Forums

Topic: eShop / Metacritic thread

Posts 1 to 20 of 23

jariw

I didn't find any thread on this, so my apologies if it already existed. I've been looking for a list on all eShop (non-VC or retail) games that have reviews on Metacritic. Since I didn't find any, I created this thread. Please feel free to add any info you find. There must be at least 4 review available for a game to be listed, due to the rules at Metacritic. Games with 80 or more appear in bold. Games between 75 and 79 appear in italics.

For comparison, there's also an eShop / GameRankings thread.

The format for each game is this: <Game_title> - Metacritic_score (positive-mixed-negative) Metacritic_Link_URL


1001 Spikes - 82 (4-1-0) Link
Abyss - 59 (0-5-1) Link
Another World: 20th Anniversary Edition - 73 (3-4-0) Link
Armillo - 72 (8-5-0) Link
Art Academy: SketchPad - 70 (1-3-0) Link
Art of Balance - 83 (7-1-0) Link
Bit.Trip Presents...Runner2: Future Legend of Rhythm Alien - 84 (16-2-0) Link
BLOK DROP U - 53 (0-4-3) Link
Bombing Bastards - 55 (0-4-0) Link
Castlestorm - 83 (7-1-0) Link
Chasing Aurora - 64 (5-21-1) Link
The Cave - 72 (5-4-1) Link
Child of Light - 83 (7-0-0) Link
Coaster Crazy Deluxe - 69 (1-3-0) Link
Cloudberry Kingdom - 75 (5-3-0) Link
Cubemen 2 - 63 (1-7-0) Link
Dr. Luigi - 65 (9-27-2) Link
DuckTales Remastered - 76 (8-2-0) Link
Dungeons & Dragons: Chronicles of Mystara - 77 (4-3-0) Link
Edge - 79 (6-3-0) Link
F1 Race Stars: Powered Up Edition - 61 (1-6-1) Link
Fist of the North Star: Ken's Rage 2 - 40 (0-2-2) Link
Gaiabreaker - 38 (0-1-3) Link
Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams - 74 (2-3-0) Link
Gravity Badgers - 48 (0-3-4) Link
Guacamelee! Super Turbo Championship Edition - 90 (9-0-0) Link
How to Survive - 55 (0-9-0) Link
Ice Cream Surfer - 55 (0-5-1) Link
Knytt Underground - 76 (8-4-0) Link
Kung Fu Rabbit - 65 (4-9-1) Link
The Mysterious Cities of Gold: Secret Paths - 60 (1-4-2) Link
The Letter - 14 (0-0-4) Link
Little Inferno - 79 (17-5-0) Link
Lone Survivor: The Director's Cut - 74 (2-2-0) Link
Master Reboot - 64 (0-5-0) Link
Mighty Switch Force! Hyper Drive Edition - 80 (16-3-0) Link
Mighty Switch Force! 2 - 74 (3-2-0) Link
Monkey Pirates - 62 (1-5-0) Link
Mutant Mudds Deluxe - 84 (6-1-0) Link
Nano Assault Neo - 71 (9-12-1) Link
NES Remix - 71 (21-11-2) Link
NES Remix 2 - 73 (20-16-0) Link
Pokemon Rumble U - 49 (0-16-6) Link
Poker Dice Solitaire Future - 55 (0-3-1) Link
Puddle - 70 (7-12-1) Link
Pure Chess - 61 (0-8-0) Link
Pushmo World - 80 (30-7-0) Link
RUSH - 77 (5-2-0) Link
Scram Kitty and His Buddy on Rails - 79 (17-8-0) Link
Shovel Knight - 88 (15-2-0) Link
Shut the Box - 46 (0-1-3) Link
Spin the Bottle: Bumpie's Party - 75 (4-6-0) Link
Stealth Inc. 2 - 83 (13-2-0)Link
SteamWorld Dig - 83 (11-2-0) Link
Squids Odyssey - 68 (8-5-1) Link
Star Wars Pinball - 83 (12-1-0) Link
Stick it to the Man! - 80 (8-1-0) Link
Super Toy Cars - 57 (0-10-1) Link
Swords and Soldiers HD 78 (8-2-0) Link
TNT Racers: Nitro Machines Edition - 62 (0-5-0) Link
Teslagrad - 80 (11-3-0) Link
Toki Tori 2 - 76 (15-12-0) Link
Trine 2: Director's Cut - 84 (22-3-0) Link
Unepic - 71 (9-9-0) Link
Wii Sports Club - 68 (2-9-0) Link
Wooden Sen'SeY - 62 (2-12-1) Link
XType Plus - 76 (5-2-0) Link
Zen Pinball 2 - 71 (2-3-0) Link


Edited on by jariw

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

jariw

Now, all the currently available eShop games with a Metacritic score have been added.

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

jariw

Adjusted Scram Kitty and Stick it to the Man!, based on the additional reviews. I also marked all games in the range of 75-79 with italics.

Edited on by jariw

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

Dreamz

jariw wrote:

Adjusted Scram Kitty and Stick it to the Man!, based on the additional reviews. I also marked all games in the range of 75-79 with italics.

75-79 seems to be an awfully small, arbitrary range....

Why not use metacritic's own scale and put scores in the 75-89 range in italics, and everything from 90-100 in bold?

Edit: Nevermind the above - I just realized there aren't any eshop games above 89 anyways, so it wouldn't be worth the effort. Maybe extend the italic range to 70-79?

Edited on by Dreamz

My 3rd Party Games List: Click here
U-Wishlist: Splatoon, Zelda U
Currently playing: Bayonetta

alLabouTandroiD

Maybe we could add nl's review score for each title too?
I think that'd be interesting.

no apple

Nintendo Network ID: LTD_2112

jariw

Dreamz wrote:

Edit: Nevermind the above - I just realized there aren't any eshop games above 89 anyways, so it wouldn't be worth the effort. Maybe extend the italic range to 70-79?

I selected the 75 level because that's the threshold for "Generally Favorable Reviews". With very few exceptions (such as the NES Remixes, where many of the favorable reviews aren't that favorable), this is where you would find the first games with more favorable reviews than meh/negative reviews.

I selected the 80 level to single out approximately the top 10% and because 80 seems like a round nice value.

As a comparison, Mario Kart 8 is at 89 with 55-0-0, and I don't think we'll find many indies above 90 in the future.

LeasTwanteD wrote:

Maybe we could add nl's review score for each title too?
I think that'd be interesting.

The NL reviews for eShop Wii U games are found here.

One of the reasons why I created this list was to have an alternative to NL's reviews, since I think the NL review scores are broken and doesn't help me as a customer (personally, I think the scores by ONM are much more consistent and fair). However, one thing I was thinking of perhaps adding was the Metacritic user scores (which sometimes differ quite much from the metascore).

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

jariw

ADDED:
F1 Race Stars: Powered Up Edition
TNT Racers: Nitro Machines Edition

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

unrandomsam

Add the Famitsu scores those are the best for me anyway. Just very hard to find.

OMN last time I checked just gives anything first party 98% or something like that last time I checked. Sucks they kept that and got rid of NGamer.

“30fps Is Not a Good Artistic Decision, It's a Failure”
Freedom of the press is for those who happen to own one.

jariw

Now I've also created an eShop / GameRankings thread, for comparison purposes. Some games are affected getting a quite different total when the average is used instead of the weighted number.

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

unrandomsam

Never knew metacritic worked like that. But it explains how EA can come out as the best publisher just by affecting the ones with the highest weighting.

(Or affecting metacritic itself by paying them to weight the ones that they have paid off highest).

“30fps Is Not a Good Artistic Decision, It's a Failure”
Freedom of the press is for those who happen to own one.

dumedum

jariw wrote:

. There must be at least 4 review available for a game to be listed, due to the rules at Metacritic.

This is something that "screws" the Wii U/Nintendo platforms all the time.
Games sometimes never appear because of a (false) lack of reviews (a multiplatform review for example that doesn't count for the Nintendo version for no reason). A game could get 36 reviews on another platform but 3 reviews on the Nintendo platform.

unrandomsam wrote:

But it explains how EA can come out as the best publisher

that only happened once.

Edited on by dumedum

"Dubs Goes to Washington: The Video Game".

Nintendo Network ID: Del_Piero_Mamba

jariw

dumedum wrote:

jariw wrote:

. There must be at least 4 review available for a game to be listed, due to the rules at Metacritic.

This is something that "screws" the Wii U/Nintendo platforms all the time.
Games sometimes never appear because of a (false) lack of reviews (a multiplatform review for example that doesn't count for the Nintendo version for no reason). A game could get 36 reviews on another platform but 3 reviews on the Nintendo platform.

For me personally, I would often not consider a Wii U game to be as good if it worked identical to other platforms in terms of game control. The exception would be a game where the Pro Controller would be the only controller that made perfect sense for the game.

A related question is why some recent eShop games get lots of reviews (such as Scram Kitty) while others (such as Squids Odyssey) get few, when none of them are reviewed as shovelware.

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

jariw

Added "Abyss" and "Squids Odyssey". Modified the numbers for "Scram Kitty" once again.

Edited on by jariw

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

kkslider5552000

I find the (#-#-#) thing more helpful than the actual metascore tbh.

Try a XENOBLADE CHRONICLES X LET'S PLAY now for the cost of nothing! : D
LeT's PlAy XENOBLADE CHRONICLES X (blind)

3DS friend code: 2878 - 9709 - 5054
Nintendo Network ID: SliderGamer55

jariw

I've updated the list with a large addition of new releases and tried to update changed scores for existing ones.

Edited on by jariw

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

faint

tag

jonrahproductions@gmail.com
friend code: 0103-9004-2456

jariw
  • Added "Art of Balance"
  • Adjusted scores for "SteamWorld Dig", "Teslagrad", "XType Plus"

Edited on by jariw

Current Top 15: Splatoon, MK8, Tropical Freeze, Pikmin 3, Super Mario Maker, Affordable Space Adventures, SM3DW, Yoshi's Woolly World, Stealth Inc. 2, LEGO City: Undercover, Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker, Runbow, Bayonetta 1+2, SSB U, Wind Waker: HD

SKTTR

Metacritic, for everyone who wants an uninformative, incomplete, thrown together collection of opinions in form of numbers.
Must be great for clueless people who want to stay clueless.

scatterkid.weebly.com

Waluigi

I normally just trust NL reviews when it comes to getting Eshop titles.

Even the Dark Lord of the Sith needs a little bit of WAAAAH!
My Mario Maker Page
DefHalan wrote:

@Darth_Vader > Darth Vader > Kylo Ren

Nintendo Network ID: pokefraker | Twitter:

Top

Please login or sign up to reply to this topic