Comments 244

Re: The Pokémon Company Releases Official Statement About Palworld

oatmaster

The legal test in the UK for this sort of thing would be whether 'a moron in a hurry' would mistake it for a Pokemon game. I'd argue that they would based on the designs. Strictly it applies to trademarks but it's often used in a broader way.

Edit: just realised I had this legal test wrong in that the test fails if 'only a moron in a hurry' would mistake two similar items rather than things needing to be sufficiently distinctive for said moron. I apologise for my error.

Re: Nintendo Confirms That Splatoon 3's Shiver Identifies As Female

oatmaster

Just a small attempt to get back to some sort of reasonableness before I get any more het up. Most of the arguments are basically semantic and unwinnable. Instead we should focus on impact and harm.

What actual impact do these issues have on you? If you're cis (I know that annoys some people but is a useful shorthand), straight, etc, what effect does inclusivity have on your life? Most I can really see is that it means you have to put a bit more care into your choice of words which is basic politeness. Or sitting through the odd boring course.

If, however, you are gay, trans, non-binary or whatever the exclusion has a much bigger impact. If every piece of culture is denying your very existence that's going to have a profound impact.

So I reckon that's the way to look at it. You can still believe whatever you want as it's only interactions that count. And if your interactions are harming someone then free speech or whatever doesn't completely clear your conscience.

edit to add: going to have to bow out on that. Had my say and this is all having a profoundly adverse effect on me.

Re: Nintendo Confirms That Splatoon 3's Shiver Identifies As Female

oatmaster

@johnvboy thing is, I don't see much middle ground. The people opposed to anything to do with gender identity seem largely affronted by the existence of people outside the classic binary. At best, they resent being required to do the basically polite thing of allowing people to decide how they're addressed, at worst they want things put in place to prevent them from existing. The best case scenario probably feels pretty extreme to a trans woman who's being told she's a bloke.

I genuinely don't know what the reasonable middle ground looks like in this context.

Re: Nintendo Confirms That Splatoon 3's Shiver Identifies As Female

oatmaster

@johnvboy their affliliations lie in the direction of internationally recognised human rights, equalities and hate speech legislation. As the publisher of all these comments they are obliged by law to not let them descend into the abyss. The disclaimers are there in a, generally fruitless, attempt to nip it in the bud.

Re: Review: Cult Of The Lamb - Animal Crossing Goes Bad In This Satisfyingly Stressful Sim

oatmaster

@FantasiaWHT The Sandman is very good for a range of LGBT+ representation with LGBT+ characters not all being depicted positively. The trick generally is that any character's evilness is incidental to their queerness, in the same way that evil straight characters can be evil without it having anything to do with their straightness.

Although The Sandman doesn't lend itself to simple interpretations tbf.

Re: Review: Cult Of The Lamb - Animal Crossing Goes Bad In This Satisfyingly Stressful Sim

oatmaster

@Not_Soos I wonder if the stigmatising depictions are a sort of confirmation bias. In that, people who have experienced strife as a result of religion are more likely to be creating stories to tell people about it. I remember a Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff podcast episode touching on something similar - the cliché of the church that is all evil. They pointed out that there must be some positive social benefit to it or it wouldn't have persisted for so long, no organisation can if it's just all evil. They were talking in the context of RPG world building and how you need to find a purpose for this religion to be existing, that certain conditions in the world must be present that the church helps and contributes to.

Re: Fangamer Is Finally Getting An EU Store

oatmaster

@Obs ah, cheers! Think my biggest was about £115 so that makes sense.

I suspect shipping costs rather than customs will be more of an advantage compared to US anyway, although they always seemed pretty reasonable to me. Think 'forfansbyfans' had some things I wanted from Slime Rancher but their shipping was bonkers compared to FanGamer.

Re: Apex Legends' Ping System Now 'Patent-Free' As EA Announces Accessibility Pledge

oatmaster

@Richnj I'd imagine they're giving free rights to use the innovations in the patents but not the actual code to implement it. The code itself would have to be quite specific to the game its used in and couldn't easily just be dropped in from one game to another.

That said, it does raise the possibility of someone developing an open version of it that could be dropped into Unreal Engine or Unity or similar without infringing anything.