Despite lighting up the sales charts and earning decent reviews, Pokémon Sword and Shield has been the subject of some pretty negative press recently.
Some of its appears justified – such as reports that the digital version of the game is corrupting people's SD cards and sending their Roku boxes crazy – while other stories need to be taken with a slightly larger pinch of salt.
Take, for example, a recent post on Reddit which suggests that the game – via its use (or abuse, rather) of the Switch's NAND memory – is slowly but surely killing consoles all over the globe.
The trigger was a Twitter post which shows a Switch console displaying a blue screen of death. A Pastebin has been established for crash reports seemingly related to this issue, and the following text tries to sum up the crux of the problem:
As is often the case with these highly emotive stories, reports have now spread across Twitter and people are taking it upon themselves to warn others off even loading up Pokémon Sword and Shield. However, almost immediately, voices of reason have entered the conversation to pour cold water over these reports.
Prolific Pokémon modder SciresM – the same person who managed to hack Omastar into the game – has responded to the rumours, calling them "bait" and "obviously false". He also points out that, as games, Sword and Shield have no special access privileges and would not be permitted by the Switch OS to access the NAND:
The question remains – what is causing the blue screens on Switch consoles? Could Sword and Shield – which push the host hardware pretty hard – but a contributing factor? We'll no doubt find out in due course, but it's pretty certain that the game accessing the console's NAND is not the cause here.
As ever, let us know if you have any insight into this issue by posting a comment below.
[source reddit.com]
Comments 105
Of course the drama won't stop, this game is buggy, that's all there is to it. So now people are kinda going nuts looking for other reasons to blame the game for stuff.
Pokemon Shield is causing me to gain weight. I got on the scale this morning and was five pounds heavier.
Will the damage this game causes never end?!
My switched bricked only days before sword and shield, so maybe it's something to do with the newest firmware?
The war never ends
that is some grade-a bs; even if it did access it, nobody would be getting bricked already. not to mention my sd card would probably be dead since im usually running my switch off emunand... terrible bait.
@Kalmaro
of course it will never stop with people like you always adding fuel to the fire. before you shout fanboy never really cared for oer played any of the games.
mind nintendolife don't help with clickbait articles
@suikoden And how have I added fuel to the fire? I just pointed out that the game is buggy, which it is. I didn't even make an article about it. NL did that for me.
@Kalmaro
because you comment on every article about the game about how you don't like etc. fine with me you don't but just move on its only a game
@suikoden - He has a point though, and it's a psychological type of thing that's natural.
People often make a judgement of someone or something roughly 30 seconds into meeting it. And for some, they will FIND reasons why someone or something "rubs them the wrong way." This just happens to be Pokémon now, people also hated MK8D as well for a similar thought pattern.
Hell, people are also acting like the records it's setting is just justifying how disappointing it will be.
@suikoden That is false, I didn't say anything about not liking the game here. I just pointed out that it's buggy.
I can't even remember the last time I said I didn't like the game. I do know I've said I didn't like Gamefreak being lazy and cutting corners.
Most likely hardware problems on these Switches.
And there is ONLY ONE THING you can do with hardware defects, contact the store you bought your Switch.
That's all.
@Kalmaro So far my favorite bug is Dottler.
I remember people ragging on Gamefreak for not releasing Pokémon earlier and now they complain that the game feels “rushed”. A lot of the features seem half baked and those critical bugs reported by people seem ghastly, but it’s definitely not new Fallout 76 (I have seen people call it that).
Obviously this is complete nonsense, not really worth reporting on. It wouldn't have bothered me even if it wasn't though as I doubt I'll ever be touching the game again anyway.
@BarefootBowser There is no hardware without defects. That's why you have warranty. So like I said, have hardware problems? Contact your store. And if they don't want to help, contact Nintendo.
Speaking of psychological, things have been blown out of proportion so much it's getting hard not to immediately dismiss these reports as more nonsense. Which isn't ideal if people want to inform others of legitimate issues.
@SmaggTheSmug How many of those complaining about the quality of the game are the same as the ones complaining about it taking too long, though? I certainly wasn't, as it's been my opinion for years that the games release way too frequently. Quantity over quality.
Haha I love those articles now. They should be made weekly with different things that those games broke.
What is next stop? Car stopped working? Pets died?
Unfortunately there are no creepy things in Sword and Shield so there will be no Lavender Town Syndrome
@SmaggTheSmug I really wish they had waited before releasing this game. I get that they felt pressure since the anime was coming... But then they could have just hired more folks ages ago. They knew how big this game was.
Sounds like a desperate reach
Reports are coming in that Pokémon sword and shield is also responsible for the Australian wildfires, the Kennedy assassination and the music of Yanni.
@Mallow If it wasn't for Pokémon sword and shield, we'd have our glorious, climate-friendly One World Communist Utopia by now!
@Kalmaro - I think the problem with Sw/Sh and Game Freak was a culmination to a perfect storm.
Experimentation, lack of HD Experience, new to console hardware development, too much focus on catchy new features, and pressure from publisher to name a few things.
Calling them lazy is a little overestimating their ability. If anything they were simply unprepared and unfocused.
@Savino - No Metroid Prime 5 yet? Metroid is dead.
What could cause it to brick? Easy. Someone with a hackable unit who chose not to make a NAND backup and tried to install the game illegitimately, and did something wrong. But instead, claims something that the hacking community knew was false.
Wait are some people unhappy with this game
@BarefootBowser nope, you’re just lucky. These issues have happened across the board for like 30 years. Some cases worse than others(Xbox 360), but nearly every console I’ve owned has bricked. Nes, ps1 and 3,GameCube, wii(almost). This is a common issue
Pokemon SW/SH causes impotence. Watch out guys.
@BenAV this is one of the key points when it comes to those kind of arguments, since more often than not the different statements are from different people.
while i enjoyed my time with sword and shield the game definitely has some major rough edges and i personally would have been fine if the game was delayed to iron them out.
We got alot of wild claims here but have no documentation or verified of the problem. This is the problem here alot of claims but nothing to backup or shown to be the cause. It just seems like because the game is the biggest coming out after Go that there are buyer's remorse. This is what is sounds like more like. If there was a problem one should update the game first. Any new release has some updates that will be needed to be updated. Take Witcher 3 full on cart but has updates coming and I am fine with that the game plays good on Portable and Gaming Monitor.
Once again, go play the DS games and call it a day.
@Ralizah "Pokemon Shield is causing me to gain weight."
Have you tried putting the Switch and the game down BEFORE you get on the scale?
I'm going to say it's very likely 1 Switch bricked while somebody was playing Pokemon considering how many people are playing Pokemon and Switch is a piece of hardware and hardware bricks sometimes. Doesn't mean Pokemon was the cause, just playing the Switch is going to brick 1 or 2 occasionally, see Xbox360 RROD. 50% failure rate, I'm guessing 0% caused by Pokemon.
https://gizmodo.com/survey-xbox-360-failure-rate-is-over-50-people-dont-5339915
@Paraka That's fair, I could certainly agree that they but off more than they could chew with their limited amount of workers and time constraints.
I still hold that they could have solved this ages ago by increasing how many people they have ages ago to compensate these bugger projects.
16 hours in and have had 0 problems. Must have got lucky with a good digital download or something
I have always been a strong supporter of NL in the past 5 years but the coverage of Sword and Shield has been dire. Multiple click bait articles daily aimed to fire up the same arguments again and again. A real shame to see this site falling so far but at this point I would just like to see Alex Olney go independent.
This is yet more lazy, sloppy and irresponsible reporting from you guys with little research or quantifiable facts to back it up.
Gotta love dem clicks though.
Wouldn't even be an article if the game didn't have a negative reputation before hand.. Way to support Nintendo guys.
This site has more bait than an expecting Butterfree impregnated via IVF.
Totally in Team @Kalmaro on this game ever since not Dexit itself, but the fear of nothing being worth the cut Pokédex - a fear that's been proven true before the games even came out, saving a lot of people a lot of money.
Whether this bricking rumor ends up proven true or false, I have to stress that skipping day one for a game never felt so insanely good.
I'd maybe be upset if pokemon games were any good. But they're not so oh well.
@Mallow Darn this game is one bad mamma jamma! I wanna get it so bad but I can't decide between this and Luigi mansion
The Japanese fans less than thrilled with Sword & Shield apparently coined a phrase "grass half year" to express their disappointment and amusement in relation to Gamefreak's ineptitude at coding their own game. I think it applies here, whether or not these games actually cause any harm to people's consoles.
草半年
@BarefootBowser you’ve been mostly lucky, full stop. Consoles should be able to just sit there and play games, and most of them do. But there’s loads of us with the same issue; thing just dies. Sometimes only a few weeks out of the box(GameCube, ps3 for me). It’s great that you’ve avoided this, but it is an issue across the board with all tech. Sorry
That being said, the switch hardware is seeing more issues than any Nintendo console before.
@Kalmaro I am definitely not in disagreement, but from where I stand, I do feel like this is a more hindsight situation.
Of course, this does not excuse the follies. But only thing they can do now is fix what they can here and pull in more for their next game.
Anyone who issues complaints by claiming that someone or something is '' should immediately be ignored and not taken seriously.
I’m using the digital version of Sword and so far no problems. I haven’t encountered anyone who has had problems besides some random twitter posts. Not saying it’s not happening but I don’t think it’s as widespread as social media would like us to believe.
As far as the game itself, I’m really enjoying it. I started with R/B/Y & didn’t come back to the series until Sun. I will say so far Shield is leaps and bounds more enjoyable than Sun was. Maybe it was my long time away but this game just “feels” better to me.
@Paraka Well they've got a lot of work to do, I wish them luck, haha.
No problems here not even one.
This is again spoiled brath behaviour.
Need some tissue? To wipe those baby bubbles of snot?
@The-Chosen-one Whelp, there you have it. You had no issues so no one else had any problems at all.
So locked up Windows,
Macs bursting in flames,
mass floods,
earthquakes,
plague of locusts,
milk going sour,
a great depression or two,
and now bricked consoles.
Did I miss anything or ?
@Kalmaro
It's getting a bit silly now isn't it ?
In other words, someone is using a smear campaign to try and stunt Pokémon Sword and Shield. I guess we should also point out that this game burned my crops, poisoned my water supply, and brought a famine upon my household.
Being upset and boycotting the game is fine, but this is freaking embarrassing.
How long before they start blaming natural disasters on Pokemon Sword and Shield?
Somehow this has got to be related to global change. It's the soccer mom SUV's that is ultimately bricking Switches everywhere! LOL just kidding people.
@KitsuneNight I, for one, welcome this trash fire. It's getting kinda cold out.
i feel like these sword and shield haters are just making crap up now blaming any issue on the game it self granted the sd card one is alittle suspicious but we dont know for sure if the game is causing that issue or could be faulty sd card or something.
@Giygas_95
no, no first other computers are affected.
@Kalmaro
Let's just hope the locusts won't show up.
@BarefootBowser hardware failure is hardware failure, and always due to a design flaw. The switch has many more than previous systems, and I’m lucky to have not experienced it. But still, every Nintendo console has had questionable design choices
The claims get more egregious, and I just grow more and more tired of the debate at all. Will people ever move on and find a new game to witch hunt already?
@damo The title change is a much, much, much needed improvement! That original title was troll bait in the worst of ways, and seemed pretty cheap. Glad that was changed!
@KitsuneNight I think Pokemon Sword and Shield did 9/11.
My only gripe with this game is the Render distance for Pokemon and objects, Iv'e never played a Pokemon game but have berry trees and Pokemon always suddenly pop up out of nowhere? Seeing an Wingull pop up when you take a step forward and disappear when you take a step backwards really grinds my gears.
@BarefootBowser lol I am an engineer. This is semantics
@BarefootBowser
Are you sure about that ?
Cause the Xbox 360 had a rushed design and it cost them.
@Crockin Gamecube was great for reliability. You could throw that thing out of the window after a frustrating game of Smash Bros and the thing will still work perfectly
@KitsuneNight what's your icon?
One day, while roaming around in Pokemon Shield, I got into a normal battle and thought I would try out my new Pokemon I captured.
Me: BSOD, I choose you!
BSOD: Blue. Blue.
Me: What? That's weird, you have only one skill. Brick sys. Hmm, weird, says it strong against Windows types. Hmm. Oh, well I guess I'll use it. BSOD use Brick sys.
BSOD: Blue. Blue.
Me: What the hell, the screen is all messed up. Oh wait, a blue screen popped up. Windows 10 has encountered a error that it cannot recover from. This message will self-destruct in 10 seconds. What? The Switch uses Windows 10 OS and what do you mean self-destruct. Boom! cries
@Kalmaro ok boomer
@BarankOrbama
She is a werewolf called Jetta from Fred Perry's Gold Digger.
An American manga influenced comic that's has been running since 1993 .
It tends to go between over the top action and humor, with a lot of fan service.
The series is creeping up to 300.
And you can find the first 199 issues free here
http://antarcticpresslibrary.com/?p=239
The URL is legit. It's been on the inside cover of every Gold Digger since 200.
You can find Jetta in issue 5
The first 50 issues are black and white then it switches to color.
@Xylnox
It's natural enemy is Kernel Panic.
@KitsuneNight thank you
@BarankOrbama
You're welcome.
@SquallLeonhart86 cosmetically it was a real tank, and probably the last very solid feeling nintendo console. I owned 2, a black launch unit which bricked while playing smash a few weeks after buying it, and a purple revised model that always had weird issues with the lens. Mostly because the lid allowed for lots dust and particles to slip in, so it would often be dirty
I heard that pokemon sword and shield may cause infertility
@BarefootBowser
Nr 71
MS rushed out the design of the 360, cut corners and the RRod was the result.
it cost them 2.1 billion.
The flaws were apparant in the testing pjase and MS pushed it out anyway because they wanted to be the first and have it out before the holiday season.
@BarefootBowser
Your point was that defects had nothing to do with the design, but with manufacturing.
But the Rrod was caused by faults in the design
faults, MS was aware off and ignored.
That was my point.
@BarefootBowser as far as I know it was simple overheating due to the overly compact design lacking proper airflow.
@NEStalgia Just to explain, this 'new' title was the one I was originally going to use, but I decided against it as I wanted to use something vaguer and less accusative. Turns out people didn't like that title much either, hence the change.
Myself and my two eldest boys have both played a good few hours on Pokemon Sword. We've not had any issues. We're all enjoying the game. I think the majority of players who don't read all this crap on the internet are probably doing exactly the same.
Uggghhh this site is turning into pure click bait now, what a shame. I know the need to pay bills is urgent, just makes me sad to see the slide into the cesspool of click bait sites.
@Damo Haha, stick with your gut - the first choice is often the right one!
This one has the right tone for sure. The first one seemed like a click-grab to sensationalize the claims as semi-legit until you read the text.
Nintendo Life: Let’s make articles that crrate a bad stigma towards Game Freak!
Also Nintendo Life: No swearing! Banned forever.
@Mallow well it turned me into a newt!
I got better though.
Burn it anyway!
@Eel "I heard that pokemon sword and shield may cause infertility"
I'm pretty sure the related comments sections demonstrate that as a scientifically proven fact, though the cause may be indirect.
@Ralizah I didn’t sleep well last night cause I was playing Sheild too much. When will Gamefreak stop!
"The drama never stops"
When you stop making articles about it, it will.
The drama doesn't stop because news sites are making articles about posts on Reddit and 4Chan.
@KitsuneNight Yes and it's playable on many different versions of Windows too.
Such lies
The haters are still butt hurt that the games are selling well even after all there complaining
Hey NintendoLife,
If you are going to censor the word "ret**ded", fine.
But don't then go write an article about a Reddit/4Chan post that uses the exact same language.
Mine is fine.
Nothing wrong happened.
Oh, well...
I will use my earphone to play Pokemon Sword and ignoring the haters / crybabies alone.
@Mick939 My Switch also bricked in the week before Sw/Sh came out, and I was wondering the same thing as I saw a couple of other cases being mentioned around the same time. I'm currently waiting for it to be assessed by the repair centre.
@Braok Whatever is happening appears to be related to going online so unless you're an idiot pirating this specific game and going online (which I doubt) you wouldn't likely see an issue.
Especially if you properly followed the steps and formatted your SD card to fat32 before using emunand when one of the problems is definitely for using a card with exFAT.
Pirates are safer than legit players in this instance by default.
The one who came up with the image said this was a hypothetical, and a couple morons ran with it as gospel (probably a falseflagger trying to defend Game Freak since you people seem to not understand everyone isn't one person). We don't actually know what is wrong but there IS definitely something wrong and only the west is defending it.
Of course people are pissed. You have what is basically an uprezzed 3DS game (As evidenced by the PS2 era textures and geometry) with 50% of the pokedex cut, a lame story that is over as quickly as it starts, and a buggy save feature, and laughably bad animations in even the most dramatic story cutscenes.
The game as a whole feels unfinished.
@BarefootBowser @Eel the RROD issue was cause by a combo of board warp and inadequate thermal paste applied between the chip and heatsink. The airflow design hastened the gooification of the paste, and allowed the heat to be more absorbed by the board and less dissipated by the sink. This made parts of the board warp slightly enough that it made the problem cyclical. You could actually tighten down a board, clean and apply a better paste, and be back in business in most cases.
Pokemon Sword/Shield is accelerating global climate change.
Hacker: Crap, my Switch got bricked! I guess I can't really find anything to blame it on other than myself...
sees psychotic Pokemon fanbase rage
Hacker: ...or maybe I can...
@Ralizah 1 month of ring fit adventure and my weight keeps going up so I do more!
Does it really push the hardware though? Not saying it's an ugly game, but I get more battery time out of Shield than most games I play.
The question remains – what is causing the blue screens on Switch consoles?
Seriously, you don't know? Simple answer really, he access the Youtube app, choose any random video about blue screen, pause the video, and took a picture of it. Then he turn that into drama and blames Pokemon Sword and Shield for it. I mean c'mon there's a blue screen video right there.
@Kalmaro I'm playing a physical cartridge of pokemon sword and I'm on my 35th hour of gameplay and still, no bugs encountered. Maybe their switch or SD cards are the problem?
where's me popcorn?
@Danjo Nah, I don't think it's links to flaws with the switch or SD card.
Does this game have Missingno?
@ReaperExTenebris "this console has had issue after issue since it's release. warped consoles, broken vents, left joycon not working, joycon drift and now bricked consoles."
Alot being said here has been attributed to User caused. And hacked console or Homebrew.
@Danjo "Maybe their switch or SD cards are the problem?"
My suspicion is HomeBrew. or User Abuse.
@R_Champ Yeah I have seen a lot of Switch hackers trying to lay blame for their issues. At the end of the day this kind of stuff is exactly why I never hack my consoles and it is exactly why I always warned people about hacking their consoles. I told them how it ruins the reliability, I told them how it can brick their console if they do something wrong, but they always told me to shut up. Now look at them.
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...