One of the key elements of any Super Smash Bros. game is the character roster. The balancing and creativity of the roster ensure an enjoyable gameplay experience, the variety of characters draws players into making a purchase, and the usual reveals can drum up more hype ahead of release than many games could ever hope to achieve. So how exactly does this crucial part of the experience take place?
Well, series director Masahiro Sakurai recently sat down with the folks at Game Informer to chat all things Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. When asked about the game's character decision process, Sakurai mentions that all decisions are made before the game even enters development, with clear goals put in place before work begins.
It is a project after all, so we take into consideration things like labor, man-hours, the time in which the title will be sold. We decide on the fighters from the very early planning stage, and from there, we calculate and begin production. We don’t add or remove any characters during the project.
We do things like base our consideration on the results of the Smash ballot, and also balance things out so that there’s a difference in the types of fighters.
One particular example mentions Incineorar - the latest Pokémon fighter to be added to the group. Apparently, as the development team knew that a new Pokémon game was on the way (which turned out to be Pokémon Sun and Moon), a character slot was saved especially for one new character from that franchise. Once the team knew a little more about the games, Incineorar was chosen above other potential candidates.
One character reveal that took almost everyone by surprise was the free DLC addition of Piranha Plant. This famous Super Mario enemy has been wiggling around on our TV screens for decades, but very few people would have ever considered it for an appearance in Smash. So was this decision made purely for the surprise appeal, or something else entirely? Here's what Sakurai had to say:
I’m actually not paying too much focus on the surprise element when we introduce a new fighter. The surprise element quickly fades once the announcement has been made.
Rather, I believe it’s important to have a good balance as a game. In the past titles in the series, Mr. Game & Watch, R.O.B. and Duck Hunt Dog were some of the examples we offered outside of people’s typical expectations. However, if we don’t have these types of fighters, and we only had typical “hero/heroine” type fighters in the lineup, there’s not much difference. It’s probably not very interesting. Correct?
As huge fans of Piranha Plant at Nintendo Life HQ, we couldn't be happier to see it included in the roster and agree that straying from the usual "hero/heroine" stars is wonderfully refreshing.
But what do you think? Feel free to let us know your thoughts on these comments down below.
[source gameinformer.com]
Comments (46)
I think beating people with Planty the Potted Plant will be awesome. It's currently the fighter I'm looking forward to the most.
I agree with Sakurai, the more surprise and random characters the better. Though honestly I kinda hoped chain chomp would be the one joining before Piranha Plant dudebro.
Also will we ever see Stanley the bugman in the series?
I just hope that at least two or three of the five DLC fighters will stem from the ballot's results. Too many ended up in the Assist Trophy blender (not a Waluigi fan, but Isaac definitely bummed me out).
The piranha plant as a player character was a bold move.....but totally agree with his inclusion.
Love how unpredictable it was and it looks like will be alot of fun to play around with.
Its the playable character I never knew I wanted
https://youtu.be/LkftiHtgWC8
Piranha Plant, the character that no one asked for. I kinda like that. Looks pretty interesting and I’m thinking about maining him along with a few other characters. December 7th seems such a very long time. 😑
Honestly I’m super smash bros out.
I ordered the limited edition contoller bundle as soon as it was available but the hype around everything and the constant justifying every decision by fan boys and media is such a turn off.
It’s a great same series but it’s being painted as perfect and no matter what they say people lap it up.
I’m meh at this point now.
Hoping I get some buzz back before release
I love the tradition of including an unexpected “gag” character in each installment, but I’m hoping the remaining five DLC characters are actual characters, instead of generic common enemies without individual identities.
I loved the Pirhana Plant reveal, and he is right, there aren't that many playable bad guys in Smash, they are all good guys.
Fair play to them for this.
Only 14 days 8 hours 31 mins (at time of writing (midnight UK time)) TO GO!!
So they added something insignificant for the sake of adding something insignificant...
@Stocksy Shame, as I feel completely the opposite. I agree that some games benefit from keeping content a surprise but we all know what we are getting with Smash Bros so the decision to release all the info is justified in my eyes. Although saying that the first time I played Melee I had no idea who the characters were and I remember the excitement of unlocking a brand new one so perhaps you have a point. I just think Sakurai and Co. were so (rightly) proud that they wanted to show off everything.
Also this was a way of putting to bed all the early criticisms about this just being a re-skin of Smash WiiU - no one is saying that any more!
I like random and I like characters that average gamers know, that’s how you grow a gsme by getting casuals interested
Not sure how adding a bunch of the same little guy with a sword and same fighting attributes does anything
There's probably about a dozen other characters I'd have preferred over Piranha Plant, but I'm still hyped for its inclusion. It looks like a super unique fighter that really adds to the game's variety, and I'm all over that!
Piranha plant is the fighter no one wanted but the one we needed. Yeah definitely a generic fighter but it looks really fun to play as, And in the end thats what really matters right?
I'm happy to have Ridley, but Pirahna Plant is my favorite announcement so far, in terms of content that goes beyond Smash 4.
'As huge fans of Piranha Plant at Nintendo Life HQ, we couldn't be happier to see it included in the roster and agree that straying from the usual "hero/heroine" stars is wonderfully refreshing.'
Does the author of this article speak for the whole NL team? I find it hard to believe everyone in any group of people have the EXACT same attitude/thoughts regarding something. This seems very much like trying to push a narrative.
@Stocksy
Your hype for a game went down because... Other people are hyped for it?
https://youtu.be/LQCU36pkH7c
K. Rool and Piranha are the fighters I’m looking forward to most unless Dixie is announced as DLC.
@BMO_Advanced
I get some people are disappointed because Sakurai "wasted" time developing Piranha Plant instead of other wanted characters.
But to me, this character was the best announcement in the last direct. I value creativity a whole lot more than popularity. And boy, Piranha Plant seems fun to play with.
I'm dissapointed, but if people enjoy it then it's not wasted. I prefer ''significant'' characters that's all.
"troll" characters are just as important as "real" characters. They are important to keep the Party aspect of the game alive
@Frenean agreed, I think a few surprises or at least knowing the unlockables take time - I love the look of the single player mode. If that wasn’t In I might have cancelled and waited until next year.
@Ooccoo_Jr yes you are. I’m not into hype trains and especially when much of the info is a buzz kill. Pretending it isn’t is just foolish. It typical of the new gaming community to lap up everything and treat games like they are perfect. So much info on this has been a buzzkill. I’m, unlike the stupid masses, making my own decision.
I’m sure they game will be great. It just could have been greater
@MagnaRoader Piranha Plant has opened the door to so many guys now. I can easily see a Goomba, Koopa, Chain Chomp (or even a trio of them). The possibilities are endless now. I am really supporting Bandanna Dee now.
To me, Piranha Plant is as generic as any pokemon (except Mewtwo), so I have no negative feelings on it. But I do wish it was Petey Piranha.
I still can't believe Piranha Plant has more source material in a moveset than Mario.
@Stocksy
Being very excited for the game doesn't mean people think it's perfect, but you're foolish if you don't think this game is going to be amazing. It's the ultimate Smash game, a series full of amazing games and this one is the best yet. Calling people who are excited for this "the stupid masses" is extremely insulting. What do you think Sakurai could have done to make the game better? Sacrifice his first born and put twice as many characters in the game?
@Stocksy I kind of feel the same way about the reveals, but I don't think it's an inherently bad thing. Showing off the new characters being revealed is a great way to build up excitement, and let people know what they're buying. At the very least, the fanfare the big reveals get is still cool, even if it does make avoiding spoilers difficult.
As for getting burnt out by endless hype, you might just want to avoid comment sections for a while. I'm planning to do the same myself, though my problem is the opposite since I'm kind of tired of people nitpicking the game or complaining about their character not getting in. Not looking for blind praise, I just tend to see a lot of default negativity, especially with character selection.
@Stocksy Think you got our names the wrong way round earlier. Don't think I said anything to upset you.
I totally get that hype can be irritating, I felt the same whenever a new Harry Potter book came out (I'm old), because I couldn't care less. But I don't think it can negatively impact my personal enjoyment of a game unless I let my own expectations go overboard.
Agreed that the Adventure Mode looks fantastic as I'm one of the few people that plays Smash mostly in single player.
@MysteryCupofJoe heck yeah I wanna see all the side characters get a chance on the Switch 2's smash in a couple of years lol 😂
He has a point there and i kinda agree.
It really isn't hard to avoid Smash articles/videos. Complaining because you're over exposing yourself to Smash is a little silly.
@Ooccoo_Jr my bad sorry mate.
Yeah I’m single player too
Just saying this will be the second game I own that feature a Pirahna Plant as a playable character, the first was Tetris Attack.

@KO-Cub I think it's more of an aspect of them not wanting to use all the available material for Mario than the material not being there for Piranha Plant.
That little biter has been in almost every Mario game (including spinoffs). I think Super Mario Bros 2 maybe the only exception (and the Philip CD games).
@WaveBoy
Hey man Bayonetta is my favorite videogame character. I love her design and personality. I do agree on having too many swordfighters though.
Piranha Plant > Waluigi + Geno
Gob bless you Sakurai, you sweet, sweet man.
@WaveBoy
I can agree with that, I definitely would love more cartoon characters like Banjo for DLC but it's more likely we'll get yet another Fire Emblem character, probably from the upcoming game. I love FE but the amount of representation, FOUR of the characters being VERY similar, bothers me. It's alright though, daddy Sakurai outdid himself and I can't wait to play!
@Mogster I mean, each individual staffer could leave a comment otherwise if they wanted to. Did NintendoLife kick over your cereal bowl this morning or something? 😂
On topic, I like the idea of PP and it does seem to fight with the other oddballs Sakurai mentioned. If the character is fun to play with, that’s what’s important to me. I’m ready for this game to come out.
@MagnaRoader piranha plants been around since the original Nintendo and have gotten more versatile forms over the years then chain chomps which are typically more of an obstical and/or someones pet except in the case of comp bros which use them as weapons.
@Kalmaro I love that reference btw.
And I too am looking forward to playing as Planty, he’s possibly my most anticipated character for Smash... I spent all those years begging for K. Rool and before even playing as him I moved on to a glorified flower. 😂
@ShadJV Best show ever, and best agent ever!
But yeah, as soon as I saw his reveal I suddenly realized that I've always needed to be able to play as a potted plant.
@Kalmaro right??? I can’t wait! Wish he would be out at launch!
Liar! There’s files for unfinished characters in the game data for Brawl (Mewtwo, Dr. Mario and Roy)! This is Fake News!
@Shadowmoon522 Super Mario Bros 3 is where chain chomp originated. Also, see Mario Tennis Switch, and Bayonetta Switch as to why I assumed chain chomp would be playable before Piranha Plants.
@MagnaRoader We saw Stanley as a trophy, but not playable, and how I wish he was.
I will play with ANY character that makes it into the roster, but I still don't like Piranha Plant's inclusion-- He doesn't hold a candle to the other known characters, and at least Mr. G&W and Duck Hunt Dog had their own games to justify their "surprise!" appearance. I'd rather have Box Boy or the water from Fluidity for crying out loud but I digress. Welcome to the party, Piranha Plant.
10/10 new main my dude
Tap here to load 46 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...