Welcome to Box Art Brawl, the series where regional box art variants battle against one another to find out which has the highest midi-chlorian count.
Last week Kirby returned to Dream Land for an Adventure on Wii and it was decided that the angry North American cover was best, with Japan coming in second and the very slightly different European version bringing up the rear.
This week, to coincide with the release of Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker in cinemas, we're going back to Episode I with one of the finest Star Wars games ever made, Star Wars Episode I: Racer for the Nintendo 64. It already made the podium in our round up of every Star Wars game released on Nintendo consoles, but does it have the strength to venture into the cave and confront itself and the Dark Side of the Force?
Let's relive the highlights of the Boonta Eve Classic and take a look at the starting lineup...
Europe
What we love about this cover is just how understated it is. The classic Drew Struzan Star Wars ensemble posters are wonderful (although let's not talk about how the covers for each new round of home format releases manage to look more and more like an amateurish photo collage), but this cover takes a totally different route and goes for something else entirely. It works because it's so different from the normal Star Wars game box art.
Other than the title, Watto is probably the most noticeable figure, faded into the black background behind the logo, but positioned prominently. On the left is the face and helmet of little Anakin Skywalker, with his main rival Sebulba on the right, partially obscured by accessory symbols. Along the bottom are a trio of podracers speeding from left to right.
We admire when box art subverts our expectations, and we expected more bombast here.
North America
The North American variant uses the same basic elements, but slaps a big red strip down the right side of the cover, separating out the accessory symbols. You also get a photo of the Expansion Pak rather than an icon.
The title logo size has been increased and little Ani and Sebulba have been cropped leaving just Watto - or perhaps his Force ghost? - in the middle. The pods are still present and are a bit more prominent at the bottom.
Obviously, it's very similar, but there's a number of subtle differences. That intrusive red strip puts a splash of colour on the cover, although we're not convinced it was needed.
Japan
The Japanese version goes for the opposite, more traditional approach. You've got Anakin up top flanked by flags and a dynamic, explosive bit of pod action below. It's a rainbow-coloured cover and sure is eye-catching, although we probably prefer the subtlety of the others. There's nothing to ‘discover’ here - it's just a pods-out, in-your-face, brains-at-the-door STAR WARS VIDEO GAME cover.
Which is fine! We don't dislike it, but it's certainly less interesting than the alternatives. But what we think matters not a jot.
Which of these three pilots sets your pulse a-racing, then? Click the one that fires up your engines and hit the 'Vote' button below to get your pick promptly off the starting line and, hopefully, onto the podium:
That's all from the Boonta Eve Classic - we're off to clean up Quadinaros' wreck. We'll catch you next time for another round of Box Art Brawl.
Comments 37
I mean, this isn't even close! Japan all the way!
NA and Europe are very bad this time around eww
@Shiiva Agreed, is there any contest?
NA and EU look much cooler at an angle
NA is definitively the worst here, it takes out the things that make PAL's actually interesting. I'll admit I only ever saw the GBC's artwork as a kid (which in NA was based on the bottom half of the JP release's pic) but... hm
I voted NA since it's the closest to having nothing on it, because they're all quite ugly.
Why is Watto front and center in the NA and EU box art? Does anyone even like Watto?
I couldn't bring myself to even vote here. None of the above.
Wow, this is easy. an amazing action scene across a colourful environment, or a bunch of spaceships flying by slowly while being watched by the ghost of a Mad Magazine caricature of Gonzo?
Europe again and easily. Lovely cover, Europe had the best covers.
Japan's is nothing to write home about, but the other two are just hideous.
@Cr4shMyCar I mean, watto is fine and all, but he literally has practically nothing to do with pod racing, so I don't even know...
Pitch-black, minimalist cover? Starring Watto, of all characters, front and center? Those are some seriously bold choices for a fast, colorful Star Wars game.
...Seriously. Watto??
@Noid "the ghost of a Mad Magazine caricature of Gonzo" is probably the best thing I'll read all day.
All terrible once again, common theme.
Easily the Japanese box art. When I see that, I think "now this is podracing!"
The red strip on the NA cover was just the standard design for all N64 cover art. (or more a red shading, but in this case since it was almost all black anyways they decided to go for a solid red strip)
The N.A. and E.U. art looks makes me think of an atmospheric horror game rather than a Star Wars based action-racer.
Japans takes first place in this case.
This is high up on my Switch port wish list (because why play new games when I can re-live my childhood in HD)
would be sick if they remaster this game with online play and everyone would be crashing rigth off the track.
You can tell a good amount of the readers are European just by the dellusional percentages their covers get in some of these polls.
When scrolling past the NA and EU box art, I was hoping the Japanese cover would be better, because the first two are so freaking bland! Japan saves the day!
No idea how the Japanese box art is “clearly the best” with that boy face and those weird goggles looking right back at you.
But apparently I’m delusional because I voted for the European box art and am a reader from Europe. Obviously everyone only votes for their region, which is why Japan leads the way. All those pesky Japanese visitors this site receives just for these box art brawls!
North America and Europe's box art is just awful, Japan's is too but not that bad.
This game is one favorite racing games of my childhood.
Japan for the action. The minimalist approach really doesn't help selling a Star Wars racing game.
Chubby naked alien watching tiny spaceship things is the obvious winner here.
Yeah, Japan wins here. Sometimes I can appreciate more simple case/box arts, but the Western versions are just boring in this case. Floating Anakin head in Euro version is just weird.
The NA and EU cover are definitely not wizard
Who wants Watto as cover for a star wars game?
I prefer Anakin all the way.
Wow! They're all horrible. I saw the Euro cover and thought, what a terrible box, I surely won't pick this as the best of the bunch. Of course, I picked it as the best of the bunch. NA is the same, but the red strip makes it worse. And Japan's box is a better concept, but the execution is a failure, in my opinion. That particular image of Jake Lloyd is not a good fit for a game cover. If they had to use a photo or screen grab, there had to be something better than that shot.
Box Art Brawls Current Total:
Europe: 4
Japan: 9
North America: 9
You're all nuts, Japanese box is garish and horrible.
Nothing wrong with being understated.
Really not a fan of any of these haha. Went with Japan basically just cuz.
@Cr4shMyCar Your commenter mind tricks won't work on us Toydarians, ONLY MONEY
They are all garbage. Here is an example of a good box art of the same game for PC.
https://www.retrogameking.com/WebRoot/StoreNL3/Shops/78704979/593C/5954/8D41/B599/F08F/C0A8/2AB8/3DEB/DSC_7062_ml.JPG
So do we just give Japan the medal now or what...
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...