25. Pokémon Ranger (DS)
Pokémon Ranger takes a while to get going — at times you'll feel like you are just walking from capture to capture, with little gameplay in between. The number of different Pokémon, their different attacks and figuring out when is best to draw those rings keeps things interesting, but it can get repetitive. Capture Challenges are enjoyable diversions and there's certainly entertainment to be had here, but ultimately this is a fun yet forgettable Pokémon spin-off.
24. Pokémon Art Academy (3DS)
Pokémon Art Academy is no gimmicky spin-off. It's a well-realized, totally engaging experience that will appeal to both the curious and long-term fans alike, and uses its host of versatile, recognizable characters to put across a broad range of styles and techniques. The lessons are enough to get anyone up and running, and with Miiverse it's easier to share your masterpieces online than ever before. Those who aren't interested in the subject matter may want to give this a miss, but tempting new additions to the mechanics and a healthy dose of charm should win over almost anyone eager to get drawing again.
23. Pokkén Tournament (Wii U)
Pokkén Tournament attempted to break into the fighting game genre with a bang, although it remains relatively niche. It stripped back unnecessary complexity from the controls which made it easy to pick-up-and-play, but with a skill ceiling that left hardcore fans with plenty of room to explore. The visuals could have been sharper — something that's also true for the only-slightly improved DX port on Switch — but these are grotesquely outweighed by the sheer polish and replayability of the core gameplay. As a lovechild of such disparate properties as Tekken and Pokémon, Pokkén Tournament was a spectacularly scrappy surprise.
22. Pokémon Puzzle League (N64)
Pokémon Puzzle League is really just Panel de Pon / Tetris Attack with a Pokemon makeover. That's not bad though, because it's still the same brilliant block puzzler. Panel de Pon fanatics will have the time of their lives regardless, but the Pokémon wrapper helps draw in and hold the attention of new players long enough for the puzzling to grab hold. With the added Pokémon anime nostalgia factor that's grown over the decades, there's even more reason to investigate Pokémon Puzzle League if it passed you by all those years ago. It's still the same old game, and it still rocks.
21. Pokkén Tournament DX (Switch)
This re-heated Wii U port, the unholy lovechild of Tekken and Pocket Monsters, is a Pokémon fan's dream come true. Rather than relying on turn-based combat to see who is the very best, you can take to a 3D arena and smash seven shades of poop out of a rival 'mon to finally decide once and for all who is (Nido)king or queen. Robust single and multiplayer options make Pokkén Tournament DX one of the most impressive competitive fighters on Switch, although the lack of mechanical depth may put off serious fighter fans.
20. Pokémon Stadium (N64)
Pokémon Stadium was a revolutionary step up for the monster-catching franchise, and that's not just due to the fact that we got to see all 151 critters in full-fledged 3D. The inclusion of the GB Tower, as well as allowing players to experience Pokémon characters in fun new ways through minigames and the Pokémon Lab, felt remarkably fresh and offered a new perspective on our repository of 'mons. Sure, the battling can get a bit repetitive and lengthy, but the awesome visuals, animations, and commentary can help keep this from becoming mundane. If you're playing this on NSO, you're of course limited to rental teams, but there's plenty to love here if you're an OG fan. And the Lickitung sushi minigame is ace.
19. Pokémon Puzzle Challenge (GBC)
Pokémon Puzzle Challenge is a deceptively meaty experience from Intelligent Systems, with plenty of content to keep you occupied for hours at a time, or you can simply dip into it every so often for a few minutes if that’s what you prefer. The Pokémon theme was hardly a necessity, but it gives the Challenge mode a bit more substance, and probably drew in a lot of people that might have otherwise overlooked this brilliant little puzzler.
18. Pokémon Pinball: Ruby & Sapphire (GBA)
Pokémon Pinball: Ruby & Sapphire is an enjoyable entry-level pinball game designed to appeal to as broad an audience as possible. Its colourful, charming visuals look great, and the vast number of Pokémon available to catch and evolve means that if you’re looking for a long-term dip-in, dip-out sort of game, you’ll have plenty to keep you occupied. It can become a bit tedious if played extensively, though, so it’s much better to enjoy it in short bursts.
17. PokéPark 2: Wonders Beyond (Wii)
PokéPark 2: Wonders Beyond is a simple game, but that's by no means a bad thing. The warm, welcoming graphics and fantastic music are the perfect frame for a game of this type. It's straightforward but it's fun, and at the end of the day that's all that really matters. Those who aren't Pokémon fans probably won't be as enamoured as those who can sing the Pokérap from memory, but for Pikachu's devoted followers, this is super effective.
16. Pokémon Pinball (GBC)
Built on the foundation of Kirby's Pinball Land from HAL Laboratory, the original Pokémon Pinball on Game Boy Color released back in 1999 and combined the fundamentals of pinball with the Pocket Monsters' mantra, Gotta Catch 'em All. Developed by Jupiter (the talented team pumping out Picross after Picross these days), it featured two tables — Red and Blue — and charged you with not only scoring big points, but also capturing the 151 Kanto region Pokémon as you did so.
Throw in a special rumble-enabled cartridge, and you've got one of the best Pokémon spin-offs ever. Its GBA sequel played with the same idea to similarly great effect.
15. Pokémon Ranger: Guardian Signs (DS)
Pokémon Ranger: Guardian Signs brings in a range of different Pokémon to keep things interesting and new additions such as aerial and underwater sections. The story gets a bit too talkative at times, and whilst there's a variety of things to do there's a disappointing lack of challenge in the main quest. The "multiplayer" missions are challenging but that's mostly as a result of having to tackle them solo. Like the Ranger series in general, there's fun to be had with Guardian Signs but it's not a must-buy Pokétitle.
14. Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia (DS)
Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia, like its predecessor, takes a while to get going and the gameplay can get repetitive, but there's a variety of attacks to learn to deal with that helps to keep things interesting; if you like collecting Pokémon, tracking them down will keep you busy. The tweak to the capture process puts an end to the sometimes frustrating failures of the previous game, but it does lessen the challenge somewhat. Pokémon Ranger: Shadows of Almia is an enjoyable game — if you like the first, then you'll like this one even more.
13. Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX (Switch)
A beautiful game with potentially hundreds of hours of gameplay, there's still no getting away from the fact that this is an ageing GBA title at its core. The dungeon-crawling genre has evolved over the years to try and make things feel less repetitive, and while Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Rescue Team DX does add some features to modernise the process a bit, they tend to fall flat. It's still fun in bursts, it just gets samey after a while.
Comments 47
I'm honestly surprised that the new Pokemon Snap was ranked so high, maybe I'm missing something.
Just checked the top of the list to make certain that Pokémon Conquest was there. Happy and amazed that it was ranked so high.
Good to see the Mystery Dungeon games get the love they deserve, even if their descriptions from the writers aren’t the most flattering.
But, I will never understand why Colosseum and XD are so loved. I played them within the last few years and I hated them. Guess it’s just a me problem, but I will never like them.
Mystery Dungeon games in the top two shakes my faith in the readership here.
Nice to see Pokemon Trozei on there. I did enjoy playing that one on the DS.
I haven't played many of the spinoffs; kinda shocked there are over 50 😅 New Pokemon Snap is one on my wishlist I want to buy if I can ever find a decent sale; such a cute game.
Explorers of Sky at #1, as it should be
@Cleefuzz Same! I'd love to see Pokémon dip into the tactical RPG space again. A modern Fire Emblem-style Pokémon game would be incredible.
@Shepdawg1 Probably because they were the closed we ever had to an mainline Pokemon games on a home console until the Switch
But yes, I also played them for the first time like 2 years ago and they are very tedious
Pokémon Puzzle League too low, list invalid (Mystery Dungeon games being at the top is great to see though)
@iLikeUrAttitude Very likely, I found it to be by far the best Pokémon game since Black/White 2.
I need to play Conquest again, love that game so much.
In my opinion, Pokémon Dash is not just "one of the weaker Pokémon spinoffs", it's one of the worst games ever made. And I've played some stinkers.
The top 3 I very much agree with. I haven't played Sky, but Time/Darkness was absolutely fantastic, and an expanded version of it couldn't be worse I suppose. New Snap is just wonderful in pretty much every way as well, I only have minor nitpicks like the music not being as good as in the original.
By the way, I just started playing Shadows of Almia today, and oh boy... I've played the other two Ranger games before, but I don't remember them being so boring at the beginning. I hope the pace picks up from here.
Pokemon Conquest definitely deserves that spot at #4. Not only is it a great spinoff, but it's one of my top favorite Pokemon games in general. If I have to nitpick, I'd say that my only gripe is that it's pretty easy. Still, samurai and Pokemon are a great mix, and one I'd definitely want to see a sequel or remake of.
Regardless of their placements in this list I'm somewhat fond of Pokemon Masters, Detective Pikachu (haven't tried the sequel yet), Pokken, and especially Pokemon Stadium as that game was one of my first N64 games, good times there.
Good to see most of the Mystery Dungeon titles as well as Conquest rank so highly.
pokemon pinball ruby & sapphire is the GOAT. I'd love to see another pokemon pinball.
Huge Pokémon fan here.
Love almost all of the spin offs.
Gen 3, 4 and 6 Mystery Dungeons are all great.
Love the 2 Poképarks.
The original Ranger was amazing.
Have so much time in Unite.
Conquest is so good, wild that there haven't been more.
The Gamecube rpgs are great.
Have gen 3 pinball but haven't played it yet though.
Still need to get New Snap sometime, liked the 64 original.
I had lots of fun with the original Rumble on Wii.
Still haven't bought the 2 Detective Pikachus, but wil someday.
Played Stadium 2 to death as a child.
Love normal Picross so having a Pokémon one on 3DS is nice.
Edit: Oh, how could I forget! And Pokkén, one of my favourite fighting games ever!
@mariomaster96 @Shepdawg1 I agree as well, XD is definitely better than colosseum but I also found them very tedious, I feel the removal of near complete choice in selecting a pokemon team is a massive let down. But I think its one of those games that felt better in its day, as I only played them for the first time around 2 years back.
Detective Pikachu Returns deserves a better ranking on what I saw , if you agree with me please comment on this post
I'm surprised Detective Pikachu Returns didn't rank higher. I realize it's a bit on the easy side from what I've read, but the impressions I get from it seemed positive. I admit I haven't played it but did play/enjoy its predecessor though.
Really wish I didn't miss the boat on Pokemon Conquest. I'd love a rerelease or new game on the Switch or its successor from that spinoff series.
Pokken Tournament DX. Pokemon Link Battle. Pokemon Puzzle League. These are the ones I most actually enjoyed. I have pnly played a couple of Mystery Dungeon games and the were okay
Definitely a lot to “lobe” in this list!
There are two kinds of people in this world: Ones who beat the Mystery Dungeon games and experienced amazing stories... and the impatient.
I love Pokemon and all, but the spin-offs are sort of a collection of average at best games. That’s not to say they aren’t fun, and I keep coming back for more for some reason, but if the games weren’t Pokemon, I’d skip them. If I had to pick my favorites, I’d pick the N64 games, but I’m aware that’s 100% nostalgia. I believe that most Pokemon spin-offs are 6/10 or 7/10s.
The mini games in Stadium 1 are probably honestly my favorite Pokemon experience outside the main games. With NSO, I’d probably guess Stadium is my most played game of the bunch because I get strangely addicted to those little games, same as I did when I was like 10-ish years old when the game came out. I’d say Snap is all-in-all the best of the bunch and Detective Pikachu has the best potential for a spin-off series. I could go for another Pokemon pinball game too. Honestly though, I sort of wish Pokemon would try a little harder with side games.
Surprised Pokemon Go isn’t higher on the list. I loved that little mobile app for a few year til having kids made it trickier to use. One kid was easy to use it, but once things got plural, man, that was over. My wife and I had a lot of fun with it though and were pretty active for what feels like a pretty long time. Objectively speaking, it’s probably truly the best spin-off game.
I don’t think cafe remix can be objectively better than masters. Having played both, at least with masters you can play more than five minutes without waiting for your pathetic energy reserves to replenish.
@iLikeUrAttitude it was good, surprised it even got made but something about the more simple first game can't be beat for me.
More ranger and pinball please!
@iLikeUrAttitude well, it is absolutely gorgeous, and if you like the gameplay, it is massively replayable. Obviously, photography may not appeal everyone, but if it grabs you, new Pokémon snap is utterly incredible.
It’s even got voice acting!
Pokémon Sleep is missing.
Zzz.
With so many titles it's hard to make this list razor sharp but it came out pretty well. Very few nitpicks, much fair
No Pokemon Box Ruby and Sapphire? 😮💨
I have a living Pokedex on it and then some! 💾
I hope that Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers of Sky deserves a remake for the Nintendo Switch soon, no matter if they keep forgetting it for so long or not.
All of the pokemon mini games and the tcg on gameboy.
Had my eye on Conquest for a little while now, annoyed I passed it up. Trending over double the original price, but it'll be a keeper I'm sure.
I saw Pokemon Stadium 2 (loose) at a carboot yesterday! Guy wanted £40 for it, which isn't bad, but I don't go carboots to pay "not bad" prices.
As someone who played one pokemon game I'm overwhelmed with the differences between all of the spinoffs, not in a good way
I understand there are people willing to play a game because of a Pokemon label but I must be one of the few who feel the opposite, it feels too tough to properly understand where an individual game sits in the larger universe
Literally just learning that Pokemon conquest wasn't a mainline entry
I think the best spin offs are:
Pokemon Stadium
Pokemon Stadium 2
Pokemon Colosseum
Pokemon XD: Gale of Darkness
Pokemon Pinball
Pokemon Pinball: Ruby & Sapphire
Pokemon Dash and Pokemon Channel are highly underrated and I'm tired of the way the fanbase treats those games.
Lastly, New Pokemon Snap is easily the best looking game in the series so far, in terms of graphics.
Didn't realise there were so many... the pinball game on gbc is nice though, as is (new) pokemon snap... Pokken a nice wiiU surprise a decade ago
the other free switch ones not more than a destraction... , the stadium games i don't see the point off (I didn't really fit in the pokemon demographic during the n64 days i guess).. and grinding rpg's i sadly don't have time for... stull it looks like it is a bit like fireemblem some, which is nice
This is actually a pretty good list. I think Pokemon Unite could have been a bit higher. Although it has a lot of issues, it's one of my top 5 most played Switch games.
@iLikeUrAttitude It's because it's Pokemon but with really good graphics. If Scarlet/Violet looked anywhere close to that, it would have sold 40+ million copies.
@Cleefuzz Exactly the same here. Can't complain too much about its placement. I love that game, and seeing it get some love here is awesome.
@Tyranexx Just play it now! The 3DS had already been out for over a year when it came out, so it was born behind the times. Really unfortunate for such a great game.
Okay, can someone please explain to me how exactly Red Rescue Team is the "best version of the game"??! I would say the people writing the article are crazy, but apparently the readers also rated Red higher than DX AND Blue for some crazy reason.
As someone who has put over 400 HOURS into Red Rescue Team...this is not the gold mine you all are making it out to be. I cannot tell you how many times I looked at a mechanic or chance of something important happening and went, "Did the devs even proofread this game?!" That's the best way I can put it. Trying to 100% this game...to say it's a chore would not do it justice. There is just way too much grinding to get your levels where they need to be to evolve, and you never have enough gummies, which you need LOADS of to evolve all the "friendship" evolutions. And whichever mons are good in the Level 1 dungeons are ARBITRARY. Also, evolving your Pokemon doesn't give you higher stats. If you want higher stats, you have to recruit them as the Pokemon you want, which is usually impossible.
Rescue Team DX has none of those issues, introduces new optional features that bring newcomers in much better, and handles levels in post-game dungeons much better. It's a much better game.
I love PMD, but the original games had a lot of nonsense that made trying to master them way too tedious. I guess you could say they're a product of their time...wait. Didn't you guys say that about DX, but then acted like that wasn't the case for the originals??? Where is the logic in that?!
Always wished I could get into the PMD games, as everything from their artwork, music, and storytelling looks top-notch. And then you get to the gameplay and the 50 floors of generic step-by-step dungeon crawl. It felt like little morsels of story as a reward for slogging through the exact opposite of game design. I wish the Chunsoft Mystery Dungeon formula had been left in the dustbin of the 90s, and the charm and heart of PMD applied to literally any other genre.
Conquest, on the other hand, is #1 on my list.
@Bret I'd love to, but sadly secondhand copies are quite pricey according to online listings I've seen. There's a cheap third party listing on Walmart's website, but I highly suspect it's a bootleg. Definitely plan to keep hunting though!
Good list. However Pokemon Mystery Dungeon Blue is kinda low, that's my favorite Pokemon game of all time.
@Tyranexx Oh, I wasn't thinking playing legitimately lol
@Bret I wondered lol. Emulating is also an option, but it will be some time before I play the game regardless of the means.
Tap here to load 47 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...