This looks like a beating. I would have played very similar to whoever was in this video. The frustration with getting that red ring at the beginning, getting damaged at the boss for dumb reasons... and I just can't stand how target locking enemies destroys momentum. I will give this a rental, but I doubt my opinion will change.
This was my first game backed on Kickstarter. After all the promising releases this year, I decided against this in the future unless the project is low on funding. With Shantae, Ghost Song, Mighty No. 9, and more, I'm glad the outlet is there. I'll just be one of those who buys through eShoo/Steam.
Disappointed, but thankful that they're being cool about it. It just goes to show, don't pay for something based on upcoming features. Make sure you like it as-is.
@JoostinOnline I have no problem with people pointing out flaws. That's give and take, conversation, discourse. What I call "being defensive" is people not even giving these ideas a chance. A quick look through the above 200+ posts will show a completely dismissive attitude by most. Is the Salon article flawed? Of course, what isn't (yes, that includes Zelda).
In your previous post, you say "More than anything, it's people's obsession with searching for stereotypes that make them continue to exist." I disagree. I say that it's a lack of understanding diverse viewpoints that continues stereotypes. Angry, dismissive attitudes towards opinions other than our own prolong this lack of understanding and strengthen stereotypes.
Ignorance may be bliss, but it is certainly not healing or helpful. Education is the answer.
I expect this post to be dismissed at least as much as those I've made above. As I've said before, NintendoLife is not a healthy environment for this type of discussion. Take what I say with a grain of salt, but at least try to understand where I am coming from. Thank you for this exchange. You are welcomed to have the last word; I am finished with this comment thread.
@Neram Honestly, I think it's important to be aware of unintentional offenses. Can you live your life in fear that you will offend someone? No. Should you do your best to help rather than hurt? Of course.
If you'd like to look up the error of a privileged mindset, I'd encourage you to do so. As I've said previously, NintendoLife is clearly not the forum to discuss social theory.
@eaglebob345 If you're confused about what I said, feel free to reread my comment. Another helpful definition of a privileged mindset would be: not caring enough about harmful social presumptions because they don't effect you.
@Klimbatize Obviously it didn't make you hate people. But it does reinforce harmful conceptions, no matter how subtly. GTA is an obvious offender, but Zelda? It's important to look at these sort of things to see how far harmful attitudes permeate our society, even our childhood. You don't have to stop playing OoT; the author is simply asking us to be aware.
@eaglebob345 It looks like you missed the part where the author called the game an amazing work of art. Did you even read the linked article?
You are privileged when you don't have to worry about being judged on the basis of your culture or physical characteristics. In our society, not everyone is able to live such a life.
Obviously, NintendoLife is not the place to discuss sociology. That being said, these examinations can have value if you take five seconds to think them through. No need to get so polemical over this.
@Shadowkiller97 Clearly. That does not at all diminish my point. When I mentioned Western preference, I was not talking about the game itself, but the way Westerners view cultural examinations.
@Neram It's not that "normal people" don't think like that, but privileged people. These kind of evaluations are GOOD if they open your eyes to the overwhelming preference in Western culture for "people like us."
Honestly, I do not understand why almost everyone on this comments section seems so defensive. This stuff is real. It's not that people are looking to find sexism, racism, etc. It's already there. If you can't see it, than the one revealing it is helping you.
Does it suck that Zelda is loaded with these harmful classifications? Yes. Have things improved since the 1940s? Yes.
Sure, there are worse games, but it's important to have a critical eye on the things we enjoy the most. The author's last paragraph says exactly this:
"On this 15th anniversary of the game’s release, I encourage readers to dust off their Nintendo 64 and return to Hyrule. Hike up Death Mountain. Swim in Lake Hylia. Explore the Lost Woods. “Ocarina” is a fantastic piece of art we can enjoy while being aware that, like so much other art, it has a lot of problems."
Don't take it so personally. Everyone has blind spots. Yes, Zelda is awesome; also, it has problems.
I love Chasing Aurora. It has excellent multiplayer. Have played it with just my wife and I, our kids, and our friends. And Yet IT Moves is also excellent. I'm disappointed I'll have to buy SoR on Steam, but it will be a day one purchase.
@rjejr Tap the Miiverse icon on the bottom of the game selection screen. It looks like three green people. You can also get there by clocking home and selecting the same icon.
To get there from Wara Wara plaza, click on a person and then "View Post in Miiverse," or something like that.
@DePapier you can quickly see these and many more by going to the community and clicking "Popular Posts." I wish they would link it here at NL, but that's my work around.
@ThomasBW84 It really is surprising because showing the sizzle real makes so much sense, but at the same time I don't have any expectation of advertising from NA based on past experience. I stay very informed of Wii U news, but my Wii U owning friends know hardly anything about new titles, let alone those yet to come. I'm hoping that will change, but I'm not holding my breath.
@WinterWarm That's fair. It wasn't my view either until a couple years ago. I took a break from consoles for a couple years only to be drawn back in by Skyward Sword, Rock Band and BitTrip. Runner. My tastes have since changed. I would love to see something for everyone on Wii U, and that's why I find crowd funded indies so exciting. With Unity on Wii U, anyone with enough determination, hard work, and support can try their hand at bringing new ideas and innovation to the gaming community. Steam already has this sort of infrastructure, but Wii U is so much more convenient than constantly setting up wired USB and/or Bluetooth controllers to my PC.
@WinterWarm these games are crowd funded because that's the route some indies are taking with Wii U. Why does that have you pissed? Cloudberry Kingdom is an amazing game, and I absolutely cannot wait for Shovel Knight (both kickstarted). @3DSAllDay, not every game needs a kickstarter. LOL!The way I see it, it only means for more games. And super awesome indie games at that.
@SmearyToast this game isn't being ported to MS or Sony systems, unless you consider Windows as MS. A lot of these kickstarters either only include Wii U or have it as the first console to be added. Anyway, this game has really sweet style, so I backed it.
@Blizzaga: this issue is also dealt with in the update:
"
•At the start of the game, when it asks you if you want to log in, we've added some feedback so it doesn't look like the game is hanging.
•The leaderboards will only save your highest score, as expected, instead of your most recent score, which it does now.
•If you lose your internet connection during play, we've allowed you to reconnect by going to the leaderboards menu.
•We've fixed false score reporting for in-game Rewards.
•We've fixed an issue with the level start mini-leaderboard telling you you're offline when you're actually online. It will populate this list with global scores if you don't have any friends who have played the game yet.
•We've fixed an issue in the settings menu that resets your settings every time you enter the menu.
And last, but not least, we've tried to fix the issue that locks up the Wii U system upon powering down or quitting out of the game via the HOME Menu.
"
Comments 134
Re: Video: You've Got To Be Quick To Catch This Sonic Lost World Footage
This looks like a beating. I would have played very similar to whoever was in this video. The frustration with getting that red ring at the beginning, getting damaged at the boss for dumb reasons... and I just can't stand how target locking enemies destroys momentum. I will give this a rental, but I doubt my opinion will change.
Re: Mighty Switch Force! 2 Dousing the North American Wii U eShop This Week
@rjejr seriously. I love me some demo.
Re: Mighty Switch Force! 2 Dousing the North American Wii U eShop This Week
Will pick it up tomorrow if it's 9.99. Love the pixel look of Pixel Patty in MSFHD.
Re: First Impressions: Shovel Knight
This was my first game backed on Kickstarter. After all the promising releases this year, I decided against this in the future unless the project is low on funding. With Shantae, Ghost Song, Mighty No. 9, and more, I'm glad the outlet is there. I'll just be one of those who buys through eShoo/Steam.
Re: Video: Wooden Sen'SeY Gets Acrobatic in New Trailer
@ricklongo As a father if three, I enjoy having bite sized gaming opportunities. Kung Fu Rabbit is pretty cool, especially for $2.49.
Re: Video: Wooden Sen'SeY Gets Acrobatic in New Trailer
I'm in!
Re: Two Tribes Confirms Toki Tori 2+ Level Editor Will Not Hatch On Wii U
@sillygostly very sensible. I wish more people exhibited such wisdom. The gaming market would be in a better place.
Re: Two Tribes Confirms Toki Tori 2+ Level Editor Will Not Hatch On Wii U
Disappointed, but thankful that they're being cool about it. It just goes to show, don't pay for something based on upcoming features. Make sure you like it as-is.
Re: Deus Ex: Human Revolution Director's Cut Will Cost $20 More On Wii U Than On PS3 And 360
@CaPPa exactly.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@JoostinOnline I have no problem with people pointing out flaws. That's give and take, conversation, discourse. What I call "being defensive" is people not even giving these ideas a chance. A quick look through the above 200+ posts will show a completely dismissive attitude by most. Is the Salon article flawed? Of course, what isn't (yes, that includes Zelda).
In your previous post, you say "More than anything, it's people's obsession with searching for stereotypes that make them continue to exist." I disagree. I say that it's a lack of understanding diverse viewpoints that continues stereotypes. Angry, dismissive attitudes towards opinions other than our own prolong this lack of understanding and strengthen stereotypes.
Ignorance may be bliss, but it is certainly not healing or helpful. Education is the answer.
I expect this post to be dismissed at least as much as those I've made above. As I've said before, NintendoLife is not a healthy environment for this type of discussion. Take what I say with a grain of salt, but at least try to understand where I am coming from. Thank you for this exchange. You are welcomed to have the last word; I am finished with this comment thread.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@Neram Honestly, I think it's important to be aware of unintentional offenses. Can you live your life in fear that you will offend someone? No. Should you do your best to help rather than hurt? Of course.
If you'd like to look up the error of a privileged mindset, I'd encourage you to do so. As I've said previously, NintendoLife is clearly not the forum to discuss social theory.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@Mellowkarp exactly!
@Koto "...it's a game." No, it's one of the best games ever made. Is it art? Than it deserves to be examined as such.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@LittleIrves exactly what I'm saying. No need for fans to be so dismissive.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@LittleKing http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=niOm01dEzzI
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@eaglebob345 If you're confused about what I said, feel free to reread my comment. Another helpful definition of a privileged mindset would be: not caring enough about harmful social presumptions because they don't effect you.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@Klimbatize Obviously it didn't make you hate people. But it does reinforce harmful conceptions, no matter how subtly. GTA is an obvious offender, but Zelda? It's important to look at these sort of things to see how far harmful attitudes permeate our society, even our childhood. You don't have to stop playing OoT; the author is simply asking us to be aware.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@eaglebob345 It looks like you missed the part where the author called the game an amazing work of art. Did you even read the linked article?
You are privileged when you don't have to worry about being judged on the basis of your culture or physical characteristics. In our society, not everyone is able to live such a life.
Obviously, NintendoLife is not the place to discuss sociology. That being said, these examinations can have value if you take five seconds to think them through. No need to get so polemical over this.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@Shadowkiller97 Clearly. That does not at all diminish my point. When I mentioned Western preference, I was not talking about the game itself, but the way Westerners view cultural examinations.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
@Neram It's not that "normal people" don't think like that, but privileged people. These kind of evaluations are GOOD if they open your eyes to the overwhelming preference in Western culture for "people like us."
Honestly, I do not understand why almost everyone on this comments section seems so defensive. This stuff is real. It's not that people are looking to find sexism, racism, etc. It's already there. If you can't see it, than the one revealing it is helping you.
Does it suck that Zelda is loaded with these harmful classifications? Yes. Have things improved since the 1940s? Yes.
Re: News Site Claims That Zelda "Takes A Dim View Of Workers, People Of Colour And Women"
Sure, there are worse games, but it's important to have a critical eye on the things we enjoy the most. The author's last paragraph says exactly this:
"On this 15th anniversary of the game’s release, I encourage readers to dust off their Nintendo 64 and return to Hyrule. Hike up Death Mountain. Swim in Lake Hylia. Explore the Lost Woods. “Ocarina” is a fantastic piece of art we can enjoy while being aware that, like so much other art, it has a lot of problems."
Don't take it so personally. Everyone has blind spots. Yes, Zelda is awesome; also, it has problems.
Re: Child of Light Co-Op Element Takes Inspiration From Super Mario Galaxy, Yet Aims For Better
That's awesome! I was hoping to play this with my daughter, but concerned about the difficulty. Now, we can both play.
Re: Chasing Aurora Began as a Prototype Based on Secrets of Raetikon, was Developed in Five Months
I love Chasing Aurora. It has excellent multiplayer. Have played it with just my wife and I, our kids, and our friends. And Yet IT Moves is also excellent. I'm disappointed I'll have to buy SoR on Steam, but it will be a day one purchase.
Re: Feature: Some Early Miiverse Favourites From Art Academy: SketchPad
@ThomasBW84 Word. Usually catch stuff like that! The art must have distracted me
Re: Feature: Some Early Miiverse Favourites From Art Academy: SketchPad
@rjejr Tap the Miiverse icon on the bottom of the game selection screen. It looks like three green people. You can also get there by clocking home and selecting the same icon.
To get there from Wara Wara plaza, click on a person and then "View Post in Miiverse," or something like that.
Re: Feature: Some Early Miiverse Favourites From Art Academy: SketchPad
@DePapier you can quickly see these and many more by going to the community and clicking "Popular Posts." I wish they would link it here at NL, but that's my work around.
Re: Video: This Super Metroid Animation is Rather Impressive
So sweet.
Re: GameStop Accused of Re-Printing Xenoblade Chronicles, Then Selling as "Used" For $90
@Kodeen exactly.
Re: Talking Point: The "Indie Spotlight" Was A Bright Point of Nintendo Direct, But More is Needed
@ThomasBW84 It really is surprising because showing the sizzle real makes so much sense, but at the same time I don't have any expectation of advertising from NA based on past experience. I stay very informed of Wii U news, but my Wii U owning friends know hardly anything about new titles, let alone those yet to come. I'm hoping that will change, but I'm not holding my breath.
Re: Ghost Song: A Journey of Hope Could Come to Wii U if Kickstarter Stretch Goal is Met
@WinterWarm That's fair. It wasn't my view either until a couple years ago. I took a break from consoles for a couple years only to be drawn back in by Skyward Sword, Rock Band and BitTrip. Runner. My tastes have since changed. I would love to see something for everyone on Wii U, and that's why I find crowd funded indies so exciting. With Unity on Wii U, anyone with enough determination, hard work, and support can try their hand at bringing new ideas and innovation to the gaming community. Steam already has this sort of infrastructure, but Wii U is so much more convenient than constantly setting up wired USB and/or Bluetooth controllers to my PC.
Re: Ghost Song: A Journey of Hope Could Come to Wii U if Kickstarter Stretch Goal is Met
@WinterWarm these games are crowd funded because that's the route some indies are taking with Wii U. Why does that have you pissed? Cloudberry Kingdom is an amazing game, and I absolutely cannot wait for Shovel Knight (both kickstarted). @3DSAllDay, not every game needs a kickstarter. LOL!The way I see it, it only means for more games. And super awesome indie games at that.
Re: Ghost Song: A Journey of Hope Could Come to Wii U if Kickstarter Stretch Goal is Met
@SmearyToast this game isn't being ported to MS or Sony systems, unless you consider Windows as MS. A lot of these kickstarters either only include Wii U or have it as the first console to be added. Anyway, this game has really sweet style, so I backed it.
Re: The Wonderful 101 Demo Coming to Europe Today
Don't start any long books! Blast! I just started The Brothers Karamozov yesterday!
Re: Nintendo Download: 8th August (North America)
I bought Spin the Bottle! Can't wait to party!
As far as D&D is concerned, @leon_x has it right!
Re: Gaijin Games: Runner 2 Fix is On The Way
@Blizzaga: this issue is also dealt with in the update:
"
•At the start of the game, when it asks you if you want to log in, we've added some feedback so it doesn't look like the game is hanging.
•The leaderboards will only save your highest score, as expected, instead of your most recent score, which it does now.
•If you lose your internet connection during play, we've allowed you to reconnect by going to the leaderboards menu.
•We've fixed false score reporting for in-game Rewards.
•We've fixed an issue with the level start mini-leaderboard telling you you're offline when you're actually online. It will populate this list with global scores if you don't have any friends who have played the game yet.
•We've fixed an issue in the settings menu that resets your settings every time you enter the menu.
And last, but not least, we've tried to fix the issue that locks up the Wii U system upon powering down or quitting out of the game via the HOME Menu.
"
http://gaijingames.com/forum/wii-u-patch-coming-soon-details-within#comment-348