Topic: Game vs. Game

Sonic CD: 3
Sonic Adventure: 1

I'm gonna say...
Sonic.........
Adventure.

I honestly liked Sonic Adventure. Sonic CD was technically more of the same as previous Sonic games.

I love both games, but c'mon, Sonic CD's soundtrack is incredible and the sprites and cut scenes are great in that game.

Sonic CD: 4
Sonic Adventure: 2

I honestly don't see why people like Sonic CD so much. It's an enjoyable game, but I thought the level design was the worst out of the classic series and I found some parts extremely annoying (Wacky Workbench >.>). Sonic Adventure on the other hand, had what I think is the best feeling physics and levels in a 3D Sonic game.

Sonic CD: 4
Sonic Adventure: 3

I agree... As long as you are talking about the Japanese version.

My vote is for Sonic Adventure... but it is an extremely close choice for me...

While I still regard Sonic CD as being one of the best Sonic games ever made I'm still going to have to throw my vote to Adventure. Sonic Adventure showed, despite bad camera, that Sonic games can make the jump to 3D and be awesome.

I am actually working through Sonic Adventure on the Dreamcast so that gets my vote, even if it is a flawed game.

I vote for Adventure, seeing that it's one of the few Sonic games I like.

Sonic the Hedgehog CD

Sonic Adventure, mainly because I hate CD's special stages.

Sonic CD: 5
Sonic Adventure: 8

Really?! I thought that they were the best special stages of any Sonic game..

Sonic CD easily.

Sonic CD: 6
Sonic Adventure: 8

Sonic Adventure

Sonic CD and its not even a close call, the Adventure games are fairly average and in no way shape or form anywhere near as fun as CD.

Sonic CD: 7
Sonic Adventure: 9

I'm a bit surprised by the somewhat split opinions regarding the vote this time around.

????????????

CD

Sonic CD: 8
Sonic Adventure: 9

This is hard, both games I have a ton of nostalgia for, but aren't that great in retrospect. I guess I'll vote for Sonic CD, since that wasn't the first domino of Sonic's potential demise.