Today marks the launch of the much-hyped NINJHAX exploit, which allows 3DS owners a backdoor to run unofficial software on their consoles. The hack is the work of 22-year-old student Jordan Rabet, and is so called because it requires a copy of the obscure puzzle platformer Cubic Ninja in order to work — a game which has suddenly shot up in value.
More interesting is the fact that the game has been subsequently removed from the Japanese eShop in an effort by Nintendo to prevent NINJHAX from working, which proves that the company keeps a keen eye on the homebrew community and any attempts to break the security of the 3DS.
However, Rabet maintains that his work isn't intended to promote piracy on the system, but instead to encourage homebrew developers to bring their projects to the console.
Speaking to Eurogamer, Rabet said:
It's very dangerous. If you release an exploit that's too powerful you might let people do whatever they want with their console - which can be great - but you also have the possibility of piracy... which isn't so great.
I don't care if people pirate in their private lives, but I don't want to be a part of it. I don't want to release something others can use to steal someone else's intellectual property. That's not what I want. I wouldn't release something that could be used for piracy... it's just not something I want to do.
Right now I'm hoping the loader attracts more developers and people start building more homebrew games. I'm working on the 3DS version of Minecraft and a bunch of people are working on emulators. I'd really like to see how far we can push the 3DS.
Of course, emulation is still considered a form of piracy by many companies, Nintendo included. It makes money from selling old games via its Virtual Console service, and even if NINJHAX doesn't allow 3DS owners to pirate retail titles, the fact it potentially takes money away from its download services will be reason enough to slam the door shut.
For Rabet, playing old games doesn't constitute piracy — within reason:
I would say the emulator itself definitely isn't piracy, to me. Pirating ROMs is definitely not legal or morally responsible - but if you own the game and want to play it on the go, I don't see anything wrong with that. I guess there's the argument that emulators may hurt Virtual Console sales but, honestly, the homebrew scene is pretty small. Cubic Ninja is not a game that was sold a lot and now it is being sold at super high prices, so it's not going to cause any significant damage.
Rabet — who deliberately held NINJHAX back when the New 3DS was announced to ensure that Nintendo didn't patch the exploit in the revised system — feels that it's only a matter of time until the Kyoto giant responds more decisively, and if you're thinking of buying Cubic Ninja for the sky-high prices it is currently selling for, you might want to reconsider:
I think they're going to try and patch it out as soon as they can. I don't know how long it's going to take them - the problem is I've already been talking about this for a couple of months so its possible they may have figured out what I've been doing.
It's just a vulnerability in a game to access a vulnerability in the system firmware. All they'd really need to do is patch the firmware and then the game doesn't even matter.
What do you think about the NINJHAX exploit? Do you think Rabet is doing 3DS owners a great service by allowing them to run more games on their consoles? Or is this kind of hack something you're not keen on seeing? Perhaps you have your copy of Cubic Ninja primed and ready to run the hack? Whatever your stance, share it by posting a comment below — though please remember to observe our Community Rules while discussing this topic.
[source eurogamer.net]
Comments 58
You guys totally aren't implying your views with that picture or anything
if it lets me play imported games then i'm all for it. just glad i already had a copy of cubic ninja. having to buy one now would suck. but i'll wait until i hear more about it before i try it.
That person is pretty much unintentionally opening up the gate to piracy, some other person will more than likely use that same exploit to make retail games available unless Nintendo shuts it off with a new system update.
Really stupid mistake on his part indeed, at least the people who were trying to get custom tracks onto Mario Kart 8 had the common sense to stop because they knew someone else would exploit their work to ruin its online.
Is Nintendo Life is promoting homebrew?
... in which may lead to some of their curious readers trying it and potentially bricking their systems? Or engage in piracy maybe?
I always want to see what the homebrew community has to offer. Some years ago I got my second PSPgo for this reason. They were some excellent emulators and games. I still play with it time to time.
However now times have changed. You can easily use android devices for emulation and homebrew and this is far more convenient of risk of bricking you device, Nintendo blocking the exploit etc. Also you can also media players, internet and social media on an android device.
I may try this to see if there are some cool homebrew especially if it somehow helps to remove the stupid relic of the past called region lock.
Some other person will open the the gates to the roms, but if you own the game and wanted on the go than what's the problem. I have bought most every game that I had a rom for. I own over 150 titles on Wii virtual console that I paid for. I own over 50 Wii U virtual console games that I bought and paid for. When I jacked up my DS Not only did I own 3 of them that I BOUGHT. The ROMs that I acquired let me play Mother 1 and 3 those are the few exceptions. The older Dragon warriors, Ultimas, Mother, I would have bought if they were available. I have purchased the older FFs and remakes so many times I can't even count them. I think for me, I like Homebrewing my older system after they have past there life cycle. I most certainly will BUY the New 3DS and purchase the games that I want. The older 3DS will be exploited. For me it is exciting to see what I can do with MY older 3DS. Can I make it a media player? Can
I make it a calculator? Can I integrated with my Mac or my garbage Surface.( don't hate on me the Surface does suck I own one waste of money.) It's all about creativity. The Roms are just part of it.
I love how the banner for this article is some random pirate mural lol.
I get so frustrated reading total noobs like Damien and most comments that will appear here. Why do you, Damien, use Smeas irl name? Why are ppl so scared? Its for bedroom coders. The big audience will never appear. cubic ninja exists in like 50 000 copies. Big deal? There are soon 50 000 000 3DS sold. Get some perspectives before saying stupid things please. Smea yellow8 and the team behind this has done a piece of art. Im sure the security apartment has a love/hate relationship to this achivement. Nintendo should be proud and happy that ppl have interest and has put so much time and effort into something cool as this. Bah, you will never understand anyeay. So why am i writing this?
@daggdroppen "So why am i writing this?"
I dunno, but a lot of alcohol seems to have been involved.
@BensonUii You're missing the key distinction between reporting on something and actively encouraging people to do it.
@daggdroppen I used his real name because he was happy to give it in the original Eurogamer interview upon which this piece of news is based. All that has been done here is that we've reported on an interview that he has given - we're not "scared" or "lacking perspective" on anything.
In fact, you seem to have failed to even read this news item and have instead dreamt up your own strange view of events in order to whip yourself into a frenzy. Try reading the piece again.
@SpookyMeths Exactly!
I like this guy, of course, theres so much he can do stop people finding exploits to his exploits for piracy, but he is trying the best to make the 3DS a much more open system, which for me, its great.
good read, hope developers can do some amazing and cool stuff with this
And who exactly says that homebrew is okay?
If you want to make homebrew Games, make them for PC, no problem with that.
But it's not only about piracy, Nintendo, as well as Sony and Microsoft, don't want homebrew on their Systems.
If they would, they would give out the tools for you to do that.
Seriously, if you want to make a game for a System then become an Indie, it isn't THAT hard.
Looking forward to virtualboy emulator on 3ds , hopy my copy of cubic ninja turns up today
I do actually have a virtualboy with a few games but it would be great to play on 3ds.
I believe that the system that I purchased is mine and I can do what I see fit with it. If I go to the grocery store and purchase American cheese, should I put it on turkey ,should I put it on roast beef? It's mine I can throw it on the wall and see if it sticks. My point is we purchase these systems. They belong to us. If we want to make it into something different then what's your gripe. We shouldn't be beholden to any of these companies if anything these companies should give us a little bit more respect and stop exploiting us.
@Damo
Except you are encouraging us to try it indirectly. See post number 5 for one and numerous others from previous homebrew articles. See also post number 6, how many really owns both the rom versions and the VC versions? I think this is one of the cases that you could compare it to online games cheating programs. You don't talk about it in the public forums as it'll encourage more hacking.
Anyway, the homebrew comments section is like the Tomodachi Patch all over again.
Good thing I run a gaming store in my state.
I just sold all my copies on eBay between the rates of 24 to 38 dollars a piece.
I might have paid out about two dollars a piece for these as they went as low as 6.99 in some stores during clearance.
I don't mind the revenue at all.
I am also an advent gamer, and do not care about hacking a console, I would rather play a game that I can physically hold in hand, than worry about a fanmade game.
And then Nintendo slams the gate tomorrow with an update that uninstalls the homebrew and..."accidentally" breaks the Cubic Ninja games in half
@belmont
Why would I want to play emulators on a Phone? Virtual gamepad sucks. Snes games on 3DS is what I want.
@River3636
The operating system on your 3DS isn't yours to modify without Nintendo's consent. You own the license to use it as Nintendo sees fit.
@WaLzgi wut
Yar, don't pirate Nintendo games, it is bad for you! But please make a PSP emulator, I want to play Locoroco and Patapon on my 3DS.
Not only was it removed from the Japanese eShop, EB in Aus are recalling all their copies. It was pulled from their site and has a price of $9999 (same as pre-orders) in their system.
@Drawdler And someone might actually pay for that, hahaha!
before emulator were called 'piracy' they were the only way to play a lot of classic games as they were no longer available at all. what happened was nintendo saw people wanted this and started to charge for it. so there you go for all of you who believe nintendo invented the virtual console
I love how the guy keeps repeating "this thing is physically impossible to use for piracy" and everyone yells "OPENS GATES FOR PIRACY".
People, is your reading comprehension that bad?
I applaud his work! It's amazing to me that we no longer need some fancy device made by a Chinese company dodging lawsuits to unlock a console's potential... The consoles now have that capability built in, it just needs to be unlocked! To me, this is not so different from jailbreaking an Apple device, which is in fact a legal option.
I do feel a bit fearful reading about this situation, though... It's as if this person has become a human rights activist, and Nintendo has become a deep state entity that is always watching for dissidents, patrolling to ensure no one "lifts the veil" from their particular vision of the virtual world. Of course, that's all just figuratively speaking, but large corporate entities now rival nations in Power, so I can't help but draw a few similarities between this and heavier real world issues. Who can forget the privatized police raids Sony sent out worldwide against their dissidents?
On a side note, it's kind of funny seeing the juxtaposition on Ninjas and Pirates... Ninjas were oftentimes honor bound servants of the higher castes, not enablers of dissidence; while (certain) Pirates were among the world's first practicers of Democracy... Though there's a distinction to be made between Pirates of the Jolly Roger (symbolizing the mind and freedom) and Pirates of the Blood (symbolizing death and survivalism).
It'll be amusing once this is patched out, no way i'm paying £30 quid for a bargain bucket game just for this
you need kernel mode for piracy/3ds roms.....
this exploit gives you usermode so basically there is no way someone can reverse engineer this so it runs 3ds roms.
@Kurt117 That depends on if this particular HBC enables a program similar to WiiBrew to write and rewrite the 3DS version of IOS...
@Drawdler It's interesting to see reactionary executive orders like that, considering the people who REALLY want to illegally assert themselves won't even bother taking the risk of being marked through buying a physical copy. If anything, it's those who do buy physical copies who are more likely to follow the law.
@Rief If you've been reading Gamasutra.com or gamesindustry.biz , there have been numerous articles written to explain the frustration of dealing with the big 3's indie processes. Even Sony, notorious for marginalizing their Indie developers' voices, has now one-upped Nintendo's early indie advantage, which Nintendo allowed to slip through their grasp.
So no, it's not easy to be approved, especially if you're self-publishing and no one else is there to back you or your group up. Most potential self-publishing developers don't make it through the partnering process. The result is many Indies resorting to making cheap phone games and diverting from their visions.
@kobashi100 Sorry I was talking more about "Gaming" android devices like xperia play, archos gamepad etc. Most of them cost 100-150 euros.
@BensonUii So you have never played homebrew games on PC, android or PSP? What is different trying it on a 3DS? There is nothing wrong with homebrew. Piracy is totally illegal though.
@BensonUii if you think that then that is your prerogative. You can go right ahead and be a sheep. I purchased my 3DS and will buy the new one. My old 3DS will be obsolete to me it is mine . I can smash it on the floor and break it into pieces if I want to. You can not tell me it is not mine that sounds like a bunch of horse manure and pig vomit.
@River3636
You can stick it up in your butt for all I care. Nintendo wouldn't care. It doesn't change the fact that you don't own the software but only the license to use it.
@PlywoodStick No way to touch any of that part from usermode none of the dangerous things are possible. (Same way you cannot just copy downloads as it is from someone elses 3DS to your sdcard). Absolute worst thing that could happen is the sdcard gets corrupt (Can be put back in and the stuff downloaded again no problem whatsoever).
@BensonUii yeah o.k. That still sounds like a bunch of donkey diarrhea to me. We can argue all day if you want to because that is exactly what's coming out of your mouth.
This comment section ... full of ignorant folks. Allow me to enlighten you.
This does NOT open the gates to piracy. Those were opened YEARS ago by a certain 3DS Flashcart. Those who really want to pirate are already able to do so. (And it's often due to their INABILITY to play certain games, i.e. Japan-exclusives, or games unavailable in their country. Several people have Gateway in order to play Flipnote Studio 3D for example.)
Also, I'm of the opinion that emulators of old ROMs shouldn't be considered piracy. It's illegal now, technically, but why should Nintendo be able to perpetually profit from ancient games? Games over 15-20 years old should definitely be fair game. This is just an opinion, and it hasn't stopped me from buying a few games from the VC.
But aside from emulators (a light-gray area), this exploit isn't powerful enough to launch ROMs. And it probably will never be. Especially since the firmware will block this out! In fact, smealum has received a lot of hate from the people who do want to pirate. /v/ calls him a moralf*g. And after reading this article I'm tempted to agree.
tl;dr Buy a Gateway card to use Flipnote Studio 3D, because pirates do what Ninntendon't.
Moral of the story: piracy is bad and Nintendo needs to release Virtual Boy and SNES games on 3ds...
@Grumblevolcano
Piracy has been available on 3DS for about a year or more now....
My 2DS is ready for this (I'll be keeping it offline only after I apply that exploit), but Cynic Ninja is too expensive now =_=
I get the Saddam Hussein from South Park feeling when he was just "baking cookies" in Heaven.
I would prefer it if Programmers just wrote proper Offically released Software for the 3DS. . . .
I wanted to put the homebrew channel on my spare 3ds but at the price cubic Ninja is at the moment most people are probably considering a flash cart to run cubic ninja to then run the exploit. Murky waters indeed but let's face it the people that want to do this probably accept there will be no more updates for there software.
@BensonUii i live in europe and european law states:
"A person having a right to use a computer program should not be prevented from performing acts necessary to observe, study or test the functioning of the program, provided that those acts do not infringe the copyright in the program."
"The authorisation of the rightholder shall not be required where reproduction of the code and translation of its form are indispensable to obtain the information necessary to achieve the interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs"
http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?qid=1416340060887&uri=CELEX:32009L0024
While this doesn't open the gates to piracy it is still exploiting the system in a way that Nintendo didn't intend and in violation of the EULA. No one that produced their own product and made a profit on that product would want someone exploiting it and making it perform in ways that they didn't specify was ok in the EULA. I'm not knocking piracy or homebrew but I still don't get why folks feel that either one of them are ok.
I know
this is a Usermode exploit which means that it has no access to the nintendo 3ds's kernel, as such it is IMPOSSIBLE to run pirated games using this exploit.
@Kaze_Memaryu Cheper than all the copies on eBay
@Noelemahc It's worse because there's already 3DS piracy...
@Sforzando THANK YOU. Sadly, most people will probably miss your post...
When homebrew is mostly about playing emulated ROMs - including DS emulators - it's really hard to say it's not about piracy. Yes, many emulators are for old games from NES, SNES, Mega/Genesis etc, but there are also ones for DS and GBA, which are 10 years and under. And considering most of these emulators as well as the other homebrew stuff can also be done on smartphones, I don't know what is the point of 3DS homebrew anyway.
Out of all the poeple here who play on emulators, is there one here who only ever plays games they already own on a different platform (which means different license required any so it's still illegal)?
I'm personally wondering what is Ubisoft's stance on this issue. After all, they're the ones who published the game in the retail space, although it is likely the developer's responsibility to re-release it on the eShop.
NINTENDO: you're seeing naturally evolved examples of disruptive innovation. I'm sorry to say, you're going about this the wrong way. This could give your systems a new lease of life: if you support and nurture homebrew, players will find uses for the hardware which you hadn't envisaged. Right now you're just recycling your back catalogue and flogging more pokemon. There are very few innovative titles on the horizon (S.T.E.A.M, Ironfall). At the rate you're releasing titles at the moment you won't compete with Sony and Microsoft. The eshop budgetware is a step in the right direction, but it's too little and too sporadic. Try something different- don't be afraid to work with users.
@caffeine_addict http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/207218/The_brick_wall_No_close_encounters_with_Nintendos_indie_exec.php
This article provides a pretty good indication of Nintendo's policies towards outsiders. (In other words, anyone who doesn't work directly under or for Nintendo.)
I know 2 people who do this. They run emulators an pc and 1 has ouya too. 1 of them still buys and plays games on lots of systems. The other does not. He hasn't paid to play or bought a game or system in like 3 years. I do not support him. He has a wii and hasn't even played skyward store yet. Too busy running Roms on his pc.
I have never tried doing stuff like this. If I ever did, I'd want a "ds" that runs emulators of old school games. But I'd buy a separate one. So Nintendo gets benifit of that, and when it comes down to it, I have 2 kids and I'm a huge gamer myself. I think nintendos future is looking ok.
If people want a platform to distribute their lousy excuses of a game for free, PC's offer everything needed. Homebrews are a waste of time, nothing good will ever come of it.
@PlywoodStick As a registered Indie for the WiiU myself, i can assure you it IS not that hard.
The only thing is that you have to pay for things like the DevKit and age ratings.
BUT you get that money back really fast, so yeah.
Still, even if it would be hard, there is no excuse to homebrew, None of the big three wants unlicensed Stuff on their devices, and if the reason is that they don't make mney out of that stuff, whats wrong with that?
It IS a company, and those run on money like a human runs on blood.
@Plywoodstick thanks for post, i found this part illuminating:
Sony and Microsoft are both funding indie games right now, and they're making a lot of noise about it. They're putting indies up on stage with them at every show, pushing them into the limelight. When you read articles about who "won" E3 2013, the answer was resoundingly Sony — the company's image was reassuringly human, and player- and developer-friendly, in part because of its huge indie push.
@Rief - wish there were more like you, doing what you do. At the moment Nintendo are doing their level best to kill their Mario brand by saturating their market with re-hashed releases. (Smash Bros is very slick- but it's preaching to the choir). Here you innovate or die. Seems from the above that Sony and Microsoft get that.
Homebrew: looking at the bottom line is important, but it's the old way of thinking. Just like marketing firms understand their message is now defined by the user, game companies should be unafraid to empower users. What if (taking this to its logical extreme) Anyone could write apps/games for the platform? Would that not (for a start) increase the size of the market? You have a small, powerful, 3D box (which communicates with others), with untapped AR potential. Set it free, Nintendo.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...