3DS Virtual Console Forum

Topic: Why the hell don't classic Gameboy games have color?

Showing 1 to 20 of 31

AuthorMessage
JustRob

JustRob

1. Posted:

So after a long time of being skeptical about Virtual Console, I decided to try it out. I bought one of my old favorite Gameboy games, Gargoyle's Quest. Now I know this was originally a game for the black and white (or black and green) Gameboys, but I still have the cartridge, and when I put it in my Gameboy Advance SP, it does have some color. Which makes it nicer in my opinion. Firebrand is actually red.

However, I was pretty astounded to find that the 3DS does not in fact have this feature. It's not even an option, it just isn't there. Surely if the Gameboy Advance was capable of this, the 3DS should be able to as well.

So I guess my question is, why not?

JustRob

AuthorMessage
Samurai_Goroh

Samurai_Goroh

2. Posted:

Nintendo is lazy. M2 ought to taught them how to do proper 3DS VC emulation. M2 does what Nintendon't.

Edited on by Samurai_Goroh

Samurai_Goroh

AuthorMessage
Maelstrom

Maelstrom

3. Posted:

They actually might have wanted it to be as close to the original as possible

My video game arrangements (sheet music for piano)
Most Recently Arranged: Running / Countdown (Smash 3DS), Snowy Mt. Valek (Night),Reviewing the Scene of the Crime (Umineko),
In progress: Not sure yet

Nintendo Network ID: aginor

AuthorMessage
iphys

iphys

4. Posted:

No way do I believe they didn't originally plan to implement a colour system to play the games eventually when they made these games back in the day. I think it's ridiculous they don't give us GBC or SGB colour palette options when they're expecting us to pay money. A lot of us suffered through the pea soup era already and don't find any novelty in paying to do so again. I would have bought at least twice as many GB VC games if we had colour palette options, but as it is I'd rather just play my cartridges on my GBA instead.

http://backloggery.com/iphys

Nintendo Network ID: iphys_eh

AuthorMessage
deadaccount

deadaccount

5. Posted:

Offer us DLC on GB games, Nintendo!
Options!!! Just the ordinary ones!

deadaccount

AuthorMessage
LztheQuackAdmin

LztheQuack

6. Posted:

Samurai_Goroh wrote:

Nintendo is lazy. M2 ought to taught them how to do proper 3DS VC emulation. M2 does what Nintendon't.

I like how M2 is somehow better than Nintendo when Nintendo told them to implement certain features. ;)

Nintendo Life Community Administrator

Fire Emblem! Enough said! TINGLE_loggery

Nintendo Network ID: LzWinky

AuthorMessage
DefHalan

DefHalan

7. Posted:

Kodeen wrote:

Unca_Lz wrote:

Samurai_Goroh wrote:

Nintendo is lazy. M2 ought to taught them how to do proper 3DS VC emulation. M2 does what Nintendon't.

I like how M2 is somehow better than Nintendo when Nintendo told them to implement certain features. ;)

It's always easier to delegate.

I don't know about that

I like to play Devil's Advocate

Nintendo Network ID: DefHalan

AuthorMessage
justlink

justlink

8. Posted:

Nintendo isn't lazy, the problem is they have two different major problems. Lack of games for WiiU and shortage on staff due to them trying to fix the shortage! They can't implement new things into games and then expect them to release news games so quickly. Emulation is emulation. It'd be a different game with new features, a remake, we're just getting simple ports. And before you download VC, its up to you to see what features it has, just don't expect them!

Hi
I'm Justlink1 on Miiverse, look me up.
Favorite Game: Spirit Tracks
Favorite Series: Zelda, SSB, Earthbound
Favorite childhood game: Sitting Ducks

AuthorMessage
MorpheelStaff

Morpheel

9. Posted:

Maelstrom wrote:

They actually might have wanted it to be as close to the original as possible

That's funny, because my original experience with GB games featured at least four different non-monochromatic colors on the screen.

Because of that, I can't really fully enjoy many of these GB games, my nostalgia glasses aren't the correct ones. I really wish Nintendo had given us better GB emulation instead of just the bare minimum+green.

I'm actually kinda relieved Pokemon hasn't been released. It would feel wrong to play these games in black and white for me.

Edited on by Morpheel

Oh look! A Morphloggery.
Oh! eShop Gurus.

Nintendo Network ID: Abgarok

AuthorMessage
unrandomsam

unrandomsam

10. Posted:

If Nintendo had used the Super Gameboy information for Donkey Kong '94 I would have enjoyed it more I think. (Still did because it is a great game. Much better than the puzzle ones.)

“30fps Is Not a Good Artistic Decision, It's a Failure”
Freedom of the press is for those who happen to own one.

AuthorMessage
Klimbatize

Klimbatize

11. Posted:

Yeah. A game like Metroid II would really benefit from a color palette option.

A person without a sense of humor is like a wagon without springs. It's jolted by every pebble on the road.

3DS FC: 1332 7785 4494

AuthorMessage
Geonjaha

Geonjaha

12. Posted:

JustRob wrote:

However, I was pretty astounded to find that the 3DS does not in fact have this feature. It's not even an option, it just isn't there. Surely if the Gameboy Advance was capable of this, the 3DS should be able to as well.

So I guess my question is, why not?

It was actually the Game Boy Color that added the palette features, so the feature has been available for even longer. I've said it before and I'll say it again - when Nintendo's paid retro emulation service cant compete with their own 15 year old hardware then they're doing something very wrong.

I make Pixel Art on occasion.
Help bring Dragon Quest back to the West, so we can all resume having fun.

AuthorMessage
Tasuki

Tasuki

13. Posted:

The reason the original Gameboy didn't have color as opposed to say the Game Gear was because Gunpei Yokoi found that the lack of color for one gave it a longer battery lifespan and that the dot matrix pixels showed up better with the black and green palette.

Push Square Moderator and all around retro gamer.

My Backlog

Nintendo Network ID: Tasuki311

AuthorMessage
andrew20

andrew20

14. Posted:

the game boy games have just the white and black version too

andrew20

Nintendo Network ID: Andrew1994fl2.0

AuthorMessage
KingMike

KingMike

15. Posted:

If it is about Game Boy games not being able to run as if they were on Game Boy Color...
someone years ago ripped the GB, SGB and GBC boot ROMs. (and I hear that was not an easy task, involving hacking up a few sacrifice consoles :( )
For Nintendo to get the GBC colors, they really just have to run the GBC startup ROM before running the game and it would do the work for them. :P

Admittedly truly accurate SGB support would be harder as it would have to emulate the SNES (including the SGB BIOS) and GB at the same time.
But still, even in the late '90s, fan emulators already took the cheat way and emulated palette/border functions.

KingMike

AuthorMessage
MorpheelStaff

Morpheel

16. Posted:

Because Nintendo

Wait what do you mean this is an old thread and I alreday commented here

Edited on by Morpheel

Oh look! A Morphloggery.
Oh! eShop Gurus.

Nintendo Network ID: Abgarok

AuthorMessage
WaveBoy

WaveBoy

17. Posted:

iphys wrote:

No way do I believe they didn't originally plan to implement a colour system to play the games eventually when they made these games back in the day. I think it's ridiculous they don't give us GBC or SGB colour palette options when they're expecting us to pay money. A lot of us suffered through the pea soup era already and don't find any novelty in paying to do so again. I would have bought at least twice as many GB VC games if we had colour palette options, but as it is I'd rather just play my cartridges on my GBA instead.

I'll take shades of green over black & white any day of the week.

But yup! Nintendo didn't even get the Pea Soup monochrome green effect right, since the contrast basically drowns out a lot of detail that's clearly present in Black and white. Black and white sparks zero nostalgia, which is why I tend to flick back to pea soup green every now and then when playing a 3DS GB VC game.

there's no excuse why Nintendo can't release a virtual contrast slider when in monochrome green mode or fix the detail drowning all together. Sega went ALL OUT for their sega 3D classics. Nintendo could learn from them. I would love to play 3DS GB games in SGB color, or again at least have that virtual contrast slider when playing in nostalgic green....And why not also add in a Blur free option for those that want the green effect but don't want the original blur that was present with the original GB? Nintendo is being lazy

As for the GBC VC, the only thing they can really add on to that would be giving us different game boy color cases, ala > Banana Yellow, lime green, Purple(Best default choice imo) ect.

Edited on by WaveBoy

Currently Playing: Back to the Future! - NES
We shall swim to Bubble Island, or you will suffer the wrath of my Trident Laser!
80s FANATIC & King of NES Tekkidome!

AuthorMessage
MorpheelStaff

Morpheel

18. Posted:

I do wish I could have my GBC VC games appear in lime green mini GBCs in the menu.

Purple is ok, but mine was green so... Nostalgia.

Edited on by Morpheel

Oh look! A Morphloggery.
Oh! eShop Gurus.

Nintendo Network ID: Abgarok

AuthorMessage
TeeJay

TeeJay

19. Posted:

andrew20 wrote:

the game boy games have just the white and black version too

Wrong

TeeJay

Nintendo Network ID: TeeJay92

AuthorMessage
andrew20

andrew20

20. Posted:

TeeJay wrote:

andrew20 wrote:

the game boy games have just the white and black version too

Wrong

they play in black and white
and in the green if you want to change it just press
L and R and press Y and the screen changes colors they talk about that in 2011

Edited on by andrew20

andrew20

Nintendo Network ID: Andrew1994fl2.0