Comments 1,637

Re: Nintendo Download: 9th January (Europe)

antdickens

@SquareOneMJ yeah I can see what you mean... typically though we like to see what new releases people are downloading, rather than anything, just to give the poll more purpose. Perhaps the last option should be "no new releases for me this week" though.

Re: Random: Pokémon Sword And Shield's Ending Has A Pretty Embarrassing Mistake

antdickens

@Heavyarms55 I would agree that it certainly seems to be more negative online in general at the moment, and perhaps that is related to the general state of things around the world at the moment - I couldn't be sure. However, NL has always been a place to 'get away from it' in my eyes and therefore I won't accept the cancer to run wild here whilst I'm still running things. I do think it doesn't help that other sites/platforms don't do more in that regard, if people behave badly on the majority of sites and get away with it, then it really sends the wrong message as far as I'm concerned.

I think the depth and level of negativity around Pokemon took us all by surprise, sure we had an idea going into it but at the same time the reaction is much, much worse than any of us expected. That said, it does seem to be a vocal minority, the game is clearly a decent (not great) game and sales have been impressive to begin with.

I respect your decision to back away from the comments on those subjects - I don't blame you at all - but I would say that we need voices of reason and positivity in the comments so we'll do whatever we can to help support those voices.

Re: Random: Pokémon Sword And Shield's Ending Has A Pretty Embarrassing Mistake

antdickens

@Heavyarms55 sorry you feel that way. We're well aware that the comments sections aren't as "nice" as perhaps they were pre-Switch and that's largely down to the massive increase in audience. We're doing more moderation of comments than ever before, but that does rely on people reporting stuff as we don't want to have to check every comment before it goes live - that's just not practical for us or the community. We're committed to keeping our rules strict and banning people that are just here to make trouble, unlike other sites/platforms. If you have any ideas that might help us achieve that then we're all ears

Re: Random: Pokémon Sword And Shield Players Are Reportedly Experiencing Issues With Their Roku Devices

antdickens

@Heavyarms55 @Kalmaro how is it clickbait? Roku have confirmed the issue? Clickbait means to post a headline that contains misleading information that then isn't the case in the article, which this isn't. If you don't want to read an article, you are welcome to not click on it.

As for using Adblock, that's disappointing for our team as all our income is from ads and affiliate links. We'd hope that any regular reader of the site would want to support our team. We try to balance the type/number of ads and believe we offer a better experience than most gaming sites on that front. We may in the future offer an ad-free subscription which maybe you would be interested in?

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@Yorumi with all that logic the only solution would be to remove review scores. I’d also always recommend that people read multiple reviews for a product if their questions/concerns aren’t answered. No one review will answer every possible question about a game, everyone’s taste is different.

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@Yorumi maybe those issues didn’t detract from the fun the reviewer had with that particular game? All the issues you mention vary in importantance depending on the game and who is playing it. This by definition causes inconsistency. I think everyone would agree that consistency is important, but context is also important as to why it’s not always achieved.

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@Yorumi I don't think many are taking the article that way, given the replies, only a handful. I can't speak for IGN, but I would agree it seems a tad high considering the issues raised by others, however, I can say Alex's review is totally justified on our scale. He's a very knowledgable Pokemon player and therefore trust his judgement 100%.

As for the user scores on metacritic, I don't see how any "legitimate reviews" could justify the 0/10 score attached for a game that clearly isn't broken. It could be an amazingly detailed and critical review, but giving it a 0/10 still isn't justified is it?

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@MrFlaminBig I think you're on to something with this, based on all the comments I've been reading over the past few days it seems like there are some very different expectations as to what people want... some want it to stay the same and some want it to change significantly, so I guess that was always going to end up dividing a fanbase.

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@SquallLeonhart86 agreed, the sample size is important too. I think once metacritic gets say, 10,000 user scores then we'll see a different picture and maybe it'll end up settling more like 6/10? It's hard to know at this point. IMDb seems to have the same issue when a film is first released.

Re: Of Course Pokémon Sword And Shield Is Getting Review-Bombed

antdickens

@SquallLeonhart86 the key difference here is the scale, games journos would never give this game a 0/10 or 3/10 would they? Because it's not a broken game that doesn't run, which is what would get such a score. So they wouldn't complain about users giving a game 5/10 etc as that is a more realistic opinion.