Nintendo gave Pikmin fans a couple of lovely surprises during the June 2023 Nintendo Direct, prepping players for Pikmin 4's debut by stealth-dropping the original Pikmin and its wonderful sequel in HD remastered form. Exciting!
Yes, if you've played these two beauties before, you'll know they're among some of Nintendo's loveliest work, and digging into the 2001 original here reveals a game that's stood the test of time remarkably well. Pikmin 1 is still a joyous, playful, cute and colourful adventure to undertake and, although this HD remaster isn't quite up to the standards we'd expect from the Big N — and nowhere near the level of remaster we got with the recent Metroid Prime Remastered — it's still a must-play in our book, especially if you've yet to sample the delights of this GameCube classic.
Pikmin 1, as it's now officially designated with this Switch port, sees you assume the role of Captain Olimar (did you know 'Olimar' is close to 'Mario' backwards in Japanese? We bet you did), a rather unfortunate employee of the Hocotate Freight Company who crash-lands his ship, the SS Dolphin, on a strange planet inhabited by helpful little creatures. Olimar's ride has been well and truly torn apart by the impact of his accident and it's now up to you to find 30 pieces of the Dolphin that have been scattered around the landscape. Oh, and Olimar's life support will run out in 30 days, so yeah, you're on a time limit. No pressure!
Facing a truly dire situation, Olimar discovers that the local friendly wildlife, which he names Pikmin due to their resemblance to his home planet's Pikpik Carrots, will follow his commands, helpfully battering down barriers, retrieving parts of his ship, dispatching hostile creatures and so on. And so we embark on a delightful puzzle adventure that sees you juggle three different types of available Pikmin in order to save yourself from certain death.
You've got the fireproof Red variety who excel in combat, bomb rock-chucking Yellows who can float a little further when thrown and are resistant to electricity (although that hazard wasn't introduced until the sequel), and Blues who can survive in water. Of course, Pikmin are also very small and therefore very weak, so fighting off foes, lifting heavy objects, or battering down a wooden barrier requires a whole lot of them working together. Luckily for Olimar, they can very easily multiply and factoring in how many you've got and how to get more is all part of the fun.
As you progress through your allotted 30 days of in-game time, each one roughly 15 minutes long, you'll need to work relatively quickly to gather up all of the parts of the Dolphin, guiding your happy-go-lucky Pikmin through well-designed little pockets of puzzle action that are as fun to get to grips with now as they were 22 years ago. There's no need to get too stressed, that time limit is quite generous.
In terms of this HD port specifically, we're looking at a version of the game that's based on the Wii's 2009 New Play Control! release, which added motion controls alongside widescreen support and upgraded textures. On Switch, we get a further bump in resolution as well as the addition of updated controls that fall in line with those found in Pikmin 3. You can also choose to use motion controls if you so wish, and there are some little nips and tucks here, such as fast-pulling multiple Pikmin from the ground by holding in 'A' rather than repeatedly pressing it, and some reworked icons and renders here and there.
Is it going to knock your socks off in terms of presentation in the same way that Metroid Prime Remastered did? No, it is not, and this is a little disappointing given the not-insignificant price point for a game of this vintage. If it's not outright sloppy, it's certainly a little bare bones in places, with the likes of the UI having been upscaled rather than recreated. It's more Mario 3D All-Stars than Prime Remastered — perfectly serviceable, but you may expect more.
Overall, though, Pikmin 1 is such a great game that it's hard to knock, even with these minor complaints with regards to this particular port. What you've got here is a timeless slice of Nintendo at its most charming and inventive. The first Pikmin nailed its uniquely approachable RTS formula so hard that over two decades later — and even if we were playing sans any sort of upgrades whatsoever — it's impossible to blast through without a great big smile on your face. If these re-releases were designed to whet our appetites for Pikmin 4, consider us now well and truly starving.
Conclusion
Pikmin 1 remains a delightful puzzle adventure that sees Nintendo at its most charming and inventive. Yes, this Switch port is a little bit underwhelming, with just a higher resolution and some new controls to get excited about, but with a core game this good, it's still an experience that comes highly recommended. Over two decades on from its original release, Pikmin's unique brand of magic remains undiminished.
Comments 96
It's just an upscaled port of the GCN game. Not like Metroid Prime remastered that more or less got remade with new assets etc.
Pikmin-imum effort.
Well, the less changes, the better. Let's preserve the original state of the games.
It is neat that they're adding more GameCube games to the Switch library, even if they're the bare minimum in terms of improvements. I hope GameCube shadow drops in Directs are a continuous thing.
If only they would drop all their biggest Wii/Gamecube games like this. I would pay 30 bucks without hesitation for Mario Strikers Charged, Super Paper Mario, Smash Melee, Twilight Princess, etc.
I am definitely happy to see more GameCube games coming to Switch, but if Nintendo doesn't go all in on remastering these games like they did with Metroid Prime than they should lower the price of these ports a bit.
“Pikmin are still as cute and funny” ...that phrase is forever ruined to me after what I witnessed...
I bought the collection yesterday on impulse. I've only played a bit of Pikmin 1 and never played 2. But I am LOVING 1 so far, I'm already at the final area and only on day 23. But I had to dedicate an extra day to growing more Pikmin, as the final boss wiped out most of mine on the first attempt.
For that reason, the price is worth it for me. It's maybe a bit steep for 2 pretty old and short games, but this collection has officially gotten me invested in the series now.
@NiallMitch14 yes. I don’t know why people were expecting this big triumphant return of pikmin 1 and 2 remastered with these reworked visuals and everything rebuilt from the ground up like Prime. The games look and play perfectly fine today, and simply adding little small features and HD upscaling should be more than enough. Not every single HD port going forward has to be Metroid Prime (years of work by lots of extra studios by the way) levels in terms of a remaster. As for the pricing, hm. At least Nintendo sweetens the pot somewhat with their bundle deal for less money.
Ashamed to admit I've never played Pikmin 1 or 2, they never looked like they would appeal to me - but then I played the demo of Pikmin 3 on Wii U and absolutely loved it. I'm very glad to have a modern way to officially own and play these games and will be buying the physical version, for sure so I can have all 4 main games on the one system.
I think the combined price is ok, especially for the physical release. Separately though, from what I've read/heard Pikmin 1 should be cheaper, its a much, much shorter game than the sequel.
So, I’m guessing there are no new extras with these remasters?
If so, that’s a bit disappointing, but otherwise this seems decent enough. Nice that they added those Pikmin 3-esque controls, should make playing these games a bit more convenient.
@IceClimbersMain I'd pay full price for Thousand Year Door, for sure!
I'm glad it's based on the Wii NPC game actually. Loved those versions. The controls sound solid if they mimic what they did with the Pikmin 3 port. Frankly sounds like an decent if unspectacular port to me of a classic. I was kinda expecting this level of port anyway.
Cheers for the review.
I'll be picking up the physical release of Pikmin 1 and 2 in September. I'm excited to dive into the series.
These should have dropped onto the NSO service, but why would Nintendo give its fans something for free when they can overcharge for them and people lap it up.
"Nintendo, port your GameCube games to the switch!"
When they do...
"Nintendo, your GameCube ports are too expensive!"
I swear, no one is ever happy with anything anymore.
a tautology:
near-perfect games have little need for improvement 👍
@Bigmanfan
are these for sure the same people? im skeptical.
on the internet, we are always going to get every reaction, but its not hypocrisy if its not the same individuals. 🙂 lets just enjoy the games and buy em if it seems worth it!
I mean it’s either gonna be fast bundle ports like this aka quick Up-Res or it’s gonna be slower but more effort ones like MP1 where we don’t get MP2/MP3 at same time.
Both has its pros and cons, but it’s nice that all the relevant Pikmin games are on platform now.
I’ve yet to see anyone mention that they’re actually charging more for these games than the Wii U ports of new play control, even with the double pack discount applied.
@Munchlax
economy bro: "ten years of inflation, plus demand for switch games is an order of magnitude higher than wii u = higher price"
im not economy bro but that is what they'd say 😐 i havent decided personally if im gonna buy these games again, but id love to have pikmin 1 on my switch.
ATTENTION EVERYONE! This review forgot to mention that the crushing glitch, AKA the worst thing about the original version, was finally fixed in this port, ergo making it the best version of the game.
Considering they just dropped it this week with no warning, I assumed it would be bare-bones. Nothing wrong with that, though. Not every port needs to be a complete remake with tons of extras.
Somehow, I've managed to never play a Pikmin game all these 22 years. Now's the perfect time to change that.
I've never played this series. Maybe this is a good place to start? Looks just weird to me, but could be fun...
I appreciate the access to a game I've never played. Metroid Prime Remastered was a way for the developer to test their Prime 4 engine. It's not a bar to measure other ports against. It's unique.
I would have liked to see them update Pikmin 1 to make how the pikmin control less infuriating. I know to some it makes them seem more “real,” but to me it’s maddening to have your pikmin constantly, CONSTANTLY splitting off to do their own thing, tripping, randomly stopping for no reason at all, getting stuck under ramps and bridges, etc. It’s overly cutesy and ultimately does nothing but waste time and sanity.
@ComfyAko The correct take. Less is more. We need more ports that preserve the original as much as possible. Metroid Prime Remastered is stunning, but if rumours are true and the second and third games are more like these Pikmin releases, I'd rather they didn't bother with that makeover.
Getting back on topic I would love to get this because playing Pikmin 1-2 on the go sounds amazing.
I wish Nintendo will re-release Luigi’s Mansion 1 on Switch as a Gamecube remaster but it doesn’t look like it’s happening with the second game getting re-released.
@MythTgr sometimes increasing framerate for these older games causes issues. RE4 QTEs and aiming are more difficult, and Leon's hitbox is bigger on the 60fps versions as an example.
My only issue with these is having to wait for the physical. I’m actually tempted to double-dip!
This is Nintendo, if they’d changed textures they’d be charging full price.
price is a bit high but ill pick up physical cart with 1 and 2 on it
@FredsBodyDouble they're amazing games, go for it!
@Chaotic_Neutral …because people want to keep the game and not feel like they’re renting it?
@StarPoint Pikmin 2's story is actually at least 20 hours long, which is more than double the length of the first game. And that's not even getting into the Challenge Mode stages, which can get pretty, well, challenging, especially if you're going for 0 pikmin deaths in all of them to unlock the secret bonus cutscene.
I'm also waiting on the physical versions. Then I'll hunt a copy of Pikmin 3 Deluxe and eventually Pikmin 4. Hopefully Hey! Pikmin can also be ported. And yes, I'm serious about it.
Aa someone who hasn't played any Pikmin game, the only thing that's really disappointing for me is the absence of "Ai no Uta" here and "Tane no Uta" in Pikmin 2.
Zero effort, but hey… it’s Nintendo so we need to give this game at least an eight….
Woo! Can’t wait to play again! It’s been a while.
"Upgraded Textures" I'm honestly not convinced. Maybe partially upscaled?
I just compared the screenshots in the eShop listing to just spinning up my Gamecube (in 480p, of course) and aside from the screen resolution bump, grass/stumps/everything seems the same.
Don't let this discourage you from playing both if you haven't. They're excellent.
@SwagaliciousJohnson 25% percent cheaper than Prime isn’t an insignificant amount, with even a better discount if you bundle
Waiting to see if I can get these games physically at MSRP if not lower here in Italy, otherwise I'll go for digital, but absolutely getting them eventually!
By the way, personally I'll take "minimum effort" (and even then fixing the crushing glitch alone is quite the significant change as @Eggolor pointed out) if it means getting more GameCube/Wii games on Switch (and at a lower price as well, the bundle including both Pikmin 1 and 2 is just €10 more than Metroid Prime Remastered)!
Yeah definitely going to wait for a sale on the bundle. Think I’ll get it eventually after 4 comes out but I can’t see myself paying more than 30$ for both games.
Still unsure whether to start here with Pikmin 1 or Pikmin 3 Deluxe. Yesterday I was leaning heavily towards 3. But after reading this, maybe I go with the first one, you know, first.
People comparing these to the Metroid Prime Remaster need to recognize that if we demand that level of quality for every single GameCube port, we're going to see far fewer of them. I'd rather have a basic port like this and get far more of them than demand the highest level of remaster and get barely any.
I will buy the physical release day one. I will admit it is a little silly that these exact same ports were on Wii U for only $20 a piece, but whatever. They're some of my favorite games ever and I've already bought them multiple times on different systems. Getting to have them both for $50 on Switch is a no-brainer for me.
Is the GameCube controller fully functional with this version?
@Logicfire Just keep in mind that while all the games are similar, each one has a pretty distinct flavor to it. I love 1, 2, and 3 and hopefully you will too. But keep in mind that if you play one and don't especially like it, the feature you don't like might very well not be in a different game. I personally feel that 3 is probably the easiest jumping in point, but 1 is close. 2 is definitely the hardest.
Whenever you do play 3, I strongly recommend going for 100% completion as I feel that's the only way to fully appreciate the game. I've seen far too many people online who did the bare minimum to reach the end and then complained about the game being too short. If you don't collect everything, you'll miss out on the best puzzles & exploration.
Pikmin 1 is short even if you do go for all items, but man it's such a fun experience that I don't care about the length.
This game ruined my childhood. We got our Cube with Pikmin, Melee and Luigi’s Mansion not too long after they came out and I was young enough to barely understand the games but fully understand the absolute horrors of Pikmin death.
@sketchturner thanks for this. It’s very helpful!
Oh no, a hate/10!
Easily my favorite Pikmin game. It was very special on Gamecube, where I still play through it fairly often!
If you’ve never played Pikmin now is the perfect opportunity! These games are so much fun and enjoyable, I’m definitely loving the upgraded visuals of Pikmin 1 so far.
I love the idea of Pikmin, but nothing I've seen has ever made me want to jump on to the series, and I'm guessing by it's relatively poor sales others feel the same.
Now Tinykin 2 (which secretes Pikmin inspiration from its pores) I'd take that like yesterday.
I really love Pikmin but this price for a 22 year-old basic port... It could only be Nintendo doing so and having people defending it.
@IronMan30 "where's my Gamecube games Nintendo???!?!?!?!?!?!? I want them on NSO, but I would prefer to own them outright!!!! Not like this Nintendo!!!!?!?!?!?!??!" It's like when they prefer their mum to make the sammich rather than dad.
@SwagaliciousJohnson I mean, this game is $30 by itself while the prime remaster was $40, so they already have
@Greatluigi There's also the option where they add GC games to the service for those of us whomdont care about owning games and sell them separately for those that dont, like gamepass and PS+ extra does. That way everyone wins, but Nintendo are far to greedy to do that and prefer to constantly squeeze ever penny from its customer base.
Feel like Nintendo are shooting them selves in the foot by pricing these remasters so high. £25 for each individually is ridiculous, as is £40 for both (£35 for physical is just about right though considering the physical aspect). Especially daft considering Prime Remastered was only £10 more digitally than one of these ports and that was a full on remaster that surely cost far more to produce than these games.
Putting at impulse buy territory between £10 and £15 would have been ideal and could have hooked people in to then buy Pikmin 4 a month later while it’s hot.
This is just what looks like a 1:1 port in order to make money. They released it on Wii U and Wii, so it's not like it was gonna disappear and they didn't even allude to it being any kind of "remaster" or "HD Update", it's just the GCN game with Switch controls.
@HammerGalladeBro «Aa someone who hasn't played any Pikmin game, the only thing that's really disappointing for me is the absence of "Ai no Uta" here and "Tane no Uta" in Pikmin 2.»
NOOOOOO!!
@WiltonRoots and yet, here I am, having fun playing official GCN games on Switch. I'm a fool!
The worst thing about Nintendo this generation is their pricing. The only budget-friendly move they've made is the vouchers, which of course are only good for digital games. I can't believe we're this many years into the Switch without any kind of Nintendo Selects or Player's Choice line of titles.
@Nintendencies 8 million copies is "poor sales"? Tough crowd
@Corvus96
Compared to their other IPs...
I think this collection has similar vibes to the 3d All stars Mario collection. Don't get too bogged down with modernisation, just play them as they were originally intended. I mean, they were great games back then. Folk get to play them.
Meh. The Wii NPC version played well and looked good enough. I'm content to stick with that if I ever care to replay the game.
@IronMan30 In all fairness none of this affects me as my Gamecube is still plugged into the SCART socket of my TV and Pikmin is within arm’s length, but hey.
@Chaotic_Neutral then quit being one of their consumers. Way too many whiners on here whenever Nintendo announces something....
And NSO isn't free anyway. You're just paying a service fee. I'd much rather own my games
I don't mind these games just being straight ports.
I only ever rented Pikmin 1 back in the day and never played 2. Just happy to have all Pikmin games on Switch.
...As others have said, these are just HD ports, nothing more, remakes would've been nice, but I'm fine with just the originals. (even if some of the treasures in the second game were changed due to various reasons, RIP Duracell battery, lol)
I played a little bit of Pikmin 1 on the Gamecube, and plenty of Pikmin 3 on Wii U, never played 2 at all, so these ports are very welcome considering how expensive a used copy of Pikmin 2 is now, and just the convenience of playing these games on the Switch. I've been playing Pikmin 1 the last couple days and absolutely loving it.
I personally don’t really care that they didn’t add anything, Im just happy I get to play them now.
Whether they're complete remakes, simple ports, or just being added to NSO, I'd love to see more GCN games on Switch one way or the other. People pine for F-Zero GX and Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door but I would love to see others like Wario World, Star Fox Adventures, and the first Luigi's Mansion.
I'm going to make another attempt at the Pikmin series eventually but I think I'd be better off starting with 3 or 4 than 1. I don't like the time limit idea. I think I should play another installment before trying this one so I can have a bit more experience.
In my opinion, the complaints about it not being on par with Metroid Prime are nonsensical. You cannot compare it with a project that was under development for years. Nintendo does not exactly have a million studios to work on every single remaster to the same extent, they have to prioritize certain project. You would never get a full on Pikmin with from the ground up visuals right now. It's either this, or nothing. If you prefer nothing, you are selfish, because for most people this is the most accessible way to play two great games.
Being pretty by-the-numbers remasters without much pizzazz like Metroid Prime is undoubtedly a shame, but I basically see these as serviceable ways to play 2 Nintendo classics on modern hardware (particularly one you can take on the go), in addition to being able to experience every mainline entry on a single system, which is genuinely a fantastic proposition. And with the price they're offering for these (with the bundle only being €10 more expensive than the singular MPR)? It's more than a fair trade off imo, will definitely be grabbing these once I get through my current backlog 🌺
@Clammy Metroid Prime Remastered change texture and it isn't full price.
@SuperWarioWorld While true, I can see why they won't do it anymore. Nintendo usually dropped prices for their games when their consoles are not doing very well. The Switch is still doing very well.
These games aren't remasters, they are ports.
You have these options:
Emulation: new system emulates old hardware to run older games.
Ports: no changes, but modified to run on the new system.
Remaster: small changes, to make the game look good on the new system. (Metroid Prime Remaster)
Remake: original game remade using new tech. (Super Mario RPG, Pokémon BDSP, LoZ Link's Awakening)
Reboot / full remake: original game remade using new controls and tech (Final Fantasy 7 Remake)
These are ports.
@Serpenterror The price of the Switch actually has dropped a decent amount, because of the inflation and the price stayed the same. Both Microsoft/XBOX and Sony/Playstation have increaded their prices or are going to.
I grabbed it. Going to start day 5 later tonight. It's a little quirky and stressful, but I'll keep at it.
Can't we just call it Pikmin? It's putting me off as I'm trying to play Super Mario World 1.
Nintendo can shove it with this one, 40 bucks here in aus!
I'd pay 25$ for any straight port from GameCube library any day, it doesn't matter how "barebones" it feels. Just give me the original game.
@Chaotic_Neutral A basic lineup consisting of 10 games would take roughly 15GB of storage space. It's too demanding for a system with only 32GB + MicroSD cards.
I missed this back in the day, and all I needed to make sure of was that the port wasn't so bad that it made the game unplayable. I didn't really expect that from Nintendo, more knee jerk reaction from how many times I've purchased a "they won't mess up one of their main games" item at release just to remember why I never do preorders.
Now that I can confirm that's not the case here; it's next on my to-buy list.*
*Unless I decide on Pikmin 2 first.
@StarPoint Pikmin 2 isn't short in the slightest. It tales around 12 to 30hrs to beat that game depending on how much you want to do.
I still have pikmin 2 on the gc, but having this just on my switch just to play a day is great.. perfect for digital download..
And having a filder with pikmin 1 to 4 will look 🥰 lovely
Btw. Pikmin 1 now has a higher resolution than pikmin 3
@Dev9417 If you want a more stress-free game as your first Pikmin one then yeah, I'd definitely recommend 3 because 1 has the time limit while 2 is the most difficult one especially because of the caves. 4 could also be a good starting point as I don't expect it to be as difficult as 2, but it does take elements from it so 3 is a safer bet in that sense.
That said, to get the most enjoyment out of the series you'd have to play them in order as there are recurring characters etc. so keep that in mind!
I have Pikmin 3 & Pikmin 1 on Wii U, but just couldn't get into either one. I played through several game days on Pikmin 3, but not too much on the first one. I didn't like using the wiimote & then having to look at the GamePad for the map. It just felt like too much of a chore to me.
I'm just happy, that I'll be able to have all the Pikmin games, on my Nintendo Switch.
Removed - trolling/baiting
An utter rip off. Not sure the prices of these games can be justified.
So this has been treated similarly to Mario Sunshine?
@-wc- Inflation takes around 35 years for prices to double. It's been less than 16 years since the Wii ports launched.
@LordPieFace
that may be true (though it seems to be an oversimplification, since rates actually fluctuate over time and we have recently historically high levels, worldwide,) but who said anything about doubling? 🤔 im lost.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...