Comments 14

Re: Talking Point: When Did 'Good Enough' Become Good Enough For Pokémon?

Scarftail

This article was an interesting meta-read. I had to think for a minute, and yes, despite the fact that this game is literally half the series ago now, Black 2 and White 2 were the last Pokémon games I would give a letter grade of A. There have been several games since that had some memorable aspects to them, but ultimately, no entry has excelled as a video game since the 2D era. However, I'm thankful that they managed to keep me as a fan all the way up to the present because one thing I can praise Game Freak for is that they make sure each individual entry doesn't feel identical to its predecessor, for better or worse. To me, despite appreciating Sun and Moon, Sword and Shield were the epitome of safe, and yet immediately afterwards, we got Legends: Arceus, Scarlet and Violet, and Legends: Z-A, with the dream game Champions coming soon and with leaks suggesting even higher ambition in the future if you can believe it. It very much looks as though the developers consistently want to make the best game they can, but the top people for one reason or another have been imposing limitations on them and only recently have they been gradually opening up to the idea that distinct games with more development time and more substance do in fact sell better.

Re: GTA 6 On 'Switch 2' Would Be "Very Tricky To Pull Off", Says Digital Foundry

Scarftail

Games are computer applications. People write them, not hardware. If Rockstar has any interest in putting this game on a Nintendo console, they can write the game to work properly for it, removing or reducing whatever they have to, properly coding, etc. This is silly. What you see in the trailer is what would potentially perform badly on a new Nintendo console.

Re: Nintendo Says It Wants To Avoid A Repeat Of Wii U With Switch's Successor

Scarftail

I'm not a fan of this article's headline. It implies there's any chance the Switch successor will fail when we know from 33 consecutive years of history that it won't if it's part handheld. I'm certain Nintendo doesn't fear that their next console will fail; just that it will be less successful. It's yet another case of people not being keen enough about what kind of console the Switch is.

Re: Nintendo Says It Wants To Avoid A Repeat Of Wii U With Switch's Successor

Scarftail

I don't think there's any real concern. It's just instinctual. All the developers and game series they have on the Switch will transition to the next console and most people will continue to play those games on said next console. Both the 3DS and Wii U were less broadly appealing than their predecessors for different reasons. The former was a victim of bad timing, where the DS had loads of owners who weren't necessarily Nintendo fans and the 3DS was straight-up outcompeted by smartphones (as silly as that is), and the latter had its own internal problems (marketing, number of games, split development teams, etc.) that prevented it from doing well on top of intentionally not trying to to be a broad-market console. Does it seem like Nintendo has any of these problems moving into the Switch's successor?

Re: Talking Point: How's Your Switch Holding Up After 5 Years?

Scarftail

So um...I've had to replace every single part of my launch Switch other than the Joy-Con rails and motherboard. Admittedly, I shared my Switch with my very rough family and friends, so I have no anecdote of how well I alone would've taken care of it. I will say my personal OLED's anti-scattering film has gotten two nicks on it in a single month, but I chalk that up to crap material.

Re: Some Trainers Are Worried About Pokémon Scarlet And Violet Returning To "Traditional" Catching Mechanics

Scarftail

@swoose The game was pegged from the beginning as a singleplayer game that focused on completing the Pokedex, and that's exactly what it is. It adds some story, lore, and sidequests on top of it, but little else. I think most of the positivity towards the game is a sigh of relief that the gameplay and scenario were overhauled, but in reality, it can't possibly appeal to everyone's tastes due to that very specific premise.