the problem with an out-of-10 system is that too many game reviewers treat a 7 as the par score, leaving anything scored 5 or below as five different kinds of crap, and the score system ends up becoming out of 5 anyway. a 5 star system works well because if we were asked on the street "did you like this game?" we would reply "yes"/"no"/"it was OK"/"i hated it"/"i loved it" (followed by "please stop following me, you're freaking me out"). one reason why a more detailed score would be necessary is for 2 versions of the same game (SFIIturbo/champion): both 5 star worthy, but one is more worthy than the other.
but most of all: a well written review says more than any number or star.
Comments 7
Re: Nintendo Download: 23-24 June 2009 (Japan)
I wonder when Gameboy and GB Colour games become available. Link's Awakening needs to be first on that list.
Re: Take Five and Double It!
the problem with an out-of-10 system is that too many game reviewers treat a 7 as the par score, leaving anything scored 5 or below as five different kinds of crap, and the score system ends up becoming out of 5 anyway.
a 5 star system works well because if we were asked on the street "did you like this game?" we would reply "yes"/"no"/"it was OK"/"i hated it"/"i loved it" (followed by "please stop following me, you're freaking me out").
one reason why a more detailed score would be necessary is for 2 versions of the same game (SFIIturbo/champion): both 5 star worthy, but one is more worthy than the other.
but most of all: a well written review says more than any number or star.
Re: SnakeByte Christmas Compo - Win Yourself Some Wii Goodies
a challenger appears:
http://media.ign.com/games/image/article/946/946691/ten-trends-that-are-saving-videogames-20090120093405749.jpg
Re: SnakeByte Christmas Compo - Win Yourself Some Wii Goodies
Congrats Jazzman!
Re: SnakeByte Christmas Compo - Win Yourself Some Wii Goodies
found: the cyborg that has been terminating all the good Virtual Console games lately. Christmas has been saved! (let us all hope so)
Re: SnakeByte Christmas Compo - Win Yourself Some Wii Goodies
"Hasta La Vista, PS3."
Re: SnakeByte Christmas Compo - Win Yourself Some Wii Goodies
"I dare the dog from Duck Hunt to laugh at me NOW!"