Sonic - Game Gear
Image: Nintendo Life

With the release of Sonic Origins Plus on the Switch, Sonic fans can now not only play as the severely underutilised Amy in all four mainline titles, but there are now 12 Game Gear Sonic games to peruse and play at your leisure from the compilation's 'Missions' menu.

Now, we're probably never going to recommend playing the Game Gear games over the superb Genesis originals, but as a handful of curiosities, they make for an interesting addition to what is already a decent package with Sonic Origins.

Of course, as with any franchise, however, some titles are better than others, so we've ranked all 12 Game Gear Sonic games from worst to best as decided by you fine folks.

The list below has been compiled according to each game's User Rating from our extensive database. What this means is, like most of our ranking lists, the order in which you'll find the games may fluctuate over time depending on subsequent ratings.

So have you spotted a particular title you think deserves to be higher? No problem, simply click on the star button and provide your own rating from 1 to 10.

So with that out of the way, let's take a look at which Game Gear Sonic title you've deemed to be the very best...

12. Sonic Labyrinth (GG)

This isometric Game Gear title from Minato Giken had you exploring four maze-like levels for keys to open a goal gate and battling a boss at the end of three Acts. With uninspiring level design and slow, soupy movement, this is a '3D' Sonic that removes the key ingredients of a Sonic game. Sonic Labyrinth was available for 3DS, but is only really for masochistic Sonic completionists.

11. Sonic Blast (GG)

Sonic Blast is a perfectly competent 2D Sonic game that released on Game Gear (and Master System in Brazil), and it's worth a dabble for interested parties and hardcore fans. It was included in Sonic Mega Collection Plus, a compilation which expanded the number of games on GameCube's Sonic Mega Collection but never released on a Nintendo console, but Blast also came to Nintendo 3DS Virtual Console as an individual release and is one of the GG offerings in Sonic Origins Plus. It's a fun curio for fans, but very far from the best of Sonic's 8-bit escapades.

10. Sonic Drift (GG)

Sonic Drift has the rather distinct honour of being the first racing game in the Sonic franchise, though we'd probably be kidding ourselves if we said it was a particularly great one. Despite taking inspiration from Super Mario Kart, Sonic Drift shares a lot more in common with games like OutRun, demonstrating the 'Super Scaler' effect sufficiently. But with overly forgiving difficulty and little replay value, you're probably safe skipping this one.

9. Tails' Skypatrol (GG)

The fact that Tails' Skypatrol was only officially released in Japan for the Game Gear is perhaps a blessing in disguise. It's quite comfortably one of the weakest Sonic games in existence, with uninspiring gameplay and relentless difficulty. If you consider yourself a fervent fan of Sonic's sidekick, it might be worth a look for curiosity's sake, but for everyone else, just stay clear of this one.

8. Sonic Spinball (GG)

Sonic Spinball in itself is a pretty decent spin-off title that showcased reasonably decent visuals and gameplay for the Genesis, but the Game Gear version undoubtedly suffers from the necessary downgrades to get the game running competently. Gameplay feels clunky and the music is a bit of a mess. Still, it's not a terrible effort, all told.

7. Tails Adventure (GG)

Tails Adventure is definitely the odd game out in the Game Gear's Sonic lineup, but it makes a sound case for its unique identity. This is SEGA's very much friendlier take on the Metroidvania-lite formula — a fun adventure platformer with excellent level design, creative items and abilities, and some much-deserved time in the spotlight for Tails. For fans of the two-tailed fox, or adventure games in general, Tails Island is well worth exploring.

6. Sonic Chaos (SMS)

Hardcore Sonic fans might get a kick out of Sonic Chaos, and it's not without charm, but compared to the greats it's a comparatively uninspired effort and far too easy for its own good. Some of the levels will only take you 30 seconds to run through and personally we'd stick to the previous 8-bit titles. Still, Chaos has its defenders and it's got some great box art, so it's not all bad.

5. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 (GG)

The personality that made the hedgehog a hit is present in spades in Sonic the Hedgehog 2, with fun gameplay ideas, beautiful graphics, a memorable soundtrack, and glimpses of speed-platforming delight. Unfortunately, the experience is somewhat marred by sporadically sadistic level design that bends over backwards to put the breaks on Sonic's joyride. There's still lots of fun between the death jingles, and its unique zones definitely make it worth playing for series fans, but if there's no nostalgia tying you to this particular cartridge, we'd personally recommend checking out the original Game Gear Sonic the Hedgehog before dashing into this one.

4. Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine (GG)

Though it may be a bit dated in terms of aesthetics, Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine's Puyo Puyo-style gameplay remains fresh decades after its initial release, and one which suits handheld gaming beautifully. It's a challenging game that may not appeal to all audiences, but puzzler fans can chill the beans right down with this one.

3. Sonic the Hedgehog: Triple Trouble (GG)

As with all the Game Gear releases, it's easy to pick on Triple Trouble for its shortcomings when compared to the home console Sonic titles, but even bearing in mind the limitations of the hardware, the game still has its share of faults. The adventure itself is quite enjoyable and there are some solid level designs, but the lack of challenge and sluggish pacing end up bringing the overall experience down a few notches. Keep your expectations at a realistic level and you might have some fun, but this is far from essential Sonic.

2. Sonic Drift 2 (GG)

It might look dated at first, but give it a chance and you'll find that Sonic Drift 2 transcends its outmoded presentation and is a blast to play. Tight controls and a great sense of speed make for thrilling races, a wonderful set of visually and mechanically diverse tracks keeps things interesting, and a two-player mode is the icing on top. It may not be up there with Mario Kart, but this remains one of the Game Gear's finest for speed freaks and Sonic fans.

1. Sonic the Hedgehog (GG)

The Game Gear version of Sonic's first adventure isn't just a competent conversion of a legendary game — it's also a fantastic platformer on its own merits, with tight controls, a great sense of speed, and plenty of personality. If they can get over the jump back from 16- to 8-bit, players with fond memories of the Mega Drive version will find fresh surprises alongside the nostalgia trip, and for first-timers, the excellent exclusive zones and soundtrack here make this almost as easy to recommend as its big-screen sibling. The series might have expanded onwards and upwards, but there's a real joy to Sonic the Hedgehog that hasn't diminished with age. This is the Blue Blur at his basic best: a speedy, smile-inducing classic.

Remember, if you haven't rated the games on this list, you can still do so now and your personal rating will count towards the ranking above — and potentially change the ordering even after publication.

Be sure to share your own thoughts on the rankings with a comment down below. Which is your favourite? Do you have any stories about the games to share? We'd love to hear it.