Comments 26

Re: Game Director Swery Will Rewrite At Least One Scene In Deadly Premonition 2

monkeydude

People in this comment section (and on the internet in general) need to realize that disagreement is not violence. Anybody who has ever been in a fight knows the difference between words and violence. Not everybody has to agree and disagreeing does not automatically equal bigotry. Losing our ability to amicably disagree with one another is a big part of the reason why the world is in such poor shape today. If you believe deadnaming is such a sign of disrespect, you can convey that message without resorting to petty namecalling, or worse, attempting to "cancel" them for being wrong in your eyes. And on the other hand, some may not get the concept of deadnaming or why some percieve it as hurtful, as many people have never even met a transperson and not all transpeople find that offensive (I personally know at least one transperson who finds this business very tiresome) - but you do still need to treat all people with basic levels of respect no matter who they are or how they differ from you. It's not justifiable to belittle transpeople or their plight just because you disagree with Swery's decision to rewrite this character, and joking about this is only going to degrade the discourse surrounding this issue.

@nessisonett I see you in particular taking to the comment section to shame anybody who thinks differently than you on a regular basis. I agree the suicide rate in the trans community is a big problem - but do you really think you are changing any minds by rushing in here and throwing emotionally charged rhetoric around? Is this the place to have that discussion properly? Or is this the comment section of a Nintendo news website? Regardless, you can criticize constructively without alienating everybody you disagree with. You can try to educate instead of tearing down anybody who doesn't see it the way you do. Telling someone they're going to "die out" will only make them close their ears to what you're saying.

Tl;dr: Maybe it's for the best that Swery learned this lesson before he inadvertently hurt anybody with his portrayal of a trans character - but let's not pretend there isn't a ton of confusion surrounding this issue even for well-meaning people, and I hardly think Swery's ignorance of the subject equates to bigotry. There has to be some level of understanding of the artist's intent before we condemn them to the court of public opinion. Clearly he felt guilty once people let him know what deadnaming is and why it's controversial.

Edit: Apologies for this long post, but it really is the sort of issue that shouldn't be relegated to a short, careless response.

Re: Pokémon Releases New Looney Tunes-Style Cartoon Starring Scraggy And Mimikyu

monkeydude

@FX102A Seems they may have been going for more of a Fleischer Studios inspired aesthetic with this cartoon, as the noodly arms and squash-and-stretch animation suggest something closer to Koko the Clown or Merrie Melodies than the Looney Tunes comparison offered in the article. I think it's very well done and captures the look and feel of the period rather successfully

Re: Gallery: Artist Reimagines Animal Crossing Characters As People

monkeydude

I'm just going to say it. Next to the rumor reporting and hacking/emulation news (which always sets off the community) these are my least favorite news items that you run. Tumblr fan art isn't a new or unique phenomenon and there is nothing newsworthy in this article. Just my opinion. Sorry to be blunt

Re: Video: Nintendo Takes A Look Back At Super Smash Bros. Ultimate's Biggest Moments

monkeydude

For me, Ultimate came very close to being the perfect Smash experience. The only thing it lacks imo is a more fleshed out campaign, closer to Brawl's or Melee's. Yeah WoL was a lot of fun and a decent replacement, but imagine how cool it would have been to explore side-scrolling recreations of the most memorable locations in Mario, Sonic, Metroid, MGS, Mother, etc. with Ultimate's huge roster. It's a shame there isn't more to do with these incredibly realized characters and move sets besides just smashing. Still looking forward to seeing who else gets announced for wave 2 DLC though

Re: My Nintendo Celebrates Mario Day With A 20% Discount On Select Merch (North America)

monkeydude

I'm going to echo what everybody else has said and pass on this offer. My Nintendo points are basically useless for anything except putting towards that meager discount on digital titles. Club Nintendo wasn't perfect but at least you were getting something tangible and unique for your trouble. Very disappointed that this is how Nintendo chooses to honor their diehard consumer base.

Re: The SNES PlayStation Was Going To Have A Super FX Chip Built-In

monkeydude

I'm glad things worked out the way they did. Both companies bring something unique and vital to the industry. Case in point, the mid-90s creative wellspring of game development that resulted from Sony going solo and needing to scrap for IP would have likely been impossible to replicate under different circumstances. I also would hate to think what Sony would have done with unfettered access to Nintendo's IP. Those CDi games were punishment enough.