Comments 60

Re: Round Up: The Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl Reviews Are In

thiz-

@JordanMiddler Thank you for replying to my comment. I appreciate you taking your time and talking to the community. I edited my comment with a Disclaimer for this so people know. Its still just a sour taste in my mouth that you rather release it early and have this important info missing instead of actually caring to give people a full picture. This is not your personal fault and a decision of the people you work for I am assuming, but the criticism is still valid I believe. Now your review just looks like a trailer-critique. Its not really what anyone should call a review.

Re: Round Up: The Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl Reviews Are In

thiz-

It does not seem like the NL reviewer finished the game or he would have noticed that no matter how much Underground Grinding you do, the leveling is a non-issue, as the jump from normal trainers to Gym Leaders and Elite Four as well as Champion is huge.

Also no mention of the endgame that includes you collecting ALL of Gen 1-4 + rebattling everyone again with really strong teams.

Trying to get praise from the pokemon hate club is one thing, but this was a bit much. Just because you dont like the art style of something doesnt mean you have to make the whole review about that one topic.

I do agree with platinum content missing being a bad thing, but the only thing thats missing is the battle frontier part, which he couldnt have reached anyways because again, I dont think he finished it.

Edit: The Reviewer did reply to this and noticed that he was not able to speak to other parts of the game due to the embargo.

Re: Review: Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl - A Middling Pair Of Remakes

thiz-

No mention of the good endgame content? How far have you played if I may ask? I agree with most, but not mentioning this is a bit of a bummer.

Being able to catch all of Gen 1 - 4 and rebattling everyone with their beefy platinum EV-trained teams, is honestly a really cool thing and a big deal that should have been mentioned. This is not really a review. It just sounds like you watched a trailer and are critiquing it for its chibi look.

  • Page :
  • 2