
Sonic the Hedgehog's third big-screen outing arrives this week and the critic reviews are now rolling in...
This outing brings Shadow into the picture and it seems the reviews have (mostly) been enjoying the fun and family-friendly action so far. Many reviews are also praising Jim Carrey's efforts as well as the addition of Keanu Reeves.
Variety said it was "faster and more fun":
"The plot finds room for the Master Emerald, the super-powered jewel introduced in the last “Sonic” film, and for Tails the fox (Colleen O’Shaughnessey) and Knuckles the echidna (Idris Elba), who are now part of Sonic’s super-critter-hero team. But the real star is Fowler’s shape-shifting filmmaking, which is deft enough to revel in blockbuster overkill and skewer it at the same time."
GamesRadar+ thought Sonic 3 was predictable, but great fun - awarding it 3 out of 5 stars:
"Sonic the Hedgehog 3 then is a piece of overstuffed franchise affair that's simple and predictable – but great fun. Anchored by two great characters, Sonic and Robotnik, it's a family-friendly adventure that does nothing to revolutionize the formula Fowler has developed but keeps the wheels turning fast enough to get everyone excited for a sequel."
Gaming Bible said Sonic 3 was the "best film of the trilogy":
"Sonic The Hedgehog 3 was amazing. It really is the best film of the trilogy by far, yet I’m still confident the next film could be even better if they keep this momentum up. It’s hard to believe that we started from a shoddy, horrific design for a live-action Sonic The Hedgehog and somehow ended up here, it’s honestly surreal."
The Hollywood Reporter thought Sonic 3 was a zippy sequel that got the job done:
"Director Jeff Fowler, repeating his assignment from the two previous features, demonstrates a clear ability to bring the Sonic characters to cinematic life, delivering a well-balanced, fast-paced blend of action and slapstick comedy that, in this case, takes place in such scenic locales as Tokyo and London. (Inevitably, the cities wind up worse for the wear.) No one will mistake the unimaginatively titled Sonic the Hedgehog 3 for sophisticated entertainment. But that’s clearly not what its audiences are looking for."
Our friends at Eurogamer called it a "fitting finale for the year of Shadow" - awarding it 4 out of 5 stars:
"Sonic 3 is a resounding success and fitting finale to the Year of Shadow. It's quippy and self-aware, balancing broad pop culture appeal with authenticity to its source material, while its flashy action thrills alongside an unbridled sense of cool that's only enhanced by Reeves as Shadow. Between this year's games and film, Sonic's shining bright with Shadow in tow."
And IGN awarded Sonic's third outing 6 out of 10 - mentioning how these movies were only getting "better as they go" and also praising Jim Carrey's performance:
"They may have started on the wrong foot, but the Sonic the Hedgehog movies appear to be getting better as they go. Pushing further past the dopey buddy comedy of the original and the tiresome pop-culture references of its marginally better sequel, this third installment offers much more pleasing CGI, blessedly fewer human foibles, and a kind of tortured nega-Sonic in Shadow, a fan favorite antihero voiced by Keanu Reeves. The real draw, though, is Jim Carrey, coaxed out of supposed retirement to deliver a dual villain performance that doubles all the exaggerated comic pleasures of his ongoing turn as Dr. Robotnik."
Will you be heading to the cinemas to catch Sonic 3? Let us know in the comments.
Comments 33
I tried hard to get into them, but the humor just isn't for me. I'm happy for Jim Carrey though. Glad to see he hasn't lost his touch.
IGN and GamesRadar+ seem a bit harsher then the others. I feel like we have to remember that this is a series aimed mostly for younger kids, adults just enjoy it as well.
If they wanted to hold it to adult standards then they would have made it PG13 or above (I haven't seen it yet but I doubt they showed Maria getting shot **BECAUSE IT'S A KIDS MOVIE**)
Mostly video game critics quoted here. What do the real movie critics say?
@Dman10
Excellent point, of course it's predictable if you've already played the game.
It's like critizing the Anime for following the Manga. It's a lose lose situation because if they were "unpredictable" then they would have said this isn't sonic at all or smth
Sure they're decent but no where near as good as the mario movie. Glad Sonic is getting a little more love these days. Now let's see a new game that gets high marks all around. Still hasn't happened yet.
No mention of the 88% on Rotten Tomatoes, eh?
@Gamergirl4 Can't say I agree with that. Doesn't need to be PG-13 at all. I've consumed animation all over the world and animation as a medium can tell mature stories whilst being aimed at younger audiences. It's just mostly American's backwards idea that kids can't digest anything other than loud noises and bright colors.
Do you need a scene showing a young female being shot? No, but one can allude to the tragedy which adds emotional weight to the character Shadow. You can add serious things to a story without it being graphic.
Japan's animation is in fact aimed at mostly younger audiences, but the level of maturity they give the medium far outclasses the west.
I am just happy that Jim Carrey seems to be killing it in such an unexpected career path.
@batmanbud2 86%
@Truegamer79
Nice opinion but heavily disagree. The Mario movie had so many more issues than both of the Sonic films for me and was a really average film.
I'm beginning to question whether IGN actually likes anything, lol.
Never really cared to watch any of these. I guess it does well for a video game movie series, but it always came across as pretty uninspired. It's just another case of video game characters ending up in the real world- which is an over-done trope that keeps being reused.
Honestly, if they can cut down on the influence and role of the non-Robotnik humans? It'll be a step up. I want a SONIC movie. Not "Donut Lord's Friends co-starring Some Blue Guy."
I liked the Sonic movies way more than Mario. The acting, humor and mix of real actors made them a lot of fun to watch. Jim carry is perfect as Eggman. Jean Ralphio as Sonic is too good. Watching the Mario Movie in theaters was the worst experience I ever had at the movies. A bunch of 30-40 year olds that just wouldn't shut up. I could bearly hear anything. I did see it when It came on Netflix and it was a solid movie. Just didn't have the heart that Sonic did.
@Not_Soos They like pain and making people rage on the internet with their illogical review scores. Note this is the site that gave She-Hulk an 8/10
Ign's review read as if the person really enjoyed it, made it sound like a solid 8/10... yet the 6 really threw me off?
@Truegamer79 Didn't shadow x sonic kinda do that?
Empire magazine have awarded it a 2 star review, but then said it was the best in the franchise so far.
I think they are missing the point .
I'm just going for the sweet sweet popcorn, the Sonic Team and Jim Carey.
@Metalinkster 6/10 is better than average. But it's certainly not the kind of proportion you'd want to risk flying with.
What does nega-Sonic mean?
Edit: Negative-Sonic?
The entire trilogy was absolute rubbish.
So overall based on these reviews and what some comments mentioned it seems that this third movie is (even) better than the previous ones, love to hear it and looking forward to watching them all when I can!
Didn't IGN say it was better than the first two and still gave it a worse score?
This movie franchise is probably the last one I would expect myself to enjoy, but it ended up surprisingly good. Will have to find time to watch this next one.
@VHSGREMLIN was? It's not even finished yet seeing as the 3rd one isn't out until tomorrow, and as such you can't know how good or bad it is personally. So quick to write off a whole trilogy...
@Baker1000 it’s available on the high seas if you catch my drift…
@shiftbarackyeaugh IGN’s reviews and critiques were never valid nor reliable.
I'm ready to see it.
@DripDropCop146 I couldn't get into it either. I love Sonic but I want a movie about Sonic. I don't want some stupid human characters. I don't even know why they have to be there. You could replace them with any of the existing cast of Sonic characters and nothing would be lost.
This is the first series I've been able to progress through at the cinema with my son as they release so holds a special place in my heart. They aren't clever but they are entertaining! Good enough for me. I'll watch Schindler's List or something when I want something with gravitas!
@NintenGuy yeah I was disappointed in the the Mario movie, it was just 90 minutes or so of ooh look, remember this from Mario World, now Smash Bros and now Mario kart just because, no real story and no heart.
I've just got back from seeing Sonic 3 and it's my favourite in the series, the setup feels a little rushed but the characters are all really good and Jim Carrey is having the time of his life
Just watched it yesterday it was so good!!!
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...