Include: Waluigi, Paper Mario and Shadow
Remove: Pokemon Trainer and Lucario (Replace them with less generic characters.)
Bring Back: Roy (Pretty please?)

Include: Waluigi, Shadow, Custom Robo robots, Metal Sonic
Remove: Lucario, Toon Link
Bring Back: Mewtwo

The one person I would like in a new SSB is Mii! Just think of it: Your Mii beating up Mario, Kirby, and Samus at the same time! That would be so AWESOME!

how about hammer bro?

Include: Knuckles, Tails, Shadow, Waluigi, Birdo, Mega Man, Bass, X, Zero, and if possible, some sort of character creator (that's asking a bit much maybe)
Remove: No one
Bring Back: Dr, Mario, Roy, Mewtwo, Young Link (I know Toon Link has filled that role, but they could both be there anyway. And give him his look from Majora's Mask as an alternate costume or something) OoT Adult Link (the new Twilight Princess Link has taken this spot, but why not have them both and make their moves slightly different? And it would be cool to see a Fierce Deity costume for him)

• Hammer Bro.
• Koopa Troopa
• Paper Mario
• Little Mac
• Simon Belmont
• Isaac

I doubt we'll ever see Mega Man and the Blue Bomber in the next SSB game. Bring back Mewtwo, Young Link, Dr. Mario, Roy, and Pichu (IMO).

They could remake that kid from StarTropics, and add him. It could give the StarTropics series a chance to be revived, and if not, he would just be cool inclusion.

We like Mike! I would like to play as Mike (the StarTropics kid), too.

This.

Oh, and HECK yes to Geno.

Mega Man IS the Blue Bomber, and I'm pretty sure Inafune expressed interest in it, but Nintendo never asked about having him as a character.

In my opinion, here's who should be added into the next one:
Little mac
Chibi-robo
Bowser jr.
Miis (if they include mii's in the next nintendo console that this game will inevitably be on)
Starfy
Vaati
Meowth
One of the main characters from either of the sin and punishment games (don't remember the names!)
Krsytal
Mega Man
Waluigi
Tom Nook
Tingle
King K. Rool
A second pokemon trainer with a different starter selection
Toad
Andy (Advance Wars)
Mike (StarTropics)
Dark Samus
Bomberman
Returning: Mewtwo, Dr Mario, Roy (and everyone in Brawl, of course)

I think this list is generally realistic, since it doesn't have a bunch of third party characters that've had one (or zero) games on a nintendo console. Sorry if this post was too long!

Your guy's list suck!

I'm ready to blow your minds,

Chibi-Robo
Love/Hate Giant
Issac
Mii/Wiifit Board
Cubivore
King K. Rool
Tom Nook
Little Mac
Balloon Man
Starfy
Professor Layton
Captain Rainbow
Sheriff
Eggplant Man (Wrecking Crew)
Donbe & Hikari
Bubbles (Clu CLu Land)
Tamagon (Devil World)
Excite Guy (Truck, Bike and Bot Mode)
Diskun
Faxanadu
Mike
Andy
Mr. Stevenson (Gumshoe)
Hogan
Keiji Thomas
Mach Rider
Starman (Pro Wrestling)
Urban Fighter
Takamaru
Dr. Wright
Virus Trio
Satoru (Card Battle hero)
Ray Legend
Hererin
Stanley

That's how you make a good list without going into third party or adding to many characters from a series already in the game.

Please, no. One Pokemon Trainer was bad enough. D:

How about giving the old Charachters with some new Moves!
before we add of buch of weak fighters

Hmmm I want really see Isa and Kachi from S & P: SS.

Two Words: MIKE HAGGAR

oh yeah I still want this guy, too.

Aiai would work well. He could throw Bananas and roll into his ball for protection.

A character from advance wars or dragon quest would be pretty cool, like Andy or slime.

Definitely Mega-man!!!! I mean, why wasn't he on it already? Imagine how his final smash would look like- a huge cannon beam from his arm--- I want to see that !
Also I agree with Ai-Ai from super monkey ball, I totally agree with Simon Belmont(reminds me of Ike and Marth )
and MAYbe Ryu or Ken from Street Fighter? Is that maybe a little ridiculous? :s
The absolute BEST choice would be my toribash avatar, Hiyabushi!! lol

Jeez guys, can't you see why mega man can't be in the next smash bros? He can't even shoot up!

And yes, I realize there were a lot of "can't"s in those sentences.