Game Review

Reel Fishing Challenge II Review

USA USA Version

Posted by Jon Wahlgren

Hook, line and stinker

Reel Fishing Challenge II is, by definition, the follow-up to Reel Fishing Challenge that hit WiiWare last year and as such is basically just more of the same. Fans of staring at full-motion video backgrounds and boring, lame fishing mechanics, rejoice!

Everything about it just feels lazy, and the fact that it's essentially a rehash of a PlayStation One game doesn't help. There is no widescreen or pointer support, precisely one FMV background and ugly underwater sections. Party like it's 1996, y'all.

Each of the game's 30 timed challenges tasks you with catching a certain number or type of fish using an assortment of lures and whatever the hell else you have in your tackle box. It's nice that the lures actually do matter in governing what type of fish you'll attract, but actually reeling in fish is, shall we say, dull.

Alright, so there you are, staring at this big ol' lake or pond or River Styx you just paid 500 Points for that is full of dumb fish, and you're determined to catch those suckers if it's the last thing you do. You twist the Remote to aim your discombobulated fishing rod left or right (which seems inconsequential anyway), hold down A and do a swinging motion to cast. It doesn't matter how hard you swing, regardless of what the instructions tell you, because that sucker is going however far it feels like. The camera jumps to an overhead view of your lure hanging out in the murkiest water this side of New Jersey, and you can reel it in either fast or slow to attract your prey. If a fish nibbles then a well-timed pull of the Remote will hook it. Reeling it in comes down to two actions: when the fish isn't doing anything then keep the controller flat and reel, otherwise hold it vertically and do nothing. Once it's caught, the screen fades white to a shot of the presumably dead fish with its weight displayed. The type and weight are saved to your high score table, but only after you exit your current session for some reason. Why it doesn't save immediately is a big Scooby mystery, but signs point to not giving a carp.

That is, of course, if you're lucky to get one nibbling. Many times you'll cast and, no matter how you jiggle or not jiggle the lure, fish will just ignore you. We suppose this is "realistic" in the sense that real fishing involves a lot of waiting and you don't hook a fish for every cast, but actually catching a fish isn't the whole, or even most important, part of the experience. But here, it is, and it's very boring.

Actually, we lied earlier when we said this was more of the same. Reel Fishing Challenge II manages to do less of the same since the Free Play option from the first is nowhere to be found, unless it's tucked away hidden where there be dragons.


If you bought the first Reel Fishing Challenge then there's no need to splurge on this one unless you're exceptionally fond of FMV backgrounds. This also makes a great gift for that friend or relative of yours who is into fishing, that you don't really like because they're stupid and ugly and hopefully they're a little blind, too. Pour a glass of water on your cash instead, or get the first game if you really need a WiiWare fishing game, or get the infinitely more interesting My Aquarium instead.

From the web

User Comments (13)



cheetahman91 said:

Not surprised by the score. A shame that this'll probably break the WiiWare Top 20 because it has fish in it.



FonistofCruxis said:

This looks crap but I highly doubt the terrible my aquarium is infinitely more interesting. I don't get why it's so popular here.



Splat said:

Is there any fishing game worth getting on the Wii? I'm not trying to be a smart ass I really want to know pretty much everyone I have seen has got a bad rep.



jbrodack said:

Yeah I was thinking this looked even worse than the original since it ONLY has mission mode. Hopefully wiiware games don't get more crappy sequels like this.



Gimpy said:

I can't even catch a fish in Reel Fishing® Challenge. My line snaps or I'm late sinking the hook or whatever. I've played that game till my arm gets sore from casting to no avail. Too bad there isn't a satisfaction guarantee or get your points back clause.



BrickRockwell said:

Yeah, I plunked down $5 one day as a spur of the moment thing b/c my brother was over and he's an outdoorsman (and not so much a gamer), so I figured, "Hey, this isn't going to be great or anything, but at least it'll be a simple little game I can enjoy with him." After struggling with the terrible controls to land even the smallest fish, he said I was an idiot for buying it and took me fishing for real, where catching fish was smooth, realistic AND fun : )

Leave A Comment

Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...