailed reply; I should have made it clearer that I already own the game on Switch and have played a few tracks (with my vintage GameCube controller, which feels quite natural for this game!). I agree with everything you've mentioned about the quality of the game (so far), and I don't recall any serious frame drops.

In other online communities, I saw many complaints about Trials Rising on all its platforms. I understand that it was rocky at launch and that the reception has improved, however. And yes, Fusion has been brought up often as the superior product.

I bow to your motoring skills 😌

Re: SkateBIRD Shreds Onto Nintendo Switch This August

CANOEberry

I’m sure there has to be a bird somewhere already figuring out the skateboard (on her own)

@iuli I was riding the subway in Toronto once when I saw a pigeon suddenly fly off the roof of a train arriving at a station which had a very large, prominent exit to the outdoors.

I thought, "Now what could motivate a pigeon to roost up there for even a moment?"

On the return trip, I saw multiple pigeons at my departing station flying above the train roof and thought, "No...". Yes - the pigeons have learned to ride the train across an entire borough.

I won't even tell you about the raccoons in that town...

Re: Nintendo's Official Website Reveals Mario + Rabbids Sparks Of Hope, Coming To Switch In 2022

CANOEberry

Well, since the rumour is now essentially confirmed...

I would be interested in a fulsome release of a Donkey Kong game of this type, even if I must tolerate the Rabbids yet again.

The Kremlings need not be the default enemy, but I would be interested in some development of those characters as well. The islands from Tropical Freeze would make excellent settings, and the concept could be stretched from its Mario+Rabbids origins in interesting ways, I think.

Re: Review: Ninja Gaiden: Master Collection - Ryu Hayabusa Deserves Better Than This

CANOEberry

This is why you check out multiple reviewers cuz switchup says it's pretty good aside from a few technical flaws. Easily patch able and they do a patch series addressing updates.

@Ocaz I understand what you're saying, but in my case, as a potential customer of the physical version, a sub-standard build on the game card itself means no buy. I don't want to keep the revision histories of games in my mind when I barely have time to play the games for weeks at a time.

Re: Review: Ninja Gaiden: Master Collection - Ryu Hayabusa Deserves Better Than This

CANOEberry

This is very disappointing. A truly complete collection on the game card would be worth the price of admission. As it is, I may have to look into a PS4 copy. I prefer to support Switch ports, but this sort of corner-cutting decision on Switch releases and collections has happened time and again, and has cost Nintendo revenue - my dollars, at least!

@Slowdive I guess we now know why there was so little word about this until the release week. Good call on your part.

Re: Review: DC Super Hero Girls: Teen Power - A Kid-Friendly Alternative To Grimdark DC

CANOEberry

why are you watching a show intended for pre pubescent girls...?

@Bizzyb Why are you reading an article about a video game intended for pre-pubescent girls? Or responding to comments about a video game intended for pre-pubescent girls?

It cuts both ways, you see.

I left a comment in the original thread about this game, and professing my interest in the concept. I don't have a daughter, but I know people that do. In addition, I very clearly remember being told that girls don't play video games, and aren't supposed to be interested in them. That is reason enough for males to comment on a thread like this. No one needs your permission.

Re: Review: DC Super Hero Girls: Teen Power - A Kid-Friendly Alternative To Grimdark DC

CANOEberry

The number of grown adults tossing their toys out of the pram

@0nett My Ignore list must be working wonders for me, because so far, I only see Doofenshmirtz behaving that way (surprise, surprise). I totally know what you mean, though.

The nonsense I was actually expecting to see was moral panic-type noise from Kotaku readers, who always find reason to attack when female characters are involved ("how dare they depict breasts!!!!1", and such).

Re: Talking Point: How Good Are You At Games?

CANOEberry

I believe in éliteness of skill, but not éliteness of attitude (sometimes called "élitism").

Our individual journeys to become proficient and overcome challenges should always be encouraged. It often seems these days that we don't wish to celebrate these journeys, based on an exaggerated fear of excluding others. I note, however, that the truly élite are those who invite others to become skilled, and pass on their own understanding.

Superhero difficulty forever!

Re: Mini Review: Mighty Goose - Have A Gander At This Stylish Run 'N' Gunner

CANOEberry

You can also select your secondary weapon, which... starts off with a simple “honk”

A game - or a review - which fails to note a hero's battle cry is spiritually incomplete. Donkey Kong beats his chest (as well as he might), Mega Man leaps and shouts when he defeats a Robot Master (take a look if you don't believe me, his mouth is open!), and Amaterasu howls. And thus into glory.

Is the game getting DLC or such?