Super Mario Bros. Wonder
Image: Nintendo Life

In October 2023, two of video gaming's biggest rivals will go head-to-head in a historic showdown pitting the platforming heroes and erstwhile rival mascots against each other in a manner that hasn't been this on-the-nose since the infamous console wars of the early '90s.

In the blue corner, Sonic Superstars launches on Switch (and other platforms, of course) on Tuesday 17th October. Built around the physics of the Retro Engine that powered the sublime Sonic Mania, this platformer from developer Arzest is bringing four-player co-op to the 2D Sonic series for the first time and is looking like a promising new — perhaps even 'New' — version of the classic side-on platforming that still excites many a fan of a blue Sega sky and a follicle-frolicking breeze.

However, in the red corner, arriving just three days later on Friday 20th October, a brand new entry in the Super Mario Bros. series is popping out of a warp pipe. The Switch-exclusive Super Mario Bros. Wonder is Mario's mainline return to two dimensions, sadly sans Charles Martinet, with a new (though specifically not 'New') platforming adventure for up to four players. We've only seen one trailer so far, but it looks like Wonder will be channelling the personality of Yoichi Kotabe's iconic promo art into the game itself like never before. We'll be finding out much more in the Super Mario Bros. Wonder Direct, but it's been nearly 11 years since the last totally new mainline 2D Mario, so expectations are high.

So, we find ourselves with the prospect of a 2D showdown in mid-October between two video gaming titans. Of course, we've seen contests between them various times over the years, not least in the Mario and Sonic Olympic Games... games, but two brand new entries in celebrated series starring characters so iconic they became mascots for their respective owners? That feels a bit special.

In fact, looking back, it's arguable that there's never been a contest this direct between Mario and Sonic. The hedgehog debuted on Genesis in North America on 23rd June 1991, with Super Mario World arriving in the region two months later on 23rd August. Super Mario Land 2 on the Game Boy was released in the same month as 1992's 'Sonic 2sday' (24th November), although the power difference between the systems negated any real comparison between those particular 2D classics.

Beyond that, gaming's princes of platforming have managed to steer clear of each other on the release calendar. Probably the closest we've come since the '90s was in November 2011 when New Super Mario Bros. U launched for Wii U four days prior to Sonic Generations, although the latter was on 3DS. 3D platformers Mario Odyssey and Sonic Forces launched within 10 days of each other in 2017, but let's keep things civil and stick to the two-dimensional plane, shall we?

The fact is that two of gaming's brightest stars are launching their latest flagship platformers within 72 hours of each other, and we're excited for some old-fashioned, good-natured, nostalgic rivalry.

Who wins? We all do, of course, but it's fun to speculate who might come out on top. Historically, if you look across the entire series, the Mario brothers have got this one in the bag... but as recovering Sega fanpeople, everything we've seen so far of Superstars suggests that this could finally be the 2D game to do justice to the 2D classics while bringing something new to the Sonic series.

So, what do you think? Is it wise for Sega to send the hedgehog out a mere three days before Mario and Co. ground-pound onto their home territory of Switch? Is this town big enough for the both of 'em? Let us know if you're Team Sonic or Team Mario in the polls below.

Two 2D titans going head-to-head in a matter of days? Is this really a good idea? (2,347 votes)

  1. No! That's some unlucky timing, right there19%
  2. Pff, good games will get their dues whenever they release - let's hope they're good35%
  3. Sure, the more the merrier!46%

Who will you be placing your platforming money on this October, Mario or Sonic? (2,759 votes)

  1. Gotta go fast for Sonic9%
  2. My money's on Mario53%
  3. I'll be bagging both27%
  4. Waiting for reviews, me5%
  5. Neither, just gimme the popcorn4%
  6. OTHER video games? Sorry, cannot escape Vampire Survivors. Send help1%

Please note that some external links on this page are affiliate links, which means if you click them and make a purchase we may receive a small percentage of the sale. Please read our FTC Disclosure for more information.