Last week, following some suggestion on social media that 2020 was shaping up to be a poor one for Nintendo on current evidence, we asked you to tell us which year you thought was Nintendo's 'worst' out of the last thirty-five.
The results showed that 23% of the people who responded counted 2015 as the worst year for Nintendo. Five years ago, it has to be said that the company appeared to be in the doldrums: Wii U was performing poorly, software releases were few and far between, and not even the incredible muppet-style puppets of Iwata, Miyamoto and Reggie were able to save a lacklustre E3 showing. It should be noted that both Splatoon and Super Mario Maker released that year, but the passing of Satoru Iwata also took its toll on the company and its followers. A tough year, that's for sure.
it's clear that many people aren't satisfied with the games offering so far this year
According to the poll, 2016 wasn't much better, with Wii U limping along as development resources were diverted to the upcoming NX. However, coming in third place with 19% was 2020 - or more accurately, the first six months of 2020. As we said last week, it's certainly been a quiet one--and far less impressive if you're not an Animal Crossing fan--but we keenly remember the lean Wii U years and the software droughts of the N64 days (which, interestingly, caused nary a blip in the poll). Only seven months into 2020, first-party software is smashing sales records, and Nintendo is having trouble keeping up with demand for its console. Even if a significant section of the audience might not be impressed, the company accountants are no doubt content - especially given the difficulties people are currently facing across the globe. Still, it's clear that many people aren't satisfied with the games offering so far this year. Hopefully, Nintendo has some aces up its sleeve over the next five months.
So, now that the negative poll is done and dusted, this week we're asking you a cheerier question: What do you consider to be Nintendo's 'best' year? Again, how you define 'best' is entirely up to you: perhaps it was the launch year of your favourite console; maybe it delivered hit after incredible hit; perhaps you're just a colossal Luigi fan.
This time we've also highlighted some of each year's most prominent releases to help jog your memory when thinking back over the past three-and-a-half decades. Note, also, that all software listed below relates to its launch year in the US.
Thanks for voting! Let us know how you made your choice in the comments.
Comments (161)
The whole gamecube era
I'm split on either 1992 or 2017.
1996 and the release of the N64 was the MOST magical video game experience for me. I will never forget going to my friend's house and watching Mario moving around in 3d for the first time. It was right up there with playing Pokémon Red for the first time. Oh, and playing ffvii for the first time...Wow, late '90s just rocked.
Nothing beats BotW, Odyssey, and Splatoon 2 for me. So many good games that year!
I voted 2020 for Animal Crossing New Horizons
The first Nintendo game i played more than 5 hours everyday.
If we are talking just sheer importance, I would say 1989 because the GameBoy solidified Nintendo's hold on the games industry (and I ended up being a GameGear kid!). But for games released, 2017 hands down. Nintendo knew they had to knock it out of the park with the Switch's launch year and 2017 was absolutely insane. 2 of the best Zelda and Mario games? Splatoon 2? Not to mention solid 3rd party support? It was truly a crazy year. Now let's see if they can launch the Switch2 with Metroid Prime 4.....
As a child (born '87), every year felt like a great year for Nintendo until the WiiU era.
Best year for me is 2017. The year Nintendo reminded me and many others what Nintendo quality and innovation means.
@DanElectrode
1992 was an amazing year for 3rd party titles, too.
Objectively, my initial thought was 2017. They turned round from a dying console (3DS) and a dead console (Wii U) to a completely unprecedented success in the Switch with a stunning first year of software to boot. However, on a purely subjective note I had to go with 1996. The move to 3D with the N64 was phenomenal. It didn't look as rough as the ps1, and videos of the Battle of Hoth from Shadows of the Empire and spinning Bowser by the tail through 360 degrees were the stuff of dreams. While there have been better consoles and better games since, I've never been so excited for a whole era of gaming before or since than I was at the time of the N64, desperately waiting for the day when I could get one.
2017 was the first time since the GameCube I actually felt Nintendo was taking the core gaming crowd seriously again. Their lineup almost emulated what happened with Sony and the PS2 back in 2000. It was the first time I actually saw people in my social circle openly voice their love for Nintendo games again after the Wii/Wii U basically turned being a vocal Nintendo fan into the equivalent of coming out of the closet in the 80s.
2017 actually reinvigorated my interest in gaming. Switch is my favourite console ever (and I never thought I would say that about a contemporary console because nostalgia is a mighty beast!)
As incredible as 2017 panned out, I had to go for 1986: the year they effectively restored the home console market from the Crash and became a household name. None of the other years would have happened without the initial global success of the NES.
2017 for me, got my switch and had some amazing games along with it that year aswell, unlike this year which has been very poor and not a good sign.
Though 1998 came close. Being a 7 year old kid and finally getting to play pokemon red and blue (could of been 1999 for UK can't remember back then). And has probably been my most played game series
Easily, EASILY the announcement for Mario 3 they built into the movie "The Wizard," I still remember the energy from that moment, and how excited I was when I learned that Mario 3 was really a thing that was coming out, and not just staged for the movie. Good times.
I haven't touched my Switch in nearly 6 months, I'm surprised at how the excitement died off about that thing.
Meanwhile, I can boot up Mario 3 anytime, and 30 years later it still brings me enjoyment.
VERY hard to put that past the announcement of the SNES, that was and is still such a strong system.
I didn't think so many people would pick 2017. The nostalgia factor would be too strong, but damn. 2017 is killing it.
Unpopular opinion but I had a blast in 2014. Not only holdovers from a great 2013 but MK8, Captain Toad, Pokemon, Smash, Kirby Triple Deluxe... And I still maintain that Nintendo’s E3 2014 presentation is their best of the last decade.
Must be 1997, 2000 and 2017 for me personally.
1997 my brother and I got a N64 for Christmas, with Super Mario 64. Coming from the 16 bit era, this was a revolution. Still remember that magical Christmas Eve, removing the wrapper revealing the new console.
From 1999 and onward, I was a Pokémon fanatic and during the first part of 2000 I saved money for Pokémon Yellow, which I then got during the summer. The problem was that I didn't own a Game Boy at the time, but thankfully I could borrow one from a friend. But on Christmas Eve in 2000 I finally got a GB Color and was able to play Yellow in colour for the first time. Also magical! The beginning of my interest in handheld gaming.
And 2017 was the year when my girlfriend got me a Switch with Super Mario Odyssey for my 30th birthday. Wow! It totally reinvigorated my interest in modern video gaming and SMO brought back those childhood feelings of wonder and excitement when I played SM64 for the first time 20 years earlier. I also got BotW a week later, which now is my favorite Zelda game. And from 2017 and onwards my Switch collection has grown a lot. So much joy with that console!
Not surprised at all this poll was skewed for Switch/2017. Its the most recent and we have a lot of people now who can't say whether the NES/SNES/n64 times were good or not as it's just history to be read.
I voted for the early 90s. SNES was amazing, Nintendo had tons of 3rd party support, in my opinion better than even now. No old or scaled down ports (not putting those down), but they had many 3rd party exclusives, and with multi-plats the Nintendo version was often the superior version. Nintendo themselves cranking out awesome games, expanding on past games and concepts. The Game Boy was established as the king of handheld, beating out much more powerful (and colour) rivals. It was a golden era for Nintendo.
As a notable mention, I don't know if it was their best year or not, but one of the most important was when they resurrected the entire gaming industry with the NES.
Wow 2017 is so ahead
But yep, Switch launch + BotW + Mario Odyssey, years can't get much better than that
2017 has some of my favorite games of all time, so I chose that. Runner up would be 1998 for me.
@Slowdive Totally agree!
I guess I answered a different question. 1989 with GB Tetris may not have been a great individual year, but what an impact that year would have on Nintendo’s future.
Tons of great games in there but I don't think any others top 2017. New, amazing, game changing system release and 2 flat out masterpieces within 6 no ths I believe. Legendary
I picked 2020 because NL is becoming MyNintendoNews, where the contributors are as big trolls as some of the commenters. That's just my way of saying this site is going down hill.
It's honestly tough to pick a "best" year, though. Maybe 2017, but that is even highly debatable. 2007 was a great year, same with 1998. I guess it's really 2017, but I'm still reluctant to call it.
2017 was so far the best year for Nintendo, i have never see Nintendo release so many games of the highest calibre in a single consiquent basis followed closely by 2019, 2017 was also the year Nintendo have two of it game fighting for the GOTY to take home, we have the best Legend of Zelda and Mario so far in 2017, the anouncemt of two big games we hope still release for Switch(Metroid Prime 4 and Bayonetta 3) and a excelent port game of a Wii U game(Mario Kart 8 Deluxe) that is still the highest/best selling Switch game, but Animal Crossing New Horizons may become the highest/best selling Switch game at the end of 2020 beginning of 2021.
So many iconic years
I just instantly clicked 2017 without even bothering to look at the other years first. It's unbeatable.
Personally I believed it was the wii but I’m sure this pandemic has boosted sales of the switch
It’s hard for me to vote on this American poll, but the second to fourth year of the NES era as well as the first two of the SNES era should be right up there in any region.
1994 saw the release of my two favorite games of all time, plus several other strong contenders. I have to vote for it.
Super Metroid, Final Fantasy III/VI, Mega Man X, Donkey Kong '94 (GB), and Donkey Kong Country is quite the lineup, not to mention stuff like Earthworm Jim and Sonic 3/Knuckles.
2013 was my personal favourite year
I picked 2000. Perfect Dark, Banjo Tooie and Majoras Mask add up to one epic year.
Tough choice but I went with 1988.
@Anti-Matter
But when you play it you cheat by time travelling 😡
I think you'll find that Super Mario Bros 3 released in Europe in 1991!
While I can’t yet say Switch is better than SNES, as far as single years go 2017 was amazing. Plus it brought me back into the Nintendo Universe as before ‘17 the previous Nintendo game I played was way back in 2010
2017 was a great year but I had to go with 96. Mario 64 blew me away...
I understand the poll is focused on nintendo, but 1993 will always be the beat year in video gaming history for me. A big part of it is the snes. 1988 is a close second. 2019 is a distant third
1990 to 2002 for me xxx
2017 was the industry's best single year to date in terms of high-quality game releases. Nintendo was dropping bombs left and right. Capcom revived Resident Evil. Atlus dropped the fantastic Persona 5. S-E released the excellent NieR: Automata. Sony had Horizon Zero Dawn, which is probably their best new IP this gen. Even poor, beleaguered Xbox One saw its best (temporary) exclusive release in the form of Cuphead. And I keep going back and finding more excellent 2017 releases that I didn't have time for that year.
I understand why people would vote 2017, but I voted 2006. The Wii phenomenon was truly a cultural marvel. I remember everyone I knew wanted their hands on one, everyone was playing Wii Sports, it was truly one of a kind.
I know the Switch is successful and there's been some great games, but it felt like the Wii was all I was hearing about when it arrived.
A lot of good Nintendo years as a someone who started with the SNES. 2017 stands out though. The Switch is a fantastic console and it launched alongside now my favorite game of all-time, Breath of the Wild. Mario Odyssey and Xenoblade 2 were also excellent games.
I had to go with 2017. BotW, Odyssey, & Xenoblade Chronicles 2 are still some of the system's best exclusives, and I enjoyed some of the smaller titles too, like Fire Emblem Warriors & Shantae: 1/2 Genie Hero.
I loved growing up with NES, SNES, GB, N64, & GBA, but the first three systems were hand me downs, and while I loved them I wasn't "there" for them during their prime, if that makes sense. As for the latter 2, while I again loved my time with them I still only got a few games a year each at the time & wasn't actively following gaming yet.
Really the only years that can compete with 2017 for me is around 2009-2010, when I got my first job and was really expanding my Wii & DS libraries in a way I hadn't been able to do before with my consoles. Also 2019 believe it or not (Astral Chain, Link's Awakening remake, & Luigi's Mansion 3 were all stellar, I again fell in love with FFX due to the HD remaster, & I enjoyed my time with Demon X Machina as well).
I debated picking 2014, but went with 2017. 2014 was arguably the Wii U's best year, though
2003 for Wind Waker and F-Zero GX. GameCube was a good console that was at least on par with the competition, combined with genius-level software design.
If I'm being objective--albeit not including the years I'm not old enough to remember as a 20-year-old--I would probably have to say 2017, which is what I voted for.
But from a personal standpoint, I might honestly have to give it to last year. 2019 had SO many great first- and third-party Switch games that I absolutely adored like Super Mario Maker 2, Cuphead, Dragon Quest XI, Spyro, Crash Team Racing, A Hat in Time, Link's Awakening, Yoshi's Woolly World, the SNES Online app, Overwatch, and probably more I'm forgetting. (Luigi's Mansion was also a big deal, even if my feelings on it were mixed.) It was crazy, from like August onward, there was a new must-have game coming out for me every other week!
This year's been quite the lull, but so was 2018 outside of Smash and Crash Bandicoot, which were bombshell announcements for me. If this year ends with another bombshell game for the Holidays that leads into another amazing year, I'm fine with this year not being that great.
Best Consoles' Year (in general): 1998
Best Nintendo's Year: 2017
Switch launch, Zelda BotW (best Nintendo game ever), Metroid 2D, Mario Odyssey, Fire Emblem Echoes, Xenoblade 2, Mario & Rabbids, Splatoon 2, Skyrim, Doom,...
PS: I love 2003 as well, as it's the year I step aside Playstation and became a fan of Nintendo, with Wind Waker and so, but truth be told, 2017 was better.
The glory years for me would be the '93-'95 time span - '95 having my all-time favorite game (Chrono Trigger), and '93 having my favorite Zelda (Link's Awakening). So I split the difference and picked '94 - which also had Super Metroid, an absolute masterpiece (coming from someone who otherwise isn't really a Netflix fan).
No big surprise that the year of the Switch and BotW dominated the poll, though - could've predicted that.
The end of NES and beginning of SNES era. Nintendo was dominating and created quality game after quality game.
I'm shocked that SMB3 only got 2%. It had a HUGE impact on the industry and they made a toys, cartoons, big screen movie and everyone talked about SMB3. It was massive and everywhere.
2017 easily for me. Depending on how you rank such a thing OBJECTIVELY, maybe it's a year in the 90s, but subjectively for me 2017 was amazing. Splatoon 2 and BotW really put it over the top for me, Mario Odysseys and XBC2 are total cherries on top. The year had surprises too, like ARMS and Kingdom Battle (Nintendo didn't make it but it was born out of them actually incentivizing a 3rd party). The release schedule was perfectly spaced out too. Throw in excellent ports of older BUT NOT ARCHAIC games like Resident Evil Revelations 2 and Doom, random fun stuff like Fire Emblem Warriors and a port of Mario Kart that fixed the battle mode and wowee. Has taken me a couple years to come down from that high.
@Giancarlothomaz 2019 wasn't imo that close on the heels of 2017 because the release schedule was whack af. It wasn't until the end of June that year that things started to get cooking. After that the titles they released for the most part were "caveat" games. Meaning, really good games with some kind of BIG BUT about them. FE3H is the best game ever tho, lol. So good.
2017 was to be expected, and not just for Nintendo. It was an incredible year in video game history with Horizon Zero Dawn, NieR Automata and many more.
2017 was a great year.
I enjoyed 2014 too
Wow, I honestly thought that 2006/2007 would be voted higher, given the Wii just launched and was quite popular at the time.
@Kwehst Me to, i still have my N64. I know the first time i booted Mario 64 and hearing Mario's voice for the first time, amazing! But i also remeber the first time i powered my N64 with Ocarina of Time... the first time i laid my eyes on Hyrule field.... it was magical at the time.
I voted in 1998 because Pokémon Red / Blue and Ocarina of Time were two games that marked my childhood; among the other games launched that year in the West I have also played a lot of Mario Party, F-Zero X and World Cup 98.
In a more impartial analysis, however, I agree with the overwhelming majority that elected 2017 as the best year of launches. New console (Switch) with highly anticipated Mario and Zelda games, and still had the ports of Mario Kart 8, Skyrim and Disgaea 5.
It's-a me, Mario!
So 1996.
1990.
Actually, the years 88-91. I know many readers weren't alive during this time, but the overall buzz in pop culture about Nintendo was something impressive. There were clothes, toys, cartoons, there was even a mario-themed Kraft Dinner and Nintendo cereal. There were pinball games, posters, Nintendo Power. Absolutely everything was nintendo, and they even made a movie in the midst of the hype. The stores had entire sections just for nintendo stuff, demos, it was incredible; a child's wonderland. And its siginficance was that it was the 1st time it happened. All the upturns in Nintendo's success that happened in the future--and in terms of overall numbers, probably greater than 1990--came as an already established brand. those 88-91 years were the ones that turned Nintendo into a worldwide behemoth.
Dear 19%, I thought the poll asked about "worst year for Nintendo", not the allegedly worst year for me or any of you. We are nothing but audiences with our sentiments and wallets completely replaceable. But by all means, continue to put your game addiction fevers on parade.🙄
That said, the new poll is also about Nintendo, so I feel ill-equipped to vote. I could easily pick the release years of Switch or NDS as definitive milestones incidentally aligning with the mention of my two all-time top favourite consoles (before anyone in 3DS club boos at that, my affinity tends to view it as but a more evolved member of the DS clan, so it's accounted for). But were those objectively best years for Ninty itself, all things considered? I can't give a sufficiently researchful answer, so I'll pass.
For me it was either the SNES or N64 launches.
@micronean yep. I also voted for 89 Tetris. It was like Michael Jordan and The Beatles.
The Switch launch wasn't anything particularly special in and of itself outside of the anticipation for Breath of the Wild (which was also on Wii U)--very few people seriously expected it to do so well, it was coming off of the back of the huge flop that was the Wii U, and it was really only loyal fanboys who were truly excited by and lining up for it day one--although it did sell well and is of course still doing well now (and the first year overall was very solid in terms first party releases). But, when the likes of the SNES and N64 launched, those were truly noteworthy moments in the industry where almost everyone even remotely interested in gaming was eagerly anticipating and genuinely excited by their releases. Anyone who was around when the N64 launched with Mario 64 knows fine well almost nothing that's happened in this industry since then has even come close to that level of both hype and indeed living up to the the hype.
None of the others would have been possible w/o the NES pulling the gaming industry out of its slump.
2013 brought my favorite Pikmin game, but 2017 is also amazing
I'm offended you didn't start the chart back in their wooden toys era. 1900 ish. Those were the days.
From a quick wiki search:
The SNES' launch year [US] was actually made of the following first party titles: Super Mario World, F-Zero, Pilotwings, Sim City and Super Tennis. That's a very solid first party lineup for the year with two of the very best and defining games on the system in Super Mario World and F-Zero literally on launch day. And remember, Nintendo consoles back then also had truly brilliant third party support even in the first year, especially the SNES, so Nintendo didn't need to work quite so hard as it might these day to make the system's library truly great in that first year, which is why it put out less games in the launch year than I imagine it could have.
And the N64's launch year [US] was actually made of the following first party titles: Super Mario 64, Cruis'n USA, Killer Instinct Gold, Mario Kart 64, Pilotwings 64, Star Wars: Shadows of the Empire and Wave Race 64. Again, another pretty stellar first party lineup with a few of the very best games on the system in that first year.
The Switch' launch year [US] was actually made of the following first party titles: 1-2-Switch, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Arms, Flip Wars, Fire Emblem Warriors, Snipperclips, Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Splatoon 2, Pokkén Tournament DX, Xenoblade Chronicles 2, Super Mario Odyssey. A extremely strong lineup--I mean really--with many of the system's best titles in the first year.
I don’t know where I’d start picking Nintendo’s best year.
If I chose based on financial success, it would be one of the years when the Wii and DS Lite were selling like hot cakes. Nothing has come close to those years, probably never will.
If I chose based on games, it would have to be a year from the 90s during the SNES or N64 era. The innovation in the games Nintendo pumped out during those years has never been superseded. Pretty much every Nintendo game since is just an iteration on games from that period.
If I chose based on impact, it would have to be a year from the 80s during the Famicom and Game Boy. They pretty much invented the phenomenon of gaming as we know it today, and created the handheld market too.
If I chose based on an arbitrary reason such as the year their current console released, I’d choose 2017.
I’m sure there’s a great deal of recency bias here - but still can’t look past 2017. Gave serious consideration to 1992 and 1998, but it’s still not really a fair contest.
Wow, Pocket Card Jockey was cited as an outstanding work in 2016? Not even Kirby: Planet Robobot or Tokyo Mirage Sessions?
2017 really did cover everything. Switch titles aside, it brought a Fire Emblem, three small Kirbys, and even a 2D Metroid. Too good to pass up.
Much as I want to say 1991 for the SNES (and for me personally, Yoshi's introduction), I really have to go with 1998 because not only did it launch one of the most beloved games of all time in Zelda: Ocarina of Time, but it also launched what is currently one of the top franchises in not only gaming, but also entertainment history as a whole with Pokémon.
That said, 2017.. I think people are giving that year a little too much credit. Yes it was an incredible year that I look back on very fondly but it's not really the best year they've had. However, if you don't look at what each of the installments did for the future (like Pokémon Red/Blue launching an entire juggernaut following), then 2017 is indeed a strong contender. But I like looking ahead at what the year did for the company in the longer run, and in that instance I don't think 2017 can quite compete with 1998.
2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2010 and 2017 are Nintendo's best years to me...and of those six, I'm going with 2005. 2005 has Animal Crossing: Wild World, Mario Kart DS, Nintendogs, Meteos, Metroid Prime Pinball, WarioWare: Touched!, Super Mario Strikers, Donkey Kong Jungle Beat and Partners In Time.
I would have liked to vote for n64/DS together, Nintendo had the best writing in their games on those consoles.
@DanElectrode they had plenty of good years but 2017 has to be the best one so far.
Had BOTW been a Wii U exclusive, it would have helped sell more Wii U consoles. However, Nintendo made the right call to have it dual release with the Switch on launch day.
2000 for me ! My favorite Zelda and Pokemon of all time!
2017 is a great pick and everything, but I really think recency bias is really taking over this poll. 1994, 1998, 2004, and 2007 all matchup to 2017.
@Tandy255 even if they just release botw on the wii u it wouldnt change the outcome of the wii u demise since its sales were quite poor to a point beyond saving.
The correct answer would be 1889, since then the company was founded.
@impurekind, are those lists supposed to have all first party launch year games?
Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Mario + Rabbids, Super Mario Odyssey, & Xenoblade Chronicles 2 also all launched in the Switch's first year in the US as well.
@RiasGremory If you go by the EU release dates, Super Mario World and Link to the Past were both 1992, so I think I'd call that a tie 😋.
But if you go by the Japanese or American dates, they were in different years, and 2017 is the only year they've ever released arguably-best-in-series games for both Mario and Zelda.
So yeah, I think I've gotta go 2017.
Financially speaking the year wii launch, a grown up zelda and all that stuff. for me and for a lot of others 2017, the year i came back to Nintendo consoles with a machine whose gimmick actually does something useful
@Hagemaru that’s the game I got the most hours in on the switch! 1475!
@DanElectrode "I'm split on either 1992 or 2017."
Me too! I went with 1992. What a year. Mario Kart AND Link to the Past!?
@TG16_IS_BAE I feel like the Wizard was specifically made just to announce SMB3 for the US lol
They made such a big deal out of it and the NES in the film. If only they actually put that much effort into the script
2001. It had my favorite game of all time (even today) Paper Mario on N64, Mario Party 3, Luigi's Mansion, and Super Smash Bros Melee (still the best Smash Bros game in my book for reasons unrelated to nostalgia and "techs").
"23% of the people who responded counted 2015 as the worst year for Nintendo."
Worst for the 3DS, sure, but the Wii U was definitely decently good that year, even with Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash and Animal Crossing: amiibo Festival released that year. The 3DS, on the other hand, barely had anything and many of the games released that year were questionable in quality at best (i.e. Codename STEAM, Chibi-Robo: Zip Lash, Animal Crossing: Happy Home Designer, etc.).
Literally the only two redeeming qualities that year for me on the 3DS were The Legend of Dark Witch 2 (my 2015 GOTY) and Hatsune Miku: Project Mirai DX.
2013 brought me personally the most joy. The games that year and the year prior were incredible.
say wat you well about this year being slow which i blame the virus 100% but still had some great games for switch so far this year mostly rpgs and animal crossing but could be more coming or the reminder of 2020 if nothing gets push back of course......Still waiting for doom eternal release date for switch.
Probably not the best year for Nintendo, but I have a real fondness for 2003. I don't think I liked both Nintendo games and games I played on Nintendo in general, more consistently, more than that year. Especially since its when I fully fell in love with technically not 2003 games, Smash Bros. Melee and Metroid Prime, which are both in my top 5 favorite games. Those and Sonic Mega Collection ruled my year along with all the actual 2003 Nintendo games.
That was also the year of Warioware, Viewtiful Joe, 3 great racing games on GCN (4 if you count Need for Speed Underground), my favorite post-Genesis 2d Sonic in Advance 2, SSX 3, Beyond Good and Evil, Wind Waker, Def Jam Vendetta, the super underrated Ultimate Muscle video game, Tony Hawk's Underground, Prince of Persia: Sands of Time, Mario and Luigi, Simpsons Hit and Run, Freedom Fighters, Rayman 3, Astro Boy Omega Factor, Castlevania Aria of Sorrow, Advance Wars 2, Final Fantasy Tactics Advance, Golden Sun: The Lost Age. Just tons and tons of games I didn't just like, but genuinely loved.
This was also the first full year I had internet at home and the first year I experienced E3 beyond a gaming magazine covering it. It was also the year of X-play, so I was all into gaming at that point. Wonderful year.
For me it all started in 1996 with the N64 and Mario. It had the wow factor, and it never got better than that.
Although 2011 came close with the 3ds and Ocarina of Time.
Earthbound and Yoshi’s Island alone are enough to make me say 1995.
2017 by far. Two of their best games of all time and Splatoon 2 and XC2?
I would have to say 98 for nostalgic reasons, that is when Nintendo was really getting in their prime and coming out with some truly memorable stuff that was unique for the time.
Breath of the wild was a great time but I have to go with 1995. I find myself revisiting Chrono trigger, Donkey kong country 2, earthbound and yoshi's island again and again. 95 also had mega man x2, mega man 7, breath of fire 2, castlevania x , Hagane and many other classics. 91 pretty good too
97 was the best year for nintendo because of rare.... pretty much any rare game on nintendo was awesome, only ones I kept.
In all fairness, the only people who should be allowed to vote are those who were around for all of the voting options.
I voted 1996 because it was when it became really clear how far superior in consoles they had become to Sega. They won their first war and were gearing up for more competition
Man, this is nearly impossible for me, although I've not played many Nintendo games on release past years their games that I have played were pretty solid and sometimes even suprisingly so (looking at you super mario 3D land) and some slightly dissapointing (I still wanna finish you but I have to get over my hate for your crappy weapon duration BotW)
I have crazy love for the SNES though Donkey Kong country and Super Metroid are two of my favorite games but then I also love both most Zelda games and there are some rocksolid GBA and DS games not to mention Gamecube, Wii and well ehm.. those WiiU remakes on switch...
All years are good Nintendo years because if you feel a new release is not for you, revisit and old classic or play one you never had in the past and maybe next year that release will come.
As someone born in 1985, my whole life is Nintendo years!
C'mon, everyone knows that the year SMW was released was the best year ever
Beating the year the two biggest franchises released their best games in over a decade its hard to do. But I really liked the year of Luigi, seemed like a great year in a pretty meh period of Nintendo!
Best, day switch came out. Best console ever and can only be topped by better versions that are always backwards compatible. Worst year, not in my lifetime, as long as I have a Nintendo console to play, which has been the majority of my 38 years
@impurekind
Why did you ignore Mario Odyssey, Splatoon 2 and Xenoblade 2 from 2017?
2013 was a great year for the 3DS!
The problem is most people are going to answer this question as "What year has your favorite game" rather than the more intended "Which year did Nintendo do the best in putting out a lineup of great products".
I voted for 2015 as the worst year before someone reminded me that Xenoblade Chronicles X came out that year. 2016 was probably worse
Best year, though? Too many for me to pick one.
@electrolite77 Dunno, maybe they didn't pop up on the list or something. You sure they were 2017 and not 2018 or something?
Edit: Ah, I see, the list was split into two parts and I only saw the first part. So, yeah, Switch' first year was very solid indeed.
@RR529 Seems I didn't see all these games on the list or something.
Edit: Ah, I see, the list was split into two parts and I only saw the first part. So, yeah, Switch' first year was very solid indeed.
I'd have to go with 2014. Tropical Freeze, MK8, Hyrule Warriors, Smash Wii U, MK8 actually getting DLC, the best E3, GBA games for VC allowing me to experience more Fire Emblem games, etc. meanwhile 3DS had an ok year.
I'd probably have given it to 2017 if BotW was a good Zelda game and Nintendo didn't ditch VC in favour of a garbage paid online service though.
@impurekind Man, your lists are all kinds of incorrect. Factually and your stated opinions. I'm not sure if you've played Pilot Wings or Sim City, but they both sucked on SNES. It wasn't a good launch year and because of that, Genesis was able to make even more headway.
Also, your Switch launch year lineup is missing tons of games. Pokken Tournament, Snipperclips, Super Mario Odyssey, Xenoblade 2, Mario + Rabbids: Kingdom Battle, Splatoon 2. Literally, all of those games are PHENOMENAL except Pokken, which is mediocre. There are millions of fans that think Xenoblade 2, Mario + Rabbids, Super Mario Odyssey and Splatoon 2 are God tier games and better than Breath of the Wild. I'm not sure if you deliberately left them off to make it look worse or just made a mistake, but Wikipedia definitely lists all of those as well.
Oh and *****, I almost forgot but there was Mario Kart 8 Deluxe and that's literally the best selling game on the entire system.
@Grumblevolcano Breath of the Wild is a good Zelda game and paid online didn't exist in 2017.
Online play was free. Seems like bad reasons to count the entire year out on reasons that aren't really accurate.
2000- because Majora's mask is my favorite game of all time, and it had paper mario that is my 2nd favorite game of all time, and pokemon gold and silver, is my favorite pokemon game.
For handheld it was 1998. N64 on the other hand was a failure so its either 2006 or 2017.. I'm surprised so little thought wiimania was the best year....
@Deltath I wasn't impressed with BotW and the online point was the about the announcement. Everyone was expecting VC to return and Switch to have a very strong retro library but then in January 2017 Nintendo announced that NSO was getting monthly classic games and later on in 2017 Nintendo confirmed that NSO was a replacement to VC and all hopes faded of Switch having a decent retro library.
If you are fortunate enough to be as old as I, then you witnessed the crossover from arcades in the stores to arcade at home in 1986. Seeing almost perfect replicas (so we thought at the time) was unbelievable for us. A memory I’ll never forget nor do I believe will ever be matched - although Mario 64 gave it a good shot.
It’s definitely not this year
@Deltath I've updated the games lists (didn't realize I'd missed those games).
I still think the other two consoles were far more hyped and anticipated and indeed had a much bigger impact in their first year though (and probably lasting too), especially the N64 with Mario 64 at launch, which just blew people's minds when that combination of paradigm-shifting console, controller and game software came out.
The Switch is very cool for what it is though.
I'm glad that 2017 is the unanimous winner. 2017 was definitely the best year of Nintendo for me. The Switch hit the ground running and has only just slowed down because of the pandemic.
@impurekind I don't really think being more hyped and anticipated equals anything meaningful, though. The SNES had somewhat of a rocky launch and first year. It wasn't the market shattering hit Nintendo hoped for. It turned into the best console of all time, in my opinion, but not in the first year. And the N64 was mostly a failure. It came screaming out of the gate with one good title and virtually nothing else. The controller and the console didn't shift any paradigm. In fact, both were historically proven to be bad choices. The controllers broke easily and caused blistering pretty easily with the joystick and the layout was awkward and uncomfortable, that's why literally no one, including Nintendo, ever tried to mimic that style again. And the system was notoriously limited. Hard to program for, had storage issues, even though in some ways it was more powerful than the PlayStation, it's inability to do CD audio, have enough storage or run the same kind of FMVs heavily limited ports.
The Switch on the other hand was underhyped but over delivered. It had the fastest selling first year of any console ever and truly did deliver a paradigm shifting console and controllers, giving people a new way to play and followed with the strongest launch year of titles Nintendo has ever produced. And if we're saying the full year by their financial standards, that also includes the Bayonetta Collection and Kirby Star Allies, because they both released before the end of Nintendo's first fiscal year.
Now, I adored the NES, SNES and 64 when they launched. But looking back at the hype versus the reality, it's hard to say the Switch doesn't win outright. It brought me back to Nintendo, too, after I stopped buying Nintendo with the Wii and Wii U eras.
@Grumblevolcano It's hard for me to be upset about NSO. I already own all the VC games I'll probably ever want to buy on previous systems. NSO has 100 some titles, many great games, which I don't have to buy but get to play anyway. And a lot are ones I probably never would have purchased, like Balloon Fight or any Kirby game (aside from Dream Course), but I've enjoyed playing through them at a rate of $5 a year on a family plan.
Probably the only complaint I'd level is I wish I could have the original Paper Mario on Switch as well as a few GBA titles, including Bomberman Tournament and Minish Cap.
I'd say 1994-1996 were great years in terms of game quality.
HOWEVER, in America we had to endure Nintendo's worst marketing years. "Play it Loud!" was so awful it a giant negative. It was painful to see such good games get such disgusting advertising. (People would rightly argue EarthBound might have been the game most adversely affected.)
@dartmonkey NSMB was 2006 (unless the PAL region release was significantly delayed from NA?). Can still recall making the unfortunate GameStop lady what while I was one of those jerks who counts out like $10 in quarters as part of the cash payment for the game on release day.
@TheFrenchiestFry Hey, the script was 90's bad, which is so bad it's good OK
1998 or 2017!
I love the SNES era and its games, but since we're looking at individual years, I gotta say that 1998 with F-Zero X, Ocarina of Time and Pokémon R/B is pretty killer! Objectively speaking 2017 was absolutely stunning! That year single-handedly set the expectations for the entire Switch generation way too high.
Thanks for adding high level milestones. I’m just concerned that I thought the year of Luigi was 2018. I’m 5 years off. Time flies.
The organ droned, and the Magitek armor crunched through the snow. The rain poured as Samus descended again into the barren rock of Zebes - and I felt for a moment as if I was walking on my own grave. Sony's S-SMP rocked as X, so large and tactile and dynamic, fell nonetheless, even while looking up to robots still newer and more powerful. Unbeknownst to me, Mother 2 captivated millions in Japan.
And though I heard tell of the Country of a big dumb ape whom I would much later grow to admire, I paid no heed, because... 1994 was the year I first kissed a girl.
This poll should be named "How old are you?"
I’ll admit I’m biased, but I chose 1987. That’s the year I played the neighbor’s Nintendo and decided I needed to have one. It’s been all downhill ever since.
I said 2019 but I didn't play the game right. I have been loving the Switch so far and I feel that Nintendo has released some of the best entries for a lot of their IPs on the Switch. 2019 may not have had my favorite releases of all time but they still had some solid releases plus most things the released in previous years for the Switch are still readily available in stores and on the eshop, but you couldn't get everything in 2018 that you can in 2019 😉. I would have picked 2020 if the year was already over but for all I know by the end of 2020 Nintendo will suddenly close their doors. Unlikely but I can't commit to saying it's the best year yet.
Also a lot of my all time favorite games were on the super Nintendo and suddenly I could play a lot of them on the Switch in 2019 so that also was a main reason I picked that year.
I said 1996 simply because of N64 and some of the best games on SNES. Runner ups are 1991 and 2017 though.
Damn, man. What a ride.
My top five:
1. 1998
2. 1997
3. 1989
4. 2017
5. 1990
Glad many here are not forgetting the GBA. Metroid Fusion and Metroid Zero Mission were great!
Can't take all these little kids going for 2017 serious.
Super Mario Odyssey dragged me back into modern gaming... I was perfectly content collecting old games until that thing released... (Now my Switch backlog alone is ridiculous.)
So even though 1996 might have been the most mind-blowing for some of us older gamers... I had to give it to 2017 like most others.
@KingMike I've edited the poll and switched it to 2006. Cheers
Voted for 2017. The first console I was actually able to get on release day was the 3DS and that was amazing, but after that I remember there not being many games I wanted for a long time. With the Switch we immediately had Breath of the Wild, and a more powerful handheld, and idk I just love the Switch. Seems like I missed out on a lot of good years though.
Majoras Mask, YES!
2000 for sure, was 17 and still full of expectations.
@Kwehst
Same experience here. Very glad i grow up with these gems
@Freddyfred and yet it almost bombed
@Bunkerneath i was 16! cool!
@PlanetaryNebulae the only launch i ever got was GBA. switch i got a year later, ps4 5 years later.
@impurekind
👍👍
1992, Link and Mario Kart were both genre redefining titles.
@Kwehst Are you me? I had the exact same experience in the late 90s with those same games. Nostalgia!
I'm pretty awful and remembering stuff like this, but I saw that the commercial success that was the DS and the greatest game of all time, Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door released in the same year, 2004. Therefore it's Nintendo's Best Year, lol.
I must've been around 10 years old at the time, and right in the middle of enjoying the best years of my life, the Gamecube era!
2017 for sure. BotW and Mario Odyssey in the same year makes it not even a contest.
I voted 2001, so many amazing games.
I would count the original releases for every game, though. Pokémon Red/Green was released in 1996, not 1998, and Gold/Silver was released in 1999, not 2000, among others. Zelda was 86, Zelda 2 was 87, Wind Waker was 2002, etc.
1991 and 2017.
I have unimaginable, amazing memories of many of these years, all the way back to when my Great Uncle bought us our first NES. And of course, many of these years stand out more than others.
But I had to pick 2006. The Wii revolutionized gaming as a whole, not just Nintendo, bring motion controls to the home at a reasonable price. Add in NSMB and Twilight Princess and you have a special year for the industry.
Of course, 2017 was close... but not as revolutionary as 2006, in my opinion.
Lots of great years... but voted 1992, since it established 2 core francihises, was the start of expansion of the snes marktrt. Mario stepping out of his game for the first time... oh and senaible soccer on the amiga
I voted for 1987, but the results say that zero people voted for 1987.
I'd say 1990 as it was the year of the SFC and Mario World not 1991.
Since this is a UK site, surprised they didn't use 1992 as the SNES launch year.
@JohnnyC yeah, Splatoon pretty much flopped in 2015.
Launch of the nes. Without that the landscape of video games would have been vastly different.
2006 for me. Having a mega drive and not getting a new console til 2000 made the 3d jump less appealing but I'd never seen anything like the build up to the Wii. From an amazing E3 to the constant adverts It was great.
And it is far from the best in the series but seeing Twilight Princess in action was epic. And games like Warioware, Excite Truck and of course Wii Sports were incredible to see for the first time.
It really was a great year but looks like a lot of the voters are more into recent years, which is cool, but I hope we will see more votes for the older years.
2005, Yoshi Touch & Go, Nintendogs, Partners in Time, Chibi Robo, Mario Strikers...
2006 and the Wii for me. Having the confidence to go up against technically superior HD consoles with similar hardware to the Gamecube except for different controllers is astounding.
@Deltath Eh, the SNES sold out at launch and came with arguably the greatest platformer of all time (literally bundled in with the console for free in America and Europe) as well as one of the very best and indeed genre-defining racers of the time on launch day, and then had an amazing launch year in terms of very solid first party support and truly superb third party support. The hype for the system was huge and on all accounts it delivered.
*"It was an instant success; Nintendo's initial shipment of 300,000 units sold out within hours, and the resulting social disturbance led the Japanese government to ask video game manufacturers to schedule future console releases on weekends. The system's release also gained the attention of the Yakuza, leading to a decision to ship the devices at night to avoid robbery." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Nintendo_Entertainment_System#Launch
And the N64 literally gave us a controller with multi-configuration capability (could be held in 3 different ways depending on the games, and more if you consider GoldenEye's dual analog control option too), analog control, rumble and 4-player functionality built-in, along with the first true example of cutting-edge 3D graphics combined with proper 3D control/input (Mario 64), which absolutely was genre defining in its day. And Mario 64 still stands as probably thee most groundbreaking, paradigm-shifting, genre-defining and indeed both extremely-highly anticipated and delivered-on-the-hype launch game of any console in history.
PS. Your recollection of how the N64 controller was viewed is garbage and informed by a bunch of plonkers in today's "social" media who like to believe it was/is garbage when they couldn't be further from the truth. The only issue with the N64 controller was the analog sticks got a little wobbly over time (but they still tended to work totally fine regardless), and I guess you could say it was confusing for some people (more true for that same bunch of plonkers today rather than most gamers who actually used the thing back in the day). It's still one of thee most ergonomic and comfortable controllers to actually hold and use in the various positions (if you simply know how to hold it properly--which is not rocket science), despite what anyone else claims, and we're all still using analog sticks and rumble to this day.
Don't undersell what those systems achieved, because by almost every account they did more than Switch ever will (other than total sales). Switch is a decent console with some great games that's selling well, and that is it. But it's not some revolutionary or defining system like the SNES (which also gave us shoulder buttons and the diamond face-button configuration--still used on most controllers to this day) and N64 absolutely were. It hasn't changed or defined the industry in any meaningful long-term way in the slightest, unless you truly believe most consoles going forward are going to be some kind of dual handheld-homeTV systems and/or have some kind of attachable/detachable controllers (Hint: They're clearly not: Xbox Series X, PS5, new Atari VCS, Vive/Rift/Quest/Index, etc).
Mine has to be 1993 when I got the snes / streetfighter 2 bundle. Was still playing that game to death at the arcades and this just blew my mind... good times 😁
For me, personally, it was definitely right around the turn of the century. I was a huge Pokémon fanatic at that point, and Pokémon is what helped me get back into Nintendo’s fold (the NES was my first console (as well as Game Boy), but then I kinda fell out of Nintendo’s grasp for a while when a relative bought me a Sega Genesis (I never did have an SNES, but I always did want one just to play Super Mario World), and my parents got me a PlayStation for Christmas of ‘98 (they originally were going to get an N64, but the store salespeople where they bought my PlayStation at told them that the PlayStation has more games, so they took their word). so I had originally missed out on 2 of Nintendo’s consoles). Seeing Super Smash Bros. commercial made me not just want- but NEED- an N64. This time period was also when I met my best friends for life via us all being Pokémon fans and being in band together. 1999-2001 were arguably some of my happiest years with Nintendo (as well as the Game Cube era).
However, 2017 is definitely Nintendo’s best year overall.
Absolutely 2017.
2017: It has the best Pokemon game (Ultra Sun & Ultra Moon), the best Mario game (Super Mario Odyysey), and the best Zelda game (Breath of the Wild)
@Bolt_Strike And Ultra Sun & Ultra Moon
@AmongUsSussy USUM was mediocre, it was one step forward and one step backward from SM and SM wasn't that good to begin with (waaaaaay too linear and handholdy). Not one of the highlights of 2017.
Tap here to load 161 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...