@RupeeClock I mean I'd be more understanding of the score but the cons to me feel like they are easily argued and the review comes off as flawed being unable to justify the 6/10 rating. It feels like he spends a majority of the review complaining about the art style, which fair enough i know is not for everyone but still.
I'm gonna have to disagree with the score here. I'm gonna have to disagree with the some of the cons from the written review. I feel like the Chibi art style is more of a personal negative than it is a widespread amongst all Pokemon fans. Cause it's clear there are fans of the art style being brought to life in 3D.
As for the lack of Platinum content this should've been expected as the trailers started coming out closer to the game's release cause the game's are exactly what they say Brilliant "Diamond" and Shining "Pearl" so it feels like you were set up for disappointment from the start. This is in no way me defending GameFreak or the company that had make this game but obviously they played it safe cause of all the uproar that had happened in the past with Sword and Shield all the way through its DLC development.
This review to me at least feels a little flawed since a majority of the cons can be easily counter-argued minus the overleveling. And hey if you still feel the same way about the game then hey more power to you it's just i think this a game that is getting overhated in the same way that Sword and Shield got when they first came out.
Honestly from someone who has played every remaster of this can i honestly say that this is one of the best remasters in recent years of this game. The thing most of the cons imo aren't really a problem. This easily a must game for fans of the original game. 9/10 for me.
@maximo_jd The only thing i can assume that the reviewer has never really played the games in the past, otherwise this is a pretty silly complaint. But for someone who has played the original and the remaster on Steam the combat was never the main focus of the game
@link3710 The camera i understand, but the combat was never the main focus in the original.
Comments 6
Re: Review: Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl - A Middling Pair Of Remakes
@RupeeClock I mean I'd be more understanding of the score but the cons to me feel like they are easily argued and the review comes off as flawed being unable to justify the 6/10 rating. It feels like he spends a majority of the review complaining about the art style, which fair enough i know is not for everyone but still.
Re: Review: Pokémon Brilliant Diamond And Shining Pearl - A Middling Pair Of Remakes
I'm gonna have to disagree with the score here. I'm gonna have to disagree with the some of the cons from the written review. I feel like the Chibi art style is more of a personal negative than it is a widespread amongst all Pokemon fans. Cause it's clear there are fans of the art style being brought to life in 3D.
As for the lack of Platinum content this should've been expected as the trailers started coming out closer to the game's release cause the game's are exactly what they say Brilliant "Diamond" and Shining "Pearl" so it feels like you were set up for disappointment from the start. This is in no way me defending GameFreak or the company that had make this game but obviously they played it safe cause of all the uproar that had happened in the past with Sword and Shield all the way through its DLC development.
This review to me at least feels a little flawed since a majority of the cons can be easily counter-argued minus the overleveling. And hey if you still feel the same way about the game then hey more power to you it's just i think this a game that is getting overhated in the same way that Sword and Shield got when they first came out.
Re: Review: Balan Wonderworld - A Charmless, Confusing Fossil From The Creators Of Sonic
@Lord Depends on what division of Square was working on this.
Re: Review: Trials of Mana - Old And New Combine To Create A Fine RPG Adventure
@Gasarakii Feels like an 8.5/10 for me. Also never trust Metacritic for a reliable source for game scores.
Re: Review: Cooking Mama: Cookstar - Definitely Needed More Time In The Oven
Yeah this is one game i'm definitely skipping.
Re: Mini Review: Ty the Tasmanian Tiger HD - A Competent Remaster That Lacks Bite
Honestly from someone who has played every remaster of this can i honestly say that this is one of the best remasters in recent years of this game. The thing most of the cons imo aren't really a problem. This easily a must game for fans of the original game. 9/10 for me.
@maximo_jd The only thing i can assume that the reviewer has never really played the games in the past, otherwise this is a pretty silly complaint. But for someone who has played the original and the remaster on Steam the combat was never the main focus of the game
@link3710 The camera i understand, but the combat was never the main focus in the original.