With the 3DS now four years old, and now that the New Nintendo 3DS has brought us another iteration with a whole load of features, we decided it was a good time to take stock of ten definitive experiences on the system. To that end we listed 50 retail games - the eShop will have its own celebrations for its June anniversary - for you, the Nintendo Life community, to vote on. You voted in big numbers, with nearly 30,000 boxes ticked in less than a day, helping us to compile the community's ten must-play games at the four year mark for the 3DS.
The results have been fascinating - every single game on the list received votes, and more besides were added in the comments section. The results have some surprising omissions, however, helping draw a bigger picture of the favourites among thousands of Nintendo Life readers.
For starters, no third-party games made it into the list of ten, with Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate and Bravely Default both coming reasonably close. Another surprise absentee is message board favourite Kid Icarus: Uprising, which missed out on 10th place by less than 100 votes.
So what about the ten that did make it? Below are your choices, ordered by the number of votes received.
Its Western release in the summer of 2013 achieved something that had seemingly been missing for some time in major Nintendo titles - it went viral online. A sales phenomenon in Japan, in the West it became a hot topic on social media, with many sharing their love for the game, and the fact some were confused by how much they adored it. You shake trees, make friends and pay your mortgage; it's an odd formula that works.
We're pleased this made the grade, not only because it gave Luigi another starring role, but also because Next Level Games did a terrific job of bringing the mini-series to the portable. Lovely music and visuals, along with gameplay suited for players of all levels, its charm is neatly characterised by Luigi singing along to his own theme.
The first main-series 'mon game of the 3DS era saw off last year's Omega Ruby & Alpha Sapphire, which shows that fully original games can get the nod over enhanced remakes. This was a big step up for the franchise, introducing a new graphical engine and whole load of new features including Mega Evolutions.
The first Zelda entry in this list is also the most recent arrival, delivering the long demanded and most diverse of games in the legendary franchise. Originally missed by some due to its relatively late arrival on the Nintendo 64, now tens of millions of 3DS owners can experience the intriguing time travelling dynamic and tackle the abilities of multiple masks.
Only just edging out Majora's Mask 3D, this was an important release in the early days of the 3DS and a lovely remaster of what's widely regarded as one of the greatest games of all time. Grezzo did a lovely job in polishing the visuals and introducing a handy inventory system that was a huge help in that Water Temple.
It had to be there, of course. Every Nintendo system has a Mario Kart game, and the 3DS entry is well-regarded by many. It has excellent online options - including the awesome Community feature - and introduced underwater racing and gliding, which have both continued to be mainstays in Mario Kart 8 on the Wii U.
It was never a question of whether this would be included, but how high it would place. Masahiro Sakurai's outstanding latest entries in the series offer surprising levels of parity between Wii U and Nintendo 3DS, and it was this portable version that arrived first. It's a bit of a technical marvel on the system - in addition to being a fantastic game - and also has amiibo support on the New Nintendo 3DS.
We're pleasantly surprised to see this so high in the list, as there are certainly plenty of vocal critics that say this 3D platformer is over-rated. This scribe disagrees, in any case, arguing that this 2D and 3D hybrid is a brilliant effort on the system - it uses the 3D effect in clever ways, but importantly is a simply brilliant platformer at its core; evidently plenty agree with that sentiment.
A well-deserved triumph for Intelligent Systems, it's easy to forget that Awakening's sales success went a long way in 'saving' the IP, with a fresh title now on the way this year. It importantly gives the option to turn off permadeath, but is still typically hardcore and tough for those that demand a challenge. Turn-based strategy at its finest.
A fairly comfortable winner, all told, and undoubtedly a genuine classic that'll stand the test of time. In fact, we know the formula will hold up in the future as this borrows very heavily from SNES title The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past. Despite that link (geddit?) this must go down as one of Eiji Aonuma's finest projects, finding an impeccable balance in honouring the series' legacy while forging fresh ideas. Right from the soundtrack, through to the graphics and the hugely impressive design, this is an outstanding experience on 3DS, and a worthy entrant as the number one must-have title on the system.
So there you have it, ten must-have 3DS games as voted for by the Nintendo Life community. A huge thanks to everyone that voted.
But wait, there's more! Our video man Alex conducted a snap poll of the Nintendo Life team for a separate list, and you can see the video for that below. Enjoy!
If you enjoyed that and fancy seeing daily videos that tackle news and questions, in addition to feature videos such as 3D recreations of classics and more, be sure to subscribe to the Nintendo Life YouTube channel.
Comments 160
Aside for fire emblem, of which I replaced with New Super Mario bros. 2, which I honestly love, this was the same as my 10 votes, although in a different order. I do however agree with the choice for No. 1 though
The lack of Shin Megami Tensei IV and Etrian Odyssey IV makes me sad. Nevertheless, I'm still cool with the first two. Link Between Worlds and FE:A are both magnificent entries in their respective series.
My list is just MH4U 10 times. What other games are there?
Good list!
I'm surprised that Kid Icarus Uprising isn't on this list.
Rune Factory 4
Rune Factory 4
Rune Factory 4
Rune Factory 4
!
!
!
!
FE:A was the second-best animu dating game I have ever played.
Maybe its just me.. But I can't stand A Link Between Worlds for anything. I really don't like it for a Zelda game. Maybe its the top down view that gets me.. Something does. I guess I'm glad people like it, but it was one of the biggest disappointments for me for Zelda.
I knew "Ace Combat: Assault Horizon 3D" would show up here but even so, it breaks my heart.
Pretty close imo, but it's missing Uprising. I'd remove Mario Kart 7 for it since Mario Kart 8 is far superior and it's really not a must play if you have a Wii U. Same with Smash too. They're still good if you don't though.
I'm surprised that Super Mario 3D Land and A Link Between Worlds were rated as highly as they were, they're my 2 fave 3DS games, although if i had to pick 5, i'd probably add Ocarina of Time, Luigi's Mansion 2, and Mario Kart 7.
I really couldn't think where to place Animal Crossing or Majora's Mask in my list of fave games. Kinda difficult when you have 30+ 3DS games.
Three Zelda games with two of them remakes? Seriously?
Where's Uprising?
I'm fine with this list
Dang, no Monster Hunter or Kid Icarus?
Oh well, at least I got Awakening at No. 2.
Surprised to see no Uprising. Other than that, good list.
I will never get the love that Zelda: A Link Between Worlds seems to get. Am I the only one who thought it was a boring Zelda that was too easy with a stupid "Item Rental" system that defeated one of the purposes of even having dungeons in the game.
Its a shame a Link Between Worlds got on the list while Uprising and OOT 3D both missed the list.
That, and it beat out Fire Emblem Awakening, which is not only the best Fire Emblem game ever made, but the best game of 2013 for the system, and the best game overall on the 3DS.
Ahh well, besides that pretty good list overall. I just have a massive dislike for Link Between Worlds.
My list would be with out remasters.
10: Kingdom Hearts 3D
9: Pokemon X/Y
8: Bravely Default
7: Luigi's Mansion Dark Moon
6: Super Smash Bros
5: Mario Kart 7
4: Animal Crossing New Leaf
3: Super Mario 3D Land
2: LoZ: A Link Between Worlds
1: Fire Emblem Awakening
I'm satisfy with this list half the games I picked are there and that is because I'm all about the RPG for the most part.
I would replace Luigi's Mansion with Kid Icarus. But besides that, this was my list, although in a different order.
Surprised at No.1.
I agree; I want Kid Icarus Uprising up there. But it just shows how many good games are on the 3DS. Sadly, it all can't fit into a top ten list...
@Caryslan Your hatred for ALBW aside, OoT 3D DID make the list.
Great list, glad ALBW beat out the two remakes.
And no Mario and Luigi: Dream Team? X(
A lot of nope. As expected though.
I'm not suprsed at LBW being number 1. When I played it and beat it I could not decide if LttP was better or not that is how good this game is. Alex summed it up nicely.
Resident Evil Revelations is a must play too.
This list is great!
I rarely played on my original 3DS apart from Mario Kart 7 though I had a few games. However, I bought the New 3DS last Wednesday and I'm in love with it. Currently playing through Ocarina of Time which I could never get into on the old model.
I so want to play Majora's Mask next and maybe A Link Between World's though that's not high on my list. Also buying Xenoblade Chronicles 3D when it's out.
Always playing on it when out, especially at the pub. Kinda a loner lol
I'm surprised by roughly 3 things on this list.
1. Kid Icarus: Uprising isn't on it.
2. Super Mario 3D Land is 3rd — I was expecting it much lower (and wish it was much lower).
3. There are 2 remakes on this list. Don't get me wrong — everyone should play OoT and MM, but it's a remake. Unless it changed a ton, it doesn't really count, imo.
@WingedSnagret - Second. 2 remakes shouldn't beat out Kid Icarus: Uprising.
Pokémon Y is the only game on the entire list that I even own...
Also, the lack of Kid Icarus and Etrian Odyssey on this list is disturbing.
This is just a list of games that have been played by the most people.
I liked Link Between Worlds but i didn't love it like other Zelda games. Its not the top down view as i love other ones, was just something about it that didn't gel with me
There's some comments here I want to rip to shreds but... i'll resist. As I've never played Kid Icarus I couldn't vote for it but it seems to be receiving a lot of love. My list was:
10. Art Academy
9. Zelda: LBW
8. Virtue's Last Reward
7. Luigi's Mansion 2
6. Mario 3D Land
5. Zelda: MM 3D
4. Fire Emblem Awakening
3. Zelda: OOT 3D
2. Mario Kart 7
1. Smash Bros
Those remakes on the list are a bit questionable. I love Zelda games but I'm not sure if they should count. I still like the picks though.
I didn't even vote for 6 of those games. Not enough love for Atlus imo.
I still think kid icarus uprising should have been on that list.
Dual Destinies? no love for our favorite attorney at law?
I admit those zelda remakes are must plays but for the sake of having one more spot they could've been labeled as one entry, e.g. N64 Zelda remakes.
But this goes to show that the 3DS has more then 10 games that are must play games which is only a good thing for us gamers
I don't think Smash Bros is a must play on 3DS, it's good, but the better version is on WiiU
@vonseux But remember, it's the first "portable" super smash bros and even with these limitations for the hardware, it loses nothing of what is Smash Bros.
@edgedino
Anyone know if Kid Icarus is taking advantage of the new C-stick?
I have not bought Kid Icarus for two reasons that the new3DS hopefully makes easier:
Will this be better with new3DS?
Aw, I was hoping Monster Hunter would at least be at number 10. Other than that, the list is pretty good though I definitely disagree with some of the choices as other games deserved those spots. looks at the remakes
Only problem with this list is MH4U missing... Amazing game with endless gameplay
Not in this order but 9 of 10 of my choices made the list, only Animal Crossing not.
great list, you could have easily made a top 20 if you wanted and added MH3U and MH4U, kid icarus uprising, sonic generations (I think it deserves to be there!), kingdom hearts 3d, tales of the abyss, street fighter, bravely default, etrain odyssey etc etc. lots of great games on the little handheld
I would've put Kid Icarus: Uprising in there before Fire Emblem or Animal Crossing, but I guess that's just me.
I think Fantasy Life could've had a spot.. Great game.
@FarsanBaloo: The only thing the C-Stick does is move Pit if you're left-handed. And unfortunately, that can't be changed either.
Yeah, list could've been better.
Kid Icarus: Uprising is so underrated
Monster Hunter (3 and/or 4) and Rune Factory 4 are missing. T.T
Its a good top 10, but sadly I don't feel that there are many 'must play' games on 3DS for me. Link between Worlds and Super Mario 3D Land are probably the only 2 that I still think about, the rest were great fun, but not especially memorable.
Smash Bros 3DS or Kid Icarus Uprising there but 3D Land is number 3?
....I am extremely disappointed.
@khululy in the original pole they stated they would count retail only releases to make choices more streamlined
Good list, all of the games on there are ones that I've either played or want to play. Still, I would have like Kid Icarus Uprising and perhaps Etrian Odyssey and Monster Hunter to appear on it as well.
Where can I get the Zelda Wii U canvas art poster?
A little sad that Etrian Odyssey IV and Fantasy Life didn't make the list. Happy about FE:A though.
Love the video countdown
Super Mario 3D Land is overrated.
However there's no denying it should be on this list.
I'm glad Dark Moon got on here as well. The vacuum mechanic may be a little less fun than the original, but Next Level Games did a fantastic job putting this game together.
@thehoppypoppy I'm sure that's because not enough people have played them. I only picked up Etrian Odyssey on a whim and couldn't believe I never had before.
This list needs Kid Icarus! in my mind ocarina and majora should share the same slot as either/or.
This list needs Kid Icarus! in my mind ocarina and majora should share the same slot as either/or.
Super Mario 3D Land at third?! I've lost all faith in this community...
@FarsanBaloo No problems with the 3D sweet spot on the new 3DS in KI:U. The C-Stick can only be used for lefties to move Pit, not as an alternate aiming option.
New Leaf deserves No. 1...second best game I've ever played! If you just count this as a list and not as a Top 10, I wholeheartedly agree.
This list was a bit boring though...
Pretty good list. Although Im not sure why Link Between Worlds is so acclaimed. Im a pretty big Zelda fan and I didn't enjoy it that much. It wasnt bad by any means, just simple, easy, and a bit underwhelming.
Great list but I would replace Animal Crossing with Monster Hunter 4 U, but this is just my taste.
And Fire Emblem to me is the very best.
@Pierson I guess you havent played a whole lot of zelda games then, because the majoraty ( ͡º ͜ʖ ͡º) of them have a topdown view.
And also in that "for a zelda game" sense I gotta disagree with you as I think Link between worlds especially nails it as a zelda game, way more in that sense than some other more recent zelda games cough skyward sword cough
Ugh at Mario Kart 7 making the list. Easily the worst Mario Kart game ever made; the roster is terrible and it's new tracks were forgettable.
Heavens. We've proved people own Nintendo devices to play Nintendo games. Plus it's a popularist poll. It's not about your favourite one game, it was the ten games people agreed to be worthwhile purchases.
Of course if Ace Attorney was a retail game (I'm sure it cost me as much as a retail game), it OBVIOUSLY wouldn't be all about Ninty.
Uprising is missing. I am disappoint.
I'm still bummed that we never got a list-worthy Star Wars game on this system. Derp.
Kid Icarus: Uprising belongs with the top handheld games of all time.
So... four of those games (LozOoT, LoZMM, SM3DL, and SSB4) were either remakes of N64 games or games with better counterparts on the Wii U.
Only 4 of the games that I voted for made it into the top 10.
The remakes are disappointing to see here and probably shouldn't have been on the list at all. 3D Land is surprisingly high up, as much as I enjoy it. Dark Moon just feels kinda soulless compared to the original and the lack of circle pad support baffles me. The lack of Monster Hunter though is really quite bizarre. Fantasy Life also deserved better.
Unlike most of the people here I'm glad uprising missed out on a top ten place for me it had the worst controls of any game I've played
Mine are as follows:
1. Fire Emblem Awakening
2. Zelda Majora's Mask 3D
3. Kid Icarus: Uprising
4. Pokemon X and Y
5. Any of the Professor Layton games (couldn't decide which one)
6. Animal Crossing New Leaf
7. Zelda Ocarina of Time 3D
8. Tomodachi Life
9. Fantasy Life
10. Super Smash Bros.
I happen to own every single one of those top 10 games except for one...
Fire Emblem: Awakening
@Sanqet Can you think of a better control scheme for it (without a second circle pad, as it came out almost three years before the new 3DS and circle pad pros are annoyingly bulky)? It would have been better on a home console with better controls, but otherwise, it takes full advantage of the 3DS and in my opinion is the best looking game on the system.
@Zeldamaster97 I agree it should have been on the wii u they maybe done the best they could with the 3ds but the controls were still very uncomfortable
Too Much Zelda!!,
even if we own all 3, I only want link between worlds on there! at least its the highest. hey @ThomasBW84 can we now have a list of eshop only games to poll on?
My stomach kind of hurts over the fact that Kid Icarus and Star Fox aren't here.
No Kid Icarus: Uprising?
No Monster Hunter (any)?
You guys are weird.
I voted for Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sappire, Pokemon X/Y, Fire Emblem: Awakening and all Monster Hunter.
Also why no discount for this mario games in eshop?
I get the feeling if e shop games were included in this list we not be seeing a clean sweep for nintendo for me some the best games for the 3ds are on the e-shop
It's pretty cool that the 3ds has had three great Zelda titles. Granted two were re-masters but since I never played them on the N64 they are as good as new to me.
Hardly surprising that this is a clean sweep for 1st party. Even given the limited alternatives to vote on there is no denying Nintendo knows their own hardware.
@Sanqet Unfortunately, the Wii U wasn't out at the time KIU came out. A sequel on Wii U, or an update to support the New 3ds c stick, would fix all the original game's problems.
All I'm getting from all these disappointed comments is that there are way too many good games on the 3ds! Hooray!
Kind of obvious choices. I don't mind the absence of Kid Icarus here. To me it was decent but nothing special. To be honest, I haven't enjoyed 3DS nearly as much as I did the original DS. Great piece of hardware but not too many memorable games really.
My list would be different except for a couple of games. I agree that Super Mario 3D Land, Fire Emblem Awakening, Pokemon XY, and Mario Kart 7 should be on the list but not every Legend of Zelda that came out for the 3D. None of the Zelda games that have come out are new. They are all remakes! Maybe A link Between Worlds because that is the most extensively remade game.
Besides the 4 that I have mentioned above I would have added Resident Evil Revelations, Etrian Odyssey IV, Kid Icarus, Bravely Default, Theatrerhythm Final Fantasy, and Mario and Luigi Dream Team. It is a shame that a lot of great mature games for the 3DS get overlooked!
I'm actually a little surprised Super Mario 3D Land didn't somehow manage to be #1, though I definitely think A Link Between Worlds is more deserving. Probably my favorite Zelda game and favorite game on the 3DS. A lot of comments here though on Uprising not making the list. I'm very happy that it missed the mark for this poll. Kid Icarus Uprising had an excellent cast, dialogue and art direction, but nearly everything else didn't sit well with me. The controls for land segments worked but were far from excellent, really making me disinterested in the overall experience.
I would put only one zelda so I could have room for other deserving games like kid icarus for example
I have all of the games on this list.LOL
@FarsanBaloo I'm pretty sure it does, it was compatale with the CPP so it should work. I play KH:DDD With the n3DS and it works. But I don't own KI.
I only played 2 of the games on the list.
Great list. I own all of those except Pokemon X/Y. Please replace with Ghost Recon Shadow Wars.
most of these are titles that i own (Animal Crossing, Mario Games, Super Smash Bros Mario Kart and Pokemon X)
However i agreed not a bad list
I feel like I have missed out by not getting a 3ds
Too bad Persona Q didn't make the cut, along with poor ol' EO4, but those can be my personal favorites in my heart.
Aw, no New Super Mario Bros. 2? Should be on spot 2 imo..
Games from my list that didn't make the cut were Kid Icarus: Uprising, Star Fox 3D, and Persona Q. Though it was such a close call on my last slot that I flaked out and chose Persona because it was the least likely to garner votes.
That said, I am very passionate about the first two.
6 out of 10 games that I voted for made it into the top 10, not too bad (Fantasy Life is missing though).
Glad to see Animal Crossing, Super Smash Bros., Luigi's Mansion, the Zelda games and Super Mario 3D Land there.
On another note, I am glad to see that Tomodachi Life and New Super Mario Bros. 2 (nothing really new about it) did not make it into the list, I did not really enjoy those games (although many of my friends did).
Bravely Default, Kid Icarus and Monster Hunter are three of the best games on the system and slightly dismayed they got overlooked because they aren't as popular. Such is life though
FE:A is a real treat, I'd probably put MH4U and KI:U instead of some of the games.
Persona Q, Kid Icarus, Bravely Default, Resident Evil, Fantasy Life were in my list!
8 of my 10, I had KI Uprising and RE Revelations instead of the 2 Zelda remakes
Animal Crossing, Super Smash Bros, Pokemon X&Y, and Fire Emblem all the way. But no Resident Evil Revealtions? The 3DS needs more games like that.
May not be the exact 10 that I selected, but I agree that each of these are must haves too.
@oninowon ALBW is a remake when you ignore the complete new story, items, dungeons, bosses and the ability to turn into a painting. Learn what your tallking about before you complain.
It warms the cockles of my heart to see so many people wondering where the RPG's and Kid Icarus are. With the exception of Fire Emblem, this list is pretty much a laundry list of highly advertised first party titles. I'm not sure I would call it a "must-play" list, so much as I would call it, "Here's our top 10 titles from the most well known first party properties!" Or at least, I would think a "must-play" list would be a bit more varied and carefully calculated than this, perhaps even containing a few titles that are relatively unknown.
At least, that's how the magazines used to do it. For example, Zack and Wiki used to show up on Wii "must-play" lists in magazines frequently, because almost no one knew it existed and it rarely appeared in stores, while having little or no advertising besides the lists, despite being one of the few really good early Wii titles. We already know all about the titles on this list, tell us more about the ones we're much less likely to have played.
But then again, the community did vote for these... "YOU'RE the King!? Well, I didn't vote for you!"
I'd add Kid Icarus: Uprising and Kingdom Hearts 3D
Virtue's Last Reward
I would have also considered Zero Escape: Virtue's Last Reward; one of the Professor Layton titles; Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars; either Shin Megami Tensei 4, Etrian Oddysey 4, or Rune Factory 4; Cave Story 3D; Rhythm Thief or one of the Theatrhythm titles; Fantasy Life or Tomodachi Life; and...
FRICKIN' Star Fox 64 3D! Seriously, there are no good space shooters or spaceflight simulators these days, so may as well highlight the best one on the 3DS.... Maybe the NintendoLife community doesn't really want another Star Fox title as much as posters keep saying we do?
@Ducked very solid list!
@TerrapinJess Thanks!
Well as a long time zelda fan I can say that this The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds is not better than A Link to The past but is not that bad either., this list is decent, I need to try 3DS fire emblem soon!!
@FarsanBaloo The 3d should work now with it and i found it incredibly easy to handle with the stylus and i have tremors to boot but the game controls can hurt your hand till you get used to it but trust me the moment u get the controls it becomes a enjoyable then painful then an enjoyable again experience.
Wow, No KI:U and ORAS?
@Pierson
So do you like any of the old Zelda games? (except Zelda 2)
I, pesonally, am just so obsessed with LTTP that LBW was, oh so good!
For those making to top 10, I didn't vote OoT (even it's awesome game, but N64 for me), Smash or Luigi's Mansion. I had Tomodachi, Kid Icarus and... something. Edit: That something was FF CC
I'm disappointed that Kid Icarus Uprising isn't on this list, what a fantastic game.
This was definitely the wrong way to do votes. Just picking 10 doesn't take into account which of the 10 people prefer. For example, a lot of people may have voted for Super Mario 3D Land, but it would be 10th on everyone's list, so really it should be lower than it is, if games got different number of points depended on how high they are on individual lists. I mean seriously, if Super Mario 3D Land is the 3rd best game on the system, then the 3ds is an atrocious console.
Don't be daft. It was 3rd most commonly chosen in this vote, no-one's saying that means it's the 3rd best apart from you.
Castlevania Lords Of Shadow Mirror of Fate, Kingdom Hearts Dream Drop Distance, Mario Golf (for the fact that it's been since Gamecube that a new one was released), Mario And Luigi Dream Team and Star Fox 64 should have been included in this list too!!!! Resident Evil Revelations should be included too!!!
Great list! I'd remove Pokemon and put Kid Icarus Uprising in there somewhere though. Can't believe it's not on here.
"Fire Emblem Awakening - 2"
Damn straight.
Lack of Kid Icarus: Uprising, and the inclusion of 3 Zelda games
u wot m8
I agree with this list.
It's a good list, but I feel like Nintendo shouldn't get all the love. There's some great games from Atlus and Capcom that could have easily made it on here. Actually, Resident Evil: Revelations is in my personal top 5. Excellent game through and through.
Even if Fire Emblem got to number 1, it's still not high enough. What a stunning masterpiece that game was.
All Nintendo games, which shows just how much Nintendo totally and utterly dominates on its own system.
I wish more third party developers would step up and deliver too.
Needs so much Monster Hunter, either 3U or 4U.
@Kirk
"I wish more third party developers would step up and deliver too."
I don't think that's a fair statement. Resident Evil: Revelations was one of the best experiences I've had on the 3DS. It's story was a little wacky, but the gameplay was solid on the system. I don't have Monster Hunter personally, but I've heard others say how wonderful it is. Also, Bravely Default was a nice surprise and could comfortably be on some people's top 10 list. Not to mention we had other solid games like Kingdom Hearts and Shin Megami Tensei IV.
The games are there, but there's two things to consider with this list. One, it's NintendoLife, so Nintendo games are going to be skewed to the top, no matter what; and two, this just proves that there are just so many great experiences on the 3DS. 10 games simply aren't enough, as it's too few to pick from.
@DarthNocturnal
U Mad
I agree with most of the list apart from 3D land and Luigi Mansion should be higher on the list.
@MoonKnight7
Yeah, there's obviously some good third party games, on all Nintendo's systems, but I still don't think third parties are on the whole anywhere near delivering on Nintendo's current-gen systems.
Really hope we get another Link Between World style game.
@OneBagTravel I would most certainly be happy to see that. Maybe if they just tweak the visuals a tiny bit so they remove that slight shiny/plastic rendered 90s look and go for a more clean look that captures the original SNES game's visuals better but still in 3D. Basically, what they have now but without the ever so slightly shiny and slightly garish, bumpy, tacky visual look to a degree. Then it would be nigh-on perfect imo.
It's really interesting to see the divide over KI:U
Personally, I quite like the control scheme, but, hey, that's just an opinion. Once you're used to it, it works like a dream.
With the exception of MK 7, which is good, but not 'must-play', I agree with the list. Especially FE:A. That really broadened my strategy game horizons.
And all this debate can only be a good thing, right? The 3DS has had so many good games that we all feel the need to mention more essentials.
'Tis very good.
This is a bit fun. The list is a bit like a middle school student council vote, while at the same time we all have lower-selling gems we love.
To be like everyone else, here's what I'd change: Fire Emblem to 1, Animal Crossing to 2, add Bravely Default, Etrian Odyssey IV and Untold, and probably Mario Golf, and delete Pokemon, the Zelda remakes and Smash.
Honourable mentions to Persona Q and Kirby Triple Deluxe.
@Caryslan I did enjoy LBW overall, though I also don't understand all the love it gets. Being based on a pre-existing world made it bland and boring, it was way too easy, and as you said, the item rental thing sort of defeated a lot of the purpose. Progression is one of the things I love most in Zelda. It was mildly fun, but not the second coming of 2D Zelda a lot of people make it out to be.
I only have one of these games (3D Land), and it is surprising how few of the rest I want. I actually bought both Pokémon Y and Animal Crossing - a first for me for either series - but sold them both on after not really 'getting' them (despite playing each for over 20 hours).
I have the original N64 Zelda games on my Wii VC, and have been a bot overloaded with Zelda of late so not interested in LBW right now. And for me, Mario Kart and Smash belong on my Wii U.
So that just leaves Fire Emblem and Luigi's Mansion, again I've not played any game in either series so don't know how much I'd like them?
If I was the one doing the list, I'd replace Pokemon X and Y with ORAS and LM: DM with KI: U and put it up a bit higher. Otherwise, great list.
Very strong list, but I disliked seeing 3 Zelda titles up there, especially since two of them are remakes. I would've at least put Kid Icarus: Uprising, but alas, it's underrated for a reason.
Personally, I'd slot in Etrian Odyssey IV and New Super Mario Bros 2 (quite an underrated game as far as NSMB goes), but it's a good list.
@DerpSandwich I guess that's my problem with the game, I was expecting something more from a game that won so many awards. What I got was a world map that felt largely rehashed from a SNES game that came out 20 years before, an item rental system that removed alot of the point of even having dungeons in the first place, dungeons that seemed to lack that touch that most Zelda dungeons have, and a game that felt easy for a Zelda game.
I guess what gets me is how this game won so many awards over Fire Emblem: Awakining. ALBW felt like Nintendo taking the concept behind the New Super Mario Bros games(retro-style game designed to appeal to older gamers with throwback gameplay) while Awakening took not only the best elements of past Fire Emblem games, but built on that foundation by moving the series forward and produced arguably the best game in the entire series.
I understand A Link Between Worlds has its fans, but I don't get how this game tops not only this list, but won so many awards over games like Fire Emblem: Awakening.
Just my personal opinion on the matter.
Too much Mario. Too much Link.
Really wish Nintendo would port some of these to the Wii U
Wow! FE:A is my #1, but I thought it would come in at 7 or 8. I guess it just goes to show that you can take a franchise that most people had never played (myself included) and make 1 off the charts amazing game and it will get the recognition it deserves
@shigulicious Maybe but it's not really surprising, Mario and Link have always dominated Nintendo consoles.
Awakening isn't a must play. Simple because this is a BAD game and the worst Fire Emblem ever!
Troll sighted above! Do not feed it!
Luigi's Mansion deserves more love, much more love.
@R-Moss Yep it is a Fire Emblem game for people who don't like Fire Emblem. (Similar to how Super Castlevania IV is a Castlevania game for people who hate Castlevania).
I would put Resident Evil Revelations on the list. It's perfect for the 3ds especially with the improved 3D and right analog.
I completely agree with this list! Im just wondering why kid icarus uprising isnt one of the games on the list.
I can't take this list seriously without any Monster Hunter. And I'll take Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire over X/Y.
No Persona Q, No Kid Icarus,No SMT IV, No Phoenix Wright Dual Destinies, No Bravely Default....
@DarthNocturnal
I was actually talking about Pokemon not Mario.
@Finntendo Um old like Minish Cap I'm just not a fan of the older top down games. I agree that they are a classic and really fun its just hard for me to get into.
@Monte Well I've played all the mainline on consoles. From Ocarina on up. Including the two DS titles and Minish Cap. I mean I just love the openness of a 3D world from third person. Top down is okay but eh. I actually really loved Skyward Sword
@Pierson
Well it is turning 11 this year... (see, since I've owned handheld only few years, I've barely paid attention to Zeldas released to those systems )
LTTP was so mindblowing experience for me when I was a kid, borrowed it from kid living in the same village, the map that came with the game and all..
But now that you mention Minish Cap, I really should play it since I bought it for Wii U....
But yeah, others like cats and others like dogs.
@Pierson it's funny how you first say you like the openness of a 3D Zelda and than that you loved skyward sword, which was pretty much the least open and most linear zelda game (and in my opinion a pain in the ass to play through)
it's ok to dislike topdown games, however it's another thing to say that Link between worlds is a disappointment as a zelda game because of it's topdown view.
But I guess it's just that our tastes are quite different, as in my opinion Link between worlds is pretty much one of the best zelda games, while Skyword Sword is just the worst (not including CDi)
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...