The 3DS has had a long and winding history. Over the years it has developed a strong collection of games for families, but which version of the hardware is the best fit these days?
Family Gamer TV works with a range of different families of varying shapes and sizes. They all play 3DS games regularly, but also all do this in different ways and with different versions of the handheld.
Making the right choice about buying a 3DS comes down to understanding how you use the hardware. Some play more at home than on the go, while others love popping theirs in a pocket when they go to town for street passing. Then there are those who are all about multiplayer games with other family members. Here's some suggestions for each handheld:
Nintendo 2DS is ideal for younger players, both as an entry point to the world of 3DS games as well as a more robust unit that will best stand up to drops and spills. The lack of 3D also makes it super simple to setup for the youngest games in the home, with no need to lock the feature off.
The position of the controls higher up the unit can also work better for smaller hands. Also, not having 3D means the battery life is slightly longer.
The original 3DS is still a great family handheld for Nintendo games. Although harder to track down in this form it can be worth finding second hand at a lower price. Of note, the speakers on the original 3DS are to our ears much better and a little louder than newer versions.
The original 3DS XL offers a strong redesign of the original 3DS format with larger screens ideal for playing games in a family where other people want to watch the action from a wider angle. It's worth noting that although the screens are big, the positions of the buttons still suit most sizes of hands.
Lacking in the 2DS and original 3DS and 3DS XL is the NFC feature that works with amiibo cards and figurines. While some have used this as an excuse to upgrade to a New 3DS or New 3DS XL, I'd still suggest that buying the additional NFC adaptor for your existing handheld is a better way to go.
The New 3DS has a bunch of enhancements over the older versions. Firstly it has more horsepower for better visuals on certain games (although not faster loading speeds in our experience). It also has an additional analogue stick for certain games, as well as more trigger buttons.
More impressive though is the super-stable 3D on both the New 3DS and New 3DS XL. This tracks the player's face to keep the 3D effect locked in and viewing experience easier. It's easy to underestimate how much of a difference this makes.
Battery life is similar with the New 3DS. Although there are more power saving features and auto screen brightness, these are offset by the extra power needed to use the stable 3D feature — as it has an infra-red light to power.
One feature unique to the New Nintendo 3DS is the cover plates. Again, it's easy to see these as a gimmick. However, kids and collectors have really got into cover plates. The variety of skins on offer along with the matching on-screen themes can make it feel like you have a new console with each new addition.
As you can let us know in the comments, everyone has a different system of choice. For families, our advice is to consider all the options in full before making that all important Christmas purchase. Oh, and if you don't have one already, make sure you purchase a charger too - most of the systems mentioned don't ship with one.
Comments (19)
If my sons and I didn't already own a 3DS each already, I would consider buying three of the Yo-Kai Watch or Mario Kart 7 2DS system bundles. I think at $99, it's a great deal. If you were going to buy either of those games anyways, it's almost like getting the system for $60-$70.
Of course Black Friday is almost upon us and there have been really great deals on the 3DS systems the past few years.
IMO, the 3DS family of systems is my favorite generation of portable systems. I have owned Gameboys and the DSs but this is the first portable generation that I jumped fully into. In the past I have basically bought a portable system to play 2-3 games on the go and that's it. But with me being more busy, I find having a portable system works best for me now. So saying that, I'm not sure it's necessarily the 3DS but more about my lifestyle changing.
Unfortunately the New 3DS XL does not have cover plates. I guess I just have to be happy with my case *fake tear.
I started with a launch 3ds. Traded for the xl Zelda edition. Then found I couldn't ever use it due to my youngest gaining interest in it. So I got a used 2ds for him. He used it for a while but still would kill my battery whenever he could. So I bought myself a new3ds launch day and now we have 3 of these systems. The 2ds is not used much lately, but it's still there. This is also why I like having cartridges to swap between them.
I have a few systems now and have owned all of them at some point. I play mostly on the smaller N3DS, mainly because the fingerprints on the outside of the new XL drove me nuts and having changeable cover plates is great because I can still get a new feel without stumping up the money for an entirely new console.
The biggest difference I've noticed between systems is wifi download speed. This is extremely fast with the New 3DS models, fast enough with the original 3DS, but really quite bad with the 2DS. Retail game download times are a few minutes with the 3DS systems, but up to 80 minutes with the 2DS using the same internet connection and downloading the same game. That was a surprise, but shouldn't be a dealbreaker. The extra solidity of the 2DS and the price make it great as a child or budget system.
In USA THEY are (i mean chargers).
In Europe aren't. So USA law is better than Europe/European Union?
@Sakura 2ds download speed is slower? I thought 2ds and 3ds have got same hardware minus that screen/s? and displaying 3d.
I actually prefer my kids' 2DSs over my own XL. They are just the right size for the hands and the screen is better suited to the relatively low resolution, compared to the large screens.
@DontPlayDumb Well, that was just my experience. Downloaded Alpha Sapphire on a N3DS and it took probably about 10 minutes. Then immediately downloaded Omega Ruby on a 2DS and it was still going well after an hour, nearer 2. System transfer also took longer from the 2DS to a 3DS than it generally takes between two 3DSes. It could just have been that particular unit, I suppose, but download of Tomodachi Life on a different 2DS also took an age. I'm so used to the zippy speeds of 3DS that it took me by surprise.
@Sakura I still remember how long i downloaded my Pokemon X.......2 hours
I'd say the 2DS, its got the advantages of being sturdy, cheaper and the corners won't dig into your hands. We have the reader thing for our amiibo and cards.
NoA please release the New 3DS in the U.S. I really want the 3D effect and better processing power while being able to carry other stuff in the same pocket.
@Michael_JF can't u just get the happy home designer bundle?
Here's an even easier buyer's guide:
Get a New 3DS if you want a small one and a New 3DS XL if you want a big one. Don't get the 2DS because it's overpriced, lacking in features, and feels incredibly cheap and is awful to play on. If you don't want your kid using 3D, see the above advice but enable parental controls to lock out 3D before you give it to your kid. Don't get the older 3DS models because they're outdated and lacking in features.
@Andremario isn't it the New 3DS XL? I'd rather have the small one
@Michael_JF No, its the standard size, with face plates.
@Knuckles Maybe. Although I'm a fan of Animal Crossing I'm really not interested in HHD. I'd rather they just release the system so I'm not paying for both it and a game I probably won't play.
I was actually thinking about getting a cheap and used 3DS just recently but after I read this part, I remembered that I had read this about the New 3DS before:
"More impressive though is the super-stable 3D on both the New 3DS and New 3DS XL. This tracks the player's face to keep the 3D effect locked in and viewing experience easier. It's easy to underestimate how much of a difference this makes."
I think I'll save up to a New 3DS, even if I may end up paying almost twice as much.
Thanks @andyrob_24_7 for reminding me again.
The Animal Crossing New Nintendo 3DS bundle price in North America is now $199.00 on Amazon (and Walmart). It was $219.99 before. In compassion, the Metallic Black (New Black in North America) New Nintendo 3DS XL standalone costs $196.19 on Amazon.
http://amzn.to/1XWjMtn
As badly as I want one- I can't justify getting it b/c my old 3ds is still in good condition. there's only one exclusive game. I think I will get one eventually b/c it looks cool. I just want to wear my other out a bit more before I take the plunge.
Tap here to load 19 comments
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...