Comments 313

Re: Review: Eschatos - A Boldly Unique And Historical Shmup Package

Tom-Massey

@X68000 @-wc- @riccyjay

Fellas, you're making me commit a cardinal sin of my own here by making me reply in a comments section, but for the sake of clarity, I'm the last person looking to offend my favourite videogame genre. Perhaps the phrasing didn't land right, but the idea was to put emphasis on just how unique Eschatos is.

Someone mentioned shmups going through a 'renaissance', but honestly, they've been going through a renaissance for the last two decades. It's always been an active genre, from X360 to PS4, and now Switch - but the format of most shmups tends to be essentially the same: either danmaku or... not danmaku.

Great as something like Fantasy Cotton is - as a recent example - it's still a shmup in a format we're all very familiar with, and it's fairly rare to see something as original as Project Starship X or Radirgy (also a pretty old series) flipping the medium on its head.

Many of the Shmups appearing on current-gen are anywhere between 10 - 20 years old now (Even Eschatos has hit a ripe old 11), and what's new tends to revisit well-established formulas with new patterns and the occasional juggling of mechanics.

I didn't mean to infer anything derogatory at all by the phrase "dangerously played-out", and if that's the way it came across, I sincerely apologise. I write for mainstream sites, but if you check my portfolio I'm anything but a typical mainstream journalist. I hoped, considering the degree to which I gargled Eschatos' balls in this review, as well as taking time to map out its heritage, that that would be communicated better.

Anyway, genuinely sorry again if you felt I was dissing the majestic shooting game, I'll be more attentive to my wording on the next one!

https://muckrack.com/tom-massey-2

Re: Review: Project Starship X - An Unconventional Shmup That's Full Of New Ideas

Tom-Massey

@DenimDemon As someone with a long history dedicated to shmup playing (and no issue recognising your avatar) I dedicated a lot of time to arrive at that score. If 5 represents an average on a scale of 10, it's a good score for a good game. Its originality within the genre is impressive, but some design aspects will occasionally irk even the most hardened genre enthusiast. I do appreciate your comments, however. Thank you for taking time to read the review.