(DSiWare)

Game Review

Music On: Acoustic Guitar Review

USA USA Version

Posted by Bryan Griffin

Good guitar or bad lyre?

Music On: Acoustic Guitar is like Charlie Brown's Christmas tree – its beauty is in the eye of the beholder. If you know your way around a fret board, you may see it as a fun tool to mess with when you can't lug your giant six-string around with you. Gamers with no prior guitar knowledge, however, will see it as a useless, complicated enemy that stole their Nintendo Points. The Music On series has brought several musical instrument simulators to DSiWare that are above average but not excellent, and this entry mostly meets that standard.

The controls for the acoustic guitar are confusing, unlike the Music On versions of keyboards and pianos. And when you think about it, that makes sense, because a guitar is arguably much more complicated to play than a piano. Unfortunately, this is no excuse for the entire system feeling disjointed and awkward and lacking a lefty-flip option as well.

The bottom screen displays the strings, which sound louder depending on how fast you strum them. It's also home to three icons that allow you to set chords, choose accompaniment, and save your session. The top screen uses standard guitar tablature to show the frets and strings that should be pressed to play the selected chord on a real guitar.

The button mapping is where everything goes wrong. You can assign chords to each direction on the d-pad, making a total of eight available at any one time. Using the diagonals on the d-pad to hit a chord is a pain, and you'll encounter some problems with it when trying to play a song smoothly. The A, B, X and Y buttons are assigned to choosing four variations of the currently selected accompaniment. The right shoulder button activates a chord-lock function, so you won't have to hold the assigned direction on the d-pad down while playing a chord at length. It's a nice attempt at stopping the bleeding caused from selecting one with a diagonal, but doesn't completely remove the problem. The left shoulder button can be pressed to palm-mute all the strings at once. You can press Start to stop the currently playing accompaniment and Select to access the Help Menu.

Aside from slightly problematic controls, the selection of chords and accompaniments is great and allows you to play pretty much anything, providing it has less than eight chords. Some chords have up to six variations to choose from, giving you plenty of wiggle room to express your creativity and play around. Because each string vibrates louder depending on how fast you strum it, the game mimics the sound of a real guitar quite well. However, longer playing sessions may make your ears feel tired, like you've just listened to hours of electronic pop music instead of practising your acoustic instrument. The sounds don't resonate deeply enough to avoid feeling a bit robotic, and on an acoustic guitar this is a bit distressing. Stick with shorter sessions and play using headphones to make the most of the audio.

The five accompaniment styles are Pop-Rock, Soft-Rock, Country, Ballad, and Blues. With four variations of each accompaniment, you'll have plenty of inspiration to create your own songs or copy some classics. Each version of the Blues accompaniment is especially pleasant and really lends the game some soul. Because the game has a very bare-bones presentation to it, this is even more of a good thing. The graphics consist mostly of your guitar strings and the chord chart against a light blue background – they serve their purpose, but that's all.

It’s worth noting again that this is a straightforward guitar simulator with no tutorials or example songs, so you’ll need to already know several songs on a guitar to get the most out of it. The save feature will be useful if you plan on using it as a writing tool, but your creations will be trapped on your DSi. The lack of SD card support never ceases to disappoint.

Conclusion

All in all, Music On: Acoustic Guitar offers a good variety of chords and, unfortunately, a clumsy control scheme. If you enjoy playing your favourite songs to yourself wherever you go, this title may be for you. Ambitious players can always look up guitar tabs on the internet and practise to their heart's content. As long as you know what you’re getting into before you download it, and are able to play some songs or are willing to learn from an outside source, you’ll have fun.

More Stories

Game Trailer

User Comments (14)

TLink9

#1

TLink9 said:

Nothing so far can beat the experience of playing a guitar. Simple go buy one.

fishman100

#2

fishman100 said:

I remember when i took guitar lessons a few years ago. I quit solely because my hands were too small and the guitar shop didn't have anything smaller.

OldBoy

#3

OldBoy said:

Well I can play guitar for real so I've no interest in this really.Seems like a nice little app though.Nice review,though I'm not sure I agree that a guitar is more complicated than a piano! :O

Motorbass

#8

Motorbass said:

Well it is a much better guitar simulator than Jam Sessions (which has similar controls but only a few chords and no automatic accompaniment).

It is only 200 points. That is not bad for a lil toy guitar in your pocket. (I don't think "buy a real guitar"- comments are helpful in this case)

ErrorSupply

#10

ErrorSupply said:

Gets a solid 7/10 from me. Strumming virtual guitar strings is a far more visceral experience than poking one tiny key at a time, like on the keyboard app. The sensitivity to strum intensity and subtle touches like hearing fingers slide across the string ridges as you change frets put it over the top. I agree diagonal chords and no lefty support are issues (I would have traded the L button palm mute for being able to switch chord sets, lessening the diagonal issue), but for someone like me who loves music but lacks the drive to learn a real guitar, it's a fun little time waster.

lOnE-WolF

#11

lOnE-WolF said:

This is a cool app (though I want my 200 points back solely cause I always sucker myself into getting these types of DSiW though I don't use em), really nice for an instrument simulator. It's great when it comes to what it was designed to do.

Biggest problem: fails thanks to me being left-handed D:

B-ry

#12

B-ry said:

@Motorbass - I wouldn't say it's better than Jam Sessions, but they both do certain things better. Music On gives you the ability to play individual strings, many chords, and automatic accompaniment, but Jam Sessions has much better control options, mic support, and some licensed music to play with. I recently saw JS for 4.99 in a bargain bin, so either choice isn't bad

DemonnPrincess

#14

DemonnPrincess said:

I play guitar and record songs, and I'm sad when I can't take my baby with me on trips because it's like a part of me. T.T So this game is neat because I can play songs I've written and it sounds sometimes (though shamefully I must admit) better than when I play on my guitar.

Leave A Comment

Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...