Pokémon Gold and Silver are the second generation instalments in the Pokémon series; released at the turn of the millennium, the games arrived just a few short years after their predecessors, Pokémon Red and Blue. Boasting a whole new world to explore, 100 new monsters (bringing the total to 251), and an entirely new cast of characters, the sequels weren't a simple continuation of the originals’ plot, but a chance to build upon what was already becoming a gaming phenomenon. 17 years later the games have been released again, this time on the 3DS Virtual Console; they are just as wonderful as ever.
These games were released at a time when Pokémon was arguably simpler to understand; concepts such as Mega Evolution, variations on a Pokémon’s form, and of course the colossal amount of creatures we have available for capture today, did not exist. Instead, what you have is a stripped-to-its-basics version of the feature-rich games we have grown used to. You begin by receiving your very first Pokémon and starting an adventure across the Johto region, battling other Pokémon and their trainers, gaining experience, catching new monsters to add to your team, and eventually taking on Gym Leaders and the Elite Four to become a Pokémon Master. Along the way you’ll have to foil the plans of the evil Team Rocket, hold off your rival and defeat him in battle, and try to catch every single Pokémon to complete your Pokédex. Quite a lot to do, then!
The differences between these re-release on Virtual Console and the games they are effectively emulating are relatively limited. Aside from a couple of minor tweaks to a selection of attack animations, the only real difference is the trading element of the games. The original Game Boy Color utilised the Game Link Cable (a cable that could connect two Game Boys so that they could communicate) to battle or transfer your Pokémon with a friend. As this is unnecessary with today’s technology, these games activate a separate Virtual Console feature to wirelessly connect to another system nearby. Local wireless is the only type of communication supported meaning that, unlike the newer Pokémon games, you cannot connect to other players online. In one way this is a slight shame, but it does mean that the games remain faithful to the experience you had when playing them 17 years ago. Meeting up with a friend to share version-exclusive Pokémon can be just as exciting as it always was.
The games have aged fantastically well, too. The graphics can admittedly feel quite dated, although you could argue that the core series Pokémon games are never particularly impressive graphically. This doesn’t matter, though; the gameplay is just as fun, just as addictive, and just as rewarding as it ever was.
Whilst nostalgia alone will be enough for fans of the originals, Pokémon Gold and Silver offer an extremely rich RPG experience that deserves to be played. The only thing we can really fault in terms of how the games stand up today is the lack of the Running Shoes. These are an item that was introduced in the third 'generation' entries to the series, Pokémon Ruby and Sapphire, which allowed your character to run by holding down the ‘B’ button as you moved. Without it, walking around from town to town can feel extremely sluggish until you gain the ability to fly between destinations later on. Players who experienced the original games may be unfazed by this, but those who are used to how the series performs today might find it slightly frustrating.
Many fans regard Pokémon Gold and Silver as the best that the series has ever produced, and it’s rather clear to see why. These games expanded upon the originals in a number of ways; the in-game clock, for example, meant that different Pokémon would appear during different times of the day, reflecting your real-life surroundings. A mobile phone system was also implemented which allowed you to face trainers you had already battled before by accepting their challenges.
On top of this there were new Poké Ball types, new Pokémon types, Pokémon breeding and eggs, the option for Pokémon to hold items for use in battle, and many more features that we simply don’t have room for here. It also boasts a unique feature that has never been replicated in the series ever since – after seeing everything there is to see in the new Johto region you are able to revisit the Kanto region from Pokémon Red and Blue, taking on a second set of eight Gym Leaders and adding countless hours onto your playtime. Wonderful stuff.
Conclusion
Pokémon Gold and Silver have always been a highlight in the Pokémon series and even now, 17 years since they were originally released, they remain a truly brilliant experience. Fans of the originals will be pleased to see how faithfully the games have been emulated and newcomers should find enjoyment in playing through what is perhaps the best value-for-money game the series has to offer. The games feel just as good as they did all those years ago and, based on the pure gameplay, would be receiving praise from critics even if they were being released today. Flip that hat around, let out your signature catchphrase, and grab yourself a copy of one of the finest RPGs around.
Comments (81)
Hoping these will eventually make their way to the Switch in some form. I gave my 3DS away.
@JTMnM likewise.
These were my jam nearly twenty years ago, but HGSS really make them irrelevant. But it's nice to play a GameBoy Pokémon where the Pokémon don't look horrific like in Red and Blue.
As some one who's only played HGSS(as far as gen 2 goes), definitely a purchase from me.
Such a spectacular game when it was released and still just as fun today. 10/10 from me.
Starfox 2 and Pokemon Gold and Silver reviews in the same day. It feels like the 90's here at Nintendo Life.
Inb4 "the score is too high!!11"
Seriously though, great review and I pretty much agree. HeartGold and SoulSilver are IMO, better games overall, but the originals still hold up very well. Currently, I'm playing through Silver( had Gold as a kid) and I'm loving the classic music and sprites.
One of my favourite games, and I still am enjoying it just as much today
@thesilverbrick Ditto. (I'm so sorry.) I still find Crystal's sprite animations the most appealing of the sprite era.
@thesilverbrick They're very different games, at least when it comes to the metagame. So that in itself can't make these games irrelevant because HGSS were everything but a 1-to-1 remake.
I played the hell out of the Gen 1 games, but I unfortunately passed on Gen 2 at the time. I've played HeartGold, but I'm excited to give the originals a try.
I picked up Silver, and my aim is to only use Gen 2 Pokemon--my current party is Bayleef, Flaafy, Hoothoot, and Wooper, and I'll be adding and replacing them as I find more. I think the party I'm aiming for is Meganium, Houndoom, Heracross, Lanturn, Skarmory, and Donphan. I'd probably try to use Tyranitar, but it seems like Larvitar is only available in the endgame.
@Octane Of course they're different, but there really isn't any way the originals are superior. HGSS arguably did everything better.
I started with Blue version but never got a game boy color so I didn't play pokémon again until HeartGold. This is my first experience with the original version of the gen 2 games and I gotta say, the game holds up much better than the originals having now played both (altho I'm still working my way thru it slowly I've only just reached Ecruteak). 10/10 from me. Not sure what more one could want out of these.
The pinnacle of the series. Hopefully the Switch game can surpass these heights!
9/10 say whaaaat. If ever a game/s was 10/10, this is it.
Crystal is 11/10. 😁
@foodmetaphors
You may want to be sitting down for this news. Gold and Silver both work on the Game Boy.
Unlike the Gen 1 Pokemon games I feel these ones are still perfectly solid games to play even without nostalgic attachment.
In my opinion this is still the highest point the series has ever reached.
Great write up. Need to finish Green before I go kick off another VC Pokémon adventure, but I'm looking forward to diving into Johto again (this would work better if Dive was actually an HM in G/S).
Perhaps Crystal will have released by the time I've cleared my backlog. Or perhaps the world will have ended.
Anyway G/S were some of my favourite games of all time, so I hope I get the change to play them one more time before the apocalypse arrives.
I hope all these Pokémon games come to Switch! 🙏🏽
@Fandabidozi
They only work on Gameboy Color, which @foodmetaphors says he never got.
@Fandabidozi must be two gold and silvers
edit: upon researching, you are correct only crystal couldnt be played on gb. mind blown
@Onion
You may want to sit down...
It seems there was a major flaw with the advertising of these two games. How many Pokemon fans were lost due to not being able to unnecessarily wangle a new GBC from their parents.
@Onion Gold and Silver both worked on the original Gameboy and the Color but were enhanced on the GBC. Crystal is the one that was only playable on the GBC. If you look at the cartridges, you'll see that the G/S carts have the notch in the top corner and Crystal doesn't. That notch was removed from all Color only games to prevent users trying to jam it into an original Gameboy. Much like how 3DS carts have a protruding edge to stop people trying to put it in an original DS.
Pokemon Golden and Silver were not only the best Pokemon games but one of the best Gameboy games of all time, next to Super Mario Land 2 six golden coins!
@Onion yeah, about that... as a few have stated, G&S played fine on GB, they were optimized for GBC but that just was for the sprite colors, the full game itself worked fine on GB.
better than sun and moon.
don't kill me people!!!
xD
@RyanCraddock The subtitle should have been "The Gold (and Silver) Standard"
This was definitely the highlight of all Pokémon games. Definitely one of my favorites. Although I played the heck out of this, I don't think I could ever backtrack on any Pokémon game. I feel that Pokémon is one of those series where you play it, enjoy it, and never look back due to the constant new content, mechanics, and Pokémon that are introduced in each iteration. Definitely will buy it to support the virtual release and get my celebi for Sun & Moon ultra tho.
@foodmetaphors sucks you missed out on one of the best gens due to a misunderstanding, I definitely played Silver version on my original GB. Not all games with "Game Boy Color" on the box required the newer hardware, many were just optimized for it. I don't recall if it noted that anywhere on the back of the box, may have required some research into each game.
One of my favourite games ever. I couldn't even finished HGSS but i still got them on my DS so i don't know if i will purchase this
@kotag when you're right you're right. G&S was the only gen to feature two regions in one game and it didn't hold your hand like S&M does. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed S&M, but dang let me explore a bit!
@ShadJV
Totally, I was a fair bit older than the average Pokemon player at the time so I was probably a bit more clued in. I bought my GBC to play Crystal, having already completed Gold and Silver on the Game Boy. Still have them and the boxes and instructions. The batteries finally gave up the ghost last year tho.
After playing Yellow on VC and now Silver... yeah, gen one held up horribly over time, it's a glitchy unbalanced mess (nostalgia left that out, had to replay it to learn that), but gen two fixed a lot, I'm rather enjoying it. Though after hatching my Togepi was disappointed to discover Togetic hardly learns any decent moves ever in gen 2. I didn't remember that, so I guess I'm not using that little guy.
Well, after trying out Pokemon Gold in both my GB and Super GB I can confirm it DOES actually work. When I say Gameboy, I mean the old brick model too, not the Pocket. So it does indeed work on an old Gameboy. I also checked the back of the box for Gold and it even says plainly it works for both Gameboy and Color.
EDIT: Just for the heck of it, I tried in the Pocket model too, and it works.
@Fandabidozi Let's see, this was year 2000? I was 11. But given my dad was an IT specialist I was a very tech savvy 11, so I knew how to look this stuff online (and actually was already playing a Japanese ROM with some English patched in before we even got it in the West, I was 11 so I wasn't necessarily the best moral compass but at least I purchased Silver when it came here anyways). I can only assume based on my blurry memory from that long ago that I must have known about the compatibility long before the game came out. Then again, I was also on those ugly late 90s websites with rumors like how to catch Yoshi in Red/Blue or the Pokegods. XD
@Onion thanks for the info on the box, I've no idea where mine is so I couldn't dig the box out to see if it was on the back. At least that means they weren't blunt about whether it worked on the original GB and didn't rely on people researching that on the dinosaur internet from back then!
@ShadJV
People complain about the state of the internet now but 90's internet was some scary stuff. 😱
@ShadJV
No problem! I'm a collector, so I own original carts/box for a lot of games and keep them organized where I can access them quickly. It definitely says Gameboy and Gameboy color, at least on my US copy. How this misconception got started, I've no clue but quick research shows that most fans definitely thought this was a Color exclusive. @foodmetaphors is not alone in mistakingly assuming it wouldn't work. Kinda sucks that people missed out G/S because of that error...
In the US, most Color games that are Color exclusive have transparent cases and the boxes read "only on Gameboy Color". Pokemon G/S must have fell through the cracks somehow.
@Fandabidozi pretty much. Occasionally I stumble upon a relic of the old net, a webpage that hasn't been updated since the 90s. It's like stepping into a time machine where every image burns your eyes. Ah the days of my youth...
@Onion All it took was reading the box. I mean it was a bit misleading to print "Game Boy Color" in big letters on the front... but given how high G&S sales were, I imagine the people that misunderstood are a vocal minority. Which still sucks, I argue this is the best gen.
Great to have a version of these games without the worry of the battery running out in just 6 years.
@ShadJV
Right. Looking at the front of the box alone, you could be mislead into believing it's a GBC game. Looking at the different boxes I own, the fronts all say "Gameboy Color" regardless of whether they work on a regular GB or not and I couldn't discern any differences on the fronts of multiple boxes. Only upon flipping them over and looking on the back do you see what systems they support. GBC only games say "Only for GBC", while some later ones say "Gameboy Advance" next to it to show it'll work on that too.
I guess no one bothered to check on the back (Including myself) to see what it supports. There's also the fact some stores (In the US at least) won't let you actually touch the game boxes on display, which means you couldn't flip them over even if you wanted to!
HGSS is better though. Not really nostalgic for Gold and Silver.
@Onion I won't argue, it was a poor design choice. I still don't think "most" fans were misled, as anyone that really was into the series likely followed the news on it (through early game sites or magazines) but there definitely were some and that sucks, Nintendo can hold some of the game (as the box art format was their choice).
My favorite in the series for sure. Maybe Crystal will make its way to 3DS as well.
They just don't make em like they used to. that being said I was a fan of Crystal
I was so happy to discover they didn't fix the saving glitch. All three starters in 20 minutes for the win. Cloning Masterballs for Ho-Oh and Lugia is still a thing too.
Even with the remakes, as @thesilverbrick duly noted... I still have a soft spot for the originals. It might be for that je-ne-sais-quoi, it might be because of dem cloning glitches, you name it. But... it's Johto. You can't really say no to Johto, man.
-Sounds just as boring as it was on my first play through....
@AlexSora89 they aged better than gen 1, I'll tell you that. And I mean HG&SS were amazing (because Johto was a well put together region) but I definitely don't regret playing through the originals again.
@AlexSora89 The originals are definitely still fun games and all, but if you've got HeartGold or SoulSilver, they are definitely a better way to experience Johto, and on the same console, too.
HG/SS are still superior to the original Gen 2 games, but these are still beyond worth playing.
While it deserves its 9/10 score based on being GBC games, there's still no point in playing these games if you can play HeartGold/SoulSilver instead. With those games you get better graphics, running shoes, Abilities and Natures, attack specific physical/special split, new evolutions, and some of the special Pokéballs no longer include major bugs (unless of course you use them to catch something like a Heracross).
HG/SS are excellent, but they aren't the same as the Gen 2 games. Gen 2 maintained some of the weirdness of Gen 1, especially in terms of how they applied stats (all Dark moves are Special, FTW!), and the EV system is the old variant where you were able to max EVs in all stats just by playing. I'm a huge fan of Heart Gold, don't get me wrong, but writing off the source material because it's older would be missing out on some classic game play.
Never played gold or silver but I did own crystal and I loved that game. Nintendo release crystal too asap, it only makes sense because you released pokemon yellow.
@Octorok385
Agreed 100%. I wish people would stop harping about HGSS. While I own both the originals and remakes, I think the point here is experiencing the original games. The remakes are better, but some people may want to experience the game the way they originally experienced it. The remakes are fantastic but there's merit to playing the originals.
Not to mention that the balance is completely different between the two and sometimes it's nice to go back to the simpler GSC era. No worrying about my Cyndaquil getting a nature I want, just boot up and play! Also GSC had some fun glitches you can't do on the remakes.
I will buy these in honor of Satoru Iwata, it's because of that man who made these games possible, Heart Gold and Soul Silver are nothing compare to these. To me the original Gold and Silver were made with the most attention to detail, fresh introduction to the region of Johto and a fresh new start to catch em all as well as introducing a gate to return back to the beginning. It's if the player move away on a journey of discovery and somehow later had the privilege to return home again. That's the real Gold and Silver, Heart Gold and Soul Silver had nothing of that cause those are just cash-cows, nothing more.
You mention the lack of running shoes, but failed to mention that the player gets access to a bicycle that can help speed up travel quite a lot. Glad to finally see these on VC - Silver (and SoulSilver) are by far my favorite Pokemon games!
While HG/SS are an improvement on these games, sure, but let me stop there.
There's nothing, nothing ever, that will compare to being 14 years old, crossing that lake east of the starting town and being told "You've taken the first step into Kanto, check your pokegear map and see!", pulling up that map and seeing the familiar gen 1 map staring back at you. Holy cow, it was chills all the way down.
These games are some of the best ever, with the only flaw being the difficulty in grinding towards the end-game superboss. And Zubat's continued existence, but mostly that first thing.
I own HGSS (they're the only post-gen 2 games I own for myself and not to help younger family members fill out their pokedexes) but I bought the VC for myself just to experience it again. And overlevel myself to take out that stupid godforsaken cow in the third gym.
Gen 2 is the best there ever was. The remakes are the gold standard for how to remake beloved games, but the originals are still worth playing too. I for one am a sucker for the sprite work in these, and thought it was neat how both versions had different Pokemon sprites. Not having to worry about natures and EV distributions is also very nice.
@ShadJV You mean like the Space Jam website and this lil gem right here to promote The Lost World: Jurassic Park?
http://www.lost-world.com/ingen/index.html
Talk about a fossi...erm, time capsule! :V
@alpha5099 That's how I was essentially. I watched the anime since the beginning until the beginning of the 4th gen and I somehow skipped over the Gen II games til some years later...after playing both Gen I and Gen III while they were airing. It's still beyond me considering I've since played through Crystal.
These (including Crystal) are my favourite games of all-time. I wrote about it a few years back here:
https://www.nintendolife.com/news/2015/11/feature_why_were_still_playing_pokemon_gold_silver_crystal
Pokemon G/S/C is one of those special games I will never be tired of (along titles like Sonic Adventure, Grandia II, Crash Bandicoot 3, Ultima VII, Little Big Adventure 2 and such).
I finished it numerous times, yet I have absolutely no problems starting my adventure again. Truly an amazing addition to my 3DS library.
The best Pokémon game in the series. Being able to go back to Johoto was a blast (thanks Iwata for making that happen with your compression magic!)
I'm somebody who, because of the latest Gens, cannot play certain Pokemon games anymore without being frustrated. These Gens are 4 and 5. I tried to play HGSS but I couldn't get into it. Gen 1-3 are still fine becuase they're old and primitive enough that it feels different enough. This is why I'm so happy that I can play Gold again (without spending £40+ getting a GBC and a game with a new battery) because this is my favourite Pokemon game and I'm so happy to play it for the first time in 15-17 years.
@Trikeboy Although I feel with cloning and blue ditto glitch, as well as pokemon bank we'll be bale to spam boxes of shinies across Gen 7. Might dilute it a little bit.
@foodmetaphors gold and silver are compatible with the game boy. Sorry to crush your dreams
Excellent games, overall. It just happens to be much easier than I remember. Trainers that gave me trouble before don't seem to stand much of a chance, anymore. There are pokemon choices that definitely give the advantage to players that know about them. Abra with the three elemental punches, anyone?
@thesilverbrick
Well, yeah. However the VC version of Gold has the unexpected upside of being a digital copy, while I have to pop in the SoulSilver cartridge in order to play with GIV Johto. Which makes them equally enjoyable to me. Additionally, the VC rerelease marks the unprecedented scenario of Pokémon from all generations being able to reach the Alolan shores.
@ShadJV
Undoubtedly so. I'm also enjoying Yellow for complementary reasons, also because aging allowed me to enjoy the games with a lot more wisdom. I'm doing a "glitch run" in Yellow, as the Mew glitch can be exploited to obtain a lot more Pokémon in a surprisingly safe way (as long as I don't save whenever Missingno pops up), whereas now I know how to clone Pokémon in Gold without resorting to trading. It's serving me well so far. Combine that with my girlfriend having Yellow and Silver and you get the picture for what I'm aiming for.
@RaizenPrime
Which kind of completes the point I made in my previous comments. The Elemental Punch TMs (TM) are to me one of the greatest missing pieces in following Pokémon games and the VC rerelease being compatible with the Pokémon Bank is going to rectify that.
@JTMnM I hope so, I still have my N3DS and still play it regularly, but I’d love to see the old Pokemon games on Switch. I’m really enjoying playing Gold again, I just wish I have someone to trade with to evolve certain Pokemon. I’m hoping my Bro will get Silver soon so I can do that.
I'm probably going to wait a while and see if they end up releasing Crystal and get that instead.
I had Gold and then Soul Silver, so I think it makes sense to pick up Crystal if it becomes available. Plus....I got Yellow a few months ago and haven't finished it yet.
Meh, can't really agree that these games haven't aged. Both 1st and 2nd gen have aged pretty poorly due to issues with Pokemon variety, region design, barebones plot, and content. The two region system is also great at first until you see the effects it has on the leveling and the difficulty, the Johto trainers are all too low, the Kanto trainers are all about the same level, and Red is astronomically high. Honestly, if I wanted to replay these games I'd go for HGSS which has much more content but in general 3rd and 4th is where it's at. Those games are the only ones in the series (and BW2 to a lesser degree) that feel like polished, well rounded experiences. Let me know when we see remakes and VC re-releases of those games (not named ORAS, as ORAS suffers from the mobilitis that plagues the modern Pokemon games and isn't quite as polished as it should be now) and then we'll talk.
I loved these games as a kid. But beyond the Nostalgia factor I don't see a reason to play this over the remakes that you can play on the SAME DEVICE. HG/SS are, almost entirely, strictly better. The nostalgia factor is huge, even for me, and I did download Gold. But almost out of reflex. And mostly my hope is that good sales of VC titles might encourage Nintendo to get the Switch VC going.
@Dizzard
I should have done so, too, but I'm a sucker for Johto and honestly all the progress I make in Gold will be beneficial when Crystal eventually comes out (playing a game the hard way and going "new game plus" on a same-gen Pokémon game is a shenanigan I love to pull off), but if it doesn't, it will still be beneficial to the newer games thanks to elemental punches, clone Mewtwos, and whatnot. In fact, a cloned Mewtwo will prove useful in GTS, if anything.
@JTMnM Too true, For me, my 3DS blew out its speakers so it's worse. I mean I "could" buy it but that means headphones and the like, but I have this full functioning Switch, just sitting there.
Your score is too low.
This game is just too good.
The scale and ambition of G/S has always astounded me, such wonderful games!
As marvellous as these games are, the existence of Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver, which also work on 3DS, make it very hard for me to warrant a purchase of this game.
Have been playing Virtual console games on my 3ds for sometime, it's only now that I noticed that if you play in pixel - perfect mode (with Gameboy border), the screen seems lightly recessed (as would have been on the original Gameboy). Nice 3d effect on the 3ds...
Tap here to load 81 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...