Topic: What are the best 3D Mario(s) in your opinion?

For me, it is:
1.Super Mario Galaxy
2.Super Mario 64

Super Mario Sunshine sucks, and Super Mario Galaxy 2 will be the best when it's released.

Super Mario Sunshine does not suck, it is the best of the three. In second is Galaxy and 64 is last. I don't think Galaxy 2 has a chance of beating Sunshine.

Here is my 3D Mario game that I rank my favorite:
Super Mario Galxy. Such a fun title, and so many secrets to uncover. I also love the diverse perspective through the planets. It's awesome! ^^ Plus, the soundtrack is fantastic!

Mario 64 is still my favorite.

I think probably Galaxy, since that's the only one I've beaten LOL. I have 64 on my DS, but the controls just plain suck. Sunshine was fun, but the gameplay just wasn't as cool as Galaxy.

Galaxy is probably the best, but Sunshine will always be my favorite. Such a brilliant game that doesn't get any love

i haven't played Sunshine, but Galaxy definitely beats SM64 by a landslide, which beats SM64DS (i didn't like the controls either, pix, nor was I a fan of the tacked-on stars or playing as other characters; it felt gimmicky). i'm'a hold off on judgment re: SMG2 until i've played it for myself, though. :3

Galaxy> 64>>>>>> Sunshine

My opinion on 64 is a little mixed though. I only played the DS version, and as timeless a game as it is, and how awesome the extra features were, the crappy controls really tainted the experience. 3D platformer were just not meant to be controlled with a D-Pad...

1. 64
2. Reserved for Galaxy 2
3. Galaxy
4. Not Sunshine
5. Sunshine

Sunshine's camera and controls just sucked. Also, the spin jump was unusable.

#1. Super Mario Sunshine
#2. Super Mario 64
#10. Super Mario Galaxy

I don't know if New Super Mario Bros. for the DS counts, but if it does, it comes as a close second.

Super Mario 64 for me

1. Sunshine
2. Galaxy
3. 64

Galaxy 2 might beat Sunshine if they make it as challenging as they say they will.

@Axoloth - Well, we'll just wait and see. But until then, more SMG for me! YAY!!!

The only downside I have with Mario 64 is I only ever got a chance to play it during visiting hours. I never have time to play it all day because I don't have the N64 original or the DS version, and I barely ever sleepover at a certain friend's or cousin's house. I really need to download it on the VC. Good game, though

Super mario galaxy! Easy but fun!

Camera: yes it sucked. Controls were fine and spin jump was very easy to use.

You want me to choose? But... that's impossible! They're all too good!
_{Although Galaxy was a bit easy.}

@RandomWiiPlayer
I'll admit the controls were okay, but the spin jump rarely worked. You'd often go in the wrong direction and not make it to where you wanted to go. The spin jump made one level, containing a yoshi and a lot of evil platforms, just plain stupid.

All three are masterpieces but if I have to make a list:

1- Galaxy
2- 64
3- Sunshine

Galaxy.