Comments 528

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@Dodger I'm sorry sir, but you are far too rational for this comments section. Please see yourself out.

I kid, though. Glad to see someone thoughtful. I agree with what you said. I love discussions about all this nonsense we see in gaming, so it's always strange when you see the people that just brush things off like we shouldn't be talking about them.

A friend of mine used to say, simply, "If you enjoy the food you eat, talk to your friend about how it tastes, and you will enjoy it more."

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@LUIGITORNADO After being stabbed in the same eye, twice and being blind in it for 5 years of my life, I've considered it. I do bump into things occasionally, so sometimes work can be difficult. That obviously has carry over when looking at fast moving things on a tiny screen. Maybe you should be a little more courteous when we are discussing games with people you know nothing about.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@LUIGITORNADO Mainly the draw initially was that people keep saying that Astral Chain is more “methodical,” in its combat. When I first read a review of Dark Souls, years ago, a reviewer at Gamespot used the same word to describe its combat. Seeing as I love Dark Souls, I was thinking that astral chain would be similar in function. Bayonetta was so fast I couldn’t see what was going on when I played in handheld mode on Switch. I like slower games, and people are claiming Astral Chain is slower.

I watched a great video from GameXplain that felt way more balanced in its review process. The reviewer mentioned that Astral Chain, while fun, is inconsistent. Like, it had a 30 minute section with no combat. For me, inconsistent pacing is enough for me to skip it. I don’t need flashy combat to stay interested, but if a game is going to rely on silly fetch quests to fill in the good stuff I am happy finding other things to play!

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@Pandaman Not necessarily looking for a negative review, but I'm always skeptical when reviewers only say good things about the games they review. I already apologized to the reviewer, and dozens of people are jumping down my throat already about it, but I understand why you would defend a member of your staff. That at least, makes sense. Please have a wonderful rest of your day, and sorry again for the dissenting opinion.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@flapjack-ashley Thank you for sharing the other review scores. That's what is so disconcerting to me; the fact that I can't seem to find a dissenting opinion about the game. I'm open to the possibility that the game is just that good, and if that's true I'll have to try it. But, even games like Ocarina of Time, which scored a perfect 10 at Gamespot years ago, were criticized by at least a couple other websites during it's original release for it's few shortcomings.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@Damo Sorry to have offended you with my opinions of your writing. I'm willing to back down, if proven wrong. I even said so in my OP, that if enough people put their weight down on the game that I would retract my opinion and get on board with things. As it currently stands, I'm not sure I trust what the media outlets are saying. I recognize that that's on me. It's strictly personal, and in the end it's only affecting whether or not I choose to buy the game.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@antdickens I have years of basis to not fully trust in journalistic integrity in video games. There are great reviewers, and there are reviewers that tread upon that integrity by pushing a game a little too hard. Nintendo Life is a public website, with a public comments section. Why should it be above being questioned? Most of the time, I love the reviews from NL, but this one feels a little too pushy to me. I think you have just decided that you do not like me, based on what I wrote initially and my opinion of Astral Chain, in general. I respect your opinions and this website, but if something seems off I'm allowed to at least say something, especially in the civil manner I'm presenting.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@joezilla83 A game that's not ho-hum to me would be anything from the Souls series, anything from classic legacy systems such as Mega Man X or Final Fantasy 3, things like Symphony of the Night or Castlevania Chronicles. Horizon: Zero Dawn.

Hopefully I'll be proven wrong about Astral Chain. As it stands I'm afraid that the hype is giving it more credit than it deserves. With games like this, I always wait for the hype to die down and see where it lies after that and form my own opinions from watching gameplay footage.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@Chunkboi79 Right! They definitely are not my cup of tea. When I played the Transformers game, I loved the action sequences, but the in-between stuff was just not for me, as it ruined the great pacing of the fights. I felt the same from Bayonetta. As I stated in my OP, I'm willing to be proven wrong. Not sure why everyone is getting butthurt about my opinion against the hype train. For example, I love Dark Souls, but I know that game isn't for everyone. I recently watched a great video of a guy deconstructing the game because he didn't like it and didn't understand the hype. I learned a lot from his dissenting opinion, and it was a cool video. In the end, I still love Dark Souls but I don't defend it so vehemently when someone dislikes it. I really hope you enjoy Astral Chain when you get your hands on it! Thank you, and have a great day.

Re: Review: Astral Chain - Platinum's Best Game Ever? You'd Better Believe It

Mr_Muscle

@antdickens Is it so hard to understand that I think the reviewer is coloring the review to be a little too positive? As in, I think he's lying a bit to push the latest Nintendo game, hence why I chose to phrase it that I don't believe the review. Sorry, but that was a weak attempt at deconstructing my opinion. I also ended my original post stating that if many people ended up enjoying the game, that it would give the review more weight, but as it stands right now it feels too good to be true. Is that better?

Re: Square Enix Confirms Final Fantasy VIII Remastered Will Be A Digital-Only Release

Mr_Muscle

@graysoncharles Also, it’s really hard to use death as an argument for “importance” because literally nothing would be important because of an individuals passing away. The point of it is to recognize that our actions matter a lot, and that everything we are doing right now is figuratively and literally passing the torch to the next group of people that will be here after we pass. You can argue that for the individual, death makes all things lose importance. Yet, here we are, with the capability to ENJOY wonderful things like games and such. Are games the penultimate of importance? Obviously not, but to come in and just call people idiots because they enjoy something that you don’t doesn’t push the conversation ahead. Don’t use death as an excuse to shut down arguments!