Comments 216

Re: Talking Point: Jargon-Heavy Xbox Series X And PS5 Reveals Vindicate Nintendo's Approach

Agriculture

The opposite is also sometimes true. Microsoft for example showed Halo 2, in a version that was very impressive, but the Xbox had no ability to run. When the game was released it was a completely different Halo 2.

I think it was a good thing that Sony revealed that their SSD would be able to handle 5.5 gb/s read times, especially since they explained that it would mean much more rich environments. Of course eventually they will have to show a game, but knowing the specs was still a good thing.

Re: Square Enix Indie Division Teases Imminent Nintendo Switch Announcement

Agriculture

"Square Enix Indie Division"? So it's a part of an entertainment giant that is somehow also independent?

When did we start calling all simpler games "indie"?

Apparently what they do is "service provider for Indie developers", so basically they remove the indie out of indie games, but they say they let the developers keep creative control, so that's good.

Re: Someone Has Already Offered $1.2 Million For The SNES PlayStation Prototype

Agriculture

@Averagewriter Nintendo relied on the idea that they would develop the must have games for a console, while 3rd party developers would create additional, less important games. The CD changed the whole dynamic of the industry, because must have games were things like Metal Gear Solid. Ocarina of Time was of course also a must have game, but people wanted things like a complex story to follow, full voice acting and lots of cutscenes.

Re: Someone Has Already Offered $1.2 Million For The SNES PlayStation Prototype

Agriculture

@Averagewriter I meant the successor to the Snes CD. And yes, the contract wouldn't extend to the next generation, but Sony would have demanded a new contract that did stipulate that Sony would collect the licensing money from CD games.

And of course Ocarina of Time would have been made differently on such a console. The alternate history that turned out to be good for Nintendo is if they had never even talked to Sony about making a CD add-on, and maybe, but not very likely, that would have made them never consider making a video game console.

Re: Someone Has Already Offered $1.2 Million For The SNES PlayStation Prototype

Agriculture

@Averagewriter Between Sony and companies like Square, it's very clear that there existed better plans for CD than FMV games like Night Trap. Here's a short description of what I meant:

Nintendo agrees to Sony's terms. Nintendo and Sony launch the Snes Play Station (all-in-one Snes with disc add-on), and much like how the Sega CD had lots of FMV-games, this one has that. Fast forward 4-5 years and a console somewhere between the N64 and PS1 launches. A 3D capable console with an optical reader, and a cartridge slot that can be used for games or ram-expansion.

Now, with this new console ALL games are on disc. When Nintendo develops Ocarina of Time it becomes, without a doubt, completely obvious it needs to be on CD. Now Sony is the one collection the licensing money from that game, and Nintendo is basically out of the hardware business.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

@KitsuneNight Yeah, it's the same with the Switch, it's way more successful than the PSP and the Vita because it launched the right time to be using mobile processors.

The time of release is something people tend to forget when arguing about which console should be successful. Right now for example, you can't release a console with a proprietary processor.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

@KitsuneNight Another big factor was that it was significantly cheaper than the original Xbox. Few people even remember this, but the original Xbox launched for $500 and Microsoft had to quickly drop the price and compensate those who bought it for $500 by giving them 2 free games.

The Xbox was much more capable, and got games like Morrowind and Halo, which probably would have never run on a PS2. The Xbox even got a nerfed version of Half Life 2. That generation of consoles was my favorite, and all 3 consoles had a ridiculous amount of great games.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

@KitsuneNight Like you said, it was released in 2001. There's tablet computers from 1995 and they are all awful. The PS2 won over the original Xbox because it used cheap memory cards, while the PS3 overtook the 360 because it didn't use cheap memory cards.

My point is that things change with time. When the PS3 was just released, having a harddrive and bluray optical reader was probably bad for the console, since it drove up the price, but during the last few years, having those things meant the console was still viable.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

@Darknyht Yes, Sony has even admitted that they deliberately made the PS3 difficult to program for so that game developers had to pick a side, which they assumed would be their side due to how successful the PS2 was. Needless to say, it backfired big time.

Even with all that said, it's not entirely easily to claim Sony could have done much better. The unique processor of the PS3 was conceived back when consumers expected new consoles to show something they hadn't seen. It wasn't until the PS4/Xbox One that someone took the step of launching a console that was just a PC with lower specs than you could already buy.

If Sony had launched a console with more standard hardware, like the 360 had, it still would have been very expensive since the harddrive and bluray drove the price up.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

@Darknyht The reason why eventually it overtook the 360 is that it did a lot of things right. Most importantly, all version had a harddrive and a bluray optical unit, and the harddrive was even interchangable. That meant that late in the console cycle, the PS3 could handle the huge games with huge patches that were released at the time.

Re: PlayStation 4 Just Overtook Wii's Lifetime Sales

Agriculture

The best part of the PS4 is how cheap it is, with games like 2016's Doom sometimes selling for as low as €6. The PS4 could outsell the PS2 if they do what Microsoft did with the all digital Xbox, except make it actually have a point.

They could release a PS4 without a disc drive, that was smaller than the PS4 slim, and cost €200 with a 1st party bundled game. If they did that, they could sell 55 million more during the next generation. This is how the PS2 reached 155 million.

Nintendo should do the same with the Switch, keeping the original when the next gen rolls out.