With all the talk around the launch (and state) of Nintendo 64 games with the Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack, it may well have slipped your notice that Pikmin — the Nintendo RTS series that grew from an idea Shigeru Miyamoto had while chilling in his garden — is now two decades old.
Yes, time marches on and we retro gaming fans feel more decrepit by the day. It was 20 years ago yesterday (26th October) that Pikmin launched in Japan and Nintendo fans got their first look at an IP both disarmingly cute and alarmingly cruel in equal measure. We often think back on the legions of little Pikmin we unwittingly marched to their doom with a tinge of sadness and not a small amount of full-on guilt.
For a series with 20 years under its belt, the number of games in the 'min stable is surprisingly few, with just three mainline games. The first entry and its excellent sequel appeared first on GameCube in 2001 and 2004 respectively before getting New Play Control versions of both came to Wii with added Wiimote controls in 2008/9. Pikmin 3 arrived on Wii U in 2013, and that came to Switch in Deluxe form almost a year ago in October 2020.
Underwhelming 3DS spin-off Hey! Pikmin came and went in 2017, and the spectre of Pikmin 4 has been wafting around in rumours for many years now. We recently got to spend time with the latest addition to the family, Pikmin Bloom — Niantic's latest mobile collaboration with Nintendo and an easy-going, flower-spreading 'sister' title to the world conquering Google Maps-powered Pokémon GO.
So, with the arrival of this 20th anniversary, we thought we'd ask your favourite game in the Pikmin series. Personally, we go back and forth between the elegance and purity of the day cycle in the first game, the expanded horizons and new, non-time limited elements of the second (and its surprisingly fun and robust multiplayer, too), and the incredible HD sheen of the fruit in the third entry. If this writer had to pick, he'd probably go with the New Play Control version of the original game.
But which is your favourite? Let us know by voting in the polls below. We've included ever release and port (and left out Pikmin Bloom because the majority of players are still waiting to get their hands on it thanks to the staggered launch roll out):
Feel free to blow your whistle about the best Pikmin games, characters, and enemies in the comments below, and pay tribute to the many Pikmin you tried to save before they stubbornly insisted on bothering a Bulborb or wandered into a body of water through no fault of your own.
Further reading:
Comments 68
Never played a Pikmin game
Pikmin 1 for me, the atmosphere is incredible. I love that Hey! Pikmin is even an option.
One of Nintendo's best ever series. 3 on Wii U is a masterpiece and even better than Breath of the Wild in my humble opinion! Also... Hey! Pikmin is underrated!
Pikmin 2 with Wii controls. I'm all over the laid back, underground-focused experience. And in the words of Reggie, "I feel like a purple Pikmin."
Dang, hard choice. 3 Deluxe's inclusion of co-op makes it the best so long as you can use that. 2 is by far the most replayable, while 1 remains a finely tuned challenge even today.
Still awaiting Pikmin 4...
Honorable mention to Pikmin Adventure on Nintendoland!
Pikmin 3. Massive game for Wii u.
All great games but I love replaying Pikmin 1
Pikmin 4 that was "very close to completion" 6 years ago
2 refined everything that the first one did and imo is the best of the bunch but the first was such an amazingly good game.The atmosphere and sence of scale was beutiful. 3 is equally delightful to play. Such a charming series.
What about Pikmin Adventure in Nintendo Land?
Never played. I've got nothing against the little guys, just haven't hung out with them. No option for that in the polls!
I’ve only played the Wii U Pikmin so that one.
Bingo Battle in Pikmin 3 for WiiU absolutely gave us many hours of fun battling against each other.
Did you say Bingo Battle should be online in Pikmin 3 Deluxe? Are you a mind reading pikmin? Run before I eat you.
@Broosh The Submerged Castle is not relaxing!
@nessisonett Fair, it certainly has tense bits like this! 😫
@mariomaster96 Should be close to release sometime before year 2030.
Pikmin 3 on Wii U was just fantastic, with the game pad contributing a lot to the multitasking. My only complaint is that it is rather short. I get quite upset when thinking about the series though, as it's been over 6 years since Miyamoto said Pikmin 4 was nearing completion...
I still haven't played a Pikmin game, but I just played the demo of 3 Deluxe on my Switch yesterday and it was super fun! I'm considering picking it up now.
Pikmin 2 is the best followed by Hey! Pikmin. Pikmin 3 never really clicked for me, and the original is the most unrelaxed of the series. 2 > Hey > 1 > 3
It seems that most voters have only played Pikmin 3 Deluxe. Pikmin 1 and 2 are better.
Pikmin 2 will always be the best for me. Taking away the constant dread timer and just letting you explore at your own pace is such a great feeling for the series. It's sad the game hasn't been re-released; I genuinely expected Nintendo to do a trilogy pack instead of just 3 on Switch, but maybe they'll surprise us one day.
Why bloat the list with ports?
Pikmin
Pikmin 2
Pikmin 3
Hey! Pikmin
How hard was that?
Discussing one's preferred version is what comments are for.
poor Pikmin fans since 2015 waiting for Pikmin 4 to release.
Pikmin 3. I loved every moment of the game and I just played through it again this past January, so it’s fresh. But honestly, all three mainline Pikmin games are 9/10, perhaps even 10/10 territory. They are simply delightful games and utterly unique and weird. They are “weird Nintendo” at its best. Pikmin is perhaps the most understated masterpiece series in Nintendo’s oeuvre.
I think the original pikmin on GameCube was the best, specifically on the first run. I had no idea what to expect or what strategy to use. Once I figured it out and I could just steamroll every area, the whole series got kinda boring for me. Like even pikmin 3 I just found myself doing the same exact thing, and it had been at least 15 years since playing the first one. Granted I played it on switch not Wii U, so maybe I missed out on what made the 3 captain system special
@Silly_G new play control and deluxe versions are very different experiences to be fair
@somnambulance Well said, few games can evoke such a unique & charming atmosphere. Total masterpieces and strangely underrated.
The only Pikmin game I have, 3 (Deluxe).
I kicked myself in the arse not purchasing the original on Gamecube when it was released. I was extremely interested in the series when I was younger but I never ended up picking it up.
Pikmin 3 Deluxe recently went on sale in Canada and I corrected that mistake. Haven’t had time to play it (beyond the first few levels in the demo). However, it was plays out better than I could imagine.
I love a tough Nintendo game and Pikmin definitely offers a unique challenge while also being adorable and accessible.
It's hard to make a choice. I love all of them
@Broosh What a great mimigame it is! It raise my interest in the Pikmin series!
I loved Pikmin 1 for the story and new setting. The original design of the onions was cute and clever, as was their ufo like design. The only thing I disliked was the strict 30-day time limit. Last time I played I got up to the last level with one day left and very few pikmin. I could not grab that last part for a 100% completion.
Just because Blue is my favorite color I have to say Blue Pikmin are my favorite, love those little guys.
I don't like Pikmin. Finally, a poll option for me!
Wii U 3's definitely my favourite. Some took issue with balancing the GamePad with the Wii Remote and nunchuck, but it made it feel like a much bigger experience for me, and the reliability of the Wii Remote's pointer was much more satisfying to work with. I did enjoy the additions to Deluxe, but I don't think it managed to fully replicate the core experience.
I really like the atmosphere of the original game. It feels the most alien of the series, and Olimar's diary entries at the end of each day really give the game a lot of heart. I think the design of 3 is the most exciting and satisfying to play though. The ability to reliably throw Pikmin at overhead targets really made the design come together for me, and the complexity of your squad's objectives each day was really fun to strategise around.
The poll is incomplete. It's missing Pikmin 4. We all know Pikmin 4 neared completion 6 years ago, so we've all played it and like it the best.
3 did a lot right, but it feels like an incomplete game that arbitrarily just stops immediately after you get your footing and abilities. If it kept going it could easily have been the best, but, instead, right when you hit your stride and look forward to getting into the meat of the game, it just....ends.
Vote for purple chonk pikmin
@Broosh A classic!
The magic of the very first original GC Pikmin combined with that magical controller. The launch period for GC is one of my most fun memories with gaming. Pikmin had me scrambling to buy this system and game as the ultimate killer app must-have for that time.
Pikmin 2 was frustrating but great.
Pikmin 3 I hated the gamepad use and feel... and I won't pay full price for a Switch port. I'll get it used way down the line sometime.
Pikmin 3 is probably objectively the best game, but the first one on the gamecube was the one I personally enjoyed the most.
Mean while, Puyo Puyo is 30 years old! What an underappricated series outside of Japan.
My only interactions with Pikmin are in Nintendo Land and Pikmin 3. I enjoyed Pikmin 3 quite a bit and the DLC.
All this red love is fascinating!!!!
I am team Yellow, but I am not surprised Rock is winning. I mean look at them
@andykara2003 For some reason, I feel like Pikmin just hasn’t hit that sales mark for some reason, which I’m not entirely sure why that is either. It’s a type of game that I feel casual gamers would like, so I can’t put my finger on where the disconnect is. Thinking about this is making me want to buy a Pikmin t-shirt or something.
I would love to replay Pikmin 1 again but alas I have no Gamecube and Nintendo refuse to re-release it on Switch. Same applies for Luigis Mansion, I love the sequels to both but the originals are my fave
@somnambulance Same goes, I guess, marketing wise, perhaps it just doesn’t have that broad in your face appeal that the general casual gaming masses are drawn to.
Pikmin is my favourite franchise of all time so every game are 10/10 masterpieces in my eyes but my (potentially controversial take is): Pikmin 1 > 3 Deluxe > 3 Wii U > Pikmin 2 (that game is still brilliant though!)
Having Pikmin 1 as my favourite probably comes across as a boomer take, especially since it's a 4 hour game that feels like a beta compared to both 2 & 3 which both expanded the franchise in so many ways but one thing that Pikmin 1 completely destroys both Pikmin 2 & 3 is conveying an excellent atmosphere where it feels like you're truly lost and alone in a weird, alien planet.
Pikmin 2 always felt way too upbeat and cheerful in my eyes (which narratively makes sense since Olimar is already aware of the dangers that await him and the end goal (for the first half at least) was nowhere near as serious or personal in comparison to his fight for survival in the 1st game) which kind of clashed with the 'alien' vibe of the game and Pikmin 3, while a lot more 'alien' and foreboding than Pikmin 2 still didn't feel quite as tense as Pikmin 1 did. What I'm trying to say is, Pikmin 1 is and will always be the one that has me the most invested whenever I play through the game and I always strive to 100% whenever I start a new playthrough (which is once every year).
Surprised though that Rock Pikmin ended up winning the most popular Pikmin type poll, I remember when Pikmin 3 was first announced they were fairly unpopular for how unconventional they were! (was expecting red or purple to win tbh)
My favourite type is blue simply because that's my favourite colour. My reasoning is that simple xD
Hey! Pikmin is the only one I've finished, and the 3 Deluxe is waiting on my shelf, I've done the demo for it. I'd say the 3DS game was quite relaxing and straightforward, I liked it for its simplicity and visuals.
Pikmin 2 is my favorite, so much content and the treasure hoard logs are fun to read. I didn't like Pikmin 3 that much but I still think it's better than 1 because of how glitch ridden it is. Hey! Pikmin was also really fun, really liked the level design in that one.
Blue pikmin are best! I just can't stand to see my pikmin drowning.
Still have only played 3 but I plan on picking up physical copies of 1 and 2 down the line. Hopefully 4 isn’t too far away…
Pikmin 2.
It is the biggest (30-40 hours to 100%)
Has no time-limits.
Best replayability (randomized dungeons).
@Jamie_R
I agree. Pikmin 3 on WiiU effectively used the GamePad very well.
To be more specific: Pikmin 3's Misson Mode, on the Wii U, is one of my top five video games of all time. Being able to move groups them around with the pad while controlling another on the screen, the complex strategy, the gorgeous look... An all-timer.
Not a fan of any of them. Own the game cube one hated micromanagement.
Pikmin 3 was an all time classic for me. Never played 1 or 2 I never was aware of the series until 3 on the Wii U.
I love all 3 Pikmin games but the 3rd is my favorite. I love the Switch version for the added content and difficulty. But my favorite way to play 3 is on the Wii U gamepad.
The tactile feel of tapping to throw Pikmin (and not even needing to look at the gamepad) was the only worthwhile satisfying use of the gamepad for any game, and I say that as a big fan of the Wii U who bought several dozen games.
3>1>2
I love the overworld of 2 but hate the caves. 1 is simple but really nice to replay.
Pikmin 4 is my favourite. Miyamoto loaned me the only dev copy a few years ago and said he'd release it when I was done. Now where did I put it.....?
Pikmin 3 (and by extension Deluxe, being the best version of 3) is easily my favorite, and one of my top 5 favorite video games of all time. It's an absolutely incredible experience with impeccable design and delight.
The original is also amazing though, and I love it's atmosphere. Some of the areas feel surreal in a unique way only Pikmin can capture. 2 is my least favorite mainly because I think the caves can be a slog at times, and it messes with the pacing of the game. I do enjoy some of the outside areas though, and I like the new Pikmin types introduced there. (Even if the new ones in 3 are better)
3 Deluxe is the absolute best, it made enough changes to perfect a good but flawed game.
I'm stunned at this poll and a lot of the comments, for me Pikmin 3 was a huge let down. It is so short and Nintendo skipped on one of the best things about Pikmin 2, the randomised dungeons. I remember replaying a lot of Pikmin 2 and getting plenty of playtime. With Pikmin 3 I was like, wait that can't be the end? Where's Google? There must be some kind of mistake.
Pikmin 3 was fun, but I still prefer 2 as my favorite. Kinda want to play 3 again with the Switch version, but...eh, I dunno. Too distracted with other games at the moment.
Also curious about Bloom because I lost interest in Pokemon Go a long time ago.
I like all 3, but 1 was perfect. I don’t like switching back and forth between characters.
@braincandy101 noooooo
They’re all my favourite
As a couple have pointed out Pikmin Adventure from Nintendo Land is not on the list.
That is my favourite because you could play up to 5 players at the same time. Not so much puzzle solving, but quick levels to beat. Me and my 2 daughters played that together all the time.
@braincandy101 more people voted "I don't like Pikmin" than they did for "Hey Pikmin"
Still curious about the 2 percent that voted for Hey pikmin though... are they joking they must be
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...