Lone Survivor:The Director's Cut seems to have arrived on the Wii U eShop as a sudden apparition; creeping unnaturally under the radar during a slew of indie title announcements that emerged from E3 this year. Now, Jasper Byrne's twisted horror is ready to infect your mind just in time for the Halloween season, and it will not go silently any longer.
Originally released for PC in 2012, the Director's Cut edition has been ported onto Wii U by Curve Studios, and features an impressive number of changes to fine-tune the experience. An entirely new lighting engine has been used, as well as updated or entirely new locations from the original, added music, and perhaps most importantly — additional endings. This is a survival horror in every sense of the term, as the player's chosen methods of keeping alive will have an ongoing effect on the protagonist's psyche. Multiple endings will tell different sides of the story, but the weight of these answers will rely on your every decision...
Waking up as an unnamed survivor only ever referred to as 'you', the story flows about as smoothly as the organic gore covering the walls of your apartment complex. What little you do know — that a terrible disease has ravaged your entire home city and left you isolated in your own room — is revealed quite early on, but the full extent of this epidemic is an ever-changing concept that rarely seems clear. It's a simple setup that's defined by the actual title of the game, but so much is left unsaid that questions will begin to pile up almost immediately. Initially this provides some welcome focus, as the first objective is simply to make your way down to the bottom floor. A seemingly straightforward mission such as this does a good job at allowing the player to get to grips with the gameplay mechanics.
Unsurprisingly, survival is at the forefront for the duration, and the individual needs that must be met just to keep going are a constant concern. Your character is scraping by in an immensely hostile environment, so will need to make sure he gets enough food and sleep to keep his strength up. On top of that, you'll need to stock up on very limited provisions for both your torch and a handgun, as well as investigate potential signs of other survivors hiding somewhere out there in the darkness — it's an exciting example of the genre that almost never lets the player feel like they're in control of the situation. Your surroundings can be scavenged and explored at your own pace, but there's an interesting duality between progression and keeping stock of supplies that doesn't ever allow you to take a breather.
While the radio and diary in your room will update to give the player a steer, for the most part you'll be left largely to your own devices. Much like in the popular Silent Hill series, the atmosphere is the main draw, and the claustrophobic hallways wreathed in darkness do an appropriately unnerving job at creating a foreboding environment. There are times when the only light is created by your personal torch, just barely picking out the disturbing details of your surroundings; similarly disturbing are the corpse-like monsters that now drag themselves around the building in search of meat. These faceless horrors need to be dealt with directly at times — as they often block your path — and this requires yet another decision to be made.You can either take care of the problem head-on and open fire, or do your best to sneak by, taking advantage of the shadows and using a limited stash of raw meat as a distraction.
Some stellar sound design really helps to make encounters like this memorable, as the creatures' mumbling erupts into a piercing roar once they've caught your scent. Even while merely traversing the city, ambient sounds wreak havoc on your nerves without apology. The hauntingly beautiful music composed by Jasper Byrne himself is also worthy of note, but the visuals are perhaps the most noticeable aspect of Lone Survivor's presentation. Rendered in a 2D, pixelated style, everything comes across as blurry and indistinct in all the right ways. While the retro graphical style has been seen countless times before, particularly with indie titles, here it's used effectively to convey a world that has become entirely alien and unfamiliar. The game will actually bend the rules of its own stylistic choice quite often, by bombarding the screen with otherworldly effects that stand out chillingly as a result.
It's safe to say that this all takes a toll on the sanity of our hero, and this has a startling effect on how the game plays out. To make another comparison to a genre icon, Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem featured an ambitious mechanic that accounted for how well you were coping with the events of the game. Reminiscent of that, Lone Survivor adds in the survival elements and very little combat to draw focus to the protagonist's mental state. Everything can whittle away at your confidence, be it spending too much time in the dark or overworking yourself in a single day, and while drugs can help sharpen your mind, they can also worsen the inevitable hallucinations. Rooms will shift and change throughout the game, characters can vanish in the blink of an eye, and it's never certain just what exactly is real.
The game world isn't particularly large, but you'll likely be revisiting areas as new information is revealed, mysterious figures demand meetings, and new paths are opened. Though everything operates on a 2D plane, the map system displays the building from a top-down perspective, and this can be confusing at first. Trying to visualize a flat corridor as anything more than simply that isn't immediately intuitive, but luckily your character will mark off locked doors and points of interest as you proceed, making it a bit easier.
You'll operate out of your own apartment, which can be accessed via a sort of fast-travel system, where peering into mirrors will cause you to arrive back home. It makes a strong case for the Wii U GamePad, which could have displayed the map at all times for reference, but sadly this isn't the case here; it could be argued as a design choice in this case, but the option would have been welcome. The controls work fine, with the possibility of assigning inventory 'hotkeys' a particularly nice feature, but with no other control options readily available it's a shame that the GamePad screen wasn't put to better use than simply mirroring the television.
That being said, playing at night in the total darkness of your room is a harrowing experience made possible by off-screen play, and as the game only lasts about 4-6 hours, it's something that could be experienced all in one spooky sitting. While this may seem disappointingly short, it can't be stressed just how worthwhile a second or even third playthrough can be, especially when everything is such a variable. A New Game+ mode adds in new items, dialogue, and of course additional endings as well, so this nightmare might just be one you revisit night after night...
Conclusion
With its 2D visuals and seemingly flat environments, Lone Survivor might seem like a simplistic take on the horror genre. Ultimately however, it's under the limitations of this simplicity that the game really shines, leaving just enough to the imagination without seeming too bare. Through the blurred lens of it's admittedly tired pixelated graphics, environments drip with atmosphere, creatures shamble along menacingly, and the search for answers is always compelling. Though it takes some getting used to, partly due to a baffling map system, the psychological horror of Lone Survivor can extend far beyond the confines of the television screen.
Comments 38
Your review is amazing @Squidzilla ! The score is a tad low, but your review is really detailed! Nice work.
I just wish it came out a week sooner. I could've included it with this year's "13 games of Halloween". Oh well, maybe next year. Sounds like a highly replayable game.
Just hate when they dont support ContPro since GamePad is just mirror.
Great review sort of sad not many Wiiu owner's haven't bought this yet.It looked like it sold poorly on the Eshop.But still it's amazing though, especially playing in the dark wearing headphones.
I just beat this game yesterday, it's really fantastic. I rarely get into horror but the atmosphere and sound design really got to me at points. And it rarely did it by being super annoying and unfun, which I appreciate since that usually kills my enjoyment of games like this.
Sounds like quite a bit of fun! I will likely end up getting it at some point!
I bought this on Vita but haven't played it too much yet. So far it's been pretty cool.
Might be the most satisfying use of off-TV on the eShop yet. Just don't forget the headphones. Highly recommended to any WiiU owners looking for a quick horror fix. It's a pretty interesting approximation of 2D Silent Hill-ish progression, so I'd mark it as a must play for any fans of that franchise.
Kinda wish it were meatier, with a real sinister turn at the end. I understand the navigational concerns are substantial, but a little extra oomph around the conclusion would go a long way towards making this an essential indie experience.
Literally picked this up earlier today. Really enjoying it so far.
@Neko_Rukiafan Thank you very much! Glad you enjoyed it.
I wish this had more reviews for Wii U on metacritic.
been waiting ages for this review, great review for a great game, i got it last week bloody gave me nightmares!!! just wish it had pro controller support.
This game looks amazing! I'll definitely be picking this game up once I am in need of a good creepy game. Bayonetta 2 just arrived so I'll be busy with that for quite a while though!
@midnafanboy How can you tell?
Well, I can't really speak for others, but I've gotta warn people not to get too wrapped up in the story. Because if you think Lost wrapped stuff up in a contrived, puzzling and deeply unsatisfying manner, you ain't seen nothing yet. If we're judging it simply as a game though, 8/10 is something I definitely agree with, in lieu of a decimal-based rating system. Not quite an 8 in my book.
Being a devout fan of pacifist runs, I've gotta say it's the best implementation of such a system as I've ever seen in an indie game, and it more than makes a strong case for itself viewed against other titles, too.
Shame no 3DS option.
@Emblem I got powers that you can never understand mortal,that's how i know.
I bought this last week on impulse and plan to start it soon..just hard to find the time to play all these games when im too busy watching Mickey mouse club house...👪
I think I'm going bankrupt in the next few weeks. Too many games I want, this one included.
@NbaJunkie Mickey Mouse Club House Road Rally. Seen it 1,000 times.
On a related note, I'm really considering this game. I enjoy a good survival horror, and I've never played one quite like this.
got this on ps3 a while ago and can't figure it out. corpse party is awesome on pstv
Will get this during a sale!
I played this with my brother on his ps vita!
As I constantly ask, why isn't this on 3DS?
@Whia1967
great SPAM, @NL
Anyways.. the game scored 3 points higher here than I had it on PC.
I find the game looks tired and the experience tends to shamble.
It's unnecessarily confusing, convoluted and even a bit pretentious.
It tries to be so much more than it ends up becoming. Another pixel fest of uninspired proportions.
The price, according to those I've talked with, is by far the most off-putting part of the game. It's more expensive than a Shovel Knight or a Steamworld Dig and that seems to be hurting sales.
1001 Spikes sold WAY more copies at 10.01$ than at 15$, in example.
This game is even more expensive than that. In fact, it's got the same price as NEW Remix 2. The competition undersold Lone Survivor, and provided more enjoyable experiences.
Played it when it originally came out for PC. The sound design and atmosphere are incredibly creepy.
Nintendo Life shows its value again! I'll add this to my "must-buy" list.
I played/beat this on PS3, and even for "free" on PS+, I didn't think the game was very good - definitely not an 8. I'd score it closer to 6. I think it was trying too hard to be creepy/weird, and in my opinion, a lot of it just wasn't very fun to play.
It's a fantastic game.. I've had it on Steam since it came out. I recommend this one to anyone!
Good to see no one throws a tantrum about the Wii U receiving this game years after PC and other consoles.
This is on my to-get list. I've heard too many good things about it. Anybody seen my time and money?
Fun game, sort of humerous.
aww, too bad, I'd have picked this up if it had a good map on the gamepad...will stick with my PC copy
Map? I've only ever played on hard, and never once missed it. My understanding is that the abstract map on offer is more confusing than using those good old' 2D mental compass honed during the 8-bit and 16-bit eras. I also enjoy the increased sense of unease before entering a doorway, not quite sure where it may lead.
To be clear, this is for survival horror fans. Does a vague representation of a 2D Silent Hill intrigue you? Those who are should definitely play it. Sadly, the game does little to impress anyone else who doesn't make that sort of correlation. Although, you could say it's a more condensed, approachable form of Survival Horror, so it could be an ideal tie-dipping for some.
Just make sure to curl up in a dark room with the Gamepad and headphones. And open up a window if it's not too cold. If there is a better way to play this game, I certainly haven't heard of it.
@Neko_Rukiafan 8 is low?
I loved this game.
I definitely need to check this out and I'm so late on this review.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...