This book was awesome. It really changed how I look at games, and game criticism. I can say that I won't be buying games based on reviews anymore. It's kind of exciting to see things through a new lens. Thank you Mr. Johnson.
I picked this up yesterday and got through the preface, introduction, and two chapters. Being a 3DS ambassador is really paying off on this one. The authors choice to write a detailed analysis is admittedly tongue in cheek, and a bit of a middle finger (or your' countries equivalent hand gesture) to game criticism. I really like his writing style, and the whole idea is so far well executed. I am going to be a lot more critical of game reviews from here on out.
@Matts14 As a stock holder, I do not want Nintendo to move into mobile gaming. I would also say a majority of stock holders do not want the company to move into mobile gaming. There is a loud minority, coupled with internet doom-and-gloomers who go on and on about Nintendo's need to move into mobile. That is not the answer. There are other problems that need to be dealt with that will have a much greater effect on pulling up Wii U sales. So, you and Peach64 are wrong.
I voted no, but I don't think the added "it just needs to find it's killer app" is true either. I like the gamepad. I like browsing the internet with it. It is my go-to controller now. This is a pretty lame article...
@Goginho Oh yeah, that was there. Depending on the TV you had, it was either really noticeable, or barely noticeable. On a flat screen TV it stands out. I think the convex glass screens of tube TV's made a difference. I never really cared about it until I fired up my original NES on a flat screen TV a few years back and was all "WTF?!". I kind of like it now. It reminds me that when I was a kid we had all of these amazing experiences with games in spite of graphical flaws. Sometimes it was part of the fun to find those flaws/exploits. I have never really been one for harshing on a game because of a glitch though. When SMB3 came out it was crazy. On the playground we were poring over our copies of Nintendo Power just in awe of how amazing it looked. When The Wizard came out we all rushed to see it, and the game footage at the end had us all creaming our jeans. Just think of whatever graphically amazing game in the past two years that has blown your mind, and equate that to SMB3 for its day.
It's a perfect game because it has perfect game-play. The balance of levels, the curve in difficulty, all the new mechanics were all just so amazing. I have played the Advance version and still prefer the original.
The original game had the side bar. It's not an emulation mistake, just true to the original. Some of you seem to be missing the point. This game is a 10/10 gem in spite of it's faults. I can see not appreciating this game if you didn't grow up with it. You whipper snappers have been ruined by graphics being the benchmark of a quality game.
If this is the extent of the changes, it's really not that big of a deal. To the people saying that we aren't children blah blah blah... realize that our social standards are different here. There are a lot of children that own a 3DS. I would wager that more children own a 3DS than adults. Parents buying games for their children might like the SUBTLE changes. I for one would prefer the western release if my son wanted this game.
Also, they look super young so it is kind of creepy.
I know it has already been addressed, but The Wonderful 101 deserved a second place nod somewhere on this list. That game is epic, exclusive, rad, awesome, great, imeancomeonwowitsgood, and just overall a remarkable experience on the Wii U. For shame.
As a new father (13 month old) all I can say is... sleep between crying. You are only going to work yourself up getting frustrated when the baby cries and you have to stop to go take care of it. Also, go in and just be AWE STRUCK OVER THE LIFE YOU HAVE BROUGHT INTO THIS WORLD AND STOP WHINING ABOUT NEEDING GAMES DUDE WTF.
Right? Bust out them AR cards. Take it for a walk and rack up those coins. Make some Miis of your family and friends. See if you can get someone (or yourself) to take you to some SpotPass zones. Have fun with it. Wii U people, ummmm, watch a movie or ten?
It's been two days. Two days with tons of other stuff going on. You people bring out the pitchforks on Nintendo faster than the PSPhanbois and Xbooxsnoobs. Dayum people, wipe up the froth.
Also, patience is a virtue. They sold a lot of units for both consoles this year. How are they to know how many units were held back for months as Christmas presents? Not to mention almost all of the Pokemon fans trying to get dat bank action going fer reeeeels doh. Calm down, stop hating, you will get your games. DOOM! DOOM AND GLOOM I TELL YOU! MUST HATE ON DER NINTERNDOOOOOSSS!!!
Sooooo, am I the only one that wants to punch that kid in the picture right in his neck? Just once, and not that hard. Something about his head and that neck, just brings it out of me...
This is exactly why I love this website. Nintendo news. Any and all things Nintendo. Thanks for stopping the trolls, and for stopping me when I troll. I heart Nintendo Life.
P.S. I hope this dude gets better. I would have to think he has had some impact on us Americanos getting some shweet games. cough*Xenoblade*cough*LastStory*cough*MH3*cough Right?
9 months isn't so bad, and you can do a lot with 40 mb if you're good. But 6000 sales before payment? That's stupid. I didn't know they did that. That would make me not want to develop for them. I love Nintendo, I really do, but I would like to see them bring us more games. Even if some end up being crap. And I love Baldur's Gate, and a Wii U enhanced version would be epic. Dreams=dashed.
I went out and purchased this today, and I love it. I love everything about it. That said, I would also give it a 7/10. All the criticisms in the review are valid, good and bad. I do hesitate to drop full price on a game when it gets a 7 or lower, but this one was worth it.
Great game. I would give it an 8/10. It would have been a 10/10 if there was any kind of story, and maybe a little less grinding needed. Sometimes I love level grinding, but you have to give me a great story for that.
Comments 216
Re: Atlus Announces Launch Week Discounts for Citizens of Earth
Ooooooooooh, on sale right away! I am totally getting this.
Re: Nintendo Direct Confirmed for 14th January, With Focus on Spring Releases
I have my wallet at the ready. New 3DS here I Come!
Re: Guide: Collecting All the Gems in Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker - Episode 3
I need this game in my life.
Re: Review: League of Heroes (3DS eShop)
Looks cool to me.
Re: Feature: The Weird and Wonderful World of Nintendo Patents
There should be an option for "All of the Above". That would have been my vote.
Re: Interview: Daniel Johnson Discusses His Critical Analysis of Wario Land 4
This book was awesome. It really changed how I look at games, and game criticism. I can say that I won't be buying games based on reviews anymore. It's kind of exciting to see things through a new lens. Thank you Mr. Johnson.
Re: Critical Analysis of Wario Land 4 Now Available on Kindle, Discount Price Extended
I picked this up yesterday and got through the preface, introduction, and two chapters. Being a 3DS ambassador is really paying off on this one. The authors choice to write a detailed analysis is admittedly tongue in cheek, and a bit of a middle finger (or your' countries equivalent hand gesture) to game criticism. I really like his writing style, and the whole idea is so far well executed. I am going to be a lot more critical of game reviews from here on out.
Re: Nintendo States There Are "No Plans" to Bring Mini-Games to Smart Devices
@Matts14
As a stock holder, I do not want Nintendo to move into mobile gaming. I would also say a majority of stock holders do not want the company to move into mobile gaming. There is a loud minority, coupled with internet doom-and-gloomers who go on and on about Nintendo's need to move into mobile. That is not the answer. There are other problems that need to be dealt with that will have a much greater effect on pulling up Wii U sales. So, you and Peach64 are wrong.
Re: Talking Point: Is There A Future For The Wii U Without The GamePad?
I voted no, but I don't think the added "it just needs to find it's killer app" is true either. I like the gamepad. I like browsing the internet with it. It is my go-to controller now. This is a pretty lame article...
Re: Nintendo States There Are "No Plans" to Bring Mini-Games to Smart Devices
@Peach64
You are wrong.
Re: Video: Levi and Sasha Slay Some Giants In This Attack On Titan DLC Mission Footage
@FantasiaWHT
Took the words right out of my mouth.
Re: Nintendo Was Dead To Us Very Quickly, States EA Source
Everyone pretty much summed up how I feel. They won't be cluttering the catalog with all of their crap.
Re: BBC is "Working to bring iPlayer" to the Wii U
I like the BBC video apps a lot. I will be very happy when it makes its way to Wii U.
Re: Talking Point: Nintendo's Wii U Struggles Bring a Challenge, Not Doom
@FullbringIchigo
I never thought about Nintendo handling 3rd party ports, but that is genius.
Re: Review: Super Mario Bros. 3 (Wii U eShop / NES)
@Goginho Oh yeah, that was there. Depending on the TV you had, it was either really noticeable, or barely noticeable. On a flat screen TV it stands out. I think the convex glass screens of tube TV's made a difference. I never really cared about it until I fired up my original NES on a flat screen TV a few years back and was all "WTF?!". I kind of like it now. It reminds me that when I was a kid we had all of these amazing experiences with games in spite of graphical flaws. Sometimes it was part of the fun to find those flaws/exploits. I have never really been one for harshing on a game because of a glitch though. When SMB3 came out it was crazy. On the playground we were poring over our copies of Nintendo Power just in awe of how amazing it looked. When The Wizard came out we all rushed to see it, and the game footage at the end had us all creaming our jeans. Just think of whatever graphically amazing game in the past two years that has blown your mind, and equate that to SMB3 for its day.
It's a perfect game because it has perfect game-play. The balance of levels, the curve in difficulty, all the new mechanics were all just so amazing. I have played the Advance version and still prefer the original.
Re: Review: Super Mario Bros. 3 (Wii U eShop / NES)
@unrandomsam Yeah, I know. And this is a 10/10 in my book.
Re: Review: Super Mario Bros. 3 (Wii U eShop / NES)
@Goginho
The original game had the side bar. It's not an emulation mistake, just true to the original. Some of you seem to be missing the point. This game is a 10/10 gem in spite of it's faults. I can see not appreciating this game if you didn't grow up with it. You whipper snappers have been ruined by graphics being the benchmark of a quality game.
Re: Western Version Of Bravely Default Features Costume Changes For Female Characters
If this is the extent of the changes, it's really not that big of a deal. To the people saying that we aren't children blah blah blah... realize that our social standards are different here. There are a lot of children that own a 3DS. I would wager that more children own a 3DS than adults. Parents buying games for their children might like the SUBTLE changes. I for one would prefer the western release if my son wanted this game.
Also, they look super young so it is kind of creepy.
Re: Nintendo Download: 2nd January (North America)
So begins another week of waiting for SMB3.
Re: Game of the Year: Nintendo Life's Staff Awards 2013
I know it has already been addressed, but The Wonderful 101 deserved a second place nod somewhere on this list. That game is epic, exclusive, rad, awesome, great, imeancomeonwowitsgood, and just overall a remarkable experience on the Wii U. For shame.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
@Anguspuss
It's hard, it will be ok.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
@Anguspuss
As a new father (13 month old) all I can say is... sleep between crying. You are only going to work yourself up getting frustrated when the baby cries and you have to stop to go take care of it. Also, go in and just be AWE STRUCK OVER THE LIFE YOU HAVE BROUGHT INTO THIS WORLD AND STOP WHINING ABOUT NEEDING GAMES DUDE WTF.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
@PinkSpider
Right? Bust out them AR cards. Take it for a walk and rack up those coins. Make some Miis of your family and friends. See if you can get someone (or yourself) to take you to some SpotPass zones. Have fun with it. Wii U people, ummmm, watch a movie or ten?
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
It's been two days. Two days with tons of other stuff going on. You people bring out the pitchforks on Nintendo faster than the PSPhanbois and Xbooxsnoobs. Dayum people, wipe up the froth.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
@Anguspuss
Or, you know, relax and wait it out.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
ITT; First world problems.
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
Also, patience is a virtue. They sold a lot of units for both consoles this year. How are they to know how many units were held back for months as Christmas presents? Not to mention almost all of the Pokemon fans trying to get dat bank action going fer reeeeels doh. Calm down, stop hating, you will get your games. DOOM! DOOM AND GLOOM I TELL YOU! MUST HATE ON DER NINTERNDOOOOOSSS!!!
Re: Nintendo Acknowledges Network Issues and Suggests Patience
I finally got in, with no problems. Put in two eShop cards and started a download. Should be getting up for everyone now I imagine.
Re: Castle of Illusion Starring Mickey Mouse Looks Set For Wii U
This would be awesome on the 3DS.
Re: Super Ubi Land Kickstarter Has Ended, Target Goal Surpassed
Oh hey how about the 3DS too eh?
Re: Action RPG CrossCode Could Be Heading To The Wii U eShop
Bring it to the 3DS please.
Re: Rodea the Sky Soldier
Is this game in Limbo or what?
Re: Best Buy R.O.B. Saga Reaches a Happy Ending
What a bunch of jerk faces.
Re: Nintendo "Very Eager" to Help Third Party 3DS Developers
Sooooo, am I the only one that wants to punch that kid in the picture right in his neck? Just once, and not that hard. Something about his head and that neck, just brings it out of me...
Re: Nintendo UK Boss David Yarnton Suffers Health Scare
@ThomasBW84
This is exactly why I love this website. Nintendo news. Any and all things Nintendo. Thanks for stopping the trolls, and for stopping me when I troll. I heart Nintendo Life.
P.S. I hope this dude gets better. I would have to think he has had some impact on us Americanos getting some shweet games. cough*Xenoblade*cough*LastStory*cough*MH3*cough Right?
(Changed sweet to shweet. Sounded better.)
Re: MDK2 Dev Will Never Develop for Nintendo Again
9 months isn't so bad, and you can do a lot with 40 mb if you're good. But 6000 sales before payment? That's stupid. I didn't know they did that. That would make me not want to develop for them. I love Nintendo, I really do, but I would like to see them bring us more games. Even if some end up being crap. And I love Baldur's Gate, and a Wii U enhanced version would be epic. Dreams=dashed.
Re: Rayman Origins 3DS Leaps the Atlantic on 20th March
Delicious.
Re: Gaijin Games Explains Why RUNNER2 Won't Reach Wii
Fricken hipster doofi. Is doofi the scientific word for many a doofus? They made me not like their game by talking.
Re: WarioWare Takes Christmas Movies and Makes Them Better
yup
Re: Review: BIT.TRIP SAGA (3DS)
I went out and purchased this today, and I love it. I love everything about it. That said, I would also give it a 7/10. All the criticisms in the review are valid, good and bad. I do hesitate to drop full price on a game when it gets a 7 or lower, but this one was worth it.
Re: Fresh Dragon Quest X Screenshots and Trailer Inside
@ElReminator
Doh! I just stopped playing after that. Holy crap. A whole new reason to go back!!!
Re: Fresh Dragon Quest X Screenshots and Trailer Inside
So what about that sequel to IX? I was bummed when I got a "to be continued" at the end, and now X doesn't appear to be that sequel...
Re: Extend 3DS Battery Life with CTA's Deluxe Power Grip
1:02
Re: Fresh Dragon Quest X Screenshots and Trailer Inside
This looks awesome. Can't wait to get this with my Wii U.
Re: Talking Point: The Most Memorable Third Party Game Boy Advance Games
My favorite would have to be Final Fantasy VI Advance. Hands down.
Re: Feature: Nintendo - Gaming in Black and White
I really like this article. Well done Jacob.
Re: Take a Look at Square Enix's Upcoming 3DS JRPG
I like what I'm seein' here! Kind of looks like if Four Heroes of Light had been a little darker and with better graphics. I could go for this.
Re: Check Out the Concept Trailer for Monster Hunter 4
Ohmygod ohmygod ohmygod.
Re: More Super Mario 3D Land Screenshots Warp Into View
@LorJumpMad How does that look like an NES game? Have you ever seen an NES game before?
The game looks awesome though. I am surprised that they didn't call it New Super Mario Bros. Galaxy.
Re: Etrian Odyssey III: The Drowned City
Great game. I would give it an 8/10. It would have been a 10/10 if there was any kind of story, and maybe a little less grinding needed. Sometimes I love level grinding, but you have to give me a great story for that.