two words:Neku Sakaraba

This would likely make the 3DS version the one I definitively get if Nintendo fails at making both versions worthwhile and unique.

[quote=34442

• Spirit Train (Fighting on it's top, this train from Spirit Tracks would cruise through the game's four regions, each affecting the arena in various ways).
  </blockquote>
  thats what I have been thinking of as well,everything you said

arena:mario galaxy theme
Its in the first level you go(has a house with a pipe on it)your in front of the house,but far away enough to see the path to the door,see the planets in the backround,star bits falling all over the place(not loads but you see a rainbow one falling down and then some coloured ones lay of the ground for a bit before schatering,dont know if the stage would be good with being able to go down to the bottom where the tower is or not

[/div]

how would tom nooks fight ?

I can see how Sora would fit the game, but I seriously doubt he'd make it in. (The fangirls would certainly go crazy though ). And I can't wait to see how much more the Kid Icarus series will be prevalent in this game, seeing as it was Sakurai's latest.

These would be nice rosters, but you all seem to be forgetting the RULES of the SSB Roster that have been used since the first one.

There are rules to SSB entries:

1. 4 characters per franchise (with the exception of Mario being 5)

2. Characters must have sufficient move sets (Bad examples: Duck Hunt Dog, Tom Nook, Balloon Fighter, Goomba)

3. Must be from Nintendo or Third-Party most affiliated with Nintendo (Good Examples: Sega, Capcom, Konami, Hudson Soft, Ubisoft. Bad Examples: Prof. Layton, Crash Bandicoot, Maxwell, Dillon)

4. Must be MAIN characters of whole franchise (Good Examples: Luigi, Zelda, Diddy Kong, King Dedede. Bad examples: Geno, Skull Kid, Giriham, Lemmy Koopa, Fawful, Rouge The Bat, Prince Pluff, Mr. L)

5. Characters must be of specified height and size and able to both FIGHT and be FOUGHT successfully (Bad examples are characters like Medusa, Gooey, Petey Piranha, Pac-Man, Waluigi, King Boo)

Take my roster for example:

What? Why? ANSWER ME MAN!

@TheN64Dude, WHY U NO LIKE PAC-MAN!

He has not been around very long and what reason SHOULD he be in there. If he's a third party character he has to have a REALLY good reason. Sonic had a good reason he was the second most famous video game character next to mario and Nintendo & Sega have a HUGE history together.

never said i hated pac-man

@TheN64Dude, Dillon/Jiro would actually be pretty reasonable. Mostly for the fact that he is first party (the same could be said for the Sakura Samurai).

Whoops. Thought he was first part for a second. Sorry man.

I didn't like the old one so i made a new one. i tried to make it real, thinking like nintendo.

Professor Layton should be in there. Or at least an assist, or something. He's made quite the presence on Nintendo handhelds.

I want Ghiriham in this game so bad! Love that guy!

I myself don't really enjoy speculating rosters at all. Sakurai's a genius. Better for me to just sit back, to think and to understand his vast wisdom through the characters he makes available.

@TysonQ7. I did that for Brawl and then ended up disappointed, so I'm kinda with you there.

I don't consider that thinking like Nintendo even in the slightest. I find that as more of an insult to Nintendo.

Pretty good fanmade line-up but still missing some good ones

Hmm, I wonder what AR Man would do? And I have one other thing to say. I'd like to see another Pikmin Captain. Either Louie/The President, or one of the four new ones in Pikmin 3. And to make sure they aren't too clone-like, the Pikmin types the new Captain uses can be different then the ones Olimar has. (For example, Rock Pikmin, and the flying Pink Pikmin can be used for recovery).