
Though the landmark has already passed in Japan, we're now approaching the fifth anniversary of the 3DS in the West. The first model launched on 25th / 27th March 2011 in Europe and North America, respectively, with the original model focusing much of its sales pitch on autostereoscopic 3D. That feature would become rather secondary in the months and years to follow, and after a slow start a drastic price-drop later in its launch year would contribute to an impressive turnaround.
Those are areas we'll write about in the coming days, but the five year mark also gives us an opportunity to look over the portable family's impressive game catalogue and consider its stand-out performers. With that in mind we want you to pick your favourites in terms of both retail and eShop 3DS games. Yet if we do this with polls they'll be, well, rather long and far from comprehensive.
So, how do you make your voice heard? It's simple, and taps into a feature we recently added to Nintendo Life that had been much in demand. You can go to any game page, provide a 'Game Collection' status update, and importantly assign it a user review score between 1 and 10 stars. It's these ratings that will define the community's favourite 3DS games for this anniversary.
How do you do this? Well, it's easy...
How to score your games
- Make sure you're logged in to Nintendo Life. If you don't have an account you'll need to create one.
- Find a game page (methods outlined below). If on a PC / Mac hover your mouse over the 'Game Rating' area and select a score. On a smart device tap the relevant area and then set a score.
- This saves your score and adds it to the overall average.
- You can also set a status in 'Game Collection', showing you own the game.
- If you want a super quick way to rate games, head to this link to bulk add games and then assign ratings.
In terms of how best to find games, there are a couple of options.
- Type a game name into the top search bar manually, go to the game page.
- Or you can navigate to the New Nintendo 3DS, 3DS and 3DS eShop areas (through the top left menu), and use the various navigation options with the 'Games' category.
- Remember there are a couple of New 3DS exclusive games to consider, too.
In terms of how the results will work, we will look at the average user ratings for 3DS retail and 3DS eShop games after 11:59 Pacific time on 25th March (which is in the small hours of 26th March Eastern US / European times) and compile top 10s for each category. These results will then be published in a pretty list with some smaller polls included.
So, here's a chance to rate some of your favourite 3DS games and have the results count towards our celebrations for the portable's fifth Anniversary. Have at it!
Comments 94
Well that's different. Good thing is I've already done this for at least most of my games. I'll have to check a few though just to make sure.
Eh, can't be bothered. Curating that list in the first place was a pain in the usability.
Where can you get that DS card rack from?
Oh and one more thing, I can see this backfiring a bit as some individuals will go to some of the games they thing might get top places and rate them low just like metacritic.
I actually kind of forgot that they don't prominently feature the 3D anymore in their ads and whatever, but the 3D most games have produced in the past couple years are greatly improved from the start of the 3DS and are improving all the time. But yeah, I also am not gonna go and add all my 3DS games and star them. The pages are a pain in the rear
This is a great idea. Please be sure to do an "honorable mentions" list!
@Spoony_Tech do your seriously think there are that many trolls so that it'd affect the results?
You give idiots too much credit.
Smart thinking on your guys part. This gets your guys' game ratings a bit more usage and you can an article of it.
Still, a good idea, now just have to go through all my games to rate them.
Pokemon. Zelda, Fire Emblem.
Make sure you also consider 'New 3DS' games, since the collection puts them in a separate category (Xenoblade Chronicles 3D and Binding of Isaac are two great games).
Nah. Can't be arsed.
@Spoony_Tech well now that you put the idea out there...
Waaaay too much work. I expected a poll.
@Spoony_Tech this website is a bit dead for trolls to make an impact. It's the same people in every article talking.
Where can i get that game card rack
Where can i get that game card rack
Don't work for free, pal
Can we please merge/average the ratings of Pokemon X/Y, as well as Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire? Giving two slots to X and Y when they're really the same game is a bit frustrating.
i did mine for Kid Icarus Uprising such a great classic gem
@gregmce x is superior to y and alpha sapphire is completely superior to omega ruby so there is a reason for them to be seperate, Also as and or technically have different stories and some different setting's.
I would have preferred a list to be fair, it's too time consuming to search for individual games given the sheer volume of decent games I own on the system.
Could you change the format to simply list all games on a single page and provide a simple tick box at the side to add games to your own collection? That can't be too difficult to implement, right?
I won't do that, but I will go over some of my favorites in these comments.
My VERY favorite 3DS game would have to be SSB: I love watching Spectator Mode whenever I'm eating alone, and have nothing else to play/watch/do. Not to mention it's SSB on the go, where can you go wrong? I do wish they kept event matches in, but hey, they were in the Wii U version, so...
Pokemon X has the most backlog time of all Pokemon games of mine currently, but Super Mystery Dungeon is probably the REAL favorite of mine. Shuffle and Rumble World were pretty awesome in their own rights though.
Tomodachi Life was a game I wasn't expecting to love as much I did, but with over 100 hours clocked in on it, it;s definitely one of the best.
I've enjoyed AC: Happy Home Designer, after my best friend convinced me to get it. He also convinced me to get New Leaf, but unlike A LOT of people here, I...didn't really enjoy it too much. Happy Home Designer though, has been much more loved by me, simply because designing my house in the original was my favorite thing to do in it anyway, and now that it's the sole focus, I guess that's why I enjoy it a lot more. Posting the pics to Miiverse is also really nice.
Mario Golf and Disney Magical World were earlier games that I invested lots of time in, but now, I haven't touched them in ages since.
Um...I'm sure there's more, but that's all for the ones that strike my mind the most. Carry on!
I've already done this for the games that I have played, so no additional effort on my part.
The only games that I'm concerned about are the ones that had some censorship done, like with Fire Emblem Fates; there are so many bogus negative votes on Metacritic for that very reason.
Done. That just reminds me that I have so many games I haven't even touch. Man... wonder when I could finish them all.
I already have all of my game collection ratings updated so there is nothing extra I have to do right now. All that is left is to wait for the results.
Too bad I am still clearing MH4U and some DS RPGs... I'll probably be done with the 3DS ones in a generation xD
@Trinexx If I wanted to rate FE, it is not the censorship/localization who would damage the note but the marketing strategy who prevented me to buy the three games as a solid item.
Oh, cool. I rated most of my games shortly after the redesign, so I don't have to do anything.
I need to figure out a way to give Project Mirai DX a 14/10 to skew your results, goodness I love that game, all it's missing is future Rin and customizable Gumi.
Fire Emblem Awakening is outstanding, and only my general badness at that genre keeps it from being a 10 for me (Fates not so much). Smash 4 is terrific though it ruined my control stick. I never imagined I'd put 150+ hours into Tomodachi Life and still come back to it on occasion. You can tell by the user pic that Gunvolt is another game I adore.
I'm assuming we're only counting the 3DS original games and not remakes/ports like Tales of the Abyss, SMB3, the Zelda N64 remakes &c &c.
Nice (game) rack!
This seems like a lot of effort.
Plus, I think that going by the number of votes a game gets would be more representative of the overall popularity of a game than going by ratings alone. It wouldn't be surprising if a game that almost nobody has played wins this.
Donkey Kong!
I'm trying to give Mutant Mudds: Super Challenge a score but the drop-down menu does not appear at least on PC. Any idea why?
Oh. I thought there'd be a poll. I can't be bothered to go rate all my games tbh. I haven't even finished adding them all.
A Link Between Worlds. There, I saved everyone the trouble.
I can't add the StreetPass games. Yeah, yeah, call it sad and all that, but I actually really enjoyed them for what they are.
I already rated Project Mirai DX so I am fine.
Best 3DS game is Tom Clancy's Ghost Recon: Shadow Wars 3D. I know it sounds silly, but it is just so good. I have spend 5x more time with it than any other 3DS game . If you have not play it, I recommend you to try it immidiately. Super fun turn-based/strategy/war/action -game, and just perfect for 3DS. 10/10 in my opinion . I am playing it at this very moment in hospital (little accident with skatebord and my ankle is in pieces)
@NImH
Just take a look at Fire Emblem Fates on MetaCritic.
Critic Scores are 87, 88 and 89 for Birthright, Conquest and the Special Edition. But User Scores? 6.9 and 7.1
Why?
"Not enough stock! 0/10"
"No petting game! 0/10"
"Dialog changes in localization! 0/10"
"Separate releases! 0/10"
No, I don't trust this system one shred of a micron.
luigi mansion 3ds - mario 3D - fire emblem games - zelda games - super smash -pokemon games - DK return
This is a wonderful idea to give your new system some retroactive ratings from your userbase
A was abit unsure about this idea... that was about an hour ago, since that moment i've been endlessly listing every game I can remember playing...and i'm absolutely hooked... great idea!... Steel Divers on a lowly 5.7?? pffft ... soon see about that : 3
@marakassi ... agreed on Shadow Wars... its a barnstormingly good strategy game and my first ever game on 3DS... held off playing Mario Kart because I knew i'd get addicted to it and ignore Tom Clancy... didn't happen!
@SepticLemon Appears to be 3D printed. http://www.3dsoup.com/index.php/nintendo-3ds-game-card-holder-3d-printer-model/
@Jayrcee Oh cool.
...but I don't have a 3D printer.
@JaxonH The first 0/10 is a valid argument though. I'm not sure I'd want to get Fates if I couldn't get the special edition.
@norwichred That's the spirit!
@EverythingAmiibo Haha, to be honest it was better than having everyone submit lists that I manually count, which would be impossible to do with the numbers. Any poll I do will just have inevitable "why isn't x included" comments, which is fair enough
MH4U! Done.
Huh, nice method.
Though, my favorite 3DS game of all time is barely played by anyone :/
Ace Combat Assault Horizon Legacy
Best Gameplay
Best Controls
Best MUSIC
of ANY 3DS game ever.
Might not have the best graphics but the use of effects makes things look more attractive when in motion.
Its only flaws are the lack of free-flight and online play. I guess the extremely unnecessary rerelease as well.
I voted for Fire Emblem Fates and Kid Icarus Uprising. Two amazing gems only available on the 3ds.
Interesting method, I'll certainly try my part, rating some of the common top games and a few gems that I hope won't be over looked!
Ooohhhh I like this!
@JaxonH You had never answered my question about laguz, can you please answer that for me?
Easy...Kid Icarus: Uprising
I still daydream about this game from time to time. It really shows off Mr. sakurai's genius and wizardry as a game designer...if only he could take a break from Smash Bros.
My top ten, which I list as if anyone here cares:
1. Ocarina of Time 3D (duh, it's frickin fabulous)
2. Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate (after 400 hours, it HAS to be up here)
3. Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater 3D (best of both a movie and a game)
4. Shovel Knight (best platformar. evar.)
5. Legend of Zelda: Link Between Worlds (no words needed)
6. Super Mario 3D Land (not quite as good as Shovel Knight, but still awesome)
7. Phoenix Wright: Dual Destinies (OBJECTION!!!)
8. SteamWorld Heist (amazing turn-based gameplay, awesome soundtrack)
9. Super Smash Bros 3DS (portable Smash)
10. Binding of Isaac: Rebirth (never have I had so much fun inflicting pain on a small child to help him kill his possessed mother!)
Honorable Mentions:
Pushmo/Crashmo
Kirby: Triple Deluxe
Professor Layton games
Mario Kart 7
If DS games were included, Pokemon Mystery Dungeon: Explorers would move down LBW for #5, and Black and White would be somewhere up there.
@Grumblevolcano
No 0/10 is valid, ever, for any game. Even the absolute worst Barbie farmhouse game, where all you do is drive a tractor down an endless road of corn, can redeem itself to at least 1 point on the scale. You may not want it without the special edition but that doesn't mean the game is zero out of 10. Now I certainly wouldn't want to miss the special edition- I would be spazzing out if that happened, but I still wouldn't miss the game over it. I wouldn't care if I had to climb a mountain to its peak just to play this game at the summit before climbing back down. Because ultimately special editions and collectors items don't bring the entertainment.
@Boyd
I answer that question like a month ago, in detail. Respectfully, you're digging up-month-old conversations and I've moved on.
But I will answer you yet again. Laguz were awesome. I love Shape shifters- they're among my favorite units to use. I also love the shapeshifters in Awakening and Fates. Like Panne the Taguel, Tiki the Dragon, Kaden the Kitsune, Keaton the Wolfskin, and of course, your very own character which is a Dragon.
So ya, love all shape shifting classes.
@JaxonH you also give idiots too much credit.
I doubt that a few pathetic types here, wasting everyone's time by down-voting the best titles will have a significant effect on the results. All that you not voting does is create a self-fulfilling prophecy with your boycott. No one's forcing you to vote for something you don't like.
If most folks here would just play it straight and vote for their favorite 3DS titles, the results will be honest enough.
@NImH
Woah woah, who said anything about not voting? I've voted for all my games..
I said I didn't trust this system, But I never said I wouldn't rate my games. All my games were already rated so it was done before the article was even written.
I did my retail games but I just don't have it in me right now to add all the eshop games I have.
@JaxonH I just assumed that someone who had no confidence in "the system" would boycott... And why wouldn't they?
I don't partake in any system that makes no sense to me.
@NImH
Just because I don't trust it doesn't mean there's no chance it can succeed. I'd certainly rather try to vote for my best games than just not even try at all. I still rate great games on Metacritic despite the fact hundreds of game hating lunatics rate them 0 and bring the scores down.
@JaxonH well, wonderful. I'm glad for your input.
That logic just doesn't make one micron of sense to me.
@NImH
"All that you not voting does is create a self-fulfilling prophecy with your boycott"
So, you think I should vote? Well I did vote.
"I just assumed that someone who had no confidence in the system would boycott... That logic just doesn't make sense to me"
So, you think I shouldn't vote?
Make up your mind here! When you think I'm not voting you lecture me on that. Then I tell you I did vote and you lecture me on that not making sense.
Get out of here kid, go bother somebody else
@JaxonH okay, who needs to make up their mind here?
You "don't trust the system one shred of a micron," but still believe that there's a chance it can succeed... Can your feet even reach both sides of a fence that high?
Naw, dude. And may I remind you that it was you who decided to tag me, play the devil's advocate and pipe up about a possible "flaw" in the system? ...And one that left you without a shed of a micron of trust for its validity?
Yeah, it's still making zero sense from this angle.
@NImH
Yes you're right, I did tag you. A mistake I woefully regret now.
You can't spin your way out of the fact that you lectured me for not doing something, and then when I told you I did it you mock me for that too. And I'm not gonna let that go because that's juvenile.
And I stand by every word I said. I don't trust the system. You better believe I don't. But call it wishful thinking or hoping there is still some good in this world yes I still voted and if you can't wrap your head around that then I suggest you find someone else to speak to
I am worried, like several others, about the system of "voting" being abused. People say its unlikely to happen or "you give idiots too much credit".
Unifortunately this is the internet, the one place people can act like an absolute ****-basket freely and there are people who litterally seem to get enjoyment out of messing with such polls. If word was to get out to one of the cesspools where they inhabit, they may swarm here just to mess with it.
Of course it also may not happen, all I can say is the NL team should check and see if the number of new registers users have shot up recently.
@JaxonH Well my logic is that given the way the releases are set out, if you can't get the special edition then either you have the game very disjointed (i.e. Buy Birthright and Conquest physically but that means you have to use a different cartridge for each path) or you get 1 of them physically and the others as DLC of which you may as well purchase the whole thing digitally. With something like the Fire Emblem franchise I don't particularly want to only have digital (that's one of the reasons why I bought FE7, Sacred Stones and Shadow Dragon on cartridge after purchasing them on the Wii U eshop, the other was the Path of Radiance bonuses).
@Grumblevolcano
I don't disagree. But I'm just saying ultimately, if I couldn't have the special edition, I'm certainly not going to let that keep me from playing one of the greatest video games ever made and one of my personal favorite franchises of all time. I certainly wouldn't be happy about it, but I wouldn't miss out on the game because of it.
In fact I liked this game so much I bought three special editions, I bought two physical copies of Birthright, two of Conquest, and two full digital copies of all 3 paths.
There was no way I was not gonna play this game
@SepticLemon
Looks to be a 3D print to me?
Sorry read through the posts and saw that you already said that
I have a fair amount of games on the 3DS that I haven't played enough to rate but here are my 9's and 8's...
9
3D Fantasy Zone II
3D Out Run
3D Super Hang-On
Animal Crossing: New Leaf
Korg DSN-12
8
3D After Burner 2
3D Shinobi III
3D Space Harrier
3D Sonic The Hedgehog
3D Sonic The Hedgehog 2
3D Streets of Rage
3D Streets of Rage 2
The Legend of Zelda: ALBW
Mighty Switch Force!
Mighty Switch Force! 2
Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate
Pilotwings Resort
Pushmo
Retro City Rampage
Sayonara Umihara Kawase
Shin Megami Tensei IV
Shovel Knight
Siesta Fiesta
Star Fox 64 3D
Super Mario 3D Land
Ultimate NES Remix
Virtue's Last Reward
@happylittlepigs so you enjoyed the 3DS Snake Eater? Did you play on the New 3DS or with a circle pad pro? I played the demo and found it hard to get along with on the 3DS.
I been pretty slack on this.
Your database is missing far too many games to try updating accurately. Every other game I try is not here. It does ot find them when spelled properly. Does't show Locks Quest, AoE Mythologies etc...
Fates deserves to be on top 5, but the fanboy backlash will keep it out.
@crimsontadpoles But if a game that almost nobody has played wins maybe that'll get a few of us to try it. Maybe this will help us discover hidden gems
@davidevoid This is exactly what I'd like to get out of this
I've never heard of 3 out of the 4 games you gave a 9:
3D Fantasy Zone II
3D Out Run
3D Super Hang-On
Korg DSN-12
Now I want to learn more about them and maybe try them out.
@davidevoid I played it on the New 3DS, which was fine for most of the game, but the later boss battles were horrible. I won't spoil anything in case you actually want to pick up this gem, but there's one late-game boss battle in particular where I simply couldn't move the camera fast enough to shoot him once I threw him down. The nub just didn't offer any grip, my thumb was sliding off of it. I remedied the situation by rubbing a little sticky tape on my thumb, but still wasn't getting the grip of a controller. I highly recommend the circle pad pro.
There are a few versions of Snake Eater out there, but the 3D version, for some reason, has the best control scheme once you get ZL/ZR and a second stick to work with. The HD collection on the 360 and I think PS3 contains an HD version of Snake Eater, but the control scheme is whack. The only way I can explain the controls on 360 to someone is by saying that the team in charge of porting Snake Eater put the various game actions (shoot, change weapon, CQC, etc) on darts, got drunk, then threw the darts at a dartboard shaped like a 360 controller. Wherever the dart landed, that's where they put the action. It's awful.
It's totally worth buying a circle pad pro to play the best version of one of the best games of all time. I highly encourage you do so.
games should be rated 0/10 if that's what someone thought they were worth.
@happylittlepigs I have both PS2 versions of the game and love it (although I prefer MGS 1 and 2). I tried the demo with a circle pad pro but I still found it not to ideal. Hmm... maybe I should just take the plunge, maybe I could get used to this version of the game. Good to know you think it's the best version, that's high recommendation right ther.
@leo13 The M2/Sega 3D classics are great, especially if you like playing with the 3D on. Some are arcade conversions, some are from the Mega Drive but they all have extra features. I'd say check out the Nintendolife reviews and see what takes your fancy. My favourites are probably Fantasy Zone II and Super Hang-On.
Korg DSN-12 is a great synth for the 3DS and allows you to make songs with multiple layers of synth. It's great if you want to learn about subtractive synthesis and step sequencing.
@SyFyTy They have pretty much every 3DS game on there though. You can submit games to the database although when they'll actually appears is anyone's guess. I uploaded Bangai-O Spirits about a month ago and it's not appeared yet.
Bleah. I hope this doesn't become ANOTHER terrible trend here. The way most other things with this site are going, though...
@davidevoid Aside from the obvious framerate issues, Snake Eater 3D really is the definitive version, which is ironic considering it's on a Nintendo handheld.
@ThomasBW84 sorry but old system - you make a poll, collate the results, publish them. You do the work, site gets a nice Google friendly page to drive some traffic.
Bravo. No problem.
New system = we do all the work, site automatically collates results, you just have to write the article. We do the work, site gets a nice Google friendly page to drive some traffic.
There is a very subtle difference between the two options. See if you can spot it?
At the end of the day, people are free to chose whether they wish to participate. We are also your audience and are free to make comments. I guess you're free to make sarky comments to your readers too. Guess that's the way it goes around here now. Great! Just don't ever ban me for making a sarky comment as you have exhibited the example now.
@davidevoid thanks
Come on hunters! Let's get MH4U to the top!
@JaxonH Did FE Fates decide to do the whole Gay and drug to be gay thing?
@Boyd
I believe the Japanese version had a support convo about that, but not in western version. Too riske I guess.
They do have characters for gay relationships in each version but nothing else.
Fire Emblem to the DEATH.
I guess it's only fair, By the way, do you know anywhere where I can find a good English version of a FE Fates Let's Play? Conquest to be exact.
Hm...I'd like a little more "feedback" when I click a score. I was expecting it to be highlighted/selected or something when I click. I click it and seemingly nothing happens. I clicked it a couple of times to make sure it was selected, but I'm a little worried that each second click was removing the selection. Just a little bitty suggestion.
This is super fun! Why I love NintendoLife! Even if I am doing this at 2 am when I have work in a few hours!
Kid Icarus! Without a doubt!
Sorry Davidevoid, I was also including DS games (as someone else did too.) Several did not show up like Locks Quest, AoE; MYTHOLOGIES and several others didn't show then.... (even though AoE AoK did)
Show Comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...