Update: Since this review went live it has been brought to our attention that the tech inside the SFANS is actually taken from a Chinese-made dongle intended for Samsung smartphones. This in no way changes our opinion of the SFANS Adapter.
Original Story: The portability concept of the Switch is something which needs no explanation; even your average person on the street can see that taking your game with you on the road - and then docking it when you eventually return home - is quite a neat trick. The stumbling block in this vision of mobile bliss is arguably the dock itself; it's not the most portable piece of kit, and to make matters worse Nintendo has slapped quite a steep price tag on it.
For this reason, people are already on the look-out for cheaper and more portable dock alternatives from third-parties. Nyko has a promising contender on the horizon and we've seen fans take fate into their own hands by customising their existing docks to make them more upwardly mobile, but the first example we've managed to get our hands on is the SFANS Adapter, a pocket-sized device which is more like a dongle than a dock but could be the ultimate option for Switch owners who value mobility over all else.
The SFANS connects to your Switch's USB Type-C port and essentially gives you all of the functionality of a docked system, and a bit more besides. There's a HDMI port for audiovisual output and a USB Type-C power connection to supply the juice. Despite the small size of the unit the manufactuer has managed to include two full-size USB ports and two additional USB Type-C ports, all of which can be used to charge other devices, like Pro Controllers and Joy-Cons in the premium Joy-Con Grip.
Once it's all connected the SFANS performs perfectly - the Switch acts as if it's docked and powers down its display, offering improved performance in many games. The key issue is how you then position the console when it's being used in this manner; laying it down flat on a table could potentially cause heat to build up on the back of the unit, while flipping it over runs the risk of scratching the display (although some Switch users will point out that the official dock does a good job of doing this regardless). Thankfully, the guys behind SFANS supplied us with a third-party play-and-charge stand which alleviated this irksome issue.
If SFANS takes your fancy then you may well be reaching for your credit card as you read this, but it's not available in any stores. It's currently on crowdfunding site Indiegogo, starting at $59.99 for the "early bird" special which only includes the SFANS. For $79.99 you can pick up the SFANS, AC adapter, HDMI cable play and charge stand. At the time of writing the campaign sits at $1,557 of a $10,000 goal, with around a month left on the clock. Should the campaign be successful, units will begin arriving with backers in August - but the team behind the unit have told us that even if the campaign fails, they will seek to begin production regardless.
What makes this campaign unique is that the individuals behind it have already proven that SFANS works - hence the fact that we've been able to bring you this review; we've got the unit right here, right now. Is it worth $60 though? That's a question you'll have to answer yourself. For us, it's going to be a real lifesaver as we've already had a few occasions where we've taken our Switch to the homes of friends without the bulky dock and been forced to huddle around the console's screen when we could have been gaming on the television, had we been in possession of an SFANS Adapter.
You could argue that unplugging the dock takes seconds to do and would save you having to spend $60 (or $80 for the full package), but if you're anything like us your Switch dock and its associated cables will already be firmly entangled in the jungle of wires which lurk behind your TV set, and freeing them isn't something we relish doing on a regular basis.
In that regard, we can see the SFANS becoming an essential item in our Switch arsenal, but there are other uses. The Switch dock doesn't fit effortlessly into every AV setup due to the fact that you need space above it to lift and insert the console, so the SFANS could be the solution you're looking for if space is at a premium around your TV. It's also ideal as a second dock in the house connected to a smaller TV in a bedroom or the like – another environment where it might not be feasible to use the bulky, full-size dock. If you're in the market for another dock and can see the benefit of having a smaller, more portable alternative at hand, then we can't see any reason not to recommend this device - although those of you who simply want a smaller version of the existing dock might be better off waiting for other options.
Does this product take your fancy? Let us know if you've pledged to support SFANS by posting a comment below.
[source indiegogo.com]
Comments 82
NYKO's portable option on the way looks like the best bet at $45 and it comes with a charger and HDMI cable. The same functionality as the official dock but half the price.
Products like this in the article, even as a Kickstarter managing to be cheaper than the official dock, shows it up for what it is. An oversized expensive plastic brick, that has its own problems. It's not a very good design but Nintendo wanted to hammer home the point that you can't look at the screen while in docked mode.
This would be absolutely perfect for playing my Switch at my work desk! I will wait 'til units are a little more widespread though, just to make sure these units are sturdy and the bugs are ironed out
Nice!
This looks great. A great option to have
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Nyko's portable dock would be perfect were it not for the lack of USB ports!
Too Expensive as it is the Nintendo Dock, is a rip off.
A Switch Dock cost more than a Pro Controller, let's be honest no way in hell that dock cost nearly as much
Aw... so cute and tiny.
But guess I will play on Handheld Mode 99%.
1% for Docked if only I am in the mood for bigger screen on TV.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE
Is NYKO Switch dock really good enough to display on TV ?
Is switch safe to operate on the tv while not standing up straight? What positions are safe for it to be in?
I'm not sure if I'm right, but can't Nintendo update the display port DRM in future and lock out unofficial devices like this?
Hopefully some revision of the NS uses side ventilators, much like many OEM graphics cards. Taking a queue from laptops by putting the main ventilator under the device was not the best idea... Not being able to place the console on a table without it overheating due to improper circulation is just asking for trouble.
But yeah, the size of this minimalist "docking" device accurately depicts the size of the official dock's circuit board. It's just a connector hub and power switch. The official dock is mostly just a cheap plastic shell. Definitely not worth $90. Well, old sayings about a fool and their money, and all.
@chardir DisplayPort is an open source platform. It doesn't allow DRM or lock out software by design, and royalties are optional. For HDMI, though, that could be possible.
@Moshugan Fairly sure you're talking about the model shown in the video and that was just a prototype. It's not the finished product.
@PugHoofGaming is the Switch not perfect for playing at the work desk without a dock? Or do you intend hooking it up to a monitor?
@johndevine I use a Hori PlayStand at the moment, but I have a decent-sized HDMI-enabled monitor on my desk that I'd love to play Switch games on
@SLIGEACH_EIRE I think the official spec for the Nyko dock says there's no USB ports.
Yeah, I'm with @SLIGEACH_EIRE on this one - the Nyko dock is not only cheaper, but looks better as well...
Kickstarter? ...this is a non-starter for me!
EDIT: @erv - you're absolutely right, the Switch should be in an upright position when docked as the vents are in the back...the picture (above) with the Switch laying flat on its back sent a shudder down my spine! Fools!
@PlywoodStick DisplayPort definitely supports DRM - open source does not mean unencrypted.
I like the idea but I wish it was more a cable, Nyko dock looks better overall
@Damo Nintendo Switch’s dumb dock gets beaten by hyper-portable Nyko option
"(Update, 2:33 p.m.: After this article went live, a Nyko representative contacted Ars via e-mail to indicate that two USB ports will be added to the PDK by the time it launches, and possibly more.)"
https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/06/nintendo-switchs-dumb-dock-gets-beaten-by-hyper-portable-nyko-option/
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Niiiice! ..another good reason to go Nyko instead!
Thanks for the info
@Damo Nyko might want to bring some clarity to that. Missing those 2 USB-A ports that are on Nintendo's 'brick' dock might be a dealbreaker to some.
Other than that, if I wanted to play on more TV's this sure is a better option than buying a separate expansive dock from Nintendo. I play on the TV a lot and don't dislike the brick as it's functional standing there like that, but moving the dock around sure would be a pain.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Ah, fair enough - was going by what was listed on the official site. Adding those ports will most likely push production back I'm imagine, which is a shame.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE A bit hard to tell the size of Nyko's based on the photos on the article, although they do say it fits in the hand.
SFANS' design looks smaller, more likely to fit in my Switch case and I like the fact it looks like the front of a docked joycon controller.
Price however is a factor and I'm not crowd funding a product. Will wait until both are in the wild and in depth testing has been performed.
@FX102A I've linked to this video before.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJDiZBkwSnE
Watch around the 3 minute mark to see the NYKO portable dock. Remember it's a prototype so it's missing the USB ports for now.
This is going on my chrimbo pressie list. I don't 'need' one but having one would be great for work trips.
@Moshugan
Agreed. I haven't managed to find the Nyko dock in the UK yet.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE
Nyko are now selling it on their site. So I am guessing it is no longer a proto type. https://nyko.com/products/portable-docking-kit-for-nintendo-switch
I just rip the HDMI out from my TV and dock, and unplug the powersupply and put everything in my neat and lite Nintendo Switch travel bag. Takes maybe 10-20 second to do.
@MegaTen
I bought my switch on the release date and use it docked an undocked and have no scratches on the screen. I am not that particularly careful when undocking. I'm not sure how some people can scratch the screen and others can't.
I love this, but I like the $44.99 Nyko portable dock more I think, because it's just as small (almost) but stands the Switch up
@MegaTen
I never got scratches either for the first week I used it, but I wasn't willing to continue taking a chance. I bought a tempered glass screen protector, and now I can cram that thing into the dock as hard as I want and don't have to worry about anything.
I would strongly advise getting a tempered glass screen protector. Not only does it make using the dock carefree (which is a great feeling, because docking does work well), but it also ensures you won't damage your screen elsewhere (I scratched my Vita screen the ONE TIME I brought to work). They're $10 for a pack of two. amFilm is the top brand, and the can be applied with zero air bubbles (glass is stiff and totally different than plastic film protectors)
@NaviAndMii
Seemingly they don't have a great reputation!
This is from a reviewer on the article site https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2017/06/nintendo-switchs-dumb-dock-gets-beaten-by-hyper-portable-nyko-option/
The problem (as you mentioned it) is that the company is Nyko. I've had products made by them in the past and they've been cheap in quality. I'm hoping this turns it around for them but after hearing your ball-pit story, somehow I'm not feeling like this is worth the investment. Somehow, I feel that something on the Switch will break because I decided to go with a company which does not have such a good track record.
Just another bit of info for the mix.
After all of the above. I personally like my oversized brick which looks cool sitting underneath my oversized TV in my oversized games room. I'm a happy Switcher.
Nyko's dock still seems much better considering it includes HDMI and USB cable for 45$.
poo is WAY over priced...
I would love one. The dock isn't going to fit in any part of my TV rack and I don't want to put it in front or behind of the TV.
Nintendo did screw up that part of the console.
@MegaTen Don't be afraid. Scratches on the screen have happened to a minuscule minority of Switch owners. Of course, everyone it happens to goes online to kvetch about it (understandably, mind you), so the problem is vastly overreported. You don't hear much about the millions of people who have had no problems whatsoever.
You're going to want a screen protector anyway, just like every other portable device you own.
I've had my Switch since launch day, in and out of the dock two or three times a day, and I share it with two kids, one of whom is nine years old and not really well known for being careful with things. There is not a single scuff mark on the screen.
Interesting! Can anyone recommend Nyko or SFANS then?
I'm looking to back/pre-order one of the two soon (leaning towards Nyko), but can't seem to find any UK links anywhere...
@Damo *Trully.
This ad is sooo dumb, the character using scissors to cut a bigger pocket? DUMB, the voiceover=DUMB, this just screams AS SEEN ON TV, so it doesn't give me a high vote of confidence for quality.
Just throwing this out there, I have a USB-C extension cable run from my Swiitch dock to the switch itself and it works great. I make sure my Swiitch is face down so the vents are facing upward and it doesn't seem to get too hot at all. Oh, and it sits on a piece of fabric that won't scratch the screen. So Yea, in that setup you should be fine using a adapter like this.
If you've never funded something on Kickstarter or indiegogo, remember the release date is a placeholder, and you should probably add a year onto it just to be safe. Most of the time these people have great ideas, but are in way over their heads in terms of finding materials, manufacturers, etc.
@easygoingthief Oh I see - in that case, it's probably best to hold off until there are a few different mini docks on the market then...quality is a must for sure
@SM4SHshorts I read about the Nyko dock in a little article in the Express - they said that it doesn't look like Nyko are currently shipping to the UK but apparently their products usually end up on Amazon for worldwide shipping... (?)
I don't understand how the Switch ever launched without the ability to output video over a simple HDMI cable, sans-dock. There's no technical reason for requiring power. The odds of taking the switch somewhere and playing for more than 3-4 hours straight is very low (for me) and I would much prefer the option to take a small, $5-$10 USB-C to HDMI cable on the go than an entire dock solution. I will admit, this is a tempting solution, since it appears it's about as good as we're going to get.
@easygoingthief The Nyko dock looks horrible. If someone sneezes it's going to take a tumble and break.
I went ahead and supported the indie-gogo page. Getting the dock, cables, and a playstand for 79 seems like a deal to me, and Nyko's option always looked like it couldn't support the switch well. In a portable setting, my friends would probably knock it over.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Indeed
@MadAdam81 As I say I am happy with my brick.
Do agree with you.
uh... i thought the whole point of the dock was to provide active cooling for when the switch was overclocked...? both of these products look like they'd let your unit cook.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE The Nyko dock doesn't give you any of the USB outputs though. Which is certainly nice for charging the pro controllers.
I think this is what every one is looking for cheaper docks, hopefully they get to the price they should be under £25 and we can leave them where ever we think we want to play and not have to lug around the dock to work.
@MegaTen the scratches thing was so overblown coming from warped docks. I've docked and undocked every single day since March 3, some days more than once. Recently i did see one fine line on the periphery of the bezel, but i think the power pack of my bone conductor headphones did that. But even if the dock ever does, were taking about the 1/3" black bezel next to the screen, NEVER the screen itself scratching. There's no reason to not use the dock because of that. None at all. These docks are purely desirable for those who want enhanced mobility for hotel use and such.
Its funny, our 3ds and wiius, we were encouraged to grind a stylus all across the screen until it had hairline scratches all over it, and nobody complained. Now with switch, people are freaking out over the remote possibility of getting a tiny scratch on the outer bezel away from the screen that you can only see in direct sunlight or a flashlight and has no effect on the actual display of games
Ouch, too expensive. A dock should not cost more than $50 in my opinion.
First of all:
I really like these portable docks - although the one from Nyko is vastly superior because of its price - and I might consider buying one in the future.
But:
I don't find the original Switch dock bulky at all, in fact it is smaller than a Wii U. It will fit into any backpack and even into a purse. If you have a Jacket with big pockets, it might even fit into those.
Also:
"if you're anything like us your Switch dock and its associated cables will already be firmly entangled in the jungle of wires which lurk behind your TV set, and freeing them isn't something we relish doing on a regular basis."
I don't follow. The Switch dock is so small, why would you even put it behind your TV set 'in the jungle of wires'?
E.g. my Switch dock sits on an elevated position at my desk where I can reach it easily anytime.
The AC adapter is connected to a multiple socket-outlet next to my desk and I have a long HDMI cable (actually it's way longer than necessary) going to my AV-receiver (which is positioned next to my TV). That and cable is hidden under a rug, which means it's not in the way and you can't trip over it.
So you see, the Switch dock doesn't have to be even close to the TV and surely not hidden in a jungle of wires. You just need a proper HDMI cable.
@day Nope, the original Switch dock also doesn't have a cooling functionality and the Switch doesn't need that either.
@duffmmann Nice to have, sure. But not really necessary as you can always just use a powerbank (which is something any portable Switch user owns anyway).
@roadrunner343: This! So much this! There is really no reason why Nintendo didn't provide us with a simple cable instead of the dock or additionally.
But fear not, the Switch does have that ability, it's just not advertised. All you need is a female-USB-C-to-male-HDMI cable.Ah sorry, I didn't remember it correctly. It still needs the dock for that. But I'm pretty sure there will be a cable-solution one day.@Biffclaven If you consider the fact that any of these docks has almost no tech in it (not more than a Rasberry Pi has) and is just a chunk of plastic, it shouldn't even cost more than 10€ if you ask me...
@duffmmann It does, see comment #21.
I love the design of the Switch except for the dock. It's just so much larger than it should be and it always leaves smudges on my Switch screen that I have to wipe off. This and the Nyko dock have peeked my interest immensely. I'll definitely be picking one of them up down the road.
Great review!
@NaviAndMii Thanks for the tip - that's such a shame!
@SLIGEACH_EIRE I was eyeing that one on Amazon a couple days ago but it's not out till October and I want it for next week lol.
at that price why the hell would I ever buy this thing?...
seriously...
That's a bit too rich for my blood. I'll just stick with tabletop mode + portable battery or handheld mode when I'm away from the dock.
Am I really the only Switch owner out there who only owns a single HDTV? I'd assume it would be commonplace for secondary TVs to still be SD for plenty of others too, making it a no-brainer for 3rd parties to address by making one with composite outs (seems like it should be a far higher priority than USB-C ports)... yet so far no one seems to be doing that, so maybe I am alone.
I like the portability, though it's more expensive than I thought. Adding the stand to properly vent it, it becomes about as expensive as the official dock, in which case I'd prefer the official as it's sturdier and...well, official so I know the quality should last
@DeltaPeng Maybe I'm just overlooking the obvious, but why would you need a stand to properly vent it when you can simply lay the system face down without blocking the vents? Even if you're worried about scratching the screen, you've got to have some kind of cloth in your home you can always set beneath it for protection.
I don't think its the smallest at all. Considering you need that kind of stand with it to make sure your Switch doesn't overheat it looks pretty klunky actually. So far only the Nyko dock seems to be the most interesting one out there.
Way to expensive. Add customs to it and it's as much as the official in europe...
@chardir HDCP can be used with it, like Apple has since 2008, but that stirs up controversy. It's usually reserved for the media consortium closed source connectors like DVI and HDMI.
@thatawesomedude What is this "secondary TV" of which you speak? 😎
@shani I've done a fair bit of searching, and I've not found an adapter that works that way. Have you found one? The video you linked to specifically says at the end not to go out and buy that adapter, because it's not going to work.
I have no doubt that this is something Nintendo could do, but it will probably require an active USB-C to HDMI cable. As far as I know, the Switch actually runs DisplayPort over USB-C, which is why a standard USB-C to HDMI adapter doesn't work right. Still, if there is a product out there like this that exists, I'd love to get one.
The issue with a portable dock is the need to carry a power adapter around as well and I have enough of those in my bag already, my usb c phone adapter will not power the switch in docked mode, I've tried. I'd be happy with the current dock if only they would sort out the price. If you buy a dock, Joycon pair and power supply separate at the moment its only £100 pound more to add in the full switch bundle!
@shani Well the Controller charging is just one of the uses for the USB input. You can at this time use a Switch USB port to connect a keyboard, the Pokken controller, as well as other USB based controllers. And who knows what kind of usb-based peripherals the future of the system will bring. Point is, while Nyko's solution looks nice, I would personally go like something like this over it as it will be more future proof and allow for USB connections that Nyko simply wont be able to allow for.
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Hope that's true, but I'll only believe it when I see it. I've seen Nyko say they'd add something to a yet to be released product only for it to come out as first shown off without the added feature before.
I am confused how there can be two products with different names that look exactly the same
SWITCH-CON is the name of this other one
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/switch-con/switch-con-worlds-first-hdmi-hub-for-switch-and-s8
@SLIGEACH_EIRE Well that's awesome if they'll add the ports! I was just going off on what was shown at E3 and their official site.
@gohanrage They don't look exactly the same.
@JaxonH "I bought a tempered glass screen protector, and now I can cram that thing into the dock as hard as I want and don't have to worry about anything."
That's all well and good until you have to one day remove/replace your screen cover. The cover itself will have done plenty of its own damage to your screen. I believe the Switch screen is plastic so even more to the point, the adhesive-like material on the back side of the cover will do a number on the actual screen over the months/years.
@gatorboi352
It does no damage whatsoever. I've used tempered glass on plastic screens before (VITA after I scratched it) and it comes off even after years of use. All the benefits of glass screen without the downside of shattering the real one.
edit
Not to mention, there's no reason to ever remove it unless it gets damaged, and if that's the case, better that it was a screen protector than the real screen. If it was the screen itself, the system would be ruined.
@duffmmann Actually, the Nyko dock does have USB ports as @SLIGEACH_EIRE mentioned in comment #21.
@roadrunner343 When I saw the videos back then, I immediately searched for such a female-to-male USB-C-cable, but didn't find any in Europe. But there were some available in the US (I would have to look for them again). So I just decided to wait until someone in Europe also sells them.
BTW which video in my post did you watch? Because I edited it shortly after posting and changed the video. The first one showed a HDMI-adapter that didn't work, but the other video simply uses a female-to-male USB-C-cable. But as I added in my other comment, it still requires the dock (but you don't have to put the Switch inside it anymore), so I just remembered it wrong.
@erv and others who wondered about the Switch and overheating. Watch Spawn Wave's video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RHy_TOdVHqQ where he tests the heating of the Switch while using this mini-dock. Half way through the video he also explains a bit about the airflow in the Switch.
@icebear80 thanks a lot for the link, very informative.
In short: switch is easily usable plugged in running max power. The way it's positioned doesn't matter much.
Having a usb-c plug with a c input and hdmi output with you will set you up to play at others' tv's just fine
Cool device. I think we will see some neat stuff. Now if we could just confirm a release of Dragon Quest X all would be right in the world.
Looks great but about 3x the price it should be.
Aren't this and the Switch-Con exactly the same product? Just one isn't is on Indiegogo and the other kitckstarter?
Is this working as the Kacosata Nintendo Switch Dock USB-C Type HDMI Adapter from Chinese too? And what are their differences?
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...