50. Mario Kart: Double Dash!! (GCN)
Super Mario Kart invented the formula and Mario Kart 64 drove us into the 3D world, so by the time it came for the GameCube to receive its very own racer, it needed a hook.
That hook would come via Double Dash’s dual-driver system that added a creatively fun wrinkle to the already rock-solid foundations of before. It not only presented a new challenge to solo players, but opened up the playbook for multiplayer frivolity, briefly freeing Mario Kart from its free-for-all shackles with a dose of teamwork.
It would go on to become the second-highest-selling GameCube game ever, destined to both forge and destroy friendships with blue shells for years to come.
Subscribe to Nintendo Life on YouTube842k
Simon Cardy (IGN)
49. Luigi's Mansion 3 (Switch)
Essentially the best Ghostbusters game we’ve yet to play, Luigi’s Mansion 3 puts Mario’s often overshadowed brother into the spotlight in his third, and best, haunted outing.
The Switch exclusive found new levels of variety inside the already established “suck and snag” formula to great effect, as Luigi’s ectoplasmic doppelganger, Gooigi, fully joined in on the fun this time around, following his introduction in the 3DS remake of the original.
Not only did this gloopy green ghosthunter add a welcome cooperative wrinkle to proceedings, but he also brought a whole new bag of puzzle-solving tricks along with him. Luigi’s Mansion finally gave the taller Super Mario brother his own adventure to headline, and this threequel is the best example of why he deserved it.
Simon Cardy (IGN)
Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.
48. Wii Sports (Wii)
A sensation of almost unparalleled popularity, there’s arguably never been a system seller of the same scale as Wii Sports since Tetris landed on the original Game Boy.
Packed in with every console, this collection of bowling, tennis, golf, baseball, and boxing kept family members of all ages enthralled just as much as it boosted the TV repair business due to free-flying Wii remotes.
It’s not complex, nor does it display a level of wild creativity Nintendo is renowned for, but its beautiful simplicity delivered one thing above all: fun. And isn’t that the most important factor of all?
Simon Cardy (IGN)
47. The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening (Switch)
We could throw around adjectives like ‘dreamy’ for a bunch of iconic Zelda locales, but few feel as deserving of the title as Koholint Island. Regardless of whether you play it on Game Boy, Game Boy Color, or Switch, Link’s Awakening remains one of the series’ very best entries, every bit as enchanting today as it was in 1993.
It has everything you’d want from a classic Zelda — puzzle-y dungeons, crafty collectables, a stunning overworld — but it holds such an intriguing mystery at its core that it may just boast one of the most memorable endings to any of Link’s adventures.
We might have played it on three different consoles already, but a return trip to the land of the Wind Fish is always a dream.
Jim Norman (Nintendo Life)
46. F-Zero X (N64)
As much as Nintendo likes to make their games as accessible as possible by including game-balancing and catch-up mechanics, F-Zero X represents that side of Nintendo design that is uncompromisingly focused on player skill and technical prowess.
F-Zero X is a high-speed pack-racing tour de force that pits players against 29 other racers on twisting and turning courses. You may be tempted to play bumper cars with that many racers on track (you can spin-attack them), but F-Zero also requires careful balancing of your craft’s energy which fuels both boost and shield power.
That risk vs reward setup is front and centre in F-Zero X – and it’s easy to forget about what’s left in the proverbial tank when you’re racing on the outside of a magnetic pipe at 620mph.
Peer Schneider (IGN)
45. Super Mario Bros. (NES)
This is it. The culmination of Nintendo's game-making expertise up to this point. The Alpha, the Omega. There's nothing left to say. It's the original and the best.
Except it isn't the best, is it? After 40 years of iteration — four entire decades of analysis and refinement — it's only natural that the first 'Super' Mario Bros. isn't quite as super anymore. Yet the design principles put down by Miyamoto and Tezuka here made this the go-to, 101 text for an entire medium.
We forget, too, how quickly Super Mario Bros.' wonderland weirdness became 'normal' through sheer quality. Just a moment with the NES' angular pad and the strangeness of this little moustachioed man's world, a place where you jump on turtles' backs and hit floating boxes to reveal gliding, size-doubling mushrooms, seemed totally normal. Natural, even!
As the developers would go on to demonstrate many, many times (hi, Odyssey), when you make a game this good, anything goes.
Gavin Lane (Nintendo Life)
44. Banjo-Kazooie (N64)
Now a Microsoft studio, UK-based Rare was at one time something of an evil twin of the world’s best development team. Rare’s games were very “Nintendo” – but often with a dark streak and a twinkle in their eye.
Banjo-Kazooie (and the underappreciated, but nearly as brilliant sequel Banjo-Tooie) shares a lot of DNA with Mario 64 – but it adds a wicked sense of humour and a visual style that makes it stand on its own two paws. From the taunts of its rhyming antagonist to the ridiculous transformations and the “thaaaaaannk you” flower pots (yeah, we all heard something different), Banjo-Kazooie keeps players chuckling throughout.
But it’s the top-tier level design and the collection of musical earworms that make BK truly unforgettable. Whether it’s the oversized organ hitting all the right notes in Mad Monster Mansion or spotting differences among the changing seasons in Click Clock Wood, Banjo-Kazooie is a delight that’s not to be missed.
Peer Schneider (IGN)
43. Super Mario Bros. Wonder (Switch)
What if Mario was an elephant? What if King Boo was an opera singer? What if Piranha Plants marched to the beat of their own catchy tune? Super Mario Bros. Wonder’s answer to all of these questions is a confident, “Yes, and?”
Wonder was the refresh 2D Mario desperately needed after nearly two decades of competent-but-samey New Super Mario Bros. games, and you can feel the pent-up creativity bursting from all corners of the Flower Kingdom. The imaginative Wonder Flower mechanics add surprise and delight to each stage, and the fresh art style and detailed animations – like the way Mario plucks his hat out of the air when entering a Warp Pipe – make Wonder the best-looking 2D Mario since at least Super Mario World.
Aside from its somewhat clunky multiplayer, Wonder feels like the first true successor to the classic NES and SNES Super Mario games, and it proved Nintendo can still make some of the best 2D platformers out there.
Logan Plant (IGN)
42. Mario Kart World (Switch 2)
Nintendo had to do something special with Mario Kart World. Not only was this the first 100% new console entry in the flagship racing series in 11 years, it was also to be the poster child of Switch 2, and the day-one purchase for most people picking up the system.
It’s a testament to the devs, then, just how refined the series’ tried-and-tested formula feels. There’s a lot to love about Mario Kart World — the wonderfully frantic Knockout Mode, intense 24-driver races, the all-timer soundtrack — and while it might not have thrown out the rulebook to quite the extent that some were hoping, you’ll be hard pushed to get more smiles from a racer.
The perfect introduction to a new console generation and some of the finest driving we’ve seen from Nintendo’s prized plumber.
Jim Norman (Nintendo Life)
41. The Legend of Zelda (NES)
The Legend of Zelda introduced a whole new way of bringing wonderfully dense atmosphere to the world of video games. Zelda laid a foundation strong enough to succeed against the side-scrolling console trends of the time, to stay the course and deliver...well, let's just say this series went places.
Played now, it still holds up thanks to tight design for each of the dungeons. While it may be nowhere near as complex as Link's latest, the base of that oh-so-addictive adventuring sauce was already being cooked up here.
PJ O'Reilly (Nintendo Life)
40. Super Smash Bros. Melee (GCN)
Super Smash Bros. Melee has essentially single-handedly kept the secondhand market for CRT televisions alive for the last 15 years. Passionate Smash Bros. fans keep lugging the unwieldy boxes around to tournaments all over the world, because that’s just how enduring Melee is.
Masahiro Sakurai’s GameCube masterpiece is still the fastest, deepest, most technical fighting game Nintendo’s ever produced, and top players continue to make new discoveries that push the competitive scene forward. It’s not just for the pros, though – Melee is an amazing game for casual players, too, with a ridiculous amount of modes, items, characters, stages, and unlockables that can keep you busy for hundreds of hours.
If you’re not sold on Melee’s legacy, look no further than the fact that Nintendo still sells GameCube controller adapters for each new Smash entry so stubborn fans (us included) can keep playing with 24-year-old hardware because it just doesn’t feel right any other way.
Logan Plant (IGN)
39. Kirby and the Forgotten Land (Switch)
Forgotten Land took Sakurai's son and placed him in a 3D adventure of which even the mighty Mario would be proud. The introduction of mouthful mode proved to be a masterstroke, both in building hype through some highly entertaining trailers and in gameplay itself, sitting comfortably alongside Kirby's usual gamut of copy abilities to make for the most rewarding and challenging outing for the food-gobbling good guy thus far.
Throw in a top-notch world full of fun puzzles, perfectly pitched boss fights, and plenty of collectables, and we're in big win city.
PJ O'Reilly (Nintendo Life)
38. Super Mario RPG (Switch)
In 1996, Square took the beloved turn-based fundamentals of its Final Fantasy series and applied them to a wholly unexpected new world: Super Mario.
Technically, the first Mario game to have gameplay in a 3D environment, it was a striking technical achievement for the time, but Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars also managed to perform alchemy and combine what made both of its touchstones so successful.
Its party and battle systems were comfortably familiar, yet still complex enough to engage Square RPG veterans, but layered on top of this was a level of charm, colour, and humour that was expected from a Nintendo Mario game. Its legacy remains to this day, almost 30 years later, with remasters, remakes, and spin-offs in no short supply.
Simon Cardy (IGN)
37. Metroid: Zero Mission (GBA)
Nintendo is, and has always been, big on remakes – so it wasn’t a huge surprise when it announced a return to the original NES Metroid with GBA’s Metroid: Zero Mission. But when it arrived in 2004 amidst a Metroid renaissance started by Prime and Fusion, it didn’t just turn out to be better than the original – it even outperformed the biggest Metroid fans’ raised expectations.
Zero Mission isn’t just a prettier version of the game that started it all, it uses familiarity with the original as a way to surprise players with the unknown. While the return to the original location supplies all the nostalgic feels returning players were hoping for, the something old and something borrowed quickly makes way for something new... and something blue.
Samus sheds her power suit to add a heavy dose of stealth to the usual exploration and combat-heavy Metroid experience. Add to that a whole new area and an emphasis of not just tolerating, but encouraging sequence-breaking, and you’ve got a timeless classic absolutely worth going back to.
Peer Schneider (IGN)
36. GoldenEye 007 (N64)
It’s hard to imagine a time when first-person shooters and consoles weren’t a perfect match, but before GoldenEye 007’s N64 release in 1997, any FPS using a D-pad was largely unplayable. But then, Developer Rare did the unthinkable.
Not only did it manage to translate a popular PC genre onto a Nintendo 64 controller, but it created a licensed game that was a genuine game of the year contender, seemingly an impossible feat not only back in 1997, but still to this day!
GoldenEye became a standard bearer for not only movie tie-in games but first-person shooters in general. Decades later, many pretenders (and even a direct remake) have failed to capture that magical formula.
Dale Driver (IGN)
35. Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury (Switch)
The Wii U was already in trouble just a year after launch, but the hardcore Nintendo faithful who owned it by November 2013 were treated to Super Mario 3D World. Nintendo took 3D Land’s, well, three-dimensional take on the classic Super Mario Bros. formula and threw every idea they had at it.
There’s the Double Cherry power-up that gives you control of multiple Marios at once, clear pipes where you have to wisely choose your path, and, of course, the iconic Cat Suit. Every level introduces a clever new idea, and the whole experience is enhanced when you add more players to the mix, as 3D World has the best multiplayer in any Super Mario game, no question.
The definitive Switch version added the wonderfully experimental Bowser’s Fury, which some hope could be a template for an open-world Mario game in the future.
Logan Plant (IGN)
34. Star Fox 64 (N64)
These days, Star Fox has a far bigger problem than the insidious Andross' designs on the Lylat system: no series entry has ever recaptured the glory of this on-rails masterpiece from 1997.
We've seen some intriguing experiments in the decades since (enough to keep Fox fans' flames burning, at least), but Nintendo EAD utterly nailed the arcade-y shooter formula with this sequel. Adding 64-bit spectacle and wonderfully corny voice acting to the framework of the Super NES original led to a nigh-on perfect realisation of blockbuster movie majesty in video game form.
Today, it's still a sensory feast; the N64's spindly, precise analogue stick forming up with a gently throbbing Rumble Pak to deliver cinematic bombast that also has subtlety. Star Fox 64 is a class act.
No game is perfect, of course. But Slippy Toad aside, they don't come much closer than this.
Gavin Lane (Nintendo Life)
33. Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze (Switch)
Retro Studios’ second crack at a Donkey Kong Country game turned out to be one of the best 2D platformers of all time. It’s hard to imagine a more cinematic sidescroller than Tropical Freeze, with incredible setpieces like riding on a minecart rail that’s actively being chopped to pieces by a buzzsaw, or frantically climbing up a crumbling iceberg on the frozen-over Donkey Kong island.
No level or moment is wasted, and the narrative Tropical Freeze weaves across each world through its excellent environmental worldbuilding is unmatched for a 2D platformer, the best of which is a juice factory that takes you through every step of the process from harvesting grapes to freezing juice into popsicles for the world’s final boss to enjoy.
On top of brilliant presentation, Tropical Freeze is hard as nails in the best way, with difficult challenges that require mastery of DK’s weighty, momentum-based physics and high-skill techniques. Oh, and you get to play as Cranky Kong. Cranky Kong!
Logan Plant (IGN)
32. EarthBound (SNES)
EarthBound is one of the few games that has truly improved with age. Long after the days of weird scratch-and-sniff promos, this is a perfect satire of America and of the RPG genre. It doesn’t just mock blindly, though, it’s also a celebration of the innocence of childhood, and of turn-based combat.
Few games are as charming, delightful, or funny as EarthBound, and its discussions on adulthood and the weirdness of growing up are eternally relevant. And without the late Satoru Iwata jumping in to help his friend Shigesato Itoi program the game, we might never have seen its magic come to light.
Alana Hagues (Nintendo Life)
31. Mega Man 2 (NES)
The original Mega Man didn’t sell particularly well upon launch, so it’s kind of a miracle that Capcom green-lit a sequel in the first place. It’s a good job it did, however, since Mega Man 2 still stands as the greatest entry in the long-running series.
Honed to perfection with buttery-smooth responsiveness and superb power-ups, the levels and bosses remain some of the most memorable of all time, and once you’ve listened to the sublime soundtrack, you’ll feel like you’ve ascended to a higher plane of existence.
Figuring out the most optimal route through the eight Robot Masters remains one of the most satisfying accomplishments in all of gaming. It’s tough, but in memorising the intricate placement of obstacles and enemies, you’ll keep coming back for more.
Ollie Reynolds (Nintendo Life)
30. Pikmin 4 (Switch)
After a decade-long wait for a new game following Pikmin 3, Nintendo delivered the franchise’s best entry yet with Pikmin 4.
It’s hard to confine Pikmin to one genre – it’s got real-time strategy, action adventure, puzzle, worker placement, and even metroidvania elements – but no matter what you call it, you can sum Pikmin up with one word: satisfying.
Whether you’re solving puzzles in caves returning from Pikmin 2, exploring the most complex and gorgeous environments the series has seen, or defending valuable resources in the new tower defense night levels, commanding your army of weird plant aliens has never felt better.
Throw in your adorable dog companion Oatchi and an entire second campaign to tackle after the credits roll, and you’ve got the definitive Pikmin experience that Pikmin 5 will have a hard time topping.
Logan Plant (IGN)
29. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (Switch)
Over the years, Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door gained a reputation among hardcore Nintendo fans that matched the tales of the legendary door itself, and its extremely passionate fanbase was finally rewarded with an immaculate Switch remake that justified why this GameCube classic is so treasured.
Mario’s quest to gather the Crystal Stars is timeless, with memorable, quirky characters like the smart and sassy Goombella and the mourning sea captain Admiral Bobbery, incredible settings including a wrestling league held on a floating island above the clouds, and sharp, laugh-out-loud writing that beautifully ties it all together. Rogueport stands as one of the most iconic locations in Nintendo history, with a gritty, comedic edge not found in many of the company’s games.
As an RPG, TTYD is no slouch either, with its flexible Badge system and the best take on Mario RPG combat, complete with a live audience that cheers when Mario does well – what a showoff.
Logan Plant (IGN)
28. Xenoblade Chronicles: Definitive Edition (Switch)
Xenoblade Chronicles isn't just a great game. Everything about it, from its graphics and technical achievements to the music, story, combat - it all comes together with such balanced cohesion that it feels almost effortless.
Its identity is not just in its excellent artistic direction, but also in its peculiar history of being localised in British English as opposed to American English, lending a relative uniqueness that only heightens the voice acting. It's not always taking itself too seriously, but when it does, lordy do you feel it.
Monsters a hundred times your size and power loom over you from the very beginning, begging you to come back once you're stronger and able to fell them. All of this, and it was somehow squeezed onto the humble Wii.
Alex Olney (Nintendo Life)
27. Pokémon Yellow Version: Special Pikachu Edition (GB)
The video game world would be very different without Pokémon.
Its influence stretches far beyond gaming and the anime, but it all started on the humble Game Boy with the very first 151. Pokémon Red & Blue (and Yellow) take the battling and levelling basics of the RPG genre and expertly pair them up with cute creature collecting.
For kids getting into games, the pure magic of going on an adventure with your animal friends was enough to birth a mega-franchise. While multiple entries have since surpassed the original, there’s something about Gen 1’s purity that still stands strong today.
Alana Hagues (Nintendo Life)
26. Castlevania: Aria of Sorrow (GBA)
The promise of a 'portable Symphony of the Night' was something Konami offered up twice before Aria of Sorrow appeared in 2003; Circle of the Moon (2001) and Harmony of Dissonance (2002) weren't bad games as such, but they fell a long way short of the greatness of the 1997 epic which gave us the term 'Metroidvania'.
However, the third time's a charm, as the saying goes, and Aria of Sorrow really did live up to the hype. While the visuals and sound are obviously a step down from the PlayStation classic, everything else about this pocket-sized adventure simply screams brilliance. It showcases hundreds of enemies to slay, a massive non-linear castle to explore and countless weapons and items to collect – not to mention the unique 'Tactical Soul' system, where powers are inherited from fallen foes.
Now accessible to a whole new generation via the sublime Castlevania Advance Collection on modern systems, this is one of the best entries in Konami's long-running franchise, which surely speaks volumes.
Damien McFerran (Nintendo Life)





Comments 122
This list, as I noted on IGN, is all over the place.
Mother 3, Diddy Kong Racing, Goldeneye, Banjo-Kazooie, and Donkey Kong Country 2 should all be so much lower on this list.
Placing Mario Kart World well ahead of Diddy Kong Racing is absolutely absurd.
Also, placing Odyssey in the top 10 but having Bananza not break the top 20 is a choice.
Nice to see Eternal Darkness and Super Castlevania IV - loved those back in the day!
Mario 64 at 25th place is criminal.
Overall great list regardless of personal opinions on the ranking, it encompasses practically all Nintendo systems and kinds of games - even more than seeing the usual suspects at the top as expected, I'm happy to see no matter if near the bottom some games that were far from guaranteed to be included considering the sheer number of candidates, 999 just to make an example (and while it had a higher chance and so is unsurprisingly also higher in the ranking I love to see Elite Beat Agents, too)!
Super Mario 64 should be number a one-a!
It's nice seeing A Link Between Worlds so high up, it's a personal favorite of mine and it feels like nobody talks about it anymore.
It has all the right notes but not necessarily in the right order.
Brings me great joy seeing TotK properly respected above BotW.
However, having Viewtiful Joe, F-Zero GX, and Donkey Kong Country 2 all ranked so low is offensive. Those are easily some of the best games ever.
Majoras Mask is too low. And Wind Waker is too high.
BOTW & TOTK at the top? Nah, no way! If Zelda is going to be at the top, it's gotta be Ocarina or Link to the Past to be honest. If Mario is at the top, then SMB3 or World, or even 64 or Galaxy. Glad to see Super Metroid in the top 10!
At the end of the day it's a list that can't hurt me, and nearly everything I would want to be on it is on it. But if I had to give it a letter grade for its ranking?
F minus.
Dragon Quest XI made it on the list and not Dragon Quest V? Unacceptable! >_<
Spoilers: Galaxy 2 beating Galaxy 1 makes me happy. The midnight launch for Galaxy 2 is a treasured memory for me..
Ah yes, another Top 100 list where everyone is more focused on the ranking of individual games than the fact that they are all on the same list of GREATEST GAMES of all time. Like being ranked #22 instead of #10 isn't a .0001 percent difference in their quality, lol.
The best thing to note is, regardless of my opinion on the arbitrary rankings, Nintendo has a lot of really good games.
How on earth did Mario Kart World make this list?
How is this a top 100 Nintendo list when there's plenty of multiplatform games on it?
Yup, had to be TOTK (or BOTW) at #1. I don’t think I’ve ever invested as much time into any game in my entire life as those two (especially TOTK). Pretty much became gaming euphoria getting lost in a world I’d always dreamed of deeply exploring. OOT is incredible and it’s always going to be there, but it was also really a 3D interpretation of ALttP. It took Nintendo to break conventions to really make something revolutionary with its complex chemical engine in TOTK. It’s not for everyone for sure (no game is) but it’s a history staple nonetheless in what can be achieved in gaming.
Side note: Galaxy 2 beating out Galaxy is pretty wild to me. I could personally repeat play Galaxy 1 over and over, but Galaxy 2 (much like the new Astro Bot) is a fantastic example of ultimate first time experience (one hit galaxies) with very little replayabily, with the tedium regrettably setting in with poorly implemented Green Star Campaign). But hey, opinions be opinions.
Wow, TotK and BotW at the top is insane. I'm playing TotK right now and it is a really good game, but I think it's a bit overshadowed by the fact that it feels a little like a collectathon at the same time. Especially when played with Zelda Notes. I'm having a great time 100+ hours in, but I still think it bleaks in comparison to BotW and A Link to the Past.
And putting Fire Emblem: Three Houses so low on the list should be a criminal offense.
Such a lot of bangers. Nintendo is such a gem.
Must have been almost impossible to create this list, and any of the top 25 can move based on personal liking I’d guess.
Earthbound blew my mind as a kid. It's still endlessly fun to play through over and over again. I thought Chrono Trigger was over-rated from the start - a good game, but nowhere close to Final Fantasy VI, and I much preferred Earthbound over both of those.
Also, F-Zero GX down in the 80's? Mario 64 in the 20's? Ugh. Oh well, not my list.
not my list, but mario odyssey at #4 is actually ridiculous. It was not as good as so many of the games under it in my opinion, still a top 10-20. but the open world zeldas at the top? Hard to disagree without your rose colored glasses on.
Well, this certainly is a list
Overall good list. Discussing individual ranking is a meaningless effort, instead we should be content that we have a gold mine full of great titles to look at.
Now, where is Space Station Sillicon Valley? I don't see it in the top 20
including 999 but not Virtue's Last Reward hurts a little (I guess I'm grateful one of these games made it)
@slowpoke_tail I'd like to play it, but it's on 3DS, and I don't want to buy a 3DS just for this (and Mecha Kirby).
Jesus, Yoshi's Island at 62,
and Donkey Kong Country 2 at 78,
this isn't a serious list.
Laters potaters.
At the very least this is just a list of 100 awesome Nintendo games, no need to look at the numbers! ^^
I wonder how many people actually played Mother 3 in the West....
Removed - advertising
Whoa! So I said on the other article that the top 5 to me were SMW, SM64, Zelda ALttP, Zelda OoT, and Super Metroid (not necessarily in that order). Four of those five were in the top 10, so I feel good about that. That said the actual ordering is bananas. Tears of the kingdom is mediocre at best, and DK Bananza is far too high as well. Mario Odyssey is fourth best Nintendo game? I’m not sure it’s even the fourth best Mario game. I hope I don’t sound too angry - I’m smiling as I type this. Bickering about the list is of course the most fun part! Sociologically it’s very interesting. I can see the taste difference of younger versus older gamers.
Wish Radiant Historia made a surprise entry
I feel like Ghost Trick is conspicuously absent.
Terranigma, Atlus games, Solatorobo (maybe too deep a cut), Inazuma Eleven, Chibi Robo…
Would rather have seen some of these instead of multiple entries of the same franchise.
Fun list! I enjoyed reading it throughout the week.
@PessitheMystic Eyy Solatorobo! Great game, great OST.
Wow. Just wow.
The top 25 are all solid bangers, but Mario 64 and Galaxy are way too low in that
Absolutely unquestionable, this top 2. When Breath of the Wild was released, it was without a doubt the best game of all time, and Tears of the Kingdom came and surpassed it in every possible aspect. It is the greatest injustice in history that the best game of all time lost the Game of the Year title to a forgettable game.
Rabble rabble rabble, I disagree with the ordering of this list, rabble rabble rabble.
In all seriousness though, Super Mario RPG (Switch) shouldn't even be on this list, let alone at #38 🤣
A list like this was ALWAYS going to be subjective but even with that in mind, I will say that seeing Mario Kart World and Animal Crossing New Horizons ranked as high as they were was...a choice, to put it nicely.
I would like a recount on Mega Man 2 please. Not sure how that got left in.
And quite how Super Mario Galaxy only gets in at 23 ... I just ...
Tetris (GB) is obviously an iconic game, but that shouldn't be allowed to compromise the integrity of this list. Have it out, bump Galaxy up to the Top 10, and restore some order to this thing.
I'd have a hard time not having Mario Galaxy, Mario 3D World and Smash Bros Ultimate in my top 10, and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe would be duking it out for the No.1 spot with Breath of the Wild.
Golden Sun is a top 20 game for me. Its criminal its so high in the list
No ones top 100 Nintendo game list will be the same. This list is way off for my choices.
This is one of the lists of all time for sure
Plenty of deserving games on here, some others not so much. And some criminal omissions (no Pikmin 2, no Resident Evil Remake, no Explorers of Sky, no Radiant Historia, Dragon Quest III, V, IX, pretty sure I never saw Bowser’s Inside Story or Metroid Fusion)
Also yeah, the order is wacky as hell, though tbf I'd probably have a hard time ordering them too.
About what I was expecting from IGN.
This list can’t seem to make up its mind on whether it’s ranking on quality or impact.
I can understand Galaxy 2 over 1, but given they are two sides of the same coin, why are they e 9 spaces apart?
The only 2 Fire Emblem titles being almost 80 spaces apart seems bizarre as well (especially since 3H is probably better…).
Donkey Kong Country 2 is one of the best platformers ever made, on any console. Being on place 78 is blasphemy. I mean Tetris on 5th place? Seriously which is the better game?
What I like about this list:
What I disagree with this list
I’m a Mario Kart World sympathizer, but above Metroid Dread? Above the original Super Mario Bros? Seriously?
And Three Houses being down in the 90’s? That’s just plain wrong.
That said, I had a wonderful time with the face off page on IGN and forcing friends and family to do it. Got some real interesting results from them, as we always know what “the gamers” will vote for, but the casuals are more unique in their choices. My sister sending me a screenshot of Mario Kart 64 vs Animal Crossing New Horizons for her final showdown was fun to see.
Weird list overrall, but I can't complain about the top 10.
Great list. People will disagree with placings. But amazing, amazing games.
@slowpoke_tail same, I've played that title dozens of times. I too was excited to see it so high, and if I recall right it was one of 2 3DS games on the list.
@Franc001 I would never dunk on DKC2, but that‘s like saying "why rate chess that high when you have games like The Settlers“ on a list of the top boardgames of all time. Sometimes perfection is in simplicity.
On one hand I want to question the sheer number of SNES games so high up on the list – I mean, I get that the SNES era was a big deal for a lot of childhoods but c'mon.
On the other hand, Breath of the Wild and Tears of the Kingdom as 1&2? Please. No way. We don't have history on those yet to tell us if they really stand the test of time. I didn't like either one, to be honest, preferring the older style Zelda games where I didn't need to eat, craft, and run out of breath every 13 seconds, but I get they need to be on the list somewhere.
And Mario 64 at 25? Nah. I hate that game but it's SO beloved that it deserves top 10, if not top 5.
All of that and my boy Fox McCloud below Toad's silly treasure tracker? Criminal.
Super Mario World and Super Mario Bros 3 are almost always concluded to be the best Mario games, while they are some of my least favorite Mario games. I just don't get the hype about them.
"76. Secret of Mana (SNES)"
Hurray. It made the list! Obviously, I rank it far higher on a personal level, but I am just glad it got mentioned.
My Super Metroid on 8 makes my enormously proud!
@beartown You had to be there. We really didn't have anything better to play until Super Mario World and Donkey Kong Country came along.
I agree with the vast majority of inclusions even if not their exact placement. I'm glad to see Wario Land 4, Wave Race 64, and The Legend of Zelda A Link Between Worlds get their flowers.
I was wondering when the IGN collaborations would start. It was good while it lasted. So long Nintendolife.
What's that Japanese game with the red cover in the cover picture?
This is what happens when you have people vote without playing most of the games. I voted in this list and I am familiar with all of them but played maybe 20 if I had to guess.
As someone who loves BOTW and TOTK, lists like this exists partially to make people hate BOTW and TOTK.
Thanks for a nice list, some good trips down memory lane for one thing. I don’t think I saw Conker’s Bad Fur Day on there though hmm
Only big disappointment was BoTW not beating ToTK, and reading that Nintendolife staff had to bow down to IGN on that one. BoTW was so momentously impactful. Goes to show I’m frequenting the better site of the two
This is a fun list to read through. I kept wondering how I would even begin to arrange my Top 100. I don’t think I could really rank them. My Top 20 would just all be basically tied for 1st. Simply some of the best games ever. With that said I’ve been whispering for years when anyone would ask what my favorite game is “The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds.” It takes the best game that held its ground for a couple of decades (A Link To the Past) and improves everything. Pure Nintendo magic, and must be played with headphones on a 3DS (XL with IPS screens preferably). I also will often say my favorite game ever is Pikmin 3, especially with all the extra co-op and content added in the Deluxe release. The other 98 games for me: impossible to easily come up with a ranking. Super Mario World was the best [video game] investment I made as a kid though (my best purchase being my first pair of waterproof hiking boots). Thanks for the fun read!
@Daniel36 It's Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan - a very fun rhythm game like Elite Beat Agents.
@kal_el_07241 I would argue Mother 3 shouldn't even be listed, as there is technically no legal way to play it on a North American or European console, other than adding a Japanese account to a Nintendo Switch, and even then you need to be fluent in Japanese.
@kal_el_07241 perhaps it's about the time like you said. I was late to the party when it comes Super Mario Bros 3 and Super Mario World. I grew up playing Super Mario Bros and Super Mario 64. I like the simplicity of these games and I also love the newer Mario games, like Super Mario Odyssey or Super Mario Wonder. The thing I don't like about World or 3 is that it's neither simple or complex enough to be fun for me. These games are too random and I also don't like the art style in them.
To me A Link to the Past and Super Mario World will always be tied as the best Nintendo games of all time.
The Fire Emblem selections feel a bit too safe in my opinion. Awakening is a great game and same with Three Houses. But I feel Fire Emblem 7, Mystery of the Emblem and Genealogy of the Holy War are notable ones that didn't make the cut due to being Japan only.
@beartown interesting perspective!
Personally I just adore Mario World including its art direction; the more connected overworld map and its secrets made it feel like a real adventure. But, I played it while it was that time period so not sure how I’d judge it otherwise. As it stands, it’s in my top 5 of all time!
@molkom yeah, I'm pretty sure they introduced some interesting concepts that have been done better later by other games. I'll give them another go at some point though.
Odyssey at number 4?!?
It’s a good game but so many other Super Mario games are better.
The design is sometimes terrible in Odyssey. New donk city and the rabbit bosses is two examples of that.
Those rankings are HORRiBLE.! Just... soooooo wrong.
Ocarina of Time is like The Eagles of top 100 lists...Both of them have been on top for so long that we don't even consider the possibility that they have aged like milk.
Removed - unconstructive feedback; user is banned
Man, I really wish I’d actually liked Breath of the Wild, it was basically everything I didn’t want in a Zelda game, and it seems like that’s the only style we’re going to get from now on. 😢
Don't worry too much about this.
Surprised by top spot as in my opinion Tears of the Kingdom kinda sucks. It felt like a game that didn't know what it wanted to do except take what it's predecessor did and add more. But in doing so it lost the cohesive design that made BotW the marvel it was.
999 is also too low as that game is the pinnacle of its genre.
Great to see Tetris so high; it's superb.
/opinions.
Thanks for sharing. It’s interesting, because, of course, my list looks much different. But then you read comments of what people are complaining about and most of the time I disagree with that choice as well lol. “Putting game X is the 20’s is insane!” I can agree with. But then they continue, “it should be much lower!” No way, it should be higher!
And thus how we have this list…as hundreds (thousands?) of people voted, all with different tastes and preferences. Also, think of the number of people who were born after many of these games were released and probably never played the games. Of course they’d vote for a game they liked and played over one they may have heard was good but never played since it’s too old.
Also, of note, I went through the whole voting thing twice. My favorite game of all time won every match up and ranked first, but my second favorite games lost 4 matches…twice in each go though against my top game. However, since it had 4 losses, it dropped it in the ranking to like 8th….even though it only lost to the 1 game. So it wasn’t a perfect system either.
I like this list because Tears of the Kingdom is awesome and criminally underrated. I’m also surprised that IGN still exists. I thought they folded sometime in the GameCube era.
Removed - unconstructive feedback
Truly the list of all time
Some entries made me chuckle. But it could’ve been worse I suppose.
Gosh what a terrible list.
I couldn't help myself. Obviously this NL/IGN list is opinionated, as it should be, but it made me curious as to how a more statistical approach would end up.
So for those interested, below is a collated "Top 50 Nintendo Games of All Time”, based on a modeled aggregation of the big sources (top 1-25 modeled more carefully than 26-50). Don't shoot me Personally, I'd not put Ocarina or Majora's Mask that high, but to each their own eh.
1. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (N64)
2. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild (Switch / Wii U)
3. Super Mario World (SNES)
4. Super Metroid (SNES)
5. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past (SNES)
6. Super Mario 64 (N64)
7. Metroid Prime (GameCube)
8. The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask (N64)
9. Super Mario Bros. 3 (NES)
10. Pokémon Gold & Silver (GBC)
11. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (GameCube / Wii)
12. The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom (Switch)
13. Chrono Trigger (SNES)
14. Final Fantasy VI (SNES)
15. Fire Emblem: Three Houses (Switch)
16. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe (Switch)
17. EarthBound (SNES)
18. Super Mario Galaxy (Wii)
19. Donkey Kong Bananza (Switch 2)
20. Xenoblade Chronicles (Wii)
21. Tetris (Game Boy)
22. Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Wii)
23. The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (GameCube)
24. Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy’s Kong Quest (SNES)
25. Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door (GameCube)
26. Resident Evil 4 (GameCube)
27. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes (GameCube)
28. Punch-Out!! (NES)
29. Animal Crossing: New Horizons (Switch)
30. The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword (Wii)
31. Mario Kart Wii (Wii)
32. The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (3DS)
33. Pokémon Ruby & Sapphire (GBA)
34. Donkey Kong Country (SNES)
35. The Legend of Zelda: Phantom Hourglass (DS)
36. The Legend of Zelda: Spirit Tracks (DS)
37. Super Mario Bros. (NES)
38. Xenoblade Chronicles 3 (Switch)
39. Kirby Super Star (SNES)
40. Pokémon Black & White (DS)
41. Dragon Quest XI S: Echoes of an Elusive Age (Switch)
42. Super Punch-Out!! (SNES)
43. Luigi’s Mansion 3 (Switch)
44. Advance Wars (GBA)
45. Pikmin 4 (Switch)
46. Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze (Wii U / Switch)
47. Mario Kart DS (DS)
48. Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver (DS)
49. The Legend of Zelda: Link’s Awakening (or Mother 3 — GBA, Japan-only)
50. Mario Kart 64 (N64)
Weighted Model Used
40% Cross-List Rank Score
(IGN, NintendoLife, GamesRadar, Polygon, TheGamer, Eurogamer, Top 100 YT lists)
30% Community Poll Score
(Reddit mega-polls, ResetEra, GameFAQs Best Game Ever, NeoGAF classics)
20% User Ratings Score
(Metacritic users, NintendoLife users, Backloggd)
10% Cultural Longevity Score
(mentions, speedrunning, staying power across decades)
This was a good list, but I couldn’t disagree with TotK being #1 more. It’s a great game but I didn’t even like it as much at BotW, let alone Link to the Past, Link Between Worlds, or Ocarina.
In my opinion, Tetris is the greatest game ever made. I really dont like Tetris but it’s basically as perfect as they come. Anyone can pick it up and play it, the mechanics are simple, and it slowly progresses in difficulty. Next up for me for Nintendo games would be Super Mario World, which I truly adore.
@beartown This is funny to me, because I ALSO grew up on Super Mario Bros and Super Mario 64. I ALSO don't really care for Super Mario World or Super Mario Bros 3 (and didn't play them until later). And I ALSO love Odyssey and Wonder.
Get out of my brain, bear.
I thought IGN were not involved in any way with the content of this site.
(Although the ad’s have become far less tolerable since they became involved.)
I think that #1 should've been either SMO or OOT. BOTW and TOTK are certainly top 5, possibly top 3, but they are not the BEST OF ALL TIME.
That said, I love them, extremely good games.
Ugh, the potshots at Mario Galaxy 1 when ranking 2 higher. I used to like 2 more, but in recent years I've come to better appreciate 1's more somber tone. Rosalina played a much bigger role the first time. Unlike 2, I've beaten 1 many times over the years without it ever feeling "vanilla" at all.
I'd say WarioWare Gold should be the best WarioWare, but it sadly came way too late for people to notice. I can understand why the first game is still so great. Even nowadays, I often find myself coming back to play Mega Microgame$ on Nintendo Classics for a quick break. Perfect for pick-up-and-play!
I agree with Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour for best Mario sports game, Superstar Saga for best Mario & Luigi, and as much as I love the original games with the Kremling Krew, Tropical Freeze for best Donkey Kong Country.
I didn't like the way voting worked for this, they should have let you vote on speciifc games you thought were best instead of the random matchup formula, especially since a game (DK 64) I would put in the top 100 wasn't even a choice in any of the matchups.
Excellent list overall and I agree with almost everything in the top 10, especially agree with TotK/BotW as top 2 and surprisingly Odyssey might actually be my favorite Mario after my third play through on Switch 2.
A bit surprised to see Donkey Kong Bananza this high but it really is that good and I agree with the write up entirely. Would personally rank Galaxy before the sequel but both are of course among the best.
very bad list
Sorry this is Incorrect Please redo Oot #1 then mario 64... no Fn way is animal crossing crappy horizons better than the game that defined all modern 3d games
Ironic that Elite Beat Agents is the only one of the Ouendan games to make it (at least beyond the header image), despite having the weakest narrative and tracks of all three titles.
I mean sure, it’s the only one most of us will have played, but the hype over the Japanese games was huge back at release. Same went for Jump Super/Ultimate Stars. And the music? Come on. Hotei Tomoyasu. Orange Range. L’arc~en~ciel (classics like Monkey Magic & Ready Steady Go for crying out loud). The Anthem and Sk8er Boi don’t really cut it in comparison.
This list is awful. Mario party jamboree is listed and Mario party 3 (the best in the series) is not even on the list?!?!
Gameboy Tetris over NES Tetris.................really?!?
Man, this kind of ranking was exactly what I was dreading when I clicked on it. This isn't a ranking of the best Nintendo games, this is a ranking of the most iconic Nintendo games. There's a near-complete absence of niche games. "Classic" games are ranked way higher than they deserve, simply on the basis of them being classics. Arcade Donkey Kong, SMB1, Zelda 1, and Mega Man 2 (the only Mega Man game on here somehow) do not belong on this list. And IGN and Nintendo Life continue to prove that Super Mario World is one of the most bafflingly overrated video games of all time. But this ranking was about what I'd expected from a list curated by gaming journalists. Where the "classic/iconic/important" factor matters more than sheer quality.
Also, saying that Mario Galaxy 2 "leaves the first game feeling a little vanilla, a little 'safe' by comparison" is genuinely a perplexing take. Galaxy 2 is the definition of a vanilla and safe sequel. I totally get why Mario Galaxy 2 is ranked above 1, but that one statement really makes me lose trust in the whole thing.
999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors, Ninety-sixth Best Nintendo Game As Chosen By Nintendo Life & IGN
Titles don’t come snappier than that.
@gcunit Thanks man, appreciated!
This is great for engagement - what a zany list
@JCLKaytwo galaxy 1 is way better
No Yoshi plus spring suit? Yes please
Placing Awakening so high on the list and Three Houses so low is definitely a choice. Some would arguee Three Houses do not have interesting gameplay. Fair enough, most of the maps are simple, even though the DLC helped greatly.
However, Awakening is even worst in that front, all strategic component are reduced to ashe thanks to the pair ability, which makes any unit into a freaking monster. And contrary to Three Houses, it does not have interesting characters, lore or story, and its replay value is significantely lower too.
I get why Marion Kart 8 is better on Switch due to its improvements and dlc etc than it was on wii u but anyone else find it strange it's Wind Waker on GCN but not the superior Wii U version but then it's Metroid Prime on Switch not GCN. Arguably things like SMB3 on gba is better than original on NES too.
It’s always challenging to make a list with current and retro games. Zelda-OOT was an amazing experience and what got me into gaming. Arguably the best game of all time…but I’m having a really hard time replaying it today because the graphics and gameplay are so clunky by today’s standards. Mario 64, I never got into (embarrassed to say that I ran around for 15 minutes back in the day, never figured out that I should jump into a painting, set it aside and never came back until 3D all stars. Now that I have played it without any nostalgia influencing me…it’s really clunky to play). I guess I could easily make 2 separate lists-funnest games to play today and most important games of all time. Fusing the two list will always cause arguments because of different opinions as to which is more important.
That said, BOTW/TOTK being 1+2 is a no brainer in my opinion. Bananza and Odyssey should be back to back as well in the top 5 (Bananza over Odyssey). Wonder should be top 10 along with MK8. OOT is easily the most important retro games (Wind Waker and MM both belong top 20). Interesting that Skyward Sword is the only 3D Zelda not on the list (and the only 3D Zelda game whose tutorial bored me so badly that I never finished it). Galaxy 1 should be higher on the list (back to back with Galaxy 2). MKW should not be on the list at all, but I’m glad to see it ranked so much lower than MK8.
Otherwise, mostly agree ignoring the games I haven’t played (and making notes about what to add to my backlog)
@kal_el_07241 it was always going to be due to the way people have to participate. I while back I did the Metal Gear one and trying to get it to be even close to my ranking was impossible, let alone doing it with 100 games.
How is Xenoblade Chronicles 3 not on the list? Unless I missed it somehow. I know X & the original Xenobldae are on the list.
Platinum not being on the list is a choice. I know Diamond & Pearl have its problems, but Platinum is way better and fixes the flaws from Diamond & Pearl.
@JCLKaytwo Honestly, the fact that the subtitle is "A century of must-have classics" does make this list even more suspicious.
This list is pure garbage… omg
LOL most of it is totally random
galaxy games put odyssey to shame.
999 should've been 99th.
No "Faxanadu" on Ye Olde NES?? Sacrilege!
** scribbles in an edit number "75a" **
Faxanadu : dead good Zelda 2-esque game that out-Zelda 2's Zelda 2. Play it, ta.
Yep. That should do it. Also : this is a good list.
Why would you infect your list with anything that IGN touches? They are the worst reviewers next to Kotaku.
I’d probably shuffle the top 25 around a little but mostly agree. The tough thing is the games I totally missed on my journey. I have a bit more snes love too with contra IV and Castlevania IV being up there
There is no way that those 75 games are all better than Secret of Mana.
Top 25 looks pretty solid though, but maybe not in that order.
@molkom this list actually makes sense, thnx for giving me closure 🤣
@STC_DX
Lol, glad to be of service 😁😂 (There are a few games that I personally wouldn’t put on it, particularly some between nr 30-50. But overall it made a bit sense to me too )
@YoshiTails definitely no
Shocked that Ring Fit Adventure made it onto the list, honestly
I agree with the top two.
I'd have Three Houses and the Xenoblade games a lot higher though.
I would have gone with the HD release of Wind Waker... that way at least Wii U would have at least some representation on the list
I'm surprised there's no Minish Cap, Hades, Kid Icarus Uprising, Xenoblade 3, or even TMNT IV. I have to think they'd be in the honorable mentions 110-101.
It's a true blasphemy that FE Three Houses is placed at 95 while it's arguably a better game compared to some of the top 10 picks. Shame on you for this.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...